That is very nice. Love the way your ethereal piano fits the mysterious parts of the story, just as well as the heavier, forte part fits the dramatic sequences at Lake Town. Thanks for the invite.
Oh my gosh this is really amazing. J.R.R Tolkien is one of my favorite authors and you brought the hobbit to life before peter Jackon. It is really incredible.
now where i've read the book, i like it miles more, just brilliant, when i'm in my bed and can't sleep, i think of the hobbit and his andventures with the dwarfs, thanks pal ...
It's a good peice of music but for me borders on vamped up 'Chaucer England' rather than fantasy 'Middle Earth'. I do like it, it's just not LOTR.......
check it in the movies and on google :-) the shire is the land : l Always thougt it was diffrent i thoght hobbiton where the land and the shire was the town
This song is really good. Beautiful actually. Thanks for sending me this. It really puts across the message in the movie. I recently watched it after seeing it maybe 5 years ago when i was 10-11. Almost forgot about the greatest movie trilogy ever made.
@zedooncadhz hobbition is a town in the shire. since you always see the shire in the map.. so shire is like yorkshire in england.. the county and hobbiton is a village
@AkaviriDragonlord ohhh yes i know that yorkshire is a county lad! lol yorkshire born and bred! Yorkshire puds ale and all that :P Yeh i reckon the shire is the biggest one actually cos you're right you do see it on the map as a giant area just called the shire. But if the shire's a county then whats the country? We must plumb the depths of this hobbit mystery!
i checked its part of the old kingdom of arnor arnor was founded by isildur's dad and that was in this region of middle of a very large region called Eriador
so its in eriador and more specifically the kingdom of arnor
@Jokerprodution I thumbs down because I disagreed. They are not like gnomes or dwarfes at all. And they live in the Shire. Hobbiton is just a city-like place.
Reminds me of the game called "agony" at the beginning, but is a very nice composition.
Keep up the good work :)
BTW; the kind of cadence and style that you gave to this theme, it suits more as part of the story, instead of being the main theme; just a suggestion; since is very melancholy and introspective, while usually the main themes have a different feeling :)
yeah, you could definitely get far with this music. except im not sure it fits the lord of the rings. its really great though. maybe if you add more string instruments such as cello, violin, string bass, viola, etc., and even brass instruments like trumpet, trombone, and any kind of horn like Shore did, it would still sound amazing and it would fit a little better with the lord of the rings, but this is really good.
This is some incredible music. Thank you very much for sending me the link! If you ever feel like selling it as an MP3 or something, let me know - I'd be glad to buy it and support your endeavors! Keep composing, you are very talented.
This feels like Howard Shore's style, and kind of a bit of Hans Zimmer thrown in there as well. All I can say is well done Josh. This is a great piece. You should compose more LOTR and HOBBIT related pieces.
Its wery fasinating to se these pictures they relly bring the LOTRS up again in your spirit and your mind, and it makes you think abaut how truly, the movie has vroght a message, abaut freindship, love and joy..<3
thanks for sending! it´s a very good track! you really should send it to the a important person, who works with the hole team, which produce the film the hobbit.
it sounds a bit like runescape music but thats just because you don't have an entire orchestrer to play it. you have great talent and should write more you never know you could be the next big name in classical music history good luck and keep going!
If I were to be critical, I would say that this is indeed very theme-like - good for a soundtrack. Movie music doesn't always contain the pop rigidity of "beginning-verse-chorus-verse-bridge-guitarsolo-end-Amen (generic example)". However, I'm sure you're aware of that, and it's hard to make movie music without the scene made for you first of all. IF you were already aware of this, I'll stfu now and leave you alone. Otherwise, that's my advice! Thanks for sharing your talent!
Thanks for the mail and.. Yes, It's a good song.. But if you look into Howard Shores music from the Lord of the Rings.. he did NOT use the piano.. It gives a diffirent feeling.. But the song is great, but I do not think it fits..
