' Who Knew' - A Tribute to Edward Elric and Alfons Heiderich

[EuphieMeguElric]

I love it video!!! amazing!

Ed and Heiderich <3 T.T

[Phantomdubber]

Haha I'm in the middle of brotherhood right now and loving it. Yet I keep on wanting to rewatch series 1 and the movie :S

[shugopower5]

this movie wasn't as sad as saikano (o-o it's 12 epi's long, but it makes u cry every epi =o) :3 anyway i did cry at the end of this film DX

[Blueyejo7533]

Poor Alfons! I cried several times during that movie, but when he was shot that was the time I cried the hardest...

[BeingHumanRocks1]

Saddest AMV I've seen for FullMetal Alchemist. The music fits perfectly. I was in the car today and we were listening to a P!nk album and when 'who knew' came on, I thought of this bid and let a tear free. TMAQueen, I congratulate you on making me depressed in a good way :'( :)

[AlexandriaSprout]

Alphonse* and he is so cute i wanna hug him

[Stairwellchild]

Trying to imagine what it must have been like for Al to see himself lying dead on the floor...

[Stairwellchild]

@MultiUtup what do you mean got his body back? You do realize that's not the Al in the armor, right?

[MultiUtup]

why is everybody so concerned with Al's name ?! It doesn't matter how u spell it as long it says it the correct way !!! I mean we don't even no the real way to spell his name !! >= {

[MultiUtup]

i cried !! It's not fair tht he has to die because he got his body back than he lived to adult form and die !!!!!!!!!!!!!(although its his fault for not staying home from work)

[Stairwellchild]

Thanks for reminding me of the good part of shambala. I forgot it amidst the suckiness. If only they had they had left out the Nazi lady and elaborated on the elric brothers and al heidrich. . . . : /

[Stairwellchild]

Thanks for reminding me of what was great about shambala. The rest of the plot sucked. I applaud you.

[Totalfangirl97]

at 1:05 you can tell ed is not good at driving... XD

[TheEscapedBalloon]

I love how randomly he died. Shot in the back, out of the blue..

Realistic deaths suck.

[brichamp123]

I cry when I think of Alfons...... I cry every November 8 so yeah.

[theRainISurFrieND]

MEEEEE! I cried, it was so sad! actually I still cry whenever I watch the movie! Great video btw

[TheAIphonseElric]

Ok I havent seen the movie yet bcse im watching the series again with my brother and now when in highest rated comments where it said he died im sad and I dont even know who he is *moe cry* gosh!

[FuchanIbuki]

AGHHHHHHHHHHH EDWARD EPIC HOTNESS! *drool*

[silentshadow2828]

cant...stop...crying T^T its probably cuz i read Precious Wonder.. its really sad but uncompleted /:

[silentshadow2828]

cant....stop....crying.... T^T

[Wolfdemonzz]

The first time I saw that movie, I almost cried when Alfons died.

But then the next time I saw it... Well I knew what was going to happen, and so the whole time Alfons was telling Ed not to forget him, I swear I had a steady stream of tears flowing down. xD

[Rawrisons97]

who spelt Al's full name wrong.. It's Alphonse Elric...

[Furubatsu]

I just finished reading the last ever chapter of Full Metal Alchemist (yes, it's over) and this video just made me cry all over agian! *Faves*

[ZeldaWolf2000]

cool vid bt it's alphonse not alfons just sayin

[MissMarientose]

@ZeldaWolf2000 no, it is Alfons. Alfons Heiderich is a german name. Alphonse Elric is...I think french. But yea, there's Alphonse and Alfons.

[ZeldaWolf2000]

@MissMarientose but if you read the subs it's spelt alphonse for elric and heidereich

[MissMarientose]

@ZeldaWolf2000 I realize that. But even the voice actors themselves spell it Alfons. So I go by that. Anyway, like I said before, it is the german way to spell the name.

[waalex11]

Uhm I'm curious is this of FMa Brotherhood

Cuz i'm watching it Dub

& Dont really remember FMA...

Can anyone tell me?

