Wow. I never knew so many people were such experts in music. Let alone have the ability to judge the worthiness of love ballads and the artists who wrote them. Cheer up, People of Doom and Gloom. It's a simple love song that has merit all its own. And a great love song at that. (My personal opinion inserted here. Nothing more.)
At least Babe and The First Time had some rockin' electric guitar in it. Tommy Shaw has indeed encroached into Barry Manilow territory with "Yes I Can". I'm not criticizing the song- I like it, but I think Tommy was wrong for putting down Dennis's ballads when they were so great. Babe even gave the band their only #1, which means millions of people loved it! I'm surprised he would make such a mushy video and song after uttering those words about Babe.
For those who didn't pay attention to what Shaw said about DeYoung's ballads... he said he didn't want to band known for just ballads like Babe, or First Time. He never said he didn't want to do any of those type songs. DeYoung and the record labels were pushing the light stuff so much that the harder rock songs were being ignored. But I would like to ask Tommy if he can say the word 'irony' sometime...
What the hell is this crap?. Tommy Shaw says that The song Dennis deyoungs "First time" was in barry manilow territory. This is worst. Lots of Flowers, just missing some little birdies. Tommy Shaw should get together with Minnie Riperton and sing "Lovin You".
I LIKE the video. Things don't have to be ugly to be cool - nothing wrong with beautiful gardens! This song is exceptional - I never was a Styx fan, but am finally impressed!
Absolutely LOVE the song (not crazy about the video tho) - awesome, Beatlesque harmonies; sure wish I could hear it in concert sometime (hint, hint guys... Thursday would be soon enough for me LOL!!)
unfortunately, glen isn't with the band any more, so no chance in hearing it live. thank god for video! ;) (i agree it's a bit weak, but at least they did a vid for it)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This is not Styx. They just call themselves "Styx." It's a tribute band featuring original members James Young and Tommy Shaw. Plus, the music is not good. This song is a total stinker and doesn't even measure up to "Don't Let it End," which was the last great Styx ballad.
Look, I realize the best of times with Styx was with Dennis as part of the group, but that song was not as good as this one is, let's be realistic. Don't Let It End is not exactly the high water mark of Styx.
I know what you mean about founding members and understand. However, being a musician, I can't help but think your comment is just sour grapes. This IS great music, Dennis had his chance to continue with the band and selfishly screwed it up. He's not a member anymore. Get over it. He has.
ok first of all this is styx it has just outreached from the original (denis deyoung was diagnosed with something that prevented him from playing so they hired gowan to take his place and john p died so they had to hire the new drummer chuck p retired so they got the new bassist so this is styx just wit new members
i agree with another viewer. its a great song but for the year the video is terrible. it looks as if its a home made vid for a contest or it was a low budget vid. +5 tho
Not bad but what happened to Tommy and JY wanting to ROCK? It seems odd with all the complaining about balleds they've done over the years. Most of the new stuff they are doing seems to be ballads and soft rock except for a few of the covers and classic songs in concert.
it's awesome, but i just can't get over not having dennis there. he was truly "the voice of styx". but this was still super cool. dennis, tommy, and jy really need to get back together.
glen left the band in 03 to pursue other interests. he released a solo album, WELCOME TO HOLLYWOOD on atenzia records, (which is HIGHLY RECOMMENDED- check ebay) is a member of the band LIVERPOOL which performs at all of the beatlefests, and has performed a number of solo shows etc, in addition to his anual Xmas Xtravaganzas. if he comes to your area and you have an opportunity to see him, GO!!!! you WILL NOT be disappointed, trust me! :D
Tommy and the new STYX should look back at the 70's and take back what they said about Dennis's ballads. Without Dennis STYX sucks. The sound is gone. Wish they could see that before they make bigger fools of themselves. Long live the pre 2000 STYX.
