David McLeod, writing for the Keaton Chronicle of the Damfinos (a Keaton fan club), looks at all the evidence the costumes worn by Keaton, Coogan, Fairbanks; the fact that neither Valentino nor Coogan were stars before 1921 -- and reasons that this film must have been shot between the spring of 1922 and early 1923.
The actual stars were in this video - watch how the scene is cut before each one emerges. This video I believe was filmed at the home of Mary Pickford and Douglas Fairbanks (Pickfair) sometime in the late 1920's. All the actors you see are the real McCoy. It's a great concept though...
Pero ¿cómo demonios hace el cambio de estatura de Jackie Coogan? Vale, sí, coloca una escalera, pero es que cuando baja, el escritorio está más alto. A no ser que haya un corte en la película, no consigo entenderlo.
so this would be about '21 right? because it's when buster was famous on his own but before roscoe had his accident, and probably right after jackie coogan did The Kid.
This is great, thanks! Very amusing that he would be Jackie Coogan at the end. :-p I had never seen anything with Harold Lloyd and my favorite, Buster Keaton, together. :)
It must be a promotion since all the actors appear as as themselves. You can see the edits when the duck behind the suitcase. The actors than do a little adjustment to themselves and stand in front so we can see them. If you watch carefull you can see the flicker of the cut. Amazing. Getting these great actors together to perform this act.
The cut always occurs when he puts on the wig. He puts it on, then ducks down; the next person you see is the real star. Love the way Fairbanks jumps over the table!
I like your video clip and have rated it as awesome. Please check out my clip of silent movie star tobacco cards. They include: Harold Lloyd, Charlie Chaplin, Rudolph Valentino, Mary Pickford, Lillian Gish, Tom Mix, Jackie Coogan and many more.
This short can be found (with excellent commentary) on the Laughsmith DVD "Industrial Strength Keaton", along with a lot of other great rarities, and I hope this clip encourages you to buy it. I persuaded two friends to pick up copies just to get this short. Regardless, though, I hope as many fans and potential new fans as possible get to see this great piece of film history while it's here.
This just made me laugh. Terrific concept.
cakebythelake 2 weeks ago
Stupendo grazie per averlo messo!!!
Busterk1989 2 months ago
Love! Love! Love! <3<3<3 Thanks for posting this!
beatingbrahms 2 months ago
actually, OMG, Buster Keaton *swoon* :)
baishengli 4 months ago 3
Omg Rudolph Valentino *swoon* .
DameHollywood 5 months ago
This is so cool!
LucyLasticAU 9 months ago
Che effetti speciali che c'erano prima. Altro che computer graphic!
lucastanley84 10 months ago
I've never seen this clip of Rudolph Valentino - you just made my day.
blaufrau3 1 year ago 5
Pure awesome.
767Sandie 1 year ago
*sigh* oh Buster....:D
jenlikeshorses 1 year ago 2
Keaton & Lloyd in the same film...a rare gem. Of course they were real life pals to the end of their lives.....
TheVirajster 1 year ago 7
awesome, and such a cool device 'watch' the artist make the change, these people truly were artists, nobody like them now.
jayscott49 1 year ago
HOW DID HE DO THAT?? I dont see the the editing or the film jumping at all~it's so seemless! Harold looked so spiffy & good! :}
MJSweetChildofGod 1 year ago
FANTASTICO!
giogioify1975 1 year ago
I'm totally in love with Harold Lloyd!!!!
4MaryAnna 1 year ago 2
Absolutely Amazing. Many thanks for the post.
jasperweary 2 years ago
Wonderful video ,
Wonderful artists .
marciatorresstar 2 years ago
David McLeod, writing for the Keaton Chronicle of the Damfinos (a Keaton fan club), looks at all the evidence the costumes worn by Keaton, Coogan, Fairbanks; the fact that neither Valentino nor Coogan were stars before 1921 -- and reasons that this film must have been shot between the spring of 1922 and early 1923.
cityofchappaquiddick 2 years ago
@cityofchappaquiddick According to the Wikipedia biography of Fatty Arbuckle, this film was made in 1925.
Impalamark64 1 year ago
Had to be before 1926 if Valentino was indeed actually in it - because that is the year he died.
GeminiNightOwl 2 years ago
The actual stars were in this video - watch how the scene is cut before each one emerges. This video I believe was filmed at the home of Mary Pickford and Douglas Fairbanks (Pickfair) sometime in the late 1920's. All the actors you see are the real McCoy. It's a great concept though...
GeminiNightOwl 2 years ago
Pero ¿cómo demonios hace el cambio de estatura de Jackie Coogan? Vale, sí, coloca una escalera, pero es que cuando baja, el escritorio está más alto. A no ser que haya un corte en la película, no consigo entenderlo.
cesarasecas1 2 years ago
nobody can grin like Fairbanks
swordfish1929 2 years ago
Splendid, simply splendid. Harold, Rudy, and Jackie Coogan were the best. This is where it all started
Tecun85 2 years ago
la tecnologia de los 20's jaja muy chido eh.... wow!! pero falto chaplin :(
deftlink 2 years ago
Damn! This guy's good!