[1984Stephanie]

:( I like the song Poor Al

[Mokumokuren13]

Fuck yeah I was looking for this song with FMA

[gliclub]

Whaaa, Fullmetal Alchemist's coolest characters always die! Like Hughs, you think nothing bad'll happen to him cause he has a little girl, BAM he dies. Now Alfons, who you think is gonna' live cause in normal animes the conflicted character usually does, bam he dies. I wouldn't trade this anime for anything else, though! Im loving Brotherhood, too, even though Hugh is always destined to die... T.T

[FailureAsaNinja]

Fullmetal Alchemist is the only anime that has made me bawl like a child. This movie is the only movie to make me cry for hours. Your AMV is now on that list as well. FMA just does that to me, I guess. ^^;

[WeBeComics]

Every time I watch Alfons' death, I start crying. FMA is the only anime that has ever made me cry. I bawled for about ten minutes when Alfons died.

[Mina1914onMapleStory]

uhggg who is Alfons Heiderich is he Alphonse? With a diff last and first name? Im confused.

[WeBeComics]

@Mina1914onMapleStory Okay, when Edward attached Alphonse's soul back to his original body, he went through the gate as Equivalent Exchange and into a parallel dimension, which is considered to be "our world." Alfons Heiderich is sort of like Alphonse Elric's "parallel self."

Does that make any sense?

[AlexanderXmouse]

@WeBeComics XD, You type just like you talk in real life. xD

[GreenJello100]

GOD I LOVE EDWARD HE'S SOO HOT WHEN HE DIED I WAS LIKE CRYIBG TO MY SELF CUZ I WAS W/ FRIENDS and i didn't want to tell my friends that i loved him but on friend (Lil' D...nick name ) and she was like .."god he's hot " and i wa slike HELL YAH HE IS AND I LOVE HIM SOO MUCH IF ONLY HE WAS REAL... (I'll keep dreaming about it)

[CrimsonKobi]

2:17 through to the end made me go from sniffling to crying, I loved Alfons Heiderich it made me so sad when he died.

[Brocakedonut]

whats the name of this movie

[candylopez1347]

*-* Alphonse is so pretty XD and he was like " Ed, get the fck off me >:o" * Push* xD

[animekillerisajoke23]

Oh mah god.. I Nearly cried.. maybe because i havent watched it for a long time..

[coldplay109]

I always thought Alfons was sexier than Alphonse OWO

I loved his manly voice XD Alphonse talks all chibi like

[Zookimer]

I love this song, and this anime... Its really well put together. I likey.

[Luvs2Rock722]

i want to kick that cops butt who kills a rocket enginer poor alfons!!!PM me if you agree!!!!!RIP Alfons Heidrich

[ichiruki4e73r]

my fav character is Ed but I think Alphons was a good guy, it's really sad that he died but at least he died happy

[emopufferfish]

this song suits them so well!!! :)

though i think 21 guns , (green day) suits them too.

I ship this pairing too!

[pokemonfan99]

omg i didnt knew al died! thats just sucks like a lot i was about to watch this movie too! but i will still... REST IN PEACE ED AND AL :'(

[PranksterOfAz]

@pokemonfan99 Which Al do you think died?

[pokemonfan99]

@PranksterOfAz the hedirich one, although that comment was like, a year ago so i dnt care for that al anymore, cause i care for Brotherhood <3

[PranksterOfAz]

@pokemonfan99 okay,There are a lot of people commenting on here & freakin' out.

[pokemonfan99]

@PranksterOfAz o: okay

[NeoLoverPet]

Al died?! WHEN?!

[ThePopimanos]

it's not alphonse elric it's alphonse Heiderich, they're not even brothers

[PranksterOfAz]

@NeoLoverPet It's a different Al.

I would shit myself if the real one died.

[cammyNpammy]

@PranksterOfAz if he did die then the series would go down the drain fans would go crazy and also everyone would cry

[PranksterOfAz]

@cammyNpammy Yup. would have been chaos.

[EdwardElricStalker]

:( I miss Alfons. Why the heck did he have to flippin die?

Reminds me of an Icon I saw once...

"Fullmetal Alchemist: We make you love them. Then they die."

