Added: 9 months ago
From: BBC
Views: 275,392
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (2,225)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Comment removed

  • I liked A Good man very, very much but this trailer made the episode seem more epic then it is...

  • Is this a good show?

  • @selenasana YES

  • @selenasana Yes, yes yes, and a thousand times yes. This is the best show in the universe (and outside of it).

  • @selenasana used to be

  • @dalektaliban It still is.

  • @mowingthefrontlawn the individual episdoes are as good as ever, but the story arcs under moffat are worse than fan fiction

  • @dalektaliban You can't keep blaming moffat. he wote some good eps and this was his best i must say. yeah i know he rush the them but he still good.

  • @CPTTAYLOR592 i will when he wrote the episodes, and single handedly raped the daleks

  • @dalektaliban What are talking about those daleks are good. the other ones have a baby voices. these have manly voices. Yes i don't like how they are ranbow daleks but they are all right.

  • @selenasana No its not a good show, it's A Superb and riveting and Magnificent show!

  • wheres my wife?!, rory turned into dom lol

  • Was the daleks sleeping because I want daleks and cyberman to fight

  • It was good but it's all redy been

  • I'm not exaggerating when I say that this episode is now one of my all-time favourites.

    The acting was superb. The action was well-done. The dialogue was funny intense and emotional all over. The story was advanced and it introduced us to many new characters each of which has strong spin-off potential.

    As a mid-season finale it ranks up there with some of the best in television history.

    Bravo Moffat, you can pat yourself on the back for this one.

  • @TheJboy88 Yes. And he can also give himself a jolly good smack in the bollocks for some of the other crap he has produced in his reign so far.

  • what was the music from 0:10 to 0:19?

  • @123skins1231 King's Legion by Two Steps From Hell

  • @sreofficialchannel Do you know the music that plays in the 'Curse of the Black Spot' Trailer? I know it's by Epic Score, but that's it :P

  • @73DoctorWho it's actually 'Armada" by Two Steps from Hell :)

  • go rory!!

  • "Where. Is. My. Wife?"

    Rory's PISSED!

  • @RedheadDane soooo scrared

  • I havent seen this yet..but why is Rory in his roman stuff again?

  • @YerDatsMe953 the doctor's idea, for fun mostly.

  • @Jarrecko haha of course, thanks

  • I must know the name of this song or where I can find it lol.

  • @CoolHarryTV kings legion two steps from hell

  • @bubblepopification1 Uhm.......it's because he's brought down a rain of destruction upon their people or people that they like at some point, or just because they wanna rid the universe of him (you may have noticed that he does do a lot of merciless destruction in the past few series. To the poeple of the Gamma Forests, "Doctor" translates as "Warrior" for that reason.

  • @bubblepopification1 ummmm? you are really slow!

  • @bubblepopification1 It's called a series arc.

  • Steven Moffat for the win. Period.

  • Bit of a disaster episode in my opinion - it was hyped up far too much, budget was blown pretty badly by recycling old villains again - there was nothing new or intriguing about this episode whatsoever - Headless monks - terrible concept -River Song's identity - Utterly Predictable [Fans found out a week earlier] This isnt the doctor who I grew up with it wasnt hyped so insaneley and then hated by 70% of viewers... I think somethings been lost and not changed- doctor who is about change not loss

  • @RegenerationStorm now viewers here in britian need to stop complaining and degrading the new doctor who series i love this show with all my heart and i was dying for someone to put it back on telly sure this new series is nothing like the classic series but people complained and made fun of doctor who all the years it ran on television nothing changes except this one thing doctor who is getting much more popular in america than here in britian i think we may lose our show to the americans.

  • @doctorw2 I'm afraid youre right - we are gonna lose Doctor Who - but why is it our fault? Why can't the head writer ask himself what he is doing wrong? I know what's going wrong - He is being fussy with it's concept too much, he is changing the series transmission, he is sending it to different countries that get it before us, he is changing matt's costume and he is making a soap drama out of his stories- No one is gonna remember this series , no one is gonna remember matts amazing doctor...

