i love there live stuff, i'm gonna see them july 7th and im excited, live they just wanna spice things up and change it around, and sound different. They have so much energy and soul into playing live
Holy shit...I expect fans to retaliate to my comment here, but the singing in this performance is fucking atrocious...that being said, I looked for this because I enjoyed the studio version a lot. I mean like, they are really into looping, why doesn't he loop the yelping part? It seems to go on forever and is painful to listen to after a while. I'm not saying this to instigate some sort of online argument, I just couldn't ignore it.
@BigPerm5000 this is so much better live. i prefer his live screams to the album woo's and the build up (intro) to this is so great, which you don't get on mpp
they are not bad live. they just do bad shows sometimes like any other band. i've seen great performances of theirs but this one was not one of them. apart from the end which i really enjoyed!
@Streetfright If you think this is a great-live-quality performance you should try to find some real good live bands. Im a huge AC fan but this is borderline insulting for people paying tickets. I guess this is why the term "studio musician" exist.
@Streetfright I agree. I have multiple live versions downloaded on my ipod, and I find myself listening to them more than the studio versions. Animal collective is amazing live.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This is awful. I like AC but every video post of them live does the great work they do on their albums no justice. I'm amazed how so obviously talented guys who expect so much from their studio work allow their live perfomances to be so poor. The only thing that sounds good is the programmed material.....sad :(
i think youre looking for something they're not TRYING to provide. they're not looking for perfect pitches and pure studio performance. they just want to celebrate and have you celebrate them.
@drewmcscott sounds like you've never seen them live. also sounds like you haven't seen enough of their live videos, as they run the entire gamut in terms of both quality and originality. dont give up just yet :)
@drewmcscott Well, I think their live performances make a lot more "sense" when you put the band's history in context- by which I mean, their pre-Sung-Tongs era. Look up the album Hollinndagain, and you'll see what I mean. Also, for an example of a knockout live performance, I highly recommend checking out their appearance on BBC Breeze Sessions, from back in 2004! You can find in on the animalcollective . org website (for free, of course).
It's the other way around for me, since this is the first version of Brother Sport I heard, it was (and still is) kind of weird for me to listen to the studio version. Without bass just seems to bring it to me.
However I do agree with the lack of bass for My Girls live, I think they've been putting more bass in live versions lately.
This song stands out to me the most out of the ones I've heard so far on MP. "You've got to open up your open up your open up your..." I was singing that in class all damn day!
Matt!!!
demmeri 2 months ago
youtube.com/watch?v=25dVNSDFuK8
brother sport remix
djpottsi 5 months ago
i love there live stuff, i'm gonna see them july 7th and im excited, live they just wanna spice things up and change it around, and sound different. They have so much energy and soul into playing live
crzyazn107 7 months ago
I saw them live in Milan 1 mounth ago, so I can say they are way better than in this video. Their live was really great!
chaiaia 7 months ago
Animal Collective just doesn't work live. Love their studio stuff, but they just can't do it live.
Rael0505 10 months ago
Live performances are not about singing in tune or executing the song perfectly, they are about the energy and spirit, which AC deffinitly have.
I wish I had been there......
Sheeeeepies1 10 months ago
@oddcrap lol we all know u be fuckin trollin so get a life fag
Wcburg1 1 year ago
Holy shit...I expect fans to retaliate to my comment here, but the singing in this performance is fucking atrocious...that being said, I looked for this because I enjoyed the studio version a lot. I mean like, they are really into looping, why doesn't he loop the yelping part? It seems to go on forever and is painful to listen to after a while. I'm not saying this to instigate some sort of online argument, I just couldn't ignore it.
BigPerm5000 1 year ago
@BigPerm5000 this is so much better live. i prefer his live screams to the album woo's and the build up (intro) to this is so great, which you don't get on mpp
schmitty3 1 year ago
@schmitty3Thank you for not getting pissed, I respect your opinion good sir.
BigPerm5000 1 year ago
@BigPerm5000 you'd just have to be there. shut the fuck up.
jamescracksthesky 1 year ago 4
@BigPerm5000 how do you like it now, after 6 months has the live version grown on you?
sfdallator 11 months ago 2
@BigPerm5000 watching is troublesome, so just enjoy the live audio !!! :-) cheers!
zomb3030 4 months ago
the sheer energy makes up for avey's questionable vocals.
twistedfirestarter13 1 year ago
I think they did this well
RobotFetish 1 year ago
Avey: WOAAAAOOOOOO!!!!!
love it
Veckatimest65 2 years ago
animal collective is one of my favorite band
TheFoodfunny 2 years ago 3
I Think Either You Love Them , Or You Hate Them. I Love Them, and for those who hate, i don`t give a shit.
kauborealis 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
bajaren12 2 years ago
hell yes.
I want to go to a concert of theirs :(
katelinholla 2 years ago 3
saw them at lollapalooza awhile back. By far a wicked experience
edensfinest 1 year ago
if you guys really think that animal collective is bad live, you don't appreciate a live performance, maybe you should stick your MP3 player.