[LacuestaFiesta]

he didn't die this is the last movie.... if you remember the last episode when edward went to a dimentional world kinda of like ours while alfons is on their home world with his body

[blueonigiri112]

*sniff* so true

[emilyinpeinwithout]

@EdwardElricStalker That icon did not lie

[StudentOfAlchemy]

I've seen the movie, I own the movie, I love the movie, and I LOVE THIS AMV!!!! You did such an awesome job on this!!! Thank you for making it and uploading it!!!!!!

[TimeCLone]

I too cried..

its feels so wrong to see

a good and innocent person die.Its just wrong.

T_T

stupid shooter who shot alphonse heidrich!

[PregnantCheese]

Hey guys, who else cried when Al Heiderich died? I cried for like, eight minutes. I actually had to pause the movie so I wouldn't miss anything :3

[blueblood1d2]

WHAAA! so did i!

[inuyashapuppy3]

@PregnantCheese ME TOO! i cryed for the rest of the movie tho... like after i thought i had it altogether i turned the movie back on and cryed some more.... same with wraths death.

[HopeOnly131]

his name is actually his name is Alphons

[FuchanIbuki]

@PregnantCheese Actually, I think I was so stubborn that I hated Alfons.

[Kaegri]

@PregnantCheese That's my way of watching movies too.Though I get too embarrassed, so only when I'm alone. :P

[rawrersful]

@PregnantCheese WHAAAT?! AL DIED??!!! NONONONONONONONO

[tikallover123]

@PregnantCheese LOOL i cried for like and hour and whenever i thought about it in class, i would burst out in tears D,X

[dhousem]

^^ Very good. I loved it

[LoveInuYashaTV]

poor al. D':

great video though. ^^

[kerorodaishoutai]

yup! died! D:

[thisiswhoiam101]

So why did he get shot he was good and should'nt have got shot.

[LaughingNinja]

Think it was because the Al elric came to that world. Can't have more then one of your self there at a time... so he had to go... very sad... very very sad... but.... *sigh* Bring him back!!

[mayaHAKIRA]

I love edward.

Poor Alphonse.....

[Lelouchsgirl69]

I agree :'(

[princessrathe12]

my fav character is al ed and roy

[petranakocic]

my fav. character is Ed but poor al!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Sasukeyaoifan]

aww~

i remember the movie..why alfons WHY?!?

Alfons and Ed were so good friends.. ;_;

Very good ^^-

[Lelouchsgirl69]

I agree

[ZockerRockerSlenzka]

Ahh Soo cool! *_*

5/5

[DachanOTS]

edward is dead?

[thephantomdragon]

you gotta see the movie xD

[jazz613]

Yes.

Just watch the movie.

[VC941118]

But I thought Ed wasn't dead?!

Ed and al were alive!

but al heidriech was dead,,ain't that rite?

[bubble22455]

such an AWSOME show and AWSOME video

[AlphonseSama]

Oh,Alfons...why? ;_; Damn,I always cry in the funeral part...

Awesome tribute,I loved it!

[PockyChan95]

The movie always makes me cry

because all he wanted was to be remembered

:'(

[rosedragon88]

Okay, if this isn't Alphonse Elric, why is Alphonse spelled like that on the video itself? When Ed is talking to him, it's spelled Alphonse.

[MakeOutMermaid]

...omg go wach the movie. its Alphonse from the other side of the gate wierdo.

[acidheadx]

Its spelt Alfons because he's German and Alfons is the german veriant of the name

[CHICOOZEE]

hahahahahahahahha...m LUVIN d comments here!!God!!u ppl juz dun understand dat itz NOT d real al!!=D

[BlueSkyPearl]

I was soooo sad when Alfons died...:(...thanks for making this video. :)

[animenut2000]

no he doesn't die

[BlueSkyPearl]

Alfons Heiderich? Yeah. O.o

Alphonse Elric? No. O.o

[krissy2020]

omg al died

[animenut2000]

no he doesn't

[JellonaKunkku]

yes he did :D:D:D:D.DD::D:D:D::D::D:DD

[animenut2000]

Al bother doesn't die

he livessssssss

as for the other dude yeah he gets killed so sadddddddddddddddddddddddddddd­dddddddddddddddddddddddddddddd­dddddddd but al elric doesn't die he livessssssss

[SilentFishHeads]

What your saying is the truth but did you have to kill English in the making. XD

[yukiEkimy]

questo video è trpp bello..mi fa piangere quando lo guardo..uff..!