  • @Regeneration everyone will still remember doctor who even when the entire series ends becuase this show is so unique and means a lot to so many people. doctor who has major fans in hollywood a lot of american celebrities love this show especialy steven moffats friend steven spielberg. matt smith said american doctor who fans are much more vibrant and passionate about the series than U.K. fans and that really made me sad we are going to lose our show becuase of derisive apathy.

  • @doctorw2 But this is what im trying to say - Doctor Who cannot be a popular british show anymore if its so uber entertaining to americans , I don't mean Doctor Who as a 50 year old show is gonna be forgotten , I'm talking about Matt Smith's era of doctor who - His iconic costume , the transmissions , the monsters - Is all a problem and it's killing it and I feel a bit soul stolen watching it look so complicated and the viewings... I just miss the show I grew up with from 2005 really badly :(

  • @RegenerationStorm i dont know whats happened to the brilliant intelligence of the people of the U.K. i hear this all the time doctor who is too complicated now and i am gobsmacked everytime i hear this. are the americans more intelligent than the peoples of the U.K. ? blymy i hope this is never the case the 2005-2009 series was a watershed version of doctor who steven moffat has brought back the shows classic style cerebral glory again and along with the shows humorous self mockery.

  • @RegenerationStorm what the fuck are you on about? Why are all the brit fans geting sad because it's getting betetr recognized with different countires? thats betetr for the show, it gets a lot more popular and famous and if the americans are far more enthusiastic then tough luck, be more enthuiastic then. It's not your show, it's not a show about britian but it was and is amde by them for the whole world. Also it's not a drama and matt's costume was changed to keep him warm during winter

  • @Smallvillenerd It's quite usual for an American to blast off at a British over Doctor Who coming over to their country LOL How would you like it if Smallville got to us first , they changed hospital or wherever the hell they work , change the cast- YOU would be complaining and pissing off the english - so please do not try to smear what the majority of britain is thinking right now - oh and for your information - Doctor Who is going downhill cos Let's Kill Hitler only got 6.2 M viewers

  • @RegenerationStorm No, that's just the overnight ratings.

  • @RegenerationStorm

    1. I'm not American

    2. Smallville is over

    3. Who cares how much views the episode gets

    4. No matter what, they won't cancel such a big show, they'd put it back on within a month of cancellation due to all the complaints

    5. really? Who cares how many fucking views it gets? it only got like .5 less like does that effect the actual episodes? NO

  • @Smallvillenerd Um yes - if Doctor Who drops to 4-5m the BBC consider it a fan series and will axe it, and I doubt anyone will want Steven Moffat's Doctor Who back. It's no longer big , it's doctor dw who bbc - a soap drama with complicated script plots and recyced monsters ;)

  • @RegenerationStorm the BBC are pricks if they axe the show, I'll axe them!

  • @RegenerationStorm It ratings are not falling. That 6.whatever million that Let's Kill Hitler got was just the overnight rating.

  • @TheCalebxy David Tennant's bad episodes got 8M overnight. Matt's get 6M. Iplayer views are potentially biased as it could be the same few hundred playing it over and over , and what kind of a family sits around a computer with their tea watching doctor who when they can watch it on tv? It's a family show , not an internet show , whoever includes the iplayer ratings is a bullshitter

  • @RegenerationStorm The Impossible Astronaut is the most recorded show in British TV history. Last year, The Eleventh Hour broke the record for the most watched program in America. This year, The Impossible Astronaut did the same thing.

  • @TheCalebxy Recorded - But get this , that technology wasn't around when David Tennant was the doctor yet by overnight he was getting 8 or more million - this is what you do not understand - Steven Moffat's got everything to advertise doctor who but you cannot say something is so amazing which actually isnt when you watch it - Russel T Davies' doctor who never let me down - not ever - and to me maybe that is the reason why ACTUALLY overnight Day of the Moon hit a shitter getting 5M ratings-

  • @RegenerationStorm Exactly, because the technology wasn't around, people had to watch it. But when everyone can easily record it, they do (which is evident by the fact that The Impossible Astronaut broke the record for the most recorded program in British TV history). And in my opinion, Moffat's Who is a lot lot lot better than RTD's.

