Monty Are I: Dublin Waltz

[myh45]

were u that bored??

[plas101]

gee an animation like that mustve taken ages haha \;

well done!

[rabbidchipmunk]

Sick bro

[thexxmaine]

This is really good... strange, but really good. You've got talent, I hope you do something in graphic design. p.s this song kicks ass.(:

[MrSideliner]

he looks like Popeye in a power ranger suit lol



[OriginalRave]

Go Go PowerRangers!

[geeksquadfilmz]

Very poorily animated. The lip sync is off and the movement is choppy. Find a new interest.

[starmanexe]

@geeksquadfilmz Meh. Nothing I see on your channel shows me that you can any better. I appreciate constructive criticism, but flat out hate isn't. Perhaps you can do better, I don't know. Personally I don't care. If you want to critic someone's work, go somewhere else.

[seabassmonster]

@starmanexe imho it doesn't seem very off sync at all. It seems very good for the time I'm assuming you put into it. Anyone who says it should have more must not realize how much time and effort it takes to even get one character's animation down well, let alone more. Good job

[xXViicPewsXx]

@geeksquadfilmz Hey dude, check your internet. The sync is perfect at my place and the vid is greatly done. Do it much better yourself, then you can talk [;

[Habeel13]

@geeksquadfilmz Dude, STFU!

[Dragongirl182]

@geeksquadfilmz

I couldn't have done any better so lay off.

They tried and to me its pretty good.

Stop being an ass and go spam people somewhere else.

[gmblr321]

saw them with hawthorne heights they were amazing

[RyokushinYuroshima]

I like this song a lot, the only thing I have about this video is that it didn't come alive like the song does when I close my eyes. It feels more medieval when I hear it, and I can actually imagine the two people dancing in a huge mansion. One guy, a duke, holding a princess dancing with her while another man, a warrior (or something) is jealous. Drinking his heart away and finally he goes up to ask her. That's how I see it. Good animation otherwise!

[MrSideliner]

@RyokushinYuroshima Awesome Idea!

[hollisterdrumboy850]

i saw monty are i, just surrender, punchline, and hawthorne heights and ill have to say monty are i rocked the house and was the best preformence

[wsoxfan1416]

i just saw them last night and i agree, they were great

[avedisdrummer989]

Why is there a Power Ranger on my screen singing a MONTY ARE I song?

[kodocha77]

LOL!!!!!!!!

[kodocha77]

You caught me off guard...that was funny!

[Omgsome1just]

lol this was my first music video i ever watched on youtube. i used to think this was the actual video.

[starmanexe]

haha That's cool. I'd love to send the band a DVD of the video, but for the life of me, I can't find any contact information for them. I'd clean up a little bit of the editing, first, too, but I'd so send it to them.

[LimbStrong93]

my best friend is friends with one of the band members

[bobbryarxcore]

@starmanexe go on their site if you havent already. i emailed them about something once and one of them answered me. i forget which one haha. i think its something like montyareiband@gmail or yahoo. it's on their official site though.

[justmeyep14]

I'm new to them, what other good songs do they have?

can anyone please tell me.

[Omgsome1just]

in this legacy was my favorite and between the sheets. their new album isnt what i expected though, maybe because im not used to listening to the songs

[starmanexe]

I enjoy Castle bound.

[shatteredrift]

@justmeyep14 "Only the Weak" is an amazing song. But I like their entire "Wall of People" album. (Haven't listened to their newer stuff yet.)

[JoePoeMoeFoe]

@justmeyep14 i personally like in this legacy, the stand, and desert

[Xentsuki]

@justmeyep14 Castle Bound, Only the Weak, Tie Off Your Veins, Just in Time, Between the Sheets to name a few. They are good band. =]

[MrSideliner]

@justmeyep14 Break though the Silence

[fightercool4]

the video is cool and pretty well put together i just gotta say that it doesn't really go with the song sorry but i give it a 5/5 for the hard work

[altrocker07]

quite impressive, the lip sync is really good! and you use lighting and camera angles well

also what program do you use for animation/modeling

i use lightwave for all of mine

[starmanexe]

Lightwave this is, as well.

[Schreisoloud]

<3 this song!

[umpm]

this is good it must have taken a lot of harwork

[virgogirl8]

cool!

