This Speaks to my Soul...I am a recent convert from Baptist to Presbyterian and this one is a Big Favorite in the Presbyterian Church...it's so angelic!God Bless-Steve
Not to make too fine a point of things, but the song written to honor the Butcher of Culloden was, "See The Conquering Hero Comes", which was part of Judas Maccabeus in the late 1740's. In 1884 Edmond Budry took the music from, "Conquering Hero", added these words, and retitled it, "Thine Be the Glory". Richard Birch Hoyle translated the words from French to English in 1923.
One man's hero is another man's butcher. I guess it depends on your point of view....in this case, though, the choice is pretty clear cut. Not only did Cumberland have wounded and surviving prisoners slaughtered, but after the battle he engaged in a campaign of extermination that was so vicious that some of his own officers protested at its sheer brutality. That sort of thing doesn't seem so "heroic" to me, but then I never did care much for tyrants. IDamn good music, though!
Interesting comments Young95 - though I'd like to see source documents to back up your more extreme claims about the Duke of Cumberland. Don't forget we're talking about 265 years ago, and warfare then - on all sides - was not governed by the Geneva Convention! Billy Cumberland was beloved by his own troops (not always the case in those days!), and adopted a conciliatory line towards clans such the Grants (my own clan) who sought unity after Culloden. Agree with you about the music though!
One of the quirks of history is that it is usually written by the victors, and those accounts tend to be just a bit biased. That Culloden was a bloody battle is not in dispute. It is its aftermath, and the wholesale slaughter of prisoners in the days following the battle that earned him the title of "butcher". Whether he personally ordered this slaughter is in question. But there is an old military adage....a commander is always responsible for what his troops do, or fail to do.
It is not only the victors who try to write history - just look at the obscenity of certain contemporary holocaust-denying "history" spewed out by neo-Nazi apologists! No-one will ever know the truth about the aftermath of Culloden - but one thing is for certain, and that is that George II and his Government had a vested interest to pursuing unity and peace once the Battle. "My own" clan, the Grants, although initially siding with the Jacobites, definitely sought unity afterwards.
Sind sie doch. Bereits vor Händel gab es hervorragende englische Komponisten und Musiker ... W.- H. Monk, Th. Ravenscroft, H. Purcell... selbst später mit Elgar und Co. Alles geniale Komponisten !!! So sieht es aus !!
Der Komponist heißt übrigens Georg Friedrich Händel und stammt aus der Stadt Halle an der Saale. Er ist später nach London ausgewandert und ist dort auch gestorben.
@Neder1and, What is "consumerism"? What caused it? What influences were operating to create the style of music that created the piece that is different from our present surroundings?
I am white and Austrian. The art and music of the Third Reich (which you must like, based on you name)is usually void of the spark of humanness which is precious in all of us. It speaks of the subjugation of individual spirit (the source of art, inspired by God) to political ideology. Do not equate race with art and music, which can be perverted to horrific ends.
sinuc how would u know Handel kept his private life very private, however he was very forthright with opinion, n thats the truth, if u call truth bitching, that with respect is ur opinion and problem
I award this 3 KING'S THEATRES for having a level of lyric phrase sensitivity and dynamic that most Händel ensemble performances do not have.This goes on my HÄNDEL AS AN ELIXIR FOR SYNTHESIS PLAYLIST
a naturalised Briton. England to all intense purposes ceased to exist in 1707. Handel was the first composer for the Union. This piece was in fact written for William Augustus Duke of Cumberland aka the "Butcher" of Culloden.
Although he indeed did live in England (I don't think he strayed very far from London), he became a naturalised Briton in 1727. I've just checked the wikipedia.
Amazing arrangement till the end :O its quite modern, timeless i say
nuggie9511 3 months ago
I am surprised - this song German children sing at Chrismas! I didn't know its from Händel.
Elberiver11 6 months ago
This Speaks to my Soul...I am a recent convert from Baptist to Presbyterian and this one is a Big Favorite in the Presbyterian Church...it's so angelic!God Bless-Steve
KmusicSteve 6 months ago
Is ANYTHING Handel wrote BAD?
NO
BasilFawlty4444 9 months ago 2
Georg Friedrich Händel
Blasmusikant97 9 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
what a fatass ugly homo
jhavid2 9 months ago
Ahhhh ........ "Another fine piece of Baroque Music compos'd by Mr Handel"
hot5pur11 1 year ago
Nice one
SandrineSoprano 1 year ago
Thumbs UP --- and God's kisses until Judgement's Day ...