  • @TheCalebxy I think the whole recording attribute is just an extra, there is no escuse for doctor who to stoop so low - Britains got talent and X Factor dominate the ratings, yet they can also be recorded etc. The End of Time got 12M when David left , and the eleventh hour got 10M to see what Matt was like , which dropped incredibly by around 4M with the beast below - and the scripts are so complicated - people dont get it and switch over - thats why the shows getting 5-6 , next year itll be 3-4

  • @RegenerationStorm No, The Beast Below did NOT get 4M. And the show is only getting 5-6M overnight. That's not the total ratings. The total for TIA was somewhere between 8-9M, and that's not including the 4M of recordings it got.

  • @TheCalebxy I cannot be bothered to discuss this with you - I didnt even say the beast below got 4M I said it fell by 4M compared to the eleventh hour and for god sake there is a reason - you cannot see it - the scripts are soap dramas, complicated - the monsters are recycled bullshit , I do not want to hear someone change my mind about the doctor who I grew up with and knowing - 1963-2009. I gave it a chance and the shows just spat in everyones faces - familys dont watch it -BBC just axe it PLZ

  • @RegenerationStorm Most of the monsters in this series have been new. In fact, the only episode so far to feature old monsters has been episode 7. But if you don't want to discuss it, then that's ok.

  • @TheCalebxy S5E3 Daleks S5E4/5 Weeping Angels s58/9 Silurians S512/13 EVERY MONSTER IN DOCTOR FLAMING WHO S6E7 Cybermen S6E11 Weeping Angels, Daleks , doctor himself [How fucking original] , S6E12/13 Silence AGAIN - The imagination is dead - deal with it

  • @RegenerationStorm Now a list of the new monsters. S5E1: the Atraxi, Prisoner Zero S5E2: the Smilers, the Star Whale S5E6: "Vampires" S5E7: Eknodine, The Dream Lord S5E10: Krafayis S5E11: Fake Tardis S6E1/2: the Silence S6E3: Siren S6E4: House S6E5/6: Gangers S6E7: Headless Monks S6E8: Teselecta S6E9: Peg Dolls S6E10: Handbots S6E11: Minotaur S6E13: Pterodactyls That's 20 new monsters, compared to 8 reused ones.
  • @RegenerationStorm Sorry, 19 new monsters, not 20. :P

  • @TheCalebxy The Ratio of old and new monsters - compared to the RTD Era - looks shit in comparison - Series 1 , 8/13 were new , Series 2 9/13 were new , Series 3 10/13 were new , Series 4 8/13 were new , Specials 3/5 were new , Series 5 6/13 were new , Series 6 - from the trailers there are weeping angels daleks silence cybermen .... you know the old kind *zzzzzz*

  • @RegenerationStorm Series 6: 9/13

  • @TheCalebxy Then the trailers have utterly failed to express that - and on average combined with Series 5 , it's not a very advertising amount of new monsters - we end up going backwards with the doctor all the damn time -.-

  • @RegenerationStorm The Comic-Con trailer shows: Gibbis, A Cyberman, A minotaur, A Silent, A Cyberman, Weeping Angels, A Peg Doll, A Dummy, A Handbot, A Viking type thing, A Minotaur, A Silent, A Minotaur, Handbots, Gibbis, A Handbot, A Silent, A Minotaur, Cybermen and finally the Astronaut.

    So it shows 12 new monsters and 8 reused monsters. Looks fine to me.

  • @TheCalebxy It was misleading - it repeatedly showed all of the old villains for my distaste. You obviously went through that really carefully to make out which monsters appeared where - wheras natrually on your first watch you can't do that - what I saw and always see is the same old recycled monsters flashing past , as if to look somewhat cool - well - according to ratings , unlikely [Colin Baker tone of voice there]

  • @RegenerationStorm Well, the fact of the matter is, it showed more new monsters than old. And maybe you only noticed the old ones because you're actually familiar with them. When you see something you know, you think "I know that monster" but when you see something you don't know, it passes through your mind unnoticed.