Styx is just taking a bit of time to mold into a new kind of sound. Think about it. Was Dennis' molding into the "Styx sound" of the mid 70's-early 80's a perfect process? The early stuff needed some time to get really good. Just be patient.
written by shaw and jack blades actually - makes me cry this song at times, and I'm not a soppy guy. Glen's song was 'kiss your ass goodbye' which is cool but a bit formulaic. But this album is definitely one of Styx' best
Do you always want the same old same old? I think not it would get boring. And there is no hard feelings between the guys and Dennis. Besids Lawrence Gowan makes a perfect if not better replacement. The band is much happier.
they didnt kick dennis he claimed he had a kind of alergic reaction to stage lights and wanted to quit but they wanted to move on atleast thats what jy said in a interview i heard on the radio...anyways is the guy playing with tommy glenn?
To je samo za mojga fanta! **
WAUena 5 months ago
Every girl's dream (not including feminazis).
mcjohnsonsgirl 6 months ago in playlist styx/tommyshaw/damn yankees
Wow. I never knew so many people were such experts in music. Let alone have the ability to judge the worthiness of love ballads and the artists who wrote them. Cheer up, People of Doom and Gloom. It's a simple love song that has merit all its own. And a great love song at that. (My personal opinion inserted here. Nothing more.)
onehotrocker99 6 months ago
This song makes me miss my grandma, good stuff guys, thanks
MrZeldasmagic 10 months ago
At least Babe and The First Time had some rockin' electric guitar in it. Tommy Shaw has indeed encroached into Barry Manilow territory with "Yes I Can". I'm not criticizing the song- I like it, but I think Tommy was wrong for putting down Dennis's ballads when they were so great. Babe even gave the band their only #1, which means millions of people loved it! I'm surprised he would make such a mushy video and song after uttering those words about Babe.
P1ckUpStyx 10 months ago
For once Tommy has a romantic song of his own.
MrTimelord77 10 months ago
For those who didn't pay attention to what Shaw said about DeYoung's ballads... he said he didn't want to band known for just ballads like Babe, or First Time. He never said he didn't want to do any of those type songs. DeYoung and the record labels were pushing the light stuff so much that the harder rock songs were being ignored. But I would like to ask Tommy if he can say the word 'irony' sometime...
jeffb2066 1 year ago
Great harmonies , this cries for an acapella arrangement
tigerman4 1 year ago
amazing song!
adnrocknroll 1 year ago
This a nice video but where is James Young?
veronica16841 1 year ago
@veronica16841 is playing guitar. in the beggining you can see all five members of Styx. James is the one with the moustache.
PauloSimmonsStanley 6 months ago
What the hell is this crap?. Tommy Shaw says that The song Dennis deyoungs "First time" was in barry manilow territory. This is worst. Lots of Flowers, just missing some little birdies. Tommy Shaw should get together with Minnie Riperton and sing "Lovin You".
countryboy7610 1 year ago
thanks SO much for posting this! I love this song ;o)
miska38 1 year ago
Styx will survive, as long as JY and Tommy remain.
darkoath13 1 year ago
I love this song but I have to admit the video is not their best
Ksvitak12 2 years ago
they are like an old buy band. a man band
dougzick 2 years ago
For me, Styx will never be as great as they were when Dennis DeYoung sang with. However, this song is one I like.
mdfreels 2 years ago
I LIKE the video. Things don't have to be ugly to be cool - nothing wrong with beautiful gardens! This song is exceptional - I never was a Styx fan, but am finally impressed!
narxly 2 years ago
Yeah JY!
darkoath13 2 years ago 2
It appears that they produced this video on a very low budget...
skierstar77 2 years ago
however, nothing against the song which is great.
skierstar77 2 years ago
Absolutely LOVE the song (not crazy about the video tho) - awesome, Beatlesque harmonies; sure wish I could hear it in concert sometime (hint, hint guys... Thursday would be soon enough for me LOL!!)
lablvrpa 2 years ago
unfortunately, glen isn't with the band any more, so no chance in hearing it live. thank god for video! ;) (i agree it's a bit weak, but at least they did a vid for it)
stmonkeys 2 years ago
Yeah, I know - bummer! I love Glen - fantastic musician and a really nice guy too! Saw him with Dennis a couple of months ago in NYC; awesome show!
lablvrpa 2 years ago
@stmonkeys What the hell? Who is with them now?