TheAaronmoses 1 year ago
Grandiose! Thanks for publishing it!
Into my language: ¡Grandioso, gracias por haberlo publicado!
alvaropstn 1 year ago
grazie di esistere
monologoinfinito 1 year ago
Majestic, divine, moving.
antonoine31 1 year ago
בהחלט לא הגיוי
gjack40 1 year ago
Im reading his biography from gutenberg and downloading his music right now..his music have always inspired since I was 14yrs old..
wisesatyr72 2 years ago
Not to make too fine a point of things, but the song written to honor the Butcher of Culloden was, "See The Conquering Hero Comes", which was part of Judas Maccabeus in the late 1740's. In 1884 Edmond Budry took the music from, "Conquering Hero", added these words, and retitled it, "Thine Be the Glory". Richard Birch Hoyle translated the words from French to English in 1923.
young95 2 years ago
Not the "Butcher" of Culloden - but the Hero of Culloden who saved Britain from Popery. Culloden was a second Boyne!
AlanDHarvey 2 years ago
One man's hero is another man's butcher. I guess it depends on your point of view....in this case, though, the choice is pretty clear cut. Not only did Cumberland have wounded and surviving prisoners slaughtered, but after the battle he engaged in a campaign of extermination that was so vicious that some of his own officers protested at its sheer brutality. That sort of thing doesn't seem so "heroic" to me, but then I never did care much for tyrants. IDamn good music, though!
young95 2 years ago 2
Interesting comments Young95 - though I'd like to see source documents to back up your more extreme claims about the Duke of Cumberland. Don't forget we're talking about 265 years ago, and warfare then - on all sides - was not governed by the Geneva Convention! Billy Cumberland was beloved by his own troops (not always the case in those days!), and adopted a conciliatory line towards clans such the Grants (my own clan) who sought unity after Culloden. Agree with you about the music though!
AlanDHarvey 1 year ago
One of the quirks of history is that it is usually written by the victors, and those accounts tend to be just a bit biased. That Culloden was a bloody battle is not in dispute. It is its aftermath, and the wholesale slaughter of prisoners in the days following the battle that earned him the title of "butcher". Whether he personally ordered this slaughter is in question. But there is an old military adage....a commander is always responsible for what his troops do, or fail to do.
young95 1 year ago 3
Dear young95,
It is not only the victors who try to write history - just look at the obscenity of certain contemporary holocaust-denying "history" spewed out by neo-Nazi apologists! No-one will ever know the truth about the aftermath of Culloden - but one thing is for certain, and that is that George II and his Government had a vested interest to pursuing unity and peace once the Battle. "My own" clan, the Grants, although initially siding with the Jacobites, definitely sought unity afterwards.
AlanDHarvey 1 year ago
deg være ære, kristus underlagt :D
vegardarnesen 2 years ago
sounds actually like a christmas song
urbis92 2 years ago
how is the artist/orchestra? it's a very lucent performance, just like the choral version. I can't find a good perfomance on internet shops
henk bouwman NL
intherdt1 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I love this music.
Too bad they were Christians =[
opiekat138 2 years ago
the choral version ist much better!
camposi 2 years ago
Vo ist mein handy?
OspreyInTheSky 2 years ago
immer fascho, immer nazi gelabber, das zerstört die wirkung dieser musik
ParisHilton1982 2 years ago
juhu schubladendenken - dummer fascho :) - also der mit den engländern xD
KeinSkin 2 years ago
Vielleicht weil er Ahnung von klassischer Musik hat? Weißt du überhaupt was ein Fascho ist?
thoumes 2 years ago
Engländer wären zu solch einer Musik wahrlich nicht fähig gewesen!
eisman1976 2 years ago
Sind sie doch. Bereits vor Händel gab es hervorragende englische Komponisten und Musiker ... W.- H. Monk, Th. Ravenscroft, H. Purcell... selbst später mit Elgar und Co. Alles geniale Komponisten !!! So sieht es aus !!
Traverso66 2 years ago 2
@Traverso66 Many of England's greatest composers are often ignored by the 'mainstream' classical listeners. John Dowland, for example.
seenherdressedinblue 2 years ago 2
@eenherdressedinblue
Yessss !! I agree with everything you said.
John Dowland is a very good example.