[Shadowcor]

this song is awesome, the lil dude in the vid sucks, but i mean the animation are awesome!

[starmanexe]

lol I agree. The Dragoon was a throw away character, and at the time the only working model I had when I came up with this idea, so I just ran with it. Came out to mine, and my viewers expectations.

[Murderdoll63]

you're pretty talented. this is awesome!

[fournineoh]

i've done my share of non-commercial 3D animation, and i have to say, wow. (Y)

[starmanexe]

lol I hope that "Wow" is a good one.

[ditzcutie]

omg i finnaly found a good quility version of the song...my favorite!!!!

[RaiganS]

GREAT JOB!!! ^_^ 5/5

i could have never done this, wonderful!

[JaleaNightshade]

That's pretty awesome!

[totocast]

love this song!

your video's pretty rockin' too

*handshake*

[starmanexe]

::handshake back:: Thank you. ^.^

[donutouch]

SPLENDID.

[youmovie08]

great job friend me we should talk

[ShakDevi]

i love this song!!!!! can anyone send it to me?

[tumamacita1]

sounds good(:

my friend Veronica is dancing this song for her waltz for her quincenaria(:

[randomripoff123]

It's really good, but it creeps me out. But hey, a lot of animation does. lol

Anyway, it's really good, and I like the song too.

[XoZOX8]

song's good i don't like the video. couldn't you just put it too pictures but good graphics

[starmanexe]

I COULD have done that but my animation portfolio wouldn't be an animation portfolio, now would it?

[jonjon1219]

yeah man, i totaly agree with you

starman just has sand up his vagina

[starmanexe]

Definitely got me there, Jonjon. Er... Too bad your comments mean nothing to me. :)

[skittlesUYA]

thats insain!!

[MetalDarkElf]

great!! very good!

[Fizzywitch]

You were really good at syncing the lips with the lyrics. I'm a little confused by vid though. Sword toss was cool :D

[starmanexe]

lol... The video was random. I didn't do the proper storyboard... I just went with it.

[ihatetheoldsn]

Yeah, APSALUTELY!

[lolagager]

:S the video is weird but i APSALUTELY LOVE this video!

[pieceoutt]

i love this song and you did a great job!

[xxdyogas1]

This video makes me sad... I dunno why!

[Axeraid]

great vid the song and the animation is awesomexD 5/5

[ariasince94]

Jonjon1219 makes me laugh.

It's so sad that he posts comments like that.

Can't he keep it to himself?

Anyway, I really like the video!

Great work!

And good song choice, this is pretty much my favourite song.

I listen to it about 20 times on repeat.

Nice work. xx

[clove007]

Great job on your 3D animation. You really put a lot of work into this! The reflections, the shadows, the perspective, the changing angles, textures...WOW! Keep up the good work. Thanks for sharing.

[ilovetherain221]

wee i get to see this band on saturday. haha i like the video..the mouth looks a little bit weird tho..hehe. it's allright though!

[beefman1337]

i'm impressed

[BOOMitsus]

great video! make more! :)

[tordack]

that was a sweet video, but that guys face looked wierd...u should have made him a robot, it would've been cooler.

[starmanexe]

Haha that was due to the fact that after I had made him with the helmet covering his mouth, I had to make him with a mouth, and had an hour to do it. XD

[tordack]

Lol, oh well. still, great animation, u rock dude.

[ouderwets]

euhm, yeah, right..

[kakashi1336]

MONTY ARE I ROCKS. great vid too

[Tizzle0207]

jonjon, could you make a video like this? No probably not. You probably sit at home all day on myspace, trying to nurse your little excuse for a social life back to health. Keep your shit to yourself.

Sweet vid, sweet song.

Monty are I kicks ass.

acwagner...props.

[chocobunny257]

whoa.

that was like the most amazing song.

and like the coolest video ever. ;-;

[Toph803]

I saw these guys at Warped Tour in 2005. I debated between seeing them or Pennywise. I like both bands but I'm lad I picked Monty Are I. They were called just "MONTY" at that time. They fucking ROCKED!

[reymysteriofan44]

monty are i fan's arent weird, theres just not enough of them, MONTY ARE I FUCKING ROCKS best band you can find..

[xxkathyy]

i love this song.

=]

[michellemxbelle]

wow good job.