JOECOXISAWESOME 1 year ago
My husband loves this song....he doesn't like much of the newer Styx music (I disagree lol), but he loves this song
JadeSilverhill 2 years ago
Tommy Shaw wrote this for his wife ,
I think it's cute =]
kikiolala 2 years ago 3
Glen Burtnik! Love that man!
Harriet123P 2 years ago 2
Love the song. Love the video. I think it's gotta really cool 60s vibe.
brywool 3 years ago
I hate the vid BUT I LOVE DA SONG WITH ALL MY HEART
(u)
Tettelito 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is not Styx. They just call themselves "Styx." It's a tribute band featuring original members James Young and Tommy Shaw. Plus, the music is not good. This song is a total stinker and doesn't even measure up to "Don't Let it End," which was the last great Styx ballad.
cohenfs 3 years ago
Look, I realize the best of times with Styx was with Dennis as part of the group, but that song was not as good as this one is, let's be realistic. Don't Let It End is not exactly the high water mark of Styx.
Maverikk68 3 years ago 3
I know what you mean about founding members and understand. However, being a musician, I can't help but think your comment is just sour grapes. This IS great music, Dennis had his chance to continue with the band and selfishly screwed it up. He's not a member anymore. Get over it. He has.
WWNF911 2 years ago
ok first of all this is styx it has just outreached from the original (denis deyoung was diagnosed with something that prevented him from playing so they hired gowan to take his place and john p died so they had to hire the new drummer chuck p retired so they got the new bassist so this is styx just wit new members
khfan627394749 2 years ago
My husband and I had our first dance at our wedding to this song. It always makes my cry when I hear it.
redbirdgirl 3 years ago 7
i agree with another viewer. its a great song but for the year the video is terrible. it looks as if its a home made vid for a contest or it was a low budget vid. +5 tho
jaw1987cchs 3 years ago
This is classic Tommy Shaw. This is to closer to stuff like mademoiselle or sing for the day.
DSmith99000 3 years ago 4
Not bad but what happened to Tommy and JY wanting to ROCK? It seems odd with all the complaining about balleds they've done over the years. Most of the new stuff they are doing seems to be ballads and soft rock except for a few of the covers and classic songs in concert.
impreziveboi 3 years ago
old styx is awesome and new styx is awesome
dastreet1 3 years ago
it's awesome, but i just can't get over not having dennis there. he was truly "the voice of styx". but this was still super cool. dennis, tommy, and jy really need to get back together.
graffitimaster9340 3 years ago
CUE JENIE! O wait no Jenie? (silently says yes) haha..
kdai2012 3 years ago
Good song... but this video is just god awful for 2003.
magnusdammit 3 years ago
Extra good/Extra good
Sqigiolie 3 years ago
This song is beautiful I remember this song being played alot at night at my house when 9/11 happen.Tommy is amazing.
Hey does anyone know what happen to Glen?
He like vanished?
Next thing I know Rickys in the band?
kdai2012 3 years ago
glen left the band in 03 to pursue other interests. he released a solo album, WELCOME TO HOLLYWOOD on atenzia records, (which is HIGHLY RECOMMENDED- check ebay) is a member of the band LIVERPOOL which performs at all of the beatlefests, and has performed a number of solo shows etc, in addition to his anual Xmas Xtravaganzas. if he comes to your area and you have an opportunity to see him, GO!!!! you WILL NOT be disappointed, trust me! :D
glen rulz
stmonkeys 3 years ago
Great song! Even with the beard I reconizd Tommy Shaw. This was a wonderful song so true to the way he played the more laid back songs
mom369222 3 years ago
Harmonies are incredible, love the song and video
styxchick4ever 3 years ago
I miss Dennis. Not a bad tune, but the video lacks something.
anakina1 3 years ago
The song isn't bad. Yet I want the old Styx back.
