The similarities between Malcolm and Burns are amazing. Both of these songs are lyrics written for older tunes. Burns' Humanist anthem was originally a "bawdy " Jacobite song (according to Carol McGuirk, editor of the Penquin Classics collection of Burns Poems) and Malcolm's ode to pastoral Scotland is written over John McClellan's great pipe tune. Thanks for putting this up. Great sound work. 5 stars.
I don't know if many in the audience got the irony of Jim's intro to "A man's a man for a' that" , or the message of the song for that matter, but fair play to Jim for representing the Bard so well here!
I must admit: I underrated jim. when i heard "no westling winds" ... well, gaughans version is unreached. And he is away from the brillance of Gaughan playing "Erin Go Bragh". BUT this kansas city stuff ... its great! I´m a new fan!
Thank you thank you thank you! In Jim Malcolm's gifted hands, a sentimental song like Lochanside becomes powerful and haunting. Kinda makes you want to jump a plane for Scotland...
Absolutely fantastic! Ggrrreat stuff Jim.
foggydayinlondon 1 year ago
The similarities between Malcolm and Burns are amazing. Both of these songs are lyrics written for older tunes. Burns' Humanist anthem was originally a "bawdy " Jacobite song (according to Carol McGuirk, editor of the Penquin Classics collection of Burns Poems) and Malcolm's ode to pastoral Scotland is written over John McClellan's great pipe tune. Thanks for putting this up. Great sound work. 5 stars.
romoly22 2 years ago
I don't know if many in the audience got the irony of Jim's intro to "A man's a man for a' that" , or the message of the song for that matter, but fair play to Jim for representing the Bard so well here!
A credit tae the auld' country indeed!
DonegalRaymie201 2 years ago
Great! Have seen him in concert several times. He only gets better
abenormal100 2 years ago
Fantastic--I've been thirsting for more Malcolm videos. There aren't enough on youtube.
BardofCornwall 2 years ago 4
I must admit: I underrated jim. when i heard "no westling winds" ... well, gaughans version is unreached. And he is away from the brillance of Gaughan playing "Erin Go Bragh". BUT this kansas city stuff ... its great! I´m a new fan!
maclink1 2 years ago
Thank you thank you thank you! In Jim Malcolm's gifted hands, a sentimental song like Lochanside becomes powerful and haunting. Kinda makes you want to jump a plane for Scotland...
Hark815 3 years ago
Great solo scottish folk singer. Two great songs. Lochanside - traditional tune. A man's a man - Rabbie Burns. Brilliant.
saundeal 3 years ago