  • @TheCalebxy Well it's beyond the point , there was so much use of time to show all of the old villains you can't really miss them - I know and can vision in my mind David Walliam's character , I know what a teradactyl looks like , they've done it in all of their finale trailers, they chuck in imagery of the old villains to win people over - well , the 5m that even saw what a Silence looked like LOL :D

  • @RegenerationStorm *7.30M

    And I don't get your point. The trailer showed more new monsters than old monsters, and it showed them more times.

  • @TheCalebxy Not from my memory of watching it back , and I watched it just now, I still see blunt cutting of every old villain brought back and that dissapoints me as a fan because I wanna see new monsters - sure they might do more new monsters but the trailer did not show that for me, :/

  • @RegenerationStorm But it *did* show more new monsters than old.

  • @RegenerationStorm In fact, in the TV trailer for series 6 part 2, the only reused monsters it shows are a Silent, twice, and the Astronaut.

  • @TheCalebxy how many classic doctor who episodes have you watched may i ask?

  • @dwho1994 Two and a bit. The Tenth Planet, Earthshock, and some of The Invasion of the Dinosaurs. Why do you want to know, may I ask?

  • @TheCalebxy well it would help if you knew more about doctor who before you claim the new stuff is good, but judging by the way Moffat is treating the show he must think the less people know about doctor who history the better as he obviously couldn't careless about the fans

  • @dwho1994 Why do I have to have watched Classic Who to know if Nu Who is any good? You don't need to compare it with anything before you're allowed to say it has good stories, good acting, good special effects, etc.

  • @RegenerationStorm I was expecting a little bit more myself I thought there was going to be a big war and stuff but all the episode really did was build up to the reaveal of river song

  • @Darkseeker109 I think it was time filler to be frank - This story was just chucked in props and costumes in a skanky old warehouse - with spare humans to fill in as soldiers and monks - the story was pointless... rivers ending was the only thing that mattered and even that was completely predictable

  • Seriously want this music! Epic!

  • @ImmyLovesHerIPod its kings legion from two steps from hell

  • Where can I find this

  • wow, i've never gotten so many replies on one comment before.

  • Rory: Whats happening to her

    The Doctor: Contractions

    Rory: Contractions?

    The Doctor: Shes going into labour

    Rory: ????

    The Doctor: I thought you supposed to be a nurse?!

  • We don't know if the little girl from 1969 was River, we know that river is Amy's daughter but we don't know if river is able to regenerate.

  • I allerady saw it

  • omg. Two Steps From Hell-King's Legion, thats the background music there that made this trailer completely EPIC.

  • River is the little girl who is also Amys Daughter, all clear now?

  • why doesnt the next ep. come out before next fall?

  • @VintageSnatchy It doesnt come out till next fall howd you find out!? OMG i didnt know that i thought it had been canceled oh what a relief so if its coming out then its probably going to be a epic awesome episode if they are taking that long

  • @ASLDude1997 it think they said it in the end of the ep. pr i read it some were, but im 100% sure it does :D and ohh yeah i hope it gonna be a looong movie or something! :DDD

  • @ASLDude1997

    August 27th, is when it's coming back.

  • @NizzleIndustries ok i know that you are trying to make a point here, and it a terrific hypothesis, but i love the name you gave her. Rivelody. brilliant. oh and also, wouldn't "River" technically be her LAST name, and "Song" would be her first. "Melody Pond" River=Pond Melody=River.

    sorry im sure you already know this but i just couldn't help but to say it to someone

  • @masteraj57 i meant Melody=Song. sorry

  • frickin epic!!! lol cant wait til nxt fall!!!

