your seriously idiots. this is the complete OPPOSITE of racisim. He talks about how the government & police all throughout america are racist and backs it up with statistics, he says nothing racist himself. Learn to fucking listen. All you dumbasses.
OMG! Ron Paul uttered something the anti-white media, liberals, Jews, blacks, etc. consider "racist!" My god, how 'horrible', how 'evil', to stand up for white American rights, interests, etc.
@SansP3R Yes, except for those aligned over the common cause of personal liberty for everyone. It is difficult to find a more disparate group than Ron Paul supporters. Isn't this, after all, what freedom is about? Respecting those who have different viewpoints so long as we all agree to live as civilized people (no initiation of any form of violence against others)?
@Laughingblades So if this is hiding and covering up Ron Paul's racist past, where are you examples of what was covered up? Why does it seem enough to you to suggest racism without providing the slightest example?
Just keep watching the Pro-Ron Paul propaganda his PR campaign pre-screened for you and put out there under various shill channels, don't research any deeper than that, if you do you may find that OpBlitzkrieg exposed connections with neonazis, or that he has a history of racist and neo-confederat rhetoric, that the charges of racism are rooted in far more than just the news letters, which he edited & proof read on the weekends and even signed a few by hand btw watch?v=NeFpEqaQvdo
Why would anyone with half a brain cell put a title like this to the clip...come on, if you don't like Dr Paul fine, you must love the laws that keep you on your knees or maybe you are a paid troll. (If they exist) I like to think you are just a confused, bitter person with an axe to grind and when you hear sense spoken you do not know any other way to react but......in this sad way.
@johnnyshamma Maybe you're too stupid to understand that this is intended to flood out any information showing that Ron Paul is in fact a racist and throw people off the trail while putting to ease those who have doubts.
It's a propaganda tactic, they are trying to ignore, hide, and cover up Ron Paul's real racist past with stuff like this.
I really hope people aren't actually interpreting this as being racist. Listen to what Ron is say. Pay attention to the context. Don't be a bigot and label someone the moment they use keywords typically found in sterotypes
@saftywireplyers: Start with "like to believe" but I know it's not true. Pres Obama disavowed Rev Wright, his alleged Kenyan birth and being a Muslim to no avail. Being against funds used in the drug war is not being for Blacks. Paul believes property owners have the right to discriminate and so is against the civil rights act, and knowing one or two Blacks does not mean you are not racist. Lastly, you lied about the subject of the video, typical Paul obfuscation you consider legitimate.
Ron Paul wants to get the goverment out of your life plain and simple IF you want to be a drug attic so be it IF you want to quit hey he'll help you. just do it in the privacy of your own home and dont cause harm to anyone else SO HOW IS THAT RACIST
When the new world order health care comes into play your going to give the goverment 13.9% tax when you sell your home in 2013 and the way that Fanny May trashed the value of your home that means if your lucky to make 5% profit on your home your going to give the goverment the 5% and come up with the balance of 8.9%
HEY How much they paying tou guys to spin RON PAULS WORDs because you definatly did not watch this vidio Your ether being payed to be stupid or your just RON PAUL BASHING I guess Its Cool to say YESS MASSSA to OBAMA and masters the new world order!!! Get EDUCATED FOOL RON PAUL may be your last chance to be able to enjoy freedom I guess you enjoy visting your familys in jail because he got busted with a joint
Fight for life my as !!! If you kill someone your ass should fry !!! Period !! You kill a policeman your ass goes to the front on the line !! Fuck Ron Paul !!!!
God is the only one that can change this country ! he have to first touch the hearts & mind of each leader. and just maybe there hearts will chance, without the racism and other ism's that follows.
Ron Paul is very bad for this country ! if you don't like that,thats to bad ! not everyone loves Ron Paul,everyone are entitled to there opion.thats what makes this country so unique. But these RonBots act so childish,the second you disagree or don't like Ron Paul,they start with the attacks & Name calling ! that show there igorances,they just need to grow up ! but there are also good people i guess that supports him that values everyones opion. good luck to them ! I'M VOTING NOPAUL 2012 !
Oooh what a racist. If you speak candidly about "race" in the U.S. you are seen as a racist. I love Ron Paul but I disagree. I grew up with Jim Crow and that lunacy was the creation of state and local government. Also, if the federal govt. is so bad, what about the inefficiency, cronyism, and corruption of local government. Hell, as an example, restaurants here are required by law to have background music! That's typical of local regulations.
this problem still remains, ron paul has said he doesn't support civil rights legislation, he would eliminate programs for the poor, food stamps, welfare, etc... he would limit the ability of the federal government to enforce the bill of rights on states...
now, how can you say you are against policies that hurt minorities, but want to eliminate policies that protect the rights of minorities? he's talking out both sides of his mouth.
Sir, you are deeply in error regarding the policies of Ron Paul. He is a Constitutionalist, Our of all the candidates, he is the BIGGEST advocate of civil rights, the bill of rights, and the personal liberties of individuals.
@HorusNoon ~ i guess you didn't really read my comment, i explained the libertarian contradiction between wanting constitutional freedoms and liberties while dismantling the means to protect them.
don't you realize we have been going in the libertarian direction for the last 30 years with deregulation, privatization, and lower taxes? you really think going further in the same direction will make things better? i agree with paul on some issues, but he's ideologically extreme.
@HorusNoon ~ the bailout saved a failed private market, everything since has been a nightmare, we should have made all those who caused it accountable, but libertarian boys ron and rand don't want regulations, and that's pretty much what we got.
the last 30 years have been deregulation, privatization, and tax cuts. taxes haven't been this low in decades, government property (the commons) is being sold in record amounts, and regulatory agencies are routinely gutted.
@HorusNoon ~ you don't listen very well do you? and you can make your own definitions all day long, doesn't mean squat.
and yes, the "free market" failed. again. altho you fake libertarian/conservatives have tried to spread the fannie/freddie horseshit for 4 years. wall street, real estate, and the banks were deregulated, (according to the libertarian mantra) and promptly took down the world economy. libertarian/conservatives have gone into fantasy land trying to rewrite this truth.