[muppetnut]

really good vid. it was so sad.

but some of the clips were REALLY random. like scar. ftw?

[Alchemais]

babycocopuff I agree with you whole heatedly on Fma!!!

Like the song!!

[ichigosuika]

doesn't the singer's voice sound similar to ed's? nice vid^^

[funkykitten123]

THE SINGER IS A GIRL AND NO!

[LilDevil2005]

How can you say that about Pink!! X3

[Kaitzvuotis]

Actually, Ed's voice actor in japanese version is a woman. Her name is Romi Paku.

[RoboticxGirl]

I think the editing wasn't very good.

You probably coudl have portrayed the feeling a lot better. Especially when Alphonz is shot.

[babycocopuff]

FMA is the best anime series I've ever seen why did it have to end T_T (i luv the movie it would be a miracle if they made a second)

[ayogirl112]

wow, SUPER-good, like it's wierd how perfect this song is for them!

[ayogirl112]

wow, SUPER-good, like it's wierd how perfect this song is for them!

[TriggerHappyRetard]

Oh, poor Alfy! I did love him so! I love how this video explores the relationship between Alfy and Ed.

[Royai92]

I love it!! *O* Awesome video ^O^

[uchidamaki]

* when ed drives off the road*

... remind me to go driving with him later.....

[demonninjagrl]

i think we learned a lesson. never let ed drive LOL

[TBBishiXO]

Alfons i lurve him!!

[uchidamaki]

lul

[fromhellicame]

luv the song. It goes so well w/ d vid.

[TheOnlyGhostQueen]

Im cunfussled which al is whick.*grabs head* oww meh tiny brain hurts! cute though

[MagicansForce]

The one with really blonde hair and blue eyes is Alfons, German spelling. The one with coppery hair and brownish eyes is Alphonse, French spelling.

[TheOnlyGhostQueen]

THANKIES!!!!

[fullmetalluva]

T_T waaaah alphonse-chan dies!!!!! i was sooo sad when i saw that part in the movie i was crying like crazy!!!!!

[edwardismylove]

he dies?!!!! how?

[fullmetalluva]

he was shot in the back T_T

[uchidamaki]

crap... that sucks!!! CURSES!!!

[lunattique]

That guy just shot him because he help Ed espace with that second Rocket.

[uchidamaki]

depressing T^T poor ally!

[fullmetalluva]

i no T_T_T_T_T_T

[uchidamaki]

which if you wanna be really mean and morbid is kinda funny ^^' i mean its like the guy walked up say alphons and edward and was like ZOMG!! and shot him........

[fullmetalluva]

hai hai T_T

[Xlemonn44]

he looked pretty happy when he got shot D:

[babycocopuff]

i know it's weird.

[Xlemonn44]

lol well it's better than dying from that disease he had. Was it tuberculosisi? :o

[Hajiobessed]

I think it's because he died helping Ed and that's all he really wanted.

[mczedd1]

Frank Archer's doppleganger is the one who shot him, his name was Rudolf Hess. *sings* Rudolf the crazy nazi, was a very strange weirdo, and if you ever saw him you would say "HOLY SHIT! RUN ALPHONSE!" *stops singing and looks around...* Umm nvm...

[TMAQueen]

I'll have to start singing that and running around the school. I have actually rocked out/danced/skipped in the halls while listening to Three Days Grace and have randomly started playing air guitar in socials class.

Do it sometimes, it's fun!

[mczedd1]

Haha, I'll try that, right after I finish acting out the "Halo-pwnage-Tea-bag" for my friends...

[TMAQueen]

The...what?

[mczedd1]

You know the game Halo? When you kill someone you run over to their body and crouch down a bunch of times. It's a way to gloat because you just owned them in the face with your gatline gun. It is called the Halo-pwnage-tea-bag. ...yeah, I'm weird.

[TMAQueen]

I`ll have to use that, I have a friend who`s obsessed with Halo

[xdarkxxsoilx]

i cried when alphons heidrick died =[

[nobby4]

[quote]i think i know who shot him! Frank Archer or Fuhrer King Bradley (these are just thoughts) I know its someone in the military and its a boy. *starts crying*[/quote]

The man who killed him is Rudolf Hess.