WSenator1 2 years ago
I love these old silent films. They actually have substance and taste, unlike most of the crap the Hollywood is churning out these days.
themanfromwyoming 2 years ago 15
@themanfromwyoming
Hollywood churned out it's share of crap back then too. It's classics like this that survive.
x24actor 1 year ago
I love this short! It's on the Valentino Rarities collection - I love seeing all of these actors together in the same film!
asocietysensation 2 years ago 2
What is "Valentino Rarities" and do you know where I can buy it? Thanks for any info.
kangadillo 2 years ago
Comment removed
asocietysensation 2 years ago
That's some good make-up! ;)
girlhitsbus 2 years ago
Nice work. keep it up. mean time come for social media marketing for esteembpo**com h
rosycarolina 2 years ago
lol.. I love it.
bayougrande 2 years ago
aw this totally cheered me up =] first of all i was like 'hey this guy *really* looks like Buster!' then i got it lol Harold Lloyd's dance is ace!
XjennydontbehastyX 2 years ago 3
so great! thanks for uploading
itsjustanillusion 3 years ago
According to the IMDb, it was made in 1925 for a party given by Pickford and Fairbanks.
praguephotog 3 years ago 4
It's a shame Chaplin was too much of a shit-heal to play along!
JohnsonBrand2000 3 years ago 3
You mean he was invited to do it and he turned it down? Why didn't he want to do it?
kangadillo 2 years ago
Chuck would never inter-mingle with other comedians!
JohnsonBrand2000 2 years ago
jesus christ what a gem
so this would be about '21 right? because it's when buster was famous on his own but before roscoe had his accident, and probably right after jackie coogan did The Kid.
jimpuppy 3 years ago 3
It would have been later - Harold Lloyd is doing the little jig from "The Freshman", and that film was released in 1925.
praguephotog 3 years ago
Did you know thats where MC Hammer got his dance? From Harorld Lloyd. Mammer time!!! LOL
zer0dahero 3 years ago
OH I love the one with Harold Lloyd. HE is so cute, the way he does his little jig.
dalvar02 3 years ago 3
That's the same "little jig"he does in The Freshman.He's so adorable,I just love him like crazy!
Mary-
4MaryAnna 3 years ago
Wow! This is marvelous! Great editing to and from the real stars. Oh how love Buster Keaton!
Brigitte3 3 years ago 18
Cool! Those impressions look identical with the 'real ones'
Amazing how he changes into another so fast, brilliant :)
ahjinry 3 years ago
Carter DeHaven would be my great grandfather if he were alive today.!!
beachchick121 3 years ago 3
Is Gloria your grandmother then? She's really a nice person--I met her through friends of hers here in Coral Gables.
MissOgeny 3 years ago
Brilliant! All those movie legends crammed into a black box! :) What a treasure. Thanks for posting!
lettyfinhadden 4 years ago 3
that was awsome!
phx88gir 4 years ago
Brilliant, thank you for putting it up :) x
annascaz 4 years ago
Great video clip and I've given you five stars. I've created a video clip featuring Douglas Fairbanks and many other 1920's movie stars.
creamofcardstv 4 years ago
Loved it!! I will put it in my favorites! Thanks so much for sharing!!
shelayne4 4 years ago
What a great switcheroo!!
JadyLester 4 years ago
This is great, thanks! Very amusing that he would be Jackie Coogan at the end. :-p I had never seen anything with Harold Lloyd and my favorite, Buster Keaton, together. :)
amazinrick 4 years ago 5
It must be a promotion since all the actors appear as as themselves. You can see the edits when the duck behind the suitcase. The actors than do a little adjustment to themselves and stand in front so we can see them. If you watch carefull you can see the flicker of the cut. Amazing. Getting these great actors together to perform this act.
bnave123 4 years ago
This is amazing! Thanks for posting it!
AliceMoving 4 years ago
That is a magnific retrospective of the the stars from the cinema's beginning. That was a pleasure to see this movie.
Thank you.
clope2000 4 years ago 2
WHat a fun video.
bencheshire 4 years ago
It's pretty apparent that these are the actual stars and not just some guy dressing up like them. What's the story? Anybody know?
swtaylor1 4 years ago
The cut always occurs when he puts on the wig. He puts it on, then ducks down; the next person you see is the real star. Love the way Fairbanks jumps over the table!
praguephotog 4 years ago
wow I love it!
somethingblue300 4 years ago
love rudy!
unursing 4 years ago 5
OMG!!!! That guy is amazing!!! He looked just like them!!!!
collinwoodgoverness 4 years ago
You should see him made up as Luke the Dog.
SurferJoe1 4 years ago
LOL! biting Buster's butt...
lifeboatB 4 years ago
I like your video clip and have rated it as awesome. Please check out my clip of silent movie star tobacco cards. They include: Harold Lloyd, Charlie Chaplin, Rudolph Valentino, Mary Pickford, Lillian Gish, Tom Mix, Jackie Coogan and many more.
creamofcardstv 4 years ago
This short can be found (with excellent commentary) on the Laughsmith DVD "Industrial Strength Keaton", along with a lot of other great rarities, and I hope this clip encourages you to buy it. I persuaded two friends to pick up copies just to get this short. Regardless, though, I hope as many fans and potential new fans as possible get to see this great piece of film history while it's here.
SurferJoe1 4 years ago
Simply amazing! However did you do this!? I'm so happy you put Harold Lloyd in here! He is my fave! And very cute charming clip you have of him!
Freakazette95 4 years ago
what a great video!
trilbyofarrell 4 years ago
wow I love when people find these rare old clips
geekyvince 4 years ago
You can say that again! Wow! Awesome video! Thanks!
putzilla1286 4 years ago