@tomitstube I think you would have a very different opinion if you did some research on these programs. First of all, these programs (Welfare, Food Stamps, Affirmative Action) DO NOT help the poor, they keep them in poverty! Please watch:
Thomas Sowell - Welfare
Thomas Sowell - In the right direction (Parts 1 - 6)
Re: I think you would have a very different opinion if you did some research on these programs. First of all, these programs (Welfare, Food Stamps, Affirmative Action) DO NOT help the poor, they keep them in poverty! Please watch:
Thomas Sowell - Welfare
Thomas Sowell - In the right direction (Parts 1 - 6)
@DSuper3 I'm a single mom [3 kids]. 5 years ago I left a violent situation to give my kids stability & healthier options. After leaving my ex, I was in a financial crisis. I took liberty in using Welfare & food stamps to get back on my feet. I used the programs for 2-3 yrs & I'm no longer using them. They were beneficial & didn't keep me in poverty. My family is healthy in all aspects. I believe in small gov't & the existence of these programs within the State's govern, not the Fed gov't.
@hma terpiece85, so true !!! then he walks out of the CNN interveiw, that have made him look very guility just right there along ! then he have said a few things that have made him look like a racist. People who supports Ron Paul should really look at some of those things that he have said. things that he have supported in the past & now,not to long ago he even have said that he would over turn some of the civilrights. then you have his documents from the past. Plus connections with hate groups
he didn't know of approve or write letter with his name in the title? Then why is he not bringing suit against those who used his name without permission? Hmm makes you think huh? No of course not because Con Paul supporters do not think they just drink his anarchist kool aid. He talks about treating people that are sick but then says the government should let you die. he is as big of a flip flopper as the rest of them. Hopefully after this election he will have passed on before the next one.
Voting machines are hacked; Vote by absentee ballot to make sure there is a paper trail of your vote that can be RECOUNTED and ensure your vote is not STOLEN by some computer program! Then if there is any discrepancy, we can compare what they say Ron Paul received and what he really received!
@DoubroDoubro you are the fucking igonrant one, bitch !!! you attack people who disgree with your hero Ron Paul. I have seen your other comments to other people who don't agree or like Ron Paul. if you like him fine ! but don't attack others who think differently then you do. it really makes you look very stupid. so don't drink so much of that Ron Paul Kool-Aid, Kool-Aid man !!!
@RepublicansAreNazis Who ever said I was pro paul, dumbass? I just don't want that kenyan running in office another term. The last thing our country needs is more trillions being added in debt. If you back Obama for after everything he has done to this country, then you are a misinformed moron and education is what you need.
@gamefreak1000000 number one, bitch ! you are showing how ingorant you are by the fucking name calling with that stupid racist remark by call obamo a Kenyan. want you go somewhere and suck one of your KKKonservative friends dick you racist bitch !!! and stop being a fucking troll !!!
@RepublicansAreNazis I doubt you even know what a troll is you stupid lout. How am I racist for calling Obama a "Kenyan?" He is a Kenyan. It's not racist if it's true. Second, he is anti American. Notice how our debt ceiling is at 14 TRILLION?! Since your mind is the size of a pea (like all other Obama supporters), let me show you just how big the number is.
14,000,000,000,000
If you can count, that's 14 digits. That is how much money we owe China. So tell me, still voting for the Kenyan?
@gamefreak1000000 How is it true he is from Kenya? He is American accept it. He was not born in Kenya nor does he live there. Yes Obama is solely responsible for a debt that Nixon started Reagan continued and Bush 1&2 put into over drive. Only Clinton had a balanced budget with an outlook of a surplus. Do you know what a surplus is? No of course not you only know words like socialist and whatever other big boy words you have heard on Rush.
@gamefreak100000 u r the common Pea Brain RepubliTARD.That don't know shit u r the one that really need to educate yourself.Being a retard & a racist is a very dangerous mix.u stupid misinformed fox news neo nazi con fool.Obama is a United States citizen.U must have been sleeping during bush term;Bush have lefted this shit. plus the debt ceiling don't have a dam thing to do with anything.bush's barrowing for china for war & 778 billion giveaway to the rich,each year. u r misinformed like Hannity
@RepublicansAreNazis Plus you are making yourself look very stupid if you think that Obama is a Kenyan. his father is from Kenyan. Hawaii is where Obama was born. do your reseach.Even the the most retarded Reichwinger,Ann Coulter knows that Obama is Born here in the United States.You are just being bias & racist just because you don't like him or black people. you will never amid that. because you are a fool, racist & asshole, to really know anything. Calling Obama a Kenyan is a code, you racist
@gamefreak1000000 Raceist! Just accept it that you so insecure with an intelligent african american that you resort to youtube to spread your hate and fear.
Okay okay okay hold up. Seriously. How the heck is Ron Paul racist? How can anyone get anything related to racism from this video? Are people even listening to the words he's saying??
Whilst Ron Paul says a lot of great words, let us not forget how many great words Obama said and that he has been about as helpful as a turd. (Smoking pot is not a disease Ron it is a choice). Unfortunately, RP calls himself a libertarian, these wankers are not helping. The only liberty that so called "libertarians" seek to defend is the liberty of the rich to take advantage of the poor. Socialism is the way forward. RP will not be able to make any real changes and will end up a turd like Obama.
@HelmetBlissta Ron Paul has a 30+ year track record of consistency in his ideology. You are a moron to compare that with a slimy Pol like Obama who can't even say he heard the racism at his church for 20 years straight. Obama had 2 yrs in Congress before he got the JOB, due to the color of his skin. He is our first affirmative acton president... didn't have the character, or consistency to be Pres... just filled the quota.
or republicans.. He has the best anti-war voting record of any congressmen in the last 30 years bar none.. By far not even close.. He is the ONLY congressmen, republican or democrat, who has accuretly predicted the economic crisis from A to Z.. better than any economist in the country. IN fact he is the best economist in the country.. He is a real statesmen. Same message for 30 years.. Ho look up his vidoes from the 80s predicting the economic crisis. I can go on and on with this if you want..
aginst ending Birthright Citizenship?? well that's not that big of a deal, maybe we should do something about those who intentionally come here for one day to have their baby born here so they can have US citizenship. We're the only nation that does that.. It's not unreasonable and "anti-liberal" to look into that..
You know what you should be talking about?? I'll tell you.
You should be praisiing Ron Paul for being the BEST anti-war candidate among ALL Congressmen, whether they be, Dems
Unfortunately,to become president Ron Paul has to reach more people outside his regular base, survive a rigged election and then avoid being assassinated. I hope he is successful but the odds are against him.