  • In regards to who blew up the Tardis and was apprently trying to erase the universe ask yourself this: Who tried to erase the entire of creation before and didn't that voice inside the Tardis sound like someone we heard before? :)

  • @LibraGamesUnlimited what voice? i mean, what did it say? i don't remember.

  • @masteraj57 I don't really recall if it was you or someone else but I THINK they were refurring to the voice inside the TARDIS before it blew up. For some reason I assumed it was Davros and that he orginally said it in the episode when he stole all the planets and tried to erase everything.

    I guess to make a long story short (too late) I was saying it was perhaps him either directly or something he did to the TARDIS during that story or something. :)

  • Jwest1892, likely River DOES remember but since she's playing things close to the chest and trying to protect the timeline she would pretend she didn't. Kinda the same reason she doesn't run up to Amy from day one and say "Oh hello mum" or something. :)

  • I2m still confused does River song loves the man she killed?

  • A faint question that's bugged me about Series 5 and 6 has always been why do our Universes' Cybermen do not ressemble that of the head found in the glass cabinet that The Ninth Doctor found in the episode "Dalek"- in "The Age of Steel" The Tenth Doctor also commented on the severed head, commenting that our Universe's Cybermen WOULD look exactly like that should we ever see one. But apprently ours are parallel with no C.

  • @RegenerationStorm Actually, in "The Age of Steel" he says "Yeah, there are cybermen in our universe too, they started on an ordinary planet just like this one, then swarmed across the galaxy". That's all he ever says of them. Anyway, their design changed almost every story, so it's not like changing the design is a new concept. Plus, the classic cybermen were rubbish. That will offend many people, but that is my opinon, and you cannot change it.

  • @imjustchillinftw I respect your views on the cybermen as a fan, but Rose adresses to the tenth doctor in the Age of steel about where that particular cyberman was- the cabinet in the museum, its on footage - it was a Revenge of the Cybermen head. I know weather its budget cuts or plain cant be bothered that the Mondas Cybermen havent returned -but I wish just for continuity reasons Moffat stuck to his guns and included that version in The Pandorica Opens and A Good Man Goes To War. :/

  • @RegenerationStorm Very true, but the Cybermen did evolve their design throughout their existence, and they did split into different factions (so the museum head may just be from a dfferent faction). The cybermen in "A Good Man Goes To War" are Mondasian (they removed the logo). I tend to ignore "The Pandorica Opens". That episode was just one massive continuity error. I think the cybermen are a special case, seeing as their design has changed so much, that we are meant to ignore their design

  • @RegenerationStorm Basically what we really need is a good, proper 2 episode cyber-story. Exclusively about the mondasian cybermen. That may hopefully clear things up :)

  • @imjustchillinftw Agreed :)

  • Comment removed

  • I really need help, I'm going to the doctor who convention tomorrow, but have NO idea for a costume? Something home made obviously, but ANY ideas would be appreciated xx Thank's x

  • @Michin725 wear a fez.

  • keep on clicking 00:20 and stop at she will be do that all the time it sounds like a arguement

  • I still don't understand why AMY and RORY's child is that much important, I'm disappointed its not AMy and Doctor's daughter it would be interesting

  • @MrQuaFLe that would have ruined the entire show. It's verging on being too silly as it is.

  • I think River Song LIED about her identity in the end of this episode. I just had that gut instinct that she can't be __________. Its just way off the plot. I know for a fact!

    Remember the Big Bang episode? Didn't she call that Queen lady from the future UK episode "Mom"? I don't believe that she is __________ (blanked out the spoilers).

