Marcus Foster - I Was Broken - Live HD at Dingwalls, London - November 2011

[tapizz92]

i can hear the "YEAH" from kristen at 00:10 :D

[xxrebelqueen]

@annbatsi1993 lol no one agrees :')

[Cullengirl231]

Well I, for one, am thankfull that twilight introduced me to Rob and kristen. And because of that, I've been introduced to a lot of different types of music and books that I would have NEVER given a second thought before.

Marcus Foster, Sam Bradley and Lee McDougall even Joan jett! they're all are on my favorite list now.

and books like Bel Ami, On the Road and cosmopolis are on my bookshelves already read twice each.

[TheAlexx1981]

Wow, cool how everyone is singing and you can see that Marcus likes it! I was at a show in Cologne one week earlier, but no one was singing there, i wish they did. Only when Marcus sang "You my love" i had to sing some words too, but it was to quiet so everyone heard me, so I had to shut down;)

[leechlover4life]

I like how Rob sings "I Was Broken". It sounded waaaaay more melodious. I love that they sing each other's songs;they're such BFFs!

[MorgeSol]

@holdmeebaby There aren't any, but I was just picturing them during this song from a description someone that saw them said :')

[379437941]

I love how he smiled through the video especially at chorus..I read some tweets yesterday &they said that Marcus was looking at Tom & Sam but especially Robsten &when I saw this& saw Marcus looking at the crowd &laughing my heart was melting..I believe that he was watching Robsten cause this song tie Marcus& Robsten together<3 & for his performance wow he sings great..yeah I came for Robsten but Marcus amazed me

P.S I would love if there would appear a video of Robsten during this wonderful song

[smilyangel013]

i can hear Rob and Kristen shouting at the end..ahh..<3i love reading these comments... Marcus is an amazing artist

[enh0988]

aw he looks so damn proud at the end <3

[msashlyjudd8]

Rob still sings it better lol.

[faster23oth]

haha kristen "Fuck YEAH!" at 0:09! Marcus you are awesome!!! Congratulations for all you've done!!! this video is greattttttt thank you so much!!! 4:12 - 4:36 yeahhhhhhh!

[misstotalyrandom15]

I was at this, it was an amazing moment, highlight of the evening, love this guy :')

[natnat2011100]

Amazing Voice !!! Marcus you rock lad !!!

[SanyaTheShe]

I love Rob and Kristen, and they DID bring me here! I'm proud to say it! ...But that doesn't mean that I don't like Marcus' music. In fact, I simply LOVE IT! I wouldn't have stayed here, and listened to this song for about 100 times, if I didn't. And it's great that ppl come here cuz of R&K, twilight etc. That way amazing musician-Marcus Foster will get attention that he deserves! I CAME HERE FOR ROB AND KRISTEN, AND STAYED FOR MARCUS! FUCK YEAH!

[carissimachrissy]

Kristen did sing along. <3

[112myboys]

I for one am greatful for Rob introducing me to Marcus. Marcus has an amazing voice and with every song I hear him sing, I fall in love with his talent further. This song is soulful and so beautiful. They way the audience was singing with him was just wonderful. Marcus you deserve the accolades!!

[hadimajzoub]

this is better than the original version

[WOQAZ]

i really love this song!!! is amazing

[hadimajzoub]

SO BEAUTIFUL!!!!! 

[00Cisca00]

what a feeling it must be for a musician, to have people singing along like that. he's just too good.

[shamil222]

Aw that was awesome! I really like that song! And it's a plus that RobstenDreams was there!

[jessjeda]

So amazing. Both him and hearing the audience sing with him. I got all choked up. loll He looked so happy. :')

[metumble5101]

He has got the most amazing voice and talent.

And all the people commenting about Robsten should be ashamed of themselves.

Freakin Marcus Foster was there! Who cares about anyone else??

[jessjeda]

@metumble5101 who cares how they got here? They're still listening aren't they? I, for one, want everyone in the world to hear him. I don't care how it happens. It *is* possible to be fans of all three and not take anything away from any of the individuals. And he sounds so amazing I doubt they're missing it. :)

[metumble5101]

@jessjeda I don't really care how they got here. I just fear that they don't really appreciate his music. It's not really surprising that they are spamming the comment-wall of "I was broken" is it? I just start asking myself if they even know his other songs! All those mindless, inappropriate comments! Some of them don't even write in full sentences! It's just not normal! I want them to show some respect to the musician. I do want everyone to listen. But I want them to do it the right way. ;)

[aimzers]

@metumble5101 - Ill give my opinion. I for one have never heard of his other songs, but because of what happened the other night, I came on here to view videos and ended up downloading his album on itunes. So.... there yah go.