Douchebag serial racist and New-Nazi idol Ron Paul was a real failure in Congress. Why didnt he run for Governor or President of Iran? Since hes so smart, he would have won in a landslide so he could try out his dumbass theories
I love the title! I love Ron Paul and I am a black man. Black people and ALL people, listen to what this man has to say and you will not walk but run to vote for him.
Everything he said is about how unfair things are and how there needs to be equal justice for everyone. Under what possible definition is that racist?
hes not racist hes realistic am latin but what he say is true most black and latuin are drugs users and dealers so dont blame him for telling the truth
@MegaChelsea25 Every non-american I've heard speak about our political process of recent feels the same. It's not just America that needs Ron Paul... the whole world needs him to end the war mongering that's going on.
He is not "Racist". He is actually the only candidate who praised Martin Luther King so loudly in this ignorant media......(good to see that everything is turning to its real side)......Ron Paul 2012
How is this a racist rant? He's taking a stance against laws that unfairly affect black people & minorities in general!!! Damn People are stupid!!! He's trying to stop these stupid drug laws that are totally racist. I'm a half black Latino & I'm voting for Ron Paul because I know he's not racist!!! I'd like to hear one of these cock sucking Neo-Cons say Martin Luther King & Rosa Parks are their heroes? They wouldn't because they're scared that their racist base wouldn't like it. Ron Paul 2112!!!
@Conquistador2112 It definatly wasn't. I think that the title was tongue-in-cheek, or it was to get people's attention and compel them to watch it. Make sure you register in time if you want to vote in your primary though.
@FieldMarshalB Yeah, I realized that a few minutes after I went off about it and felt like an idiot LOL!!! I'm going to vote for Ron Paul in our primary & the general election for sure.
People, use common sense. The video title was clearly IRONIC. No, it's not racist, that was the uploader's point. I'm not even a Ron Paul supporter and I could see it.
@DarkEmergence You're probably right but I guess we're a little hyper sensitive because were tired of him being branded a racist when his policies and this video clearly indicate that he's not.
@xMaXiMuSx Not that you were the person who asked or that you're actually interested, but I'm pro-choice, believe in healthcare and social programs, against ending Birthright Citizenship, for minimum wage. You know, Liberal policies. I can't list my entire political leaning in 500 characters so I'll just say I agree with him on somethings, but he goes against my political leanings in many areas. Alright, officer?
Ok Ron Paul might disagree with you a little bit on the abortion issue.. HE believes in heatlh care too.. Who doesnt?? LoL what a stupid thing to say, it's how health should be provided..
Our social programs will collapse if we continie these inflationary policies and dont get our budget in orders.. Dollap collapse is inevitable.. There are biggger issues that need to be dealt with like the federal reserve and the monetary system.. We need to go back to sound money..
I'm black and I don't find anything he said in this video to be racist at all. He is bringing up facts about obvious social injustices in our country that most, if not all, politicians refuse to even acknowledge.
Some black people are addicted to baiting the race issue and I think it is profoundly sad because it reveals that THEY are in fact the racist who is creating phantom justifications for their anti human illness. The term 'racism' covers a variety of behaviors not the least of which is the dynamic of black people who are obsessed with looking for people who don't like them. I think life would render more rewards if those people went looking for people who are color blind and acknowledged spirit.
@thewhisperingeagle You do realize your comment wasn't only not color blind, but after viewing the video, it's clear you have some hangup with black people that you were obsessed with getting out.
i can only say that i was dem i will not vote rep but if Ron Paul would run independent i will vote for him but i cannot or will not vote for a traitor Obama signed the wrong thing NDAA he's a traitor
@SuperMax328 Yes. Obama is a traitor along with the rest of congress, both dem & rep who voted & signed the NDAA into law. I would suggest changing your stance on voting for Ron Paul regardless of the Rep. banner. He is the 1 that is bringing back what the party use to stand for, upholding the constitution and civil liberties for all mankind. I am an independent myself and will 4 vote Dr. Paul and I would encourage you to consider it to not let the traitors win!
If Ron Paul is not racist that's find, but I think we need a better explanation for the racist articles that were written in his newsletters under his name.
@mansamusa2012: I would like to know why you feel that there needs to be an explaination. Just like a magazine has several different people writing stories for the magazine Ron has said that it was someone else that wrote their opinion on the news letter. If it is so important than why doesn't the mainstream media find the original author? You see it isn't important enough to find out the whole truth. The mainstream media just wants to pin something that happened many years ago on Ron Paul.
@bond519 You made an excellent point. From a black person's perspective you must understand that so many white people have smiled in our face but behind closed doors they're someone else.
@mansamusa2012 He was the publisher & wrote the financial section, there were other writers on the newsletters and he was not the editor. The main stream media has got people twisted over this and they keep bringing this back up because it is the only thing they think they have on him, it is just not truth. This video should be enough to prove that he is not a racist. Dr. Paul's record speaks for itself, he is a just, fair, and honest man, very rare in politics. Embrace him.
Ron Paul! The ONLY politician who speaks honestly and makes so much sense to me. Let's get behind him! Please! For once can we not be afraid to vote for someone out of the mainstream! Ron Paul, I Love You!
US congresswoman Cynthia McKinney has come out and blamed the pro-Israel Lobby in America (AIPAC, ADL, ZOA, etc) for ruining her political career. While in congress she refused to sign the pro-Israel pledge and took a pro-Palestinian stance. Because of this, McKinney said “war was declared” on her by the Jewish lobby. In 2009 she told TIU's Ognir that “more than 99% of Congress work for Pro Zionist Israeli interests.”
I have gotten a good laugh looking at these comments from people who don't realize this is a 'gotcha' title to reel you in.
Hey, dumbasses - GOTCHA!
jilrita 8 hours ago
your seriously idiots. this is the complete OPPOSITE of racisim. He talks about how the government & police all throughout america are racist and backs it up with statistics, he says nothing racist himself. Learn to fucking listen. All you dumbasses.
hamburgler 8 hours ago
Yup this youtube account is funded by the feds!
TheCast209 13 hours ago
When he was a doctor he had black patients and even sparred them medical bills are certain points
chazzybadazz 13 hours ago
OMG! Ron Paul uttered something the anti-white media, liberals, Jews, blacks, etc. consider "racist!" My god, how 'horrible', how 'evil', to stand up for white American rights, interests, etc.