  • @Blueknightex she calls her "ma'am", not "mum", seeing is she is Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth X, you'd give her some respect, even if she is sitting on the floor pointing a gun at you, and even if you are River Song holding a painting of the TARDIS blowing up :)

  • @imjustchillinftw oh I see. My bad then xD I'm still shocked that she is Amy's daughter. This is confusing x-/

  • @Blueknightex Not for me. I'm curious as to how the SIlence managed to take control of the TARDIS and blow it up, there must be some Time Lord involvement (possibly Omega or The Rani). Also, I hope Moffat explains why on this occasion blowing up the TARDIS would erase history, because that has been threatened countless times throughout the show's history, with the Doctor never showing any concern for universal erasion (if that's a word). Also, the Daleks destroyed many TARDISes in the Time War

  • @imjustchillinftw Hey i think part of the reason it took the universe with it was because thats what whoever blew it up wanted:) like i dont think they always do but in that case it was designed to if that makes sense i think he says something about it in the big bang:)

  • @TheDanTooker I agree, but I hope that it's explicitly explained, so as to avoid confusion. :)

  • @imjustchillinftw Yeahh, your right there :) like there was a lot of confusion about rory whether he was still plastic or not :)

  • @imjustchillinftw WHo says the Silence blew up the Tardis?

  • @TheCalebxy Well, i think that's what's implied, they must have some conection to it, because they always said "the universe is cracked. the pandorica will open. silence will fall." My theory is that te Silence were charged with protecting the little girl (possibly River), and turning her into a weapon, by Korvarian and her army, who is being guided/assisted by the Rani, who is working for Omega. He originally gave the Silence the means to destroy the tardis (cont. on next comment)

  • @imjustchillinftw and a way in which to make it erase the universe, as a revenge attack on this universe (coz he is trapped in his own antimatter universe, so would be unharmed). This initial plan failed, so he designed the plan to turn River into a weapon to destroy the Doctor, which would open the way for an invasion or something like that. Also, the Silence were placed on earth as a tool for Omega/The Rani. Just a THEORY :)

  • @imjustchillinftw They didn't say that. Prisoner Zero did.

  • @TheCalebxy By "they" i meant that characters in general said that (or variations thereof). There was also the disembodied voice in the TARDIS in Pandorica Opens, and the constant references throughout the series. I say we sit and wait until Part 2 of the series and the finale for an explanation :)

  • @imjustchillinftw I'm pretty sure "Silence will fall" was only said twice in series 5. Once by Prisoner Zero and once by the voice in the Tardis.

  • @nickshep626 Blowing sh*t up is the Masters job

  • The 'Eyepatch Lady' Reminds Me Of 'Bette Davis' From A Movie Called 'The Anniversary'.

  • Notice at around 0:09 how the Cyberman on the left has the coolest gun-sling move ever.

  • @tojeemIV Interesting... You are a BEAST!

  • i missed this ep.cuz i was away. Anybody know where i can c the full ep?

  • @ButterflyofOceans If you have itunes you can download it for £1.89 and £2.49 for it in HD. I'm sure you know what itunes.

  • @LaurentzandLuke lol i dont have itunes. Im so behind the times

  • I missed out on this season's episodes. Although, I did see clips and River S. revealing to Amy that she is her daughter...but who is the father?

  • @OnCloudNine62

    Rory - they are married after all

  • @OnCloudNine62 Rory

  • @OnCloudNine62 Definitely Rory. In the opening of the episode, Amy tells her daughter all about her father, the Last Centurion.

  • @OnCloudNine62 It is Rory. Who else? LOL it can't be the Doctor. Just look up the episode online and watch it. A lot of people have already uploaded it.

  • Anybody know what the music in this trailer is? It sounds a lot like Two Steps from Hell, but I can't find anything that matches.

  • @Pythosblaze Sctratch that, I just found it. The music is "King's Legion" by Two Steps From Hell. Thank you, Shazam app.

  • How is it that River can regenerate, and she died in the first episode she was in?

  • @whattheheckification Just because she can regenerate doesn't mean she's immortal. I mean, the Doctor himself was killed in "Turn Left" and in "The Impossible Astronaut". I don't remember who said it, but someone said that if he's killed before he can regenerate, the Doctor (or any Time Lord/Lady) stays dead.

  • @whattheheckification 2 things: Time Lords have the ability to regenerate, but this does not mean they cannot die; and who says River really dies then? You'll notice her body was missing after all the missing people were uploaded from the central computer system of the Library. Maybe not so final after all?