Streetfright 2 years ago 26
they are not bad live. they just do bad shows sometimes like any other band. i've seen great performances of theirs but this one was not one of them. apart from the end which i really enjoyed!
limaa91 2 years ago 4
@Streetfright If you think this is a great-live-quality performance you should try to find some real good live bands. Im a huge AC fan but this is borderline insulting for people paying tickets. I guess this is why the term "studio musician" exist.
ThePhil230 1 year ago
Comment removed
sandmb1kes 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Streetfright I agree. I have multiple live versions downloaded on my ipod, and I find myself listening to them more than the studio versions. Animal collective is amazing live.
sandmb1kes 7 months ago
MAAAAAAAAAATT!!!!!!!
i think it sounds pretty cool actually!
the crowd seems to like it too lol
dont know why you guys dont like it
musiclovecomedy2630 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is awful. I like AC but every video post of them live does the great work they do on their albums no justice. I'm amazed how so obviously talented guys who expect so much from their studio work allow their live perfomances to be so poor. The only thing that sounds good is the programmed material.....sad :(
drewmcscott 2 years ago
nope
schmitty3 2 years ago 18
@schmitty3 yep
SergeantSteezy 1 year ago
@schmitty3 oh come on...you know it. it's so bare boned and empty sounding compared to the canvas they paint with their recordings
toddbolden 1 year ago
@drewmcscott
i think youre looking for something they're not TRYING to provide. they're not looking for perfect pitches and pure studio performance. they just want to celebrate and have you celebrate them.
alliant 1 year ago
@drewmcscott
well excuse me but I find this to be quite ear-pleasing.
PullThenTake 1 year ago
@drewmcscott This is from 2007, listen to more recent live versions of the song.
SpoonHysteria 1 year ago
@drewmcscott sounds like you've never seen them live. also sounds like you haven't seen enough of their live videos, as they run the entire gamut in terms of both quality and originality. dont give up just yet :)
dicsballer9 1 year ago
@drewmcscott Well, I think their live performances make a lot more "sense" when you put the band's history in context- by which I mean, their pre-Sung-Tongs era. Look up the album Hollinndagain, and you'll see what I mean. Also, for an example of a knockout live performance, I highly recommend checking out their appearance on BBC Breeze Sessions, from back in 2004! You can find in on the animalcollective . org website (for free, of course).
DravenX53 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is a bunch of fucking worthless noise.
lemke777 2 years ago
What else is there? Everything is noise...doesn't make it worthless.
chandru1103 2 years ago
lol why did this get -6? He was defending AC....
Wak3me 1 year ago 3
exactly what I have been trying to figure out. I reckon it has a lot to do with the illiteracy in the world.
chandru1103 1 year ago
@lemke777 dude what the fuck, you fucking suck this is music, youre a worthless piece of crap
Wcburg1 1 year ago
What is panda duing with the back of one of his sp-303s?
andersersand 2 years ago
until fully grown
youve got the real good shot
youve got so much inside
let it come let it come right out
ndubblove68 2 years ago
finally a crowd with some movement! every other AC vid i've seen, the crowds have been dead.....
AdamWaz704 2 years ago 9
What's the other version?
homestarfan2008 2 years ago
These guys are awesome on their studio albums but this is borderline Grateful Dead here. They're so high.
homestarfan2008 2 years ago 3
it beats me why they can't just play the bass live, its kind of awkward without it
anewyorkthing 2 years ago
It's the other way around for me, since this is the first version of Brother Sport I heard, it was (and still is) kind of weird for me to listen to the studio version. Without bass just seems to bring it to me.
However I do agree with the lack of bass for My Girls live, I think they've been putting more bass in live versions lately.
Jenetik214 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I love them so much.... But god do they suuuuuuuck live.
kevwink86 2 years ago
Still the shit
jtallen12345 3 years ago 2
club med?
huh..
freedumbmouse 3 years ago
you're all quoting the lyrics wrong
kainindustries 3 years ago
i know
the0ctagon 3 years ago
You got to weigh all you say
Have you seen the way you play
You gotta wake up in the mornin'
You gotta have what's on your mind
the0ctagon 3 years ago 2
You've got to weigh all he said
He helped you shape the way you play
You've got to get rid of the mourning
Sort out the habits of your mind
VeryAmpersand 2 years ago
This song stands out to me the most out of the ones I've heard so far on MP. "You've got to open up your open up your open up your..." I was singing that in class all damn day!
dc4cshmogle 3 years ago
You got to wait all day
While you change what you planned
You gotta wake up in the mornin'
You gotta have a real good time
fidelmadeira 3 years ago
You've got to weigh all he said
He helped you shape the way you play
You've got to get rid of the mourning
Sort out the habits of your mind
VeryAmpersand 2 years ago
You are fully grown
You got a real good shot
You got so much inside
Let it come, let it come right out
superslinkey 3 years ago
Until you're fully grown
You've got a real good shot
Open up to hold inside:
"Keep it real, keep it real
Shout out"
the0ctagon 3 years ago
i cant wait to blast this shit in my headphones!!!
MichaVids 3 years ago 7
arghhhhhhhhhhhhhh Brother Sport is the best Animal Collective song I want an album versionnnnnnnnnn
limpviscid 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
And now you have it.
Blackwaterdesigns 3 years ago
this song's name is BrotherSport
it is amazing.
MusicSwirl89 3 years ago 6