LONG LIVE 'RACISM!'
Veritas699 3 days ago
no racist comments hit my ears and i am Wide awake
POUIUIHUGGF 3 days ago
Your all fuckin' dumb go back to high school and learn to listen..
Bobdylan2889 4 days ago
dont see hows this is racist
bridget783 4 days ago
change the GODDAMN title, its misleading to this saint.
JakRusslo 5 days ago
SNAP!
hangtime911 5 days ago
ron paul is 2012
TheBlaster814 5 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
LIKE THIS:
Here are five sensible ways to make Dr. Ron Paul the nominee this August:
1. When your state has a caucus or primary, vote for him.
2. Go to his website and either donate directly to his cause or purchase stuff from his store.
3. Get at least ten friends or family members to vote for him.
4. Frequently wear Ron Paul attire or carry a campaign sign out in public. Tell others why you support him when they ask.
5. Copy this message and paste it to every YouTube video you watch.
badgermushroomskater 6 days ago
Confusing Title. It should have read, "Ron Paul argues with racist."
bmccoll505 6 days ago
i see what you did there
findjairo 1 week ago
Its racist idiots clearly people do things to not look racist what the hell is he just talkin about blacks for all people need help
Iwritemzk 1 week ago
hes not racist fools corporate media brainwashes you fools
JeanKmr 1 week ago
I'm confused about the racism... I just don't see it.
ZombieKillerThor 1 week ago
where daehell was he racist what he said is true
Mr2quick1 1 week ago
I see no racism here.
Ischmitie 1 week ago
@SansP3R Yes, except for those aligned over the common cause of personal liberty for everyone. It is difficult to find a more disparate group than Ron Paul supporters. Isn't this, after all, what freedom is about? Respecting those who have different viewpoints so long as we all agree to live as civilized people (no initiation of any form of violence against others)?
runr100 2 weeks ago
Vote Ron Paul 2012!
DEM0N0FTHEN0RTH 2 weeks ago
How is this racist?
TheAcenck 2 weeks ago 2
@TheAcenck It's not, but partisans are so inclined to follow their party they're more like lemmings than people.
SansP3ur 2 weeks ago
He actually defended Blacks here, those who are calling him racists are blind to reality.
ellelaby123 2 weeks ago 3
STAND UP FOR RON PAUL.....HE IS NOT A RACIST....
nelly81842 3 weeks ago 4
HE IS NOT A RACIST. HE THINKS THAT BLACKS ARE TREATED UNFAIRLY.
nelly81842 3 weeks ago 3
@Laughingblades So if this is hiding and covering up Ron Paul's racist past, where are you examples of what was covered up? Why does it seem enough to you to suggest racism without providing the slightest example?
arthurneddysmith 3 weeks ago
Just keep watching the Pro-Ron Paul propaganda his PR campaign pre-screened for you and put out there under various shill channels, don't research any deeper than that, if you do you may find that OpBlitzkrieg exposed connections with neonazis, or that he has a history of racist and neo-confederat rhetoric, that the charges of racism are rooted in far more than just the news letters, which he edited & proof read on the weekends and even signed a few by hand btw watch?v=NeFpEqaQvdo
Laughingblades 3 weeks ago
Why would anyone with half a brain cell put a title like this to the clip...come on, if you don't like Dr Paul fine, you must love the laws that keep you on your knees or maybe you are a paid troll. (If they exist) I like to think you are just a confused, bitter person with an axe to grind and when you hear sense spoken you do not know any other way to react but......in this sad way.
johnnyshamma 3 weeks ago
@johnnyshamma Maybe you're too stupid to understand that this is intended to flood out any information showing that Ron Paul is in fact a racist and throw people off the trail while putting to ease those who have doubts.
It's a propaganda tactic, they are trying to ignore, hide, and cover up Ron Paul's real racist past with stuff like this.
Laughingblades 3 weeks ago
I really hope people aren't actually interpreting this as being racist. Listen to what Ron is say. Pay attention to the context. Don't be a bigot and label someone the moment they use keywords typically found in sterotypes
oldschoolrulz 3 weeks ago
he seems like a sensible guy.
(i live in australia, but if we had a candidate like that i'd for sure vote for him/her)
taffysaur 3 weeks ago
the smalled minority is the individual
MirageScience 3 weeks ago
OMG HE'S SO RAYCISS
Morrakiu 3 weeks ago 14
@Morrakiu where is racism in here?
ribashacker 1 week ago
youtube.com/watch?v=uRVp63Ui0K8
OneTruth4Life 3 weeks ago
Ron Paul leads the way music video is really good
OneTruth4Life 3 weeks ago
Great video, thanks for posting. Check out this cool and catchy video on Ron Paul and some issues he raises:
OneTruth4Life 3 weeks ago
Ron Paul 2012
rahmizzle84 3 weeks ago
He stands up for minorities and then is seen as a racist. What an Orwellian pile of garbage we live in.
ItsAllAboutGuitar 4 weeks ago
Ron Paul 2012
princessvaladez 1 month ago
PLEASE FEEL FREE WHILE YOU STILL CAN TO TRY AND SPIN AQOTES FROM THIS VIDIO I'll BE MORE THAN HAPPY TO EDUCATE YOU FURTHER
saftywireplyers 1 month ago
@saftywireplyers: Start with "like to believe" but I know it's not true. Pres Obama disavowed Rev Wright, his alleged Kenyan birth and being a Muslim to no avail. Being against funds used in the drug war is not being for Blacks. Paul believes property owners have the right to discriminate and so is against the civil rights act, and knowing one or two Blacks does not mean you are not racist. Lastly, you lied about the subject of the video, typical Paul obfuscation you consider legitimate.