  • when this video was aired there was 2 words, 2 words resonating in every mind, in every species, on every planet, throughout the entirety of time and space, 2 words. FUCKING, EPIC!

  • I felt the episode seemed rushed and should have been a two-part mid season finale.  I was a bit disappointed at how it went but i absolutely love the River Song character. She is the best and has a great actress playing her that makes it even better!!!

  • i would honestly like to see a finale that doesn't involve daleks, cybermen, sontarons, the master etc. it's getting really stale

  • @Demonsword92 Well the season ain't over yet.

  • @laur3ooo yes but we haven't seen the master for a while so to please the fans, he'll need to make another appearance -_- apparantley omega is coming back and i'd imagine the master is involved somehow

  • If River is the little girl, i wonder why it seems like she is seeing the silence and the space suit for the first time. If she was the one that broke out of the suit, wouldn't she have remembered it?

  • @jwest1892 spoilers

  • @jwest1892 well i think River foresaw this happening and repressed the memories by way of a Targeted Neuron Implosion, like when the Doctor regenerates, but causing her to lose that part of her memory. or her memories were in a time lock.

  • @jwest1892 no thats the whole point about the silence you dont remember them.

  • @doctorw2 i would think she would remember being a little girl though

  • @jwest1892 not when someone has fabricated your memories.

  • @doctorw2 yeah, i guess that could be. Just gonna have to wait a few months and see.

  • @jwest1892 time can be rewriten

  • @jwest1892 maybe it's because they erase your memory of the encounter? I don't know, just a guess. :)

  • @jwest1892 She is a very good at not "spoiling" things. For instance, in The Pandorica Opens, she pretends not to know Rory.

  • @TheCalebxy Yeah im beginning to think maybe she just didnt know like at some point shes had her memory tampered with?

  • @jwest1892 also if that was her killing the doctor why would she shoot herself

  • @jwest1892 Personally, i think that could be the doctor and Rivers child, But probs not lol x

  • @jwest1892 thats exactly what i thought, but there's always a possibility that she had to pretend not to recognize anything so that a specific event (such as the doctor "dying") would still occur.

  • @jwest1892 At first i would of been like: Moffat will think of something up. But he's really becoming an ass now. he's sort of outstaying his welcome with the recent epsiodes and i still prefer him to RTD in so many ways that RTD just made the show boring and predictable and a drama where it wont take risks but in Day of the Moon, so much was crammed in it felt he was adding plot points in that he forgot and will do nothing with. the ep 7 cliffhanger was predicatble and dumber than the ep 6 one

  • @jwest1892

    River Song's story is being told backwards. When she was first introduced she was killed and put into that library. So as River's story goes on she'll eventually meet her younger self. Also Alex Kingston (River Song actor) knew the entire time that her character was the daughter of Amy and Rory. The director or executive producer i forget which tells the actors tidbits of information about their character without the others knowing. So essentially she knows the entire story.

  • @jwest1892 i wasn't aware that River WAS the little girl. i thought she was just Amy's daughter.

    but if she IS the little girl, maybe she doesn't remember because she technically died in 10's time as the Doctor. so maybe it messed her up. or maybe, since the little girl appears to be a reincarnating time lord.......ohhhhhhh.

    IDK

    Time Travel's Compilicated

  • @jwest1892 But we don't know if River regenerations are as the Time Lord ones, it could be that he doesn't remember anything after regenerating...

  • @jwest1892

    Who said she was the little girl from the first episode??

  • @jwest1892 but remember, you can only remember the silence when you are looking at them

  • @jwest1892 Didnt they clone the doctor once?

  • @jwest1892 I think she didn't give her knowledge away on purpose,after all,she's very good in keeping the "spoilers" as secrets and acting like she doesn't know anything.

  • @jwest1892 = shes reacting completely normal its called childhood trauma... if i was facing my childhood fears for the first time, and they were that bad and freaky !!!! i think i would have been running... doctor speed... lol ;)

    p.s.

    you CANT remember the silence.... remember!!?