@Icefloris Although he doesn't use much piano in LOTR, Howard Shore still used it. In many pieces it can be heard in the background to give even more emotional effect and in some it even takes the foreground as the main instrument. Speaking of Howard Shore and piano pieces. Have you or anyone reading this, heard his Eclipse score. It's an entirely piano built and sustained score. It is mind-blowingly beautiful, almost as beautiful as the previous New Moon score by Alexandre Desplat.
This is beautiful music, but think that it just isnt proper for this story. This is escentially a song that talks about peace, and in the hobbit there are many thrilling parts. But that's just me. I am no expert. Its my humble opinion.
That was... BEAUTIFUL! That was... PERFECT! You should definitely contact the creators of the new movie The Hobbit and submit this piece as soundtrack! It's amazingly right for the mood of the story and would fit like a glove! I'll do some research for you and if I find any way to contact them I'll message you!
Amazing
Matheusnightwish 2 months ago
Niceeeee.... you might still be able to score it ;)
AnGeLWiNgS93 2 months ago
You sir, got skills :) I hope you get far with your music!
naztybeaver 2 months ago
Comment removed
Kadda1234 5 months ago in playlist Breaking Benjamin
Incredible
sabuomarrr1 5 months ago
impressive
Nettsapi 6 months ago
very nice
KaptainMarvin1 7 months ago
Bello!
Dellerma 8 months ago
brave and professional effor.
srmohsin 8 months ago
This was very good. And incredibly good paintings.
Nice pianist!
Duggibobo1 10 months ago
good !
jesuisKIA 11 months ago
That is very nice. Love the way your ethereal piano fits the mysterious parts of the story, just as well as the heavier, forte part fits the dramatic sequences at Lake Town. Thanks for the invite.
earlejohn3 11 months ago
great post
CHRIS1974100 1 year ago
Music is great!
Volumpitiki 1 year ago
You've got the pictures in the order of the storyline from the book! :D awesome
1Clouderon1 1 year ago
This was a good book
1Clouderon1 1 year ago
So Well done!!!!!!!!!!!
helloalexis 1 year ago
awesome!!!
TheHolford 1 year ago
hope the movie will be as great as the LOTRs
lilAtid 1 year ago
beautiful!
HanumanLoki 1 year ago
Très joli!!
flipendo93 1 year ago
nice man it is so full of joy and happiness
bio0rx 1 year ago
Hey thanks for sending it to me, it's really good .
Sorry to respond so late.
You should maybe look for a job like composing
Just a suggestion
GArbedg 1 year ago
Really nice & interesting picture show about The Hobbit! Thumbs up.
I'm very curious about the coming movie! ... I have the comic trilogy and the audio drama -> great entertainment too.
artfantasies 1 year ago
This is excellent =D
This is indescribable =D
This is better than anything else =D
bigchen000 1 year ago
Oh my gosh this is really amazing. J.R.R Tolkien is one of my favorite authors and you brought the hobbit to life before peter Jackon. It is really incredible.
Animequeen219 1 year ago
0:39 to 1:00 possibly the best piece of music ive ever heard
MrBarbzX 1 year ago
@MrBarbzX Hey I believe from 0:00 to 4:51 was the best =D
bigchen000 1 year ago
very nice, a fitting and inspired tribute. now to watch lotr for the tenth time on my new widescreen!
coughcool72 1 year ago
Awesome!!!!!
mrNaruto818 1 year ago
How can someone not like this? Its such a great piece. Beautiful imagery, great score, just simply beautiful
TheTurowski 1 year ago
this song encuraged me to reread The Hobbit again, just awazing how well it fits to the story in my opinion.
MRhejsan1 1 year ago
Very beautiful. Keep doing what you love, because you are very good at it.
gamesandmusic4life 1 year ago
great i love the LOTR trilogy and i espeachially enjoyed the hobbit good work
stucktommy 1 year ago
now where i've read the book, i like it miles more, just brilliant, when i'm in my bed and can't sleep, i think of the hobbit and his andventures with the dwarfs, thanks pal ...