[teamF3]

very wonderful this video, but poor al heiderich because he die..

[Angelysty]

Great AMV! I loved the movie!

[SnowAlchemist4eva]

i cant even watch this video!

its really sad!

i am even cryin rite now! LOL

i dont care if thats not Alphonse Elric he still gets hurt(dies) so i cant take it!

[SnowAlchemist4eva]

sad video :(  wat is the movie called

[Angelysty]

The Conquerer of Shamballa

[Angelysty]

my bad *Conqueror* teehee

[sasukesgirl272]

al dies omg im really cring dude  it's good but sad i can't watch it again

[XHateToLoveX]

It looks like the guy who's a half robot. The one who trapped Izumi and Edward in the last few episodes.

[SnowAlchemist4eva]

i think i know who shot him! Frank Archer or Fuhrer King Bradley (these are just thoughts) I know its someone in the military and its a boy. *starts crying*

[SnowAlchemist4eva]

alphonse noooooooooo! i rlly wanna know who shot him! if i knew and the person(or homunculus) i would beat them up and to finish shoot them!

[princessusuk]

Nooo! poor Al... Dam the person who shoot him!

[Nimtila]

I almost started crying ...

[Original3coco]

i hated that alphonse.

[thephantomdragon]

man, i shoulve read your commnt! i havent seent he movie! XD yeah thats not al, his eyes are not blue! i was actually thinking that trough the vid

[NaruHinaBurnigFlower]

its this sickness in the very late 1800's

its when the lungs become weak and the rib from the inside and yeah it messes with the organs inside your body and you cough up blood.

Mountain air is a good cure

but in those times they didnt have the right medicine so most people died.

[Reauxkringgirl]

They are not freakin' gay, and they are not really the ELRIC BROTHERS. Sheesh. Anyways, to review, I LOVED Alfons Heidrich and it was so sad the way he got tuberculosis, knew he was going to die from that, but got shot...I was like...NO!!! @_@ -__

[Fidgeteyes]

I'm kinda thinking it was actually lung Cancer.

It seems like Tuberculosis, but Lung Cancer would be more likely.

He got it from being around the rockets, so yeah. He probably just inhaled too much smoke.

But then again, it was around the time when Tuberculosis was spreading. So it could have been either.

[Reauxkringgirl]

Yeah, that was my thought. Could it have been mesothelioma?

[Fidgeteyes]

That's a very good possibility, actually.

[saragurl45]

=o makes me want to cry lmao Love it ^_^

[narutotwenty4seven]

This video... makes me want to cry...

4/5.

Faved.

Great idea.

[kitsunegirl14]

be strong. at least a few people know that its NOT yaoi,and NOT the elric brothers. great job by the way!

[TMAQueen]

A few, -sigh-

I just posted the thing so hopefully people would read it, I doubt they will, but yeah. :D

[xxKonokaxx]

Such a cute movie ^_^

* faves * This is 5 star material!

Good Job! This is one of my favorite videos now!

[misaki93]

This video makes them seem gay. I know they are close brothers but still

[mnmrox]

What's wrong with it if they are? People are allowed to be homosexual, you know.

[CutieMimi15]

YEAH!@ I GOT YOUR BACK! even tho this wasnt yaoi at all >.>

[CutieMimi15]

wtf. thats alphons heidrich. hes from the fma movie. id tell ya mroe but that would be ruinning the movie. -.-

[PranksterOfAz]

@misaki93 Their not even brothers.

[willray10]

both Alphonse Elric and Alphonse Heidrich are so hott or just really, really, really cute! SO IT MADE ME CRY BIG TIME!!!!!!!!!!!

[Sokkalovesme]

MINNNNNNNNNEEEEEEEEE!!??

[willray10]

*giggles* ok.

[DragonAlchemist63]

where did you find the movie clips?

[jess02827]

my friend that i talk to on myspace said this was a yoai video, i totally disagree this is to show the close friendship they have , AWESOME VIDEO^^

[TMAQueen]

This is a yaoi video??

-watches- No kissing/making out/sex.

Your friend might be thinking this is shounen-ai(sp?)

If it seems like yaoi or shounen-ai, it was unintentional.