[jessjeda]

@metumble5101 part of the reason they're spamming this video is because of fan accts of R/K singing along and having fun during this song along with the rest of the audience. And Kristen was IN the video for I Was Broken so of course they know this song. Maybe they didn't know his other songs. Maybe they will after this. Not all of them will like his music. But all of them listened. You don't start OUT respecting a musician's talent. You learn to respect it if it touches you.

[metumble5101]

@jessjeda that is true of course. but it just doesn't change how I feel about those comments. In general I believe that actors and musicians should not be treated like zoo animals. And those comments I read here not only don't belong to a Marcus Foster vid but could also be about some cute little pandabears. The audience sang along! THAT is magical. not some actress who happened to be there. a little of topic: Have you seen the other I was broken video? That is pretty magical too ;)

[jessjeda]

@metumble5101 I do get where you're coming from. A few of the comments are.....I don't even know. But the vast majority are just using this space to express their happiness about what happened that night. I've been a fan of MF for years and have learned that they're just excited about what they love not disrespectful. I might not like all of it but I'm still so happy that people who wouldn't have heard him are hearing him b/c of Rob and Kristen. And yes, I actually like the other video more. :)

[metumble5101]

@jessjeda he's got some acting talent in that one :) I guess I'll just try to ignore as I will never understand. twilight will fade with time but the music is there to stay. I have a good feeling for the Foster, all fingers crossed ;)

[metumble5101]

I mean just look at the comments. How many do you count that are actually about the real star of that eve?

[annbatsi1993]

@metumble5101 I soooo agree with you! Marcus Foster ftw! Who cares who was there and who wasn't? ;) It was HIS show, not those particular one's who were there! :D

[tintinlundgren95]

this is such an amazing song!

[London2521]

love this. 200 + people singing back to you must be so amazing. You deserve it Marcus!

[tumefascines]

1:01 - 1:07 Do you think it's Robsten's scream?

[hadimajzoub]

@tumefascines you are so fucking a obbsessive so do i =)

[tumefascines]

@hadimajzoub yeeeeeep. twihard forever!

[rhiandotra]

He's so fucking amazing singing his fucking amazing song

[carolmsaantos]

crying, thanks robsten!

[MollHasThePower]

i'm here for marcus foster, not kristen stewart and robert pattinson!

[wolfgirlbabe]

omg I wish some people would stfu about robsten in the comments. if you came to the guys show just to see them and not marcus foster then why go at all? seriously grow up. why are rob and kristen's personal lives so important to you anyway?

[MorgeSol]

Crying because it's so beautiful, Crying from picturing Rob and Kristen and crying because i should have/ could have so easily been there... !

[holdmeebaby]

@MorgeSol  where are pic of robsten?

[726rach]

Rob and Kristen were there together (pictures), and several people who were there as well said Kristen sang along to this song <3

[bnwlondon]

Where are Robsten?

[AlineCorintiana]

I was Broken! <3

[TheLoveeverybody]

oh god rob was there and this makes me cry.

[matiildaengstrom]

GOOSEBUMPS. <3

[miadelacruz]

i luv seeing and hearing marcus singing coz i know rob sings like him too..i see a glimpse of rob in him..love the Brit pack

[miadelacruz]

robs version was more deep and giving me lots of goosebumps

[juh0741]

this song... OMG! is so... I don't know, touching... owwww!!! could appear at Robert and Kristen singing, but still is worth...

[uniqueJoGee]

Imagining Rob and Kristen singing along. Don't mind me, I'm just having a moment. Gah this song slays my heart at the best of times.. Just going to find a corner and weep. No biggie.

[Lori29J]

I truly <3 this song!!!

[Leaveatrail07]

Thinking that Kristen was singing along makes this magical :')

[priradcliffe]

He's absolutely amazing, I wish he could come to Brazil, I'd love to listen something like that live

[FanRobstenRus]

WOW!!!!! AMAZING!!! I love this song!!!

[milousoda]

That was beautiful. :) <3