SThetig 1 year ago 14
It's beautiful. Thank you for sharing. :)
mexnuk 1 year ago
beautiful.
scorpin969 1 year ago
Wow, this is great stuff. Keep up the good work ! :)
salsadance22 1 year ago
if u made this vid ur self ur a f_cking genius
mrtobi7 1 year ago
Wow! just wow! thanks for the message man! we've gotta keep in touch!
pirate7175 1 year ago
I like this soundtrack ,but i like and LOTR (Lord Of The Rings) soundtrack. I wish there was created film "The Hobbit". Thanks.
lolazaurus1 1 year ago
great stuff congrats!!!!
fullellinaras 1 year ago
Perfect, I love your video !!!
soulkeeper2912 1 year ago
It's a good peice of music but for me borders on vamped up 'Chaucer England' rather than fantasy 'Middle Earth'. I do like it, it's just not LOTR.......
bigbeef30 1 year ago
congratulations... very good work!!
love it! =]
david00351 1 year ago
Very very nice. Thanks for PMing me this is wonderful.
kylethedarkn 1 year ago
nice well done i loved it
WOW529 1 year ago
Whoa, this is awesome :D
ROOKI3LINKX 1 year ago
check it in the movies and on google :-) the shire is the land : l Always thougt it was diffrent i thoght hobbiton where the land and the shire was the town
Jokerprodution 1 year ago
@Jokerprodution
lotrDOTwikiaDOTcom/wiki/Main_Page
grear website.
its telll you all you need to know on the lotr and other books made by jrr tolkien
AkaviriDragonlord 1 year ago
i love it !
Kenjihst 1 year ago
this song is really awesome, thank you for sending it!
smeagolfishy 1 year ago
This song is really good. Beautiful actually. Thanks for sending me this. It really puts across the message in the movie. I recently watched it after seeing it maybe 5 years ago when i was 10-11. Almost forgot about the greatest movie trilogy ever made.
fartingtube 1 year ago
concerning hobits:
a hobbit is a small man and is the same kind of creuture like gnome and dwarf,
their from a country in middle earth cald hobbiton.
you might know this: THEIR AWESOME :D
thumb up if your agreed!
Jokerprodution 1 year ago 22
@Jokerprodution
the country is hobbiton? if thought hobbiton was a town/area place and the shire was the whole thing? or is it the other way round
AkaviriDragonlord 1 year ago
@AkaviriDragonlord All i know is, there's definitely times where they say "In alllll of hobbiton"
So i reckon hobbiton is hobbitland and the shire is part of it.
zedooncadhz 1 year ago
@zedooncadhz hobbition is a town in the shire. since you always see the shire in the map.. so shire is like yorkshire in england.. the county and hobbiton is a village
like hobbitown
AkaviriDragonlord 1 year ago
@AkaviriDragonlord ohhh yes i know that yorkshire is a county lad! lol yorkshire born and bred! Yorkshire puds ale and all that :P Yeh i reckon the shire is the biggest one actually cos you're right you do see it on the map as a giant area just called the shire. But if the shire's a county then whats the country? We must plumb the depths of this hobbit mystery!
zedooncadhz 1 year ago
@zedooncadhz
i checked its part of the old kingdom of arnor arnor was founded by isildur's dad and that was in this region of middle of a very large region called Eriador
so its in eriador and more specifically the kingdom of arnor
AkaviriDragonlord 1 year ago
@AkaviriDragonlord yeah maybe your right... il go check it on google now :P
Jokerprodution 1 year ago
@Jokerprodution kugh shire kugh
luukluuk34 1 year ago
@Jokerprodution I thumbs down because I disagreed. They are not like gnomes or dwarfes at all. And they live in the Shire. Hobbiton is just a city-like place.
sixpointneuf 7 months ago
@sixpointneuf what are you talking about? i said they were some kind of mixture, polite and smart like gnomes but can also be strong and barbaric!