Lwaxy 3 years ago 2
this is a good song... but it really is a horrible music video hahaha
JGLS500 3 years ago
Thank you Jenie for the video! I bet she made it (Tommys wife) shes in alot of computer junk haha
kdai2012 3 years ago
what are you talking about? tommy's wife is jeanne. what do you mean by "she's in a lot of computer junk?" she's a hairstylist.
stmonkeys 3 years ago
I watched a show and she says she does alot of photograph and digatle stuff lol =]
I see we meet again stmonkeys member me?
haha
-Kayla
kdai2012 3 years ago
you cant blame dennis for quitting after all he is allergic to light
snaylor2 3 years ago
too bad dennis was a quitter
clemthecat 4 years ago
Tommy and the new STYX should look back at the 70's and take back what they said about Dennis's ballads. Without Dennis STYX sucks. The sound is gone. Wish they could see that before they make bigger fools of themselves. Long live the pre 2000 STYX.
civilwardude2002 4 years ago
Styx is just taking a bit of time to mold into a new kind of sound. Think about it. Was Dennis' molding into the "Styx sound" of the mid 70's-early 80's a perfect process? The early stuff needed some time to get really good. Just be patient.
BallofBase 4 years ago
they sound a lot better without dennis, even though with dennis they sounded good.
dman7791 4 years ago
I dunno, this is one of my favourite styx songs, but i really really dislike mr. roboto hahaha.
JGLS500 3 years ago
Oh come on guys, even Tommy has to do a ballad sometimes. :P
shincyriades 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what a bunch of mushy crap...
DoctorAxe 4 years ago
How can this be mushy compared to Babe? The lyrical content is pretty much the same; that's what one would define "mushy" by.
PS: Babe isn't mushy. Neither is this.
BallofBase 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
They wanted to do rock music and their sing this crap?!? Hello???
KM2008 4 years ago
Such a beautiful song. Its one of my favorites. Thanks for posting it.
styxgirl812 4 years ago
written by shaw and jack blades actually - makes me cry this song at times, and I'm not a soppy guy. Glen's song was 'kiss your ass goodbye' which is cool but a bit formulaic. But this album is definitely one of Styx' best
TaSwavo 4 years ago
this would be glens song wich is why its like this
lillivplayer54 4 years ago
Do you always want the same old same old? I think not it would get boring. And there is no hard feelings between the guys and Dennis. Besids Lawrence Gowan makes a perfect if not better replacement. The band is much happier.
thesuzannester 4 years ago
oh... trust me. you dont want to go there with Froy. ;)
stmonkeys 4 years ago
They bitch at Dennis for not rockin and they put out this church music,
Another dud
froy2 4 years ago
complain to Damn Yankees. this was supposed to be on the infamous 3rd album. ;)
stmonkeys 4 years ago
wait a sec damn yankees had 2 albums?
RUMELSKIN 4 years ago
Yes. DY put out their eponymous first album in '90, and Don't Tread in 92.
stmonkeys 4 years ago
Comment removed
RUMELSKIN 4 years ago
they didnt kick dennis he claimed he had a kind of alergic reaction to stage lights and wanted to quit but they wanted to move on atleast thats what jy said in a interview i heard on the radio...anyways is the guy playing with tommy glenn?
spader201 4 years ago
if u pause it at 00:57 from left to right glen, jy, todd, larry, tommy
RUMELSKIN 4 years ago
at 1:43 Tommy on left, glenn of right
RUMELSKIN 4 years ago
wow... i didnt know they had a video for this... cool!
BobFudgeRules 4 years ago
they probably made it the 4 of them
lillivplayer54 4 years ago
...trippy. Beautiful song though.
briellejacobs 4 years ago