NuBN2471 3 weeks ago
Ron Paul wants to get the goverment out of your life plain and simple IF you want to be a drug attic so be it IF you want to quit hey he'll help you. just do it in the privacy of your own home and dont cause harm to anyone else SO HOW IS THAT RACIST
saftywireplyers 1 month ago
When the new world order health care comes into play your going to give the goverment 13.9% tax when you sell your home in 2013 and the way that Fanny May trashed the value of your home that means if your lucky to make 5% profit on your home your going to give the goverment the 5% and come up with the balance of 8.9%
saftywireplyers 1 month ago
HEY How much they paying tou guys to spin RON PAULS WORDs because you definatly did not watch this vidio Your ether being payed to be stupid or your just RON PAUL BASHING I guess Its Cool to say YESS MASSSA to OBAMA and masters the new world order!!! Get EDUCATED FOOL RON PAUL may be your last chance to be able to enjoy freedom I guess you enjoy visting your familys in jail because he got busted with a joint
saftywireplyers 1 month ago
propaganda! ron paul is playing black w/ KKK stats! please: blacks on drugs, blacks in jail. THAT IS ALL he thinks of blacks
tamramb 1 month ago
HOW IS THIS RACIST???? morons
FreeHeathen 1 month ago
@FreeHeathen is sarcasm -_-
obviously the point of the vid is that ron paul is not racist
darckjo 3 weeks ago 2
Fight for life my as !!! If you kill someone your ass should fry !!! Period !! You kill a policeman your ass goes to the front on the line !! Fuck Ron Paul !!!!
Bullet2551 1 month ago
Ron Paul rolls right over this type of propaganda. JOIN THE REVOLUTION
ordocaelum 1 month ago
@RepublicansAreNazis There is no god, and your grammar is abominable.
that1commandment 1 month ago
God is the only one that can change this country ! he have to first touch the hearts & mind of each leader. and just maybe there hearts will chance, without the racism and other ism's that follows.
RepublicansAreNazis 1 month ago
Ron Paul is very bad for this country ! if you don't like that,thats to bad ! not everyone loves Ron Paul,everyone are entitled to there opion.thats what makes this country so unique. But these RonBots act so childish,the second you disagree or don't like Ron Paul,they start with the attacks & Name calling ! that show there igorances,they just need to grow up ! but there are also good people i guess that supports him that values everyones opion. good luck to them ! I'M VOTING NOPAUL 2012 !
RepublicansAreNazis 1 month ago
war on drugs or war on drug users?
cbjgdicad1 1 month ago
So you want cookie cutter politicians like we have had for so long? Liars who say what they think we want to hear. Ron Paul-2012!
sweet161402 1 month ago
Save us Ron Paul!
kedanna 1 month ago
Oooh what a racist. If you speak candidly about "race" in the U.S. you are seen as a racist. I love Ron Paul but I disagree. I grew up with Jim Crow and that lunacy was the creation of state and local government. Also, if the federal govt. is so bad, what about the inefficiency, cronyism, and corruption of local government. Hell, as an example, restaurants here are required by law to have background music! That's typical of local regulations.
hamnose 1 month ago
this actually proves me wrong about ron paul.
this problem still remains, ron paul has said he doesn't support civil rights legislation, he would eliminate programs for the poor, food stamps, welfare, etc... he would limit the ability of the federal government to enforce the bill of rights on states...
now, how can you say you are against policies that hurt minorities, but want to eliminate policies that protect the rights of minorities? he's talking out both sides of his mouth.
tomitstube 1 month ago
@tomitstube
Sir, you are deeply in error regarding the policies of Ron Paul. He is a Constitutionalist, Our of all the candidates, he is the BIGGEST advocate of civil rights, the bill of rights, and the personal liberties of individuals.
DO YOUR HOME WORK!!
HorusNoon 1 month ago
@HorusNoon ~ i guess you didn't really read my comment, i explained the libertarian contradiction between wanting constitutional freedoms and liberties while dismantling the means to protect them.
don't you realize we have been going in the libertarian direction for the last 30 years with deregulation, privatization, and lower taxes? you really think going further in the same direction will make things better? i agree with paul on some issues, but he's ideologically extreme.
tomitstube 1 month ago
@tomitstube
Sir/Madam,
You state: "don't you realize we have been going in the libertarian direction for the last 30 years..."
This is laughable... do you realize we've recently had massive bailouts/stimulus, gov't healthcare, and almost complete internet censorship???
You call that Libertarian???
Libertarian = Protecting Personal Liberty
Ron Paul has a non-interventionist foreign policy = STRONG NATIONAL DEFENSE
Take a class at a University for help understanding PoliSci. :)
HorusNoon 1 month ago
@HorusNoon ~ the bailout saved a failed private market, everything since has been a nightmare, we should have made all those who caused it accountable, but libertarian boys ron and rand don't want regulations, and that's pretty much what we got.
the last 30 years have been deregulation, privatization, and tax cuts. taxes haven't been this low in decades, government property (the commons) is being sold in record amounts, and regulatory agencies are routinely gutted.
it has failed.
tomitstube 1 month ago
@tomitstube
Wait...
Do you seriously believe what you just wrote me?
Like I said, you need to take a class in a University and learn political terminology, as well as where these political systems are on the paradigm.
Libertarian DOES NOT MEAN Liberal.
Libertarian = Teachings/Doctrine of "Liberty"
The bailout DID NOT SAVE the private market... Are you serious?
It was a "Corporate Bailout" as we are in a Corporatist system; not a Capitalist system.
GOOGLE: The Corporatocracy.
HorusNoon 3 weeks ago
@HorusNoon ~ you don't listen very well do you? and you can make your own definitions all day long, doesn't mean squat.
and yes, the "free market" failed. again. altho you fake libertarian/conservatives have tried to spread the fannie/freddie horseshit for 4 years. wall street, real estate, and the banks were deregulated, (according to the libertarian mantra) and promptly took down the world economy. libertarian/conservatives have gone into fantasy land trying to rewrite this truth.
tomitstube 3 weeks ago
@tomitstube I think you would have a very different opinion if you did some research on these programs. First of all, these programs (Welfare, Food Stamps, Affirmative Action) DO NOT help the poor, they keep them in poverty! Please watch:
Thomas Sowell - Welfare
Thomas Sowell - In the right direction (Parts 1 - 6)
DSuper3 1 month ago 6
@DSuper3 ~ right, welfare only works for rich people.
tomitstube 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@DSuper3 I don't get you?