Yeah sorry about the Hobbiton thing though, sometimes i confuse them.
Jokerprodution 7 months ago
Very nice piece, well played and athmospheric.
Reminds me of the game called "agony" at the beginning, but is a very nice composition.
Keep up the good work :)
BTW; the kind of cadence and style that you gave to this theme, it suits more as part of the story, instead of being the main theme; just a suggestion; since is very melancholy and introspective, while usually the main themes have a different feeling :)
2frikkincraze 1 year ago
WOW! This is REALLY GREAT! I love it!!! Thanks for sending it to me, you're a really good composer :)
destinymr97 1 year ago
yeah, you could definitely get far with this music. except im not sure it fits the lord of the rings. its really great though. maybe if you add more string instruments such as cello, violin, string bass, viola, etc., and even brass instruments like trumpet, trombone, and any kind of horn like Shore did, it would still sound amazing and it would fit a little better with the lord of the rings, but this is really good.
LProck4everGD1 1 year ago
This is some incredible music. Thank you very much for sending me the link! If you ever feel like selling it as an MP3 or something, let me know - I'd be glad to buy it and support your endeavors! Keep composing, you are very talented.
leadingladybug 1 year ago
wow... really, you're incredible.. it's a great soundtrack!!! thanks for sending! you're an artist <3
SweeneyScissorhands 1 year ago
It's great! Thanks for sending! :)
Snnijp 1 year ago
one word : great !
goofyrockz356 1 year ago
This feels like Howard Shore's style, and kind of a bit of Hans Zimmer thrown in there as well. All I can say is well done Josh. This is a great piece. You should compose more LOTR and HOBBIT related pieces.
leeallen01 1 year ago
Hey this was great. Thank you for informing me of it. You are an excellent composer and hope you write more. I love it, thank you again.
zaz6561 1 year ago
Its wery fasinating to se these pictures they relly bring the LOTRS up again in your spirit and your mind, and it makes you think abaut how truly, the movie has vroght a message, abaut freindship, love and joy..<3
DKVIPSEN 1 year ago
Really touches My soul. Well done my friend. i kind of Love it.
pr0gram1st 1 year ago
Favorited.
ParallelW0rld 1 year ago
Did you record with orchestra or is the sound synthetic?
adfdasfadfdaaaa 1 year ago
Great, I like it very much!
adfdasfadfdaaaa 1 year ago
Amazing ! suitable for a LOTR soundtrack good luck in the future josh best wishes !
ehwfan4life 1 year ago
very nice really you should do something with this^^
riggidiggi 1 year ago
This is very good. Thanks for sending it to me ^.^
QddpprrQ 1 year ago
thanks for sending! it´s a very good track! you really should send it to the a important person, who works with the hole team, which produce the film the hobbit.
i´ll hope my english is not sooo bad. :)
Mrsbabe4u 1 year ago
AMAZING!!!!!
cclelouchfan1000 1 year ago
100000000000000000/5
parangatekutirimikua 1 year ago
this is tooo good. You need to do something with this.
naviejosh 1 year ago
I <3 it! its so good, you should think its from the Lord Of The Rings
cikkirock 1 year ago
@cikkirock the movie
cikkirock 1 year ago
nicely done m8!
ManilaMadDog 1 year ago
dude thanks for telling me to check this out, it brought back memories from when i read the book
Clinto2011 1 year ago
great work, thanks for sending it
RMphan 1 year ago
great stuff.tom bombadill would be very proud
MrGavtheblade 1 year ago
excellent, a couple of parts could be improved but overall this is a great effort and amazing composition :)
rachefrank 1 year ago
love it!!!
mrNaruto818 1 year ago
oh i freaking love this
Qunlord 1 year ago
huh, nice i liked it
creamsoda178 1 year ago
This music is beautiful... why do artists like Danny Elfman become famous when composers such as your self are not yet famous??? Just awesome...
nateisbord2 1 year ago
I love the artwork, but the music is very nice as well, impressive that you composed it yourself.