Traverso66 2 years ago
Der Komponist heißt übrigens Georg Friedrich Händel und stammt aus der Stadt Halle an der Saale. Er ist später nach London ausgewandert und ist dort auch gestorben.
Arminius1984 3 years ago
The theme song of Jack Frake!
Beethovens7th 3 years ago
Consumerism killed arts.
This piece of art is not to be compared with commericalized Rap or R&B. This (and Classical music in general) is pure devotion, passion, and emotion.
Neder1and 3 years ago 32
Classical was shit. Baroque is where it's at!
userblue 2 years ago
@Neder1and, What is "consumerism"? What caused it? What influences were operating to create the style of music that created the piece that is different from our present surroundings?
colorado4815162342 8 months ago
Great version!!
Neder1and 3 years ago
First day of Khanucca today and thanks to Handel who gave us one of this Holiday's most beautiful songs.
יום ראשון של חנוכה היום ותודה לגאורג פרידריך הנדל שנתן לנו את אחד משירי החג היפים ביותר
ernent 3 years ago
I am white and Austrian. The art and music of the Third Reich (which you must like, based on you name)is usually void of the spark of humanness which is precious in all of us. It speaks of the subjugation of individual spirit (the source of art, inspired by God) to political ideology. Do not equate race with art and music, which can be perverted to horrific ends.
- Hans
lichtbroeder 3 years ago 32
Period.
fofoitkonen 2 years ago
@lichtbroeder Would Carl Orff be an exception to this, in your view?
seenherdressedinblue 2 years ago
@lichtbroeder
Well said, Austrian! Regards from Spain.
alvaropstn 1 year ago
Wow - I didn´t know that this chrismassss-song was from Händel?!?
camposi 3 years ago
he anglicized his name as George Frederick Handel..
danielevans89 3 years ago
sinuc how would u know Handel kept his private life very private, however he was very forthright with opinion, n thats the truth, if u call truth bitching, that with respect is ur opinion and problem
praskovia13 3 years ago
At least the name should be right.
Georg Friedrich Händel.
rbb74 3 years ago 4
Not when he was in Great Britain. He wrote his own name like this
Guangwudi 3 years ago
this composition I sang when I was seven years in germany at school, at christmas , but I don't knew that it was of haendel
zoroas7 3 years ago
I award this 3 KING'S THEATRES for having a level of lyric phrase sensitivity and dynamic that most Händel ensemble performances do not have.This goes on my HÄNDEL AS AN ELIXIR FOR SYNTHESIS PLAYLIST
smithsherman 3 years ago
The BBC World Cup version of this song is much better!! A potential soundtrack to be played in Superhero films (i.e. Superman)
mramo 3 years ago
When the US plays Pomp and Circumstance at their graduation ceremonies, Japan plays this at their ceremonies. It's very royal, don't you think?
URhnsi35 3 years ago
@URhnsi35 It's very regal. Also much more calm. I wonder what that says about the US...
seenherdressedinblue 2 years ago
I heard this in Westminster Abbey the other day. Marvellous acoustics, and the choir sang like angels
URhnsi35 3 years ago
Thank you for this music by Handel. I truly love it.
sharonlct 3 years ago
wonderfull !!!!
DIDIDIDIEGGGOO 4 years ago
i hope u know that hes actually from germany but lived in england!?
geesoul 4 years ago 2
a naturalised englishman
englishjac 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
he`s a german bitch.
sinuc 3 years ago
a naturalised Briton. England to all intense purposes ceased to exist in 1707. Handel was the first composer for the Union. This piece was in fact written for William Augustus Duke of Cumberland aka the "Butcher" of Culloden.
reb0118 2 years ago
Handel lived most of his life in England, and became English by Act of Parliament in 1727. Check it out.
oldgattonian2 2 years ago
Although he indeed did live in England (I don't think he strayed very far from London), he became a naturalised Briton in 1727. I've just checked the wikipedia.
reb0118 2 years ago
@reb0118 "to all intents and purposes."
seenherdressedinblue 2 years ago
Quite right.
reb0118 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
very good but not as good as DAFT PUNK i saw on saturday. they changed my life.
hellathatguy 4 years ago
Wow, I have to download this video because I cant find the music ANYWHERE. And thats without the vocals..
d2eux 4 years ago
soooooo relaxing. i love handel.
KC1967 4 years ago 4
Absolutely beautiful rendition of one of Handel's finest pieces. So majestic and stirring, nothing today even comes close!
Marylandguineapigguy 4 years ago 3