Re: I think you would have a very different opinion if you did some research on these programs. First of all, these programs (Welfare, Food Stamps, Affirmative Action) DO NOT help the poor, they keep them in poverty! Please watch:
Thomas Sowell - Welfare
Thomas Sowell - In the right direction (Parts 1 - 6)
machinaking 2 weeks ago
@DSuper3 I'm a single mom [3 kids]. 5 years ago I left a violent situation to give my kids stability & healthier options. After leaving my ex, I was in a financial crisis. I took liberty in using Welfare & food stamps to get back on my feet. I used the programs for 2-3 yrs & I'm no longer using them. They were beneficial & didn't keep me in poverty. My family is healthy in all aspects. I believe in small gov't & the existence of these programs within the State's govern, not the Fed gov't.
surrealyzm 1 week ago
@hma terpiece85, so true !!! then he walks out of the CNN interveiw, that have made him look very guility just right there along ! then he have said a few things that have made him look like a racist. People who supports Ron Paul should really look at some of those things that he have said. things that he have supported in the past & now,not to long ago he even have said that he would over turn some of the civilrights. then you have his documents from the past. Plus connections with hate groups
RepublicansAreNazis 1 month ago
he didn't know of approve or write letter with his name in the title? Then why is he not bringing suit against those who used his name without permission? Hmm makes you think huh? No of course not because Con Paul supporters do not think they just drink his anarchist kool aid. He talks about treating people that are sick but then says the government should let you die. he is as big of a flip flopper as the rest of them. Hopefully after this election he will have passed on before the next one.
hmasterpiece85 1 month ago
@hmasterpiece85 thank you i got your back also ! these reichwinger bitches don't know shit !!!
RepublicansAreNazis 1 month ago
He is a far from racist as one can be how that isnt painfully obvious to all is a mystery to me
ciapillo 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Voting machines are hacked; Vote by absentee ballot to make sure there is a paper trail of your vote that can be RECOUNTED and ensure your vote is not STOLEN by some computer program! Then if there is any discrepancy, we can compare what they say Ron Paul received and what he really received!
ocsob007 1 month ago
You should have titled this video another way. Rant isn't a good word.
blattdanielmain 1 month ago
Ron Paul is a good Freemason. One of the few good-masons left on this planet.
HorusNoon 1 month ago
@HorusNoon Where is your proof that he is a freemason?
mwowner1 1 month ago
@mwowner1 he quotes king solomon a lot in some of the other videos.
selymak 1 month ago
@DoubroDoubro You are fucking ignorant.
RepublicansAreNazis 1 month ago
Comment removed
RepublicansAreNazis 1 month ago
Comment removed
RepublicansAreNazis 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@DoubroDoubro you are the fucking igonrant one, bitch !!! you attack people who disgree with your hero Ron Paul. I have seen your other comments to other people who don't agree or like Ron Paul. if you like him fine ! but don't attack others who think differently then you do. it really makes you look very stupid. so don't drink so much of that Ron Paul Kool-Aid, Kool-Aid man !!!
RepublicansAreNazis 1 month ago
Obama 2012 !!!!
RepublicansAreNazis 1 month ago
@RepublicansAreNazis You're a moron, so you have no say.
Nobama 2012
gamefreak1000000 1 month ago
@gamefreak1000000 You are the moron, so go back and keep suck that that Paulpipe bitch !!! NoPaul 2012
RepublicansAreNazis 1 month ago
@RepublicansAreNazis Who ever said I was pro paul, dumbass? I just don't want that kenyan running in office another term. The last thing our country needs is more trillions being added in debt. If you back Obama for after everything he has done to this country, then you are a misinformed moron and education is what you need.
gamefreak1000000 1 month ago
@gamefreak1000000 number one, bitch ! you are showing how ingorant you are by the fucking name calling with that stupid racist remark by call obamo a Kenyan. want you go somewhere and suck one of your KKKonservative friends dick you racist bitch !!! and stop being a fucking troll !!!
RepublicansAreNazis 1 month ago
@RepublicansAreNazis I doubt you even know what a troll is you stupid lout. How am I racist for calling Obama a "Kenyan?" He is a Kenyan. It's not racist if it's true. Second, he is anti American. Notice how our debt ceiling is at 14 TRILLION?! Since your mind is the size of a pea (like all other Obama supporters), let me show you just how big the number is.
14,000,000,000,000
If you can count, that's 14 digits. That is how much money we owe China. So tell me, still voting for the Kenyan?
gamefreak1000000 1 month ago
@gamefreak1000000 How is it true he is from Kenya? He is American accept it. He was not born in Kenya nor does he live there. Yes Obama is solely responsible for a debt that Nixon started Reagan continued and Bush 1&2 put into over drive. Only Clinton had a balanced budget with an outlook of a surplus. Do you know what a surplus is? No of course not you only know words like socialist and whatever other big boy words you have heard on Rush.
hmasterpiece85 1 month ago
@gamefreak100000 u r the common Pea Brain RepubliTARD.That don't know shit u r the one that really need to educate yourself.Being a retard & a racist is a very dangerous mix.u stupid misinformed fox news neo nazi con fool.Obama is a United States citizen.U must have been sleeping during bush term;Bush have lefted this shit. plus the debt ceiling don't have a dam thing to do with anything.bush's barrowing for china for war & 778 billion giveaway to the rich,each year. u r misinformed like Hannity
RepublicansAreNazis 1 month ago
@RepublicansAreNazis I got your back lol. Damn tea baggers! Con Paul needs to be put in a home and given a lobotomy.
hmasterpiece85 1 month ago
@RepublicansAreNazis Plus you are making yourself look very stupid if you think that Obama is a Kenyan. his father is from Kenyan. Hawaii is where Obama was born. do your reseach.Even the the most retarded Reichwinger,Ann Coulter knows that Obama is Born here in the United States.You are just being bias & racist just because you don't like him or black people. you will never amid that. because you are a fool, racist & asshole, to really know anything. Calling Obama a Kenyan is a code, you racist
RepublicansAreNazis 1 month ago
@RepublicansAreNazis Tell me, was it also Bush's fault that you can't spell and use proper grammar? Liberalism truly is a mental disorder.
gamefreak1000000 1 month ago
@gamefreak1000000 Raceist! Just accept it that you so insecure with an intelligent african american that you resort to youtube to spread your hate and fear.
hmasterpiece85 1 month ago
@gamefreak1000000
RepublicansAreNazis 1 month ago
Okay okay okay hold up. Seriously. How the heck is Ron Paul racist? How can anyone get anything related to racism from this video? Are people even listening to the words he's saying??
TheSilviepie 1 month ago
beautiful speech
liamlloyd77 1 month ago
Ron Paul is my Hero, If i were not Canadian but American*USA* I WOULD VOTE RON PAUL.