AngryLoo 1 year ago
wow tnx 4 youre mail yes i enjoy this its nice and the pictures perfect youre good maby i subscribe i dont know yet first youre other vid
luukluuk34 1 year ago
oohh sooo nice!!!! well done! :)
t1908s 1 year ago
it sounds a bit like runescape music but thats just because you don't have an entire orchestrer to play it. you have great talent and should write more you never know you could be the next big name in classical music history good luck and keep going!
noahjell 1 year ago
great job! wow it is really fantastic :D
ljubicaLordmortensen 1 year ago
outstanding indeed :)
MrRalexanderb 1 year ago
Very moving... :)
SaianSitara 1 year ago
difficult to say,that there are better songs....great song, well done !
I´ll put it on, hmh, lets say ...place 3 or 4 in my top 10 ^^ ( it´s not so easily to manage this )
greatings
Hleid 1 year ago
*greetings =P
Hleid 1 year ago
outstanding! Well Done!
mcmantry 1 year ago
If I were to be critical, I would say that this is indeed very theme-like - good for a soundtrack. Movie music doesn't always contain the pop rigidity of "beginning-verse-chorus-verse-bridge-guitarsolo-end-Amen (generic example)". However, I'm sure you're aware of that, and it's hard to make movie music without the scene made for you first of all. IF you were already aware of this, I'll stfu now and leave you alone. Otherwise, that's my advice! Thanks for sharing your talent!
GingerJoberton 1 year ago
Great composition! Really captured the folklore theme.
MRhejsan1 1 year ago
woooooow its great
thanks alot for the personal message
davidwie 1 year ago
Nice music nice pics :D:D
Sergeant1990 1 year ago
congrats first spam mail i actually bother to click on and well thanks for sending me the spam 10 thumbs up if i could
BenFosterification 1 year ago
This is pretty good.
KotorFan97 1 year ago
it was good :)
ilikedogschit92 1 year ago
Wowww this was gorgeous ! A great sound with a sweet and lovely melody. Beautiful. :)
glamourboy69 1 year ago
nice job,
axeljordan1 1 year ago
very soft and subtle music infact it is very beautiful also,.,.,...,when is the hobbit releasing
theViperace 1 year ago
this is great! big LOTR and Hobbit fan it is definitely good!
6buffdude9 1 year ago
love this :)
Leeium 1 year ago
Awesome melody.
TheSensationalMusic 1 year ago
Yes, this is very nice melody. Keep going.
Hunt8849 1 year ago
love this great work man! im adding it onto my favs!
MajorAALAN 1 year ago
very nice
BodyBuilderSteve555 1 year ago
great song :) and theres also a great book written about it
arkantos4dead 1 year ago
Nice
FriendlyFantom 1 year ago
This is really awesome =] the music really parallels the story good job
cutiebirdy95 1 year ago
Thanks for the mail and.. Yes, It's a good song.. But if you look into Howard Shores music from the Lord of the Rings.. he did NOT use the piano.. It gives a diffirent feeling.. But the song is great, but I do not think it fits..
Icefloris 1 year ago
@Icefloris Although he doesn't use much piano in LOTR, Howard Shore still used it. In many pieces it can be heard in the background to give even more emotional effect and in some it even takes the foreground as the main instrument. Speaking of Howard Shore and piano pieces. Have you or anyone reading this, heard his Eclipse score. It's an entirely piano built and sustained score. It is mind-blowingly beautiful, almost as beautiful as the previous New Moon score by Alexandre Desplat.
leeallen01 1 year ago
@Icefloris
This composition has nothing to do with Howard Shore, he just made his own and is nice as is.
2frikkincraze 1 year ago
Sounds awesome. Thankyou for notifying me. :]
Flaphand 1 year ago
It's good man! Keep writing, it's good stuff.
14music94 1 year ago
I like it, I think you're a very talented composer.
I like this music, but the piano sounds a bit strange..
If you work hard, one day you'll maybe be famous :) you could be very successful.