[jonjon1219]

by far one of the dumbest things ive ever seen, u watch WAY to much anime, the eyes are like in the beck of the head, and his upper lip is his nose, if thats wht it evn is. all he does is drop down, wlk, sing to the camera, fall down, walk some more, and sing to the camera some more, pulls out that thing on his back, raises it in the air and bangs his head, then reaches to the sky. this has dumbass written all over it

[starmanexe]

Glad you think so, but it wasn't meant to be anything fancy. If you didn't like it, you didn't hafta watch it. Love to see you do better within the time constraints I had. I apprecitate critism, but make constructive. Those make me improve. That comment, just makes me laugh. Clearly, it is not I who is the dumbass in this one.

[Seonce]

wow, you are truely idiotic for flaming someone who put about 4 months of their life into something like this. I truely think he did a great job with the time it took to do it, you need to keep your damn opinion to yourself if its gonna be nothin but negative bs

[Seonce]

comment was to jonjon1219 btw, quite an idiot

[acwagner8178]

Wow holy shit you are fucking stupid. Sorry this wasn't up to your "standards" but OH FUCKING WELL. Did YOU go to college? What for? Do you have a degree? Lets fucking see it fuck bag! From the looks of it, you didn't make it past 1st grade. So go learn how to spell and keep your goddamn shitty ass comments to yourself. kthnxbai.

[fanattic006]

jonjon1219, are you mental? starmanexe i think you did a great job, way better then this loser could ever hope to do. Monty and I are amazing and the animation is really cool. keep up the good work starmanexe

[deadMENdie]

dude jonjon ur a freakin douche this was a cool vid haha

[leilaxxerror]

whoaaa. you got the mouth movements and reflections and shadows and everything down really well. and this is an amazing song. A+ for you :D

[nmendillo]

i hope this was like... for a grade. cuz it'd be an A+...but if it wasn't for a grade then you need a LIFE. man, MAI fans are fucking weird...

[starmanexe]

lol This was for a grade. I did this as the coup de grais on my portofolio display for my last last before graduation. I had many people knowing what I was working on, but none of them knew it was so big. It was hit.

[geeksquadfilmz]

I know you've worked hard on this and the animation is good, but what is the point of this?..A guy dressed up that stands still and sings?..Maybe try Castle Bound and instead of singing make an actual video.(Not trying to be mean, and sorry if you take it like that)

[starmanexe]

Oh no, lol. The only reason that I chose that character is the that I had already had him made. And I made him sing to try to test my lipsync skills. Also to test different lighting affects, camera angles, and other stuff.

[mightyjo13]

This video is amazing great job!!

[LOZERloser]

what is this done in?

[starmanexe]

Lightwave 3-D 8.0

[LOZERloser]

thats pretty sweet, i use that program. :D

[starmanexe]

Really? How did you get it? Any training?

[LOZERloser]

Im in a technical high school, im being trained in that feild along with post production and 2D animation right now.

im hoping to get it at home soon though. You?

[mikinzie10]

OMG! this rox! u must have tooken a long time 2 make it! its great u should make more! also monty are i is awesome!!!

[wizard5007]

I thought I recognized some Lightwave elements in this animation! Glad someone else already asked the question. I just finished a 3D animation project in Lightwave (7 I believe) for my broadcasting class. I certainly feel your pain. Excellent job on the lip syncing. I didn't have to get into any of that, thank God. Keep up the good work.

[starmanexe]

haha thanks. Lip Sync is not as bad, but it is worth it.

[justjk88]

awesome band+awesome song by awesome band +awesome animation= awesomevideo

yup that pretty much summs it up.

[starmanexe]

Thank you. I spent nearly two months staring at my computer, adjusting the lip sync frame by frame. A total of 1,500 frames. I'm proud of my work, and seein' people like you love it makes it all worth while.

[Ershnill]

Haha thanks. Great video. Loved the ending part. He breaks it down. ;3

[acwagner8178]

love it! good job!!

[Kaihri]

This is really good :D I like how the mouth does go right in sync with the lyrics not missing a momment! Great job!

[horseychic06]

wow this is great....looks like you took a lot of time working on it great job!...its really really good!

[mortsanglant]

I don't even know if I know how long you've been working on this. But it's awesome. His mouth really moves with the words. It's great!