GerrettJihad 1 month ago
Whilst Ron Paul says a lot of great words, let us not forget how many great words Obama said and that he has been about as helpful as a turd. (Smoking pot is not a disease Ron it is a choice). Unfortunately, RP calls himself a libertarian, these wankers are not helping. The only liberty that so called "libertarians" seek to defend is the liberty of the rich to take advantage of the poor. Socialism is the way forward. RP will not be able to make any real changes and will end up a turd like Obama.
HelmetBlissta 1 month ago
@HelmetBlissta Ron Paul has a 30+ year track record of consistency in his ideology. You are a moron to compare that with a slimy Pol like Obama who can't even say he heard the racism at his church for 20 years straight. Obama had 2 yrs in Congress before he got the JOB, due to the color of his skin. He is our first affirmative acton president... didn't have the character, or consistency to be Pres... just filled the quota.
DoubroDoubro 1 month ago
@DoubroDoubro As I said RP will be unable to effect any real change. But good luck anyway. Maybe he'll try to end the Fed and be killed.
HelmetBlissta 1 month ago
REPEAL the WAR ON DRUGS. Ron are you ON DRUGS?
gambler414 1 month ago
or republicans.. He has the best anti-war voting record of any congressmen in the last 30 years bar none.. By far not even close.. He is the ONLY congressmen, republican or democrat, who has accuretly predicted the economic crisis from A to Z.. better than any economist in the country. IN fact he is the best economist in the country.. He is a real statesmen. Same message for 30 years.. Ho look up his vidoes from the 80s predicting the economic crisis. I can go on and on with this if you want..
xMaXiMuSx 1 month ago
aginst ending Birthright Citizenship?? well that's not that big of a deal, maybe we should do something about those who intentionally come here for one day to have their baby born here so they can have US citizenship. We're the only nation that does that.. It's not unreasonable and "anti-liberal" to look into that..
You know what you should be talking about?? I'll tell you.
You should be praisiing Ron Paul for being the BEST anti-war candidate among ALL Congressmen, whether they be, Dems
xMaXiMuSx 1 month ago
He is not qualified to be a doctor or to lead. He will die soon enough and the Paulbots can go back under their rocks.
chewbaccajoe 1 month ago
no racist at all, the government trying to make him look bad again
oskar123419 1 month ago
Unfortunately,to become president Ron Paul has to reach more people outside his regular base, survive a rigged election and then avoid being assassinated. I hope he is successful but the odds are against him.
adrianriviera 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the only thing people keep talking about is race and so it goes there can be no peace till that question is addressed
edwards21416 1 month ago
the only thing people keep talking about is race and so it goes there can be no peace till that question is address
edwards21416 1 month ago
Dr. Paul is more black than Obama!
zucchini2007 1 month ago
Why do they only give them 30 seconds to answer their questions??
zucchini2007 1 month ago
@zucchini2007 so it proves you know your points unlike Sarah Palin who doesn't even remember her own points
balisongtutorials 1 month ago
ironi
MrJavivi86 1 month ago
how is this racist at all?
variousrodent 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
FACTS only Ron Paul seems to understand:
300 million Americans.
138 million WORKING Americans.
21 million of those are GOVERNMENT employees.
60 million on Social Security.
48 million collecting some type of Welfare.
2 million in prison or jail...etc.
What percentage of a population can feed at the public trough before that society collapes?
sgapplebee 1 month ago
its a cheap fake provocation from some retard - he cut some phrases out of context - find his whole speech somewhere here on youtube
whole speech idea was anti-racist
megalolka 1 month ago
In what way is this racist?
ramonkey0807 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Douchebag serial racist and New-Nazi idol Ron Paul was a real failure in Congress. Why didnt he run for Governor or President of Iran? Since hes so smart, he would have won in a landslide so he could try out his dumbass theories
lmacorp 1 month ago
I love the title! I love Ron Paul and I am a black man. Black people and ALL people, listen to what this man has to say and you will not walk but run to vote for him.
jdmoonwalker 1 month ago
the title is misleading
vibol03 1 month ago
nice title
okkvlt 1 month ago
Everything he said is about how unfair things are and how there needs to be equal justice for everyone. Under what possible definition is that racist?
adamef93 1 month ago
I thnk the titles is tongue in cheek
thecommish2012 1 month ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
Sound like Dr. Paul is anti-Rockefeller laws. "MY MAN!"
My BLACKASS will be voting for this OUTSTANDING "RACIST". "HOLLA!!!"
- RON PAUL 2012 BITCHES!
BillyBatsonMarvel 1 month ago
Comment removed
BillyBatsonMarvel 1 month ago
This isn't racist at all. He's just showing statistics and saying why the system is corrupt because stuff like that shouldn't happen.
VOTE RON PAUL 2012!
wassupbrah1 1 month ago
i love you Congressman Ron Paul!
firemystic76 1 month ago
How in any way is this a racist rant? He does nothing but support blacks and state facts. People really just hear whatever they want.
Myconditionisdire 1 month ago
Brilliant!!! Use the headline to grab attention then they see the truth from his own mouth. I applaud you.
daekru92 1 month ago
Comment removed
daekru92 1 month ago
He's not racist. He's just telling the truth. Plain and simple.
Mangobrain82 1 month ago
hes not racist hes realistic am latin but what he say is true most black and latuin are drugs users and dealers so dont blame him for telling the truth
elak47pr 1 month ago
jeff55369 - Absolutely brother
MegaChelsea25 1 month ago
I am not american, but if I was, I would definately vote RON PAUL!!!
MegaChelsea25 1 month ago
@MegaChelsea25 Every non-american I've heard speak about our political process of recent feels the same. It's not just America that needs Ron Paul... the whole world needs him to end the war mongering that's going on.
Jeff55369 1 month ago
He is not "Racist". He is actually the only candidate who praised Martin Luther King so loudly in this ignorant media......(good to see that everything is turning to its real side)......Ron Paul 2012
TheNighmare2000 1 month ago
Comment removed
TheNighmare2000 1 month ago
THIS IS FACT. HE IS USING STATISTICS! RACISM IS CHARACTERIZED BY OPINION!
theabyss650 1 month ago
How is this a racist rant? He's taking a stance against laws that unfairly affect black people & minorities in general!!! Damn People are stupid!!! He's trying to stop these stupid drug laws that are totally racist. I'm a half black Latino & I'm voting for Ron Paul because I know he's not racist!!! I'd like to hear one of these cock sucking Neo-Cons say Martin Luther King & Rosa Parks are their heroes? They wouldn't because they're scared that their racist base wouldn't like it. Ron Paul 2112!!!