(sorry for my bad english~)
aoixme 1 year ago
piano is sometimes a little piercing.....that doesnt always fit. Maybe work it a little on the computer?
But great piece, really
Kadda1234 1 year ago
Sounds great! I loved it! Thanks for inviting me to listen to it! Thumbs up!
michaelandcarina 1 year ago
Pretty. I like everything but the very beginning... it seems a bit stark to me.
ashleylynnjoan 1 year ago
Very well my friend.
Thanks for sending me the e-mail.
I really enjoyed.
Dragolite 1 year ago
Really nice music..:)
VojvodaMirkoCG 1 year ago
this is awesome,keep up the good work man
MrClubbo 1 year ago
hey dude..thanks for sending me this video..i like it:)
fermerwuvu 1 year ago
wow, I REALLY enjoyed listening to it <3 just GREAT!!!
thx for sending me it
kadddl 1 year ago
Respect this is nice.
Famizen 1 year ago
thanks, dude! it makes me want to read the books again lol
Veo17 1 year ago
wow, thanks for sending! this is soo great, I love it!! =D
it's just awesome, you're awesome!
;) xx<3
Janice3aballadeer 1 year ago 6
Very nice composition :)
I agree, it very much fit the mood.
Hehehe saw your post and came to the video through MEC. Hope to see you there sometime soon.
Arvedui01 1 year ago
WOW...that was amazing
thealexstrikesback 1 year ago
Yeh im glad you sent me the link to this. Its very good
CoasTbeaTs 1 year ago
favorited, hope you make more =)
TheLaElc 1 year ago
*favorited*
PYROFIREMANIAC 1 year ago
wow, AWESOME!
mappoprimo 1 year ago
This is beautiful music, but think that it just isnt proper for this story. This is escentially a song that talks about peace, and in the hobbit there are many thrilling parts. But that's just me. I am no expert. Its my humble opinion.
You are a really good composer, anyway
acroboyargentina 1 year ago
@acroboyargentina
It makes me think of a journey through the mist... as in the parts of the book in-between the action.
whittleddownbattery 1 year ago
love it.
omeagaultimate 1 year ago
I'm lovin' it man thanks for sending it to me!
echoven 1 year ago
Realy good! I love the growing aditude of the song!
migouldspleaklor 1 year ago
Thanks dude, I really needed to escape into a fantasy world right about now.
whittleddownbattery 1 year ago
awesome!
aznboi11218 1 year ago
i could definitely see this in the movie
1995trueman 1 year ago
Banging man. Banging.
tom36450 1 year ago
realmente precioso
manativaldivia 1 year ago
That was... BEAUTIFUL! That was... PERFECT! You should definitely contact the creators of the new movie The Hobbit and submit this piece as soundtrack! It's amazingly right for the mood of the story and would fit like a glove! I'll do some research for you and if I find any way to contact them I'll message you!
IWork4Dessert 1 year ago
Really original and wonderful thank you for private message and invitation to listen this music ; )
Rezkomi 1 year ago
Amazing...Thanks a lot Joshua. I enjoyed and cried listening this song. I can imagine everything in my mind.
Huargo 1 year ago
Love it ^^
SarinhaIris 1 year ago
Wow! This is freaking amazing... you should totally send this in to the ones whos making the Hobbit movie!
iWearCapeIRL 1 year ago
it's New Line Cinema :) i guess they're filming The Hobbit
Krapivina81 1 year ago
Perfectly fits the mood! You should contact NLC, maybe a soundtrack? :)
Krapivina81 1 year ago
@Krapivina81 hey thanks :) sorry, but whats NLC?
futurerocknroll 1 year ago
@futurerocknroll thanks for contacting me on my gmail, love this song
Emil3411 1 year ago
@futurerocknroll he means new line cinema who produce the lotr movies :)
thealexstrikesback 1 year ago
I loved it!
Rocksechelon 1 year ago 7
awesome mate seriosly u are blessed
BeyondGrappling 1 year ago