Conquistador2112 1 month ago
@Conquistador2112 It definatly wasn't. I think that the title was tongue-in-cheek, or it was to get people's attention and compel them to watch it. Make sure you register in time if you want to vote in your primary though.
FieldMarshalB 1 month ago
@FieldMarshalB Yeah, I realized that a few minutes after I went off about it and felt like an idiot LOL!!! I'm going to vote for Ron Paul in our primary & the general election for sure.
Conquistador2112 1 month ago
People, use common sense. The video title was clearly IRONIC. No, it's not racist, that was the uploader's point. I'm not even a Ron Paul supporter and I could see it.
DarkEmergence 1 month ago 13
@DarkEmergence You're probably right but I guess we're a little hyper sensitive because were tired of him being branded a racist when his policies and this video clearly indicate that he's not.
Conquistador2112 1 month ago
@DarkEmergence Why dont you support Ron Paul? Just wondering?
MrTroutguy 1 month ago
@MrTroutguy I'm Liberal.
DarkEmergence 1 month ago
@DarkEmergence
so ok you're liberal?? What the hell does that mean anymore?? Nothing.. What exactly are your policies and where do you disagree with PauL??
xMaXiMuSx 1 month ago
@xMaXiMuSx Not that you were the person who asked or that you're actually interested, but I'm pro-choice, believe in healthcare and social programs, against ending Birthright Citizenship, for minimum wage. You know, Liberal policies. I can't list my entire political leaning in 500 characters so I'll just say I agree with him on somethings, but he goes against my political leanings in many areas. Alright, officer?
DarkEmergence 1 month ago
@DarkEmergence
Ok Ron Paul might disagree with you a little bit on the abortion issue.. HE believes in heatlh care too.. Who doesnt?? LoL what a stupid thing to say, it's how health should be provided..
Our social programs will collapse if we continie these inflationary policies and dont get our budget in orders.. Dollap collapse is inevitable.. There are biggger issues that need to be dealt with like the federal reserve and the monetary system.. We need to go back to sound money..
xMaXiMuSx 1 month ago
This is not racist. Liberals are racist.
jtruej 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
GO RON PAUL!!!
First they ignore you.
Then they laugh at you.
Then they fight you.
Then you win. -Mohandas Gandhi
tubeviewerX20 1 month ago
I'm black and I don't find anything he said in this video to be racist at all. He is bringing up facts about obvious social injustices in our country that most, if not all, politicians refuse to even acknowledge.
itsjoshcox 1 month ago
Some black people are addicted to baiting the race issue and I think it is profoundly sad because it reveals that THEY are in fact the racist who is creating phantom justifications for their anti human illness. The term 'racism' covers a variety of behaviors not the least of which is the dynamic of black people who are obsessed with looking for people who don't like them. I think life would render more rewards if those people went looking for people who are color blind and acknowledged spirit.
thewhisperingeagle 1 month ago
@thewhisperingeagle You do realize your comment wasn't only not color blind, but after viewing the video, it's clear you have some hangup with black people that you were obsessed with getting out.
DarkEmergence 1 month ago
he be doing drugs... that's why lol
Love4MusicGirl03 1 month ago
how is that racist ?! hes bein real
youngluvr93 1 month ago
i can only say that i was dem i will not vote rep but if Ron Paul would run independent i will vote for him but i cannot or will not vote for a traitor Obama signed the wrong thing NDAA he's a traitor
SuperMax328 1 month ago
@SuperMax328 Yes. Obama is a traitor along with the rest of congress, both dem & rep who voted & signed the NDAA into law. I would suggest changing your stance on voting for Ron Paul regardless of the Rep. banner. He is the 1 that is bringing back what the party use to stand for, upholding the constitution and civil liberties for all mankind. I am an independent myself and will 4 vote Dr. Paul and I would encourage you to consider it to not let the traitors win!
jdmoonwalker 1 month ago
I love how the reporter at the end goes "uh hugh"
pizzamovies 1 month ago
If Ron Paul is not racist that's find, but I think we need a better explanation for the racist articles that were written in his newsletters under his name.
mansamusa2012 1 month ago
@mansamusa2012: I would like to know why you feel that there needs to be an explaination. Just like a magazine has several different people writing stories for the magazine Ron has said that it was someone else that wrote their opinion on the news letter. If it is so important than why doesn't the mainstream media find the original author? You see it isn't important enough to find out the whole truth. The mainstream media just wants to pin something that happened many years ago on Ron Paul.
bond519 1 month ago
@bond519 You made an excellent point. From a black person's perspective you must understand that so many white people have smiled in our face but behind closed doors they're someone else.
mansamusa2012 1 month ago
@mansamusa2012 He was the publisher & wrote the financial section, there were other writers on the newsletters and he was not the editor. The main stream media has got people twisted over this and they keep bringing this back up because it is the only thing they think they have on him, it is just not truth. This video should be enough to prove that he is not a racist. Dr. Paul's record speaks for itself, he is a just, fair, and honest man, very rare in politics. Embrace him.
jdmoonwalker 1 month ago
Ron Paul! The ONLY politician who speaks honestly and makes so much sense to me. Let's get behind him! Please! For once can we not be afraid to vote for someone out of the mainstream! Ron Paul, I Love You!
AlasiaBud24 1 month ago 2
So, apparently, any statement mentioning blacks, EVEN IF IT'S FACTUAL STATISTICS, is racist?
KayRoxxxx 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Let's tell THE WHOLE TRUTH.
US congresswoman Cynthia McKinney has come out and blamed the pro-Israel Lobby in America (AIPAC, ADL, ZOA, etc) for ruining her political career. While in congress she refused to sign the pro-Israel pledge and took a pro-Palestinian stance. Because of this, McKinney said “war was declared” on her by the Jewish lobby. In 2009 she told TIU's Ognir that “more than 99% of Congress work for Pro Zionist Israeli interests.”
w(dot)zioncrimefactory com/jew-world-order
LordLindsey12 1 month ago
Hasn't anyone realized that the title of the video is sarcastic?
NATEG01 1 month ago
love when asserts himself at 3:40
jackobthesnakob 1 month ago
Ron is not a RAcist
TIBONERFULL 1 month ago