Added: 5 years ago
From: myhopesaresohigh
Views: 248,269
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,084)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I think that Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson are perfect for the roles they play! All u people for hate Kristen Stewart...are u serious!! ugh! She is so BEAUTIFUL!!!! She makes whoever that girl was look like country cow manure. Rob-hottest man alive. but he is so much more. jeez. hes got such a funny personality!!!!!! hes beautiful inside and out. so all you twilight haters--suck it.

  • He is the most tan, un vampire looking boy band refuge I have ever seen. And she looks like someone you would punt on kick a ginger day. Other then that, its cute to see little kids like you use your imaginations. But maybe you should just make your own story rather then ruin someone elses.

  • @lollipopfop Emily Browning was Stephanie Meyer's Original choice becuase she wrote the book in her description, look in the movie archives in 2007, of stephanie meyers website so don't offend the poor girl for getting at least the female role right.~

  • @lollipopfop Congrats on being my first troll! It's awesome that you have your own opinions of who should play these characters, but these were my choices four years ago. And I'm sure someone of your superior maturity level can understand that with novels it is up to the reader to interpret how the characters look, and therefore no one can actually ruin your version of the story if you have a strong enough imagination in the first place.

  • twilight was a terrible movie and Emily is just to good for that low crap

  • this was my fave video before the movies it even is now, i still think this is the perfect cast i dont like kristen stewart as an acress robert pattinson has kinda grown on me though

  • whats the guys name? i reckon he wud hav bin a better edward

  • This is still one of my favorite videos on Youtube. It reminds me of the good old days in the Twilight fandom. Before all of it blew up into the circus it is now.... I miss those days. When talking to Stephenie Meyer was as simple as getting on her myspace page and only a few (intelligent) people knew what Twilight even was. I wish they'd chosen Henry and Emily (neither are too old! twenty-somethings play teenagers ALL OF THE TIME!)... I still see them in my head when I read the books.

  • you've done such an amazing job at making this video!!!

    this brings back the days when twilight was only known to like a few people and waaaay before the weird fan obsession- or would i say "robsession" - and before the day the media made it look horrible. (just my opinion- please don't flame me!)

    i wish emily browning and henry cavill played edward and bella!! not saying that rob and kirsten are bad actors but their personality and interpretation of the characters are waay off the planet...

  • @1LG1116 Aw thank you! I miss those good old days too! I think the fan girls are wayyyyyy too crazy about it! I mean, I used to be, but it felt like it was in a more intelligent way back then! hahaah

    I wish they had played the characters too, or at LEAST Emily over Kristin! She's pretty atrocious! hahah

  • @myhopesaresohigh i know what u mean!! i remember reading twilight and feeling slightly more intelligent but now i'm kinda sad that masses of haters out there associated it with being well... anything negative =(

    i know nothing's perfect, but u can't help feeling a little down and dissapointed when things go a little- umm... "awkward" with the movies and dodgy merchandising.....

  • OMGGG henry cavill is one of the most fittest men ever lol, mannnn hes hot... he is the Edward in my head, exactely how he should look, everything is perfect... even though i still do love rob :) Emily should have been Bella!!

  • the first edward in the vid was a bit 2 fat... i personaly choose emily browning as bella cos im biased. i liked it when emily did a series of unfortunate events

  • i dont get it? can somone explain this to me like seriously

  • Wow, I really love your twilight videos! They are what inspired me to make mine! i could definitely see that girl as Bella! Rob is........well, he is'nt the best match, but close :) great job :) <3 subscribe to my channel please?

  • glad these 2 wernt chosen there nothing comperd to Robert and Kristen

  • el vato esta bien ffeeeeooo

    encambio emily si esta hermosisisimaa

  • Okay Emily Browning and Gaspard Ulliel ( look him up) were MADE to be Edward and Bella. Instead the director chose a washed up druggie 18 year old and a party animal 20 year old

  • if emily browning had gotten the role. I might look past my problems with the series , and watch the films

  • man....wonder how they would have done if they got the parts... they look great and more the part i think

  • Henry Cavill the best for Edward ;)

  • Anybody would have been better as bella than Kristen Stewert. That girl can't act her way out of a paper bag.

  • I always imagined both of these as the characters when I was reading twilight. Dream teammmm

  • perfect awsome but..i think of gaspard ulliell mybe he will fit well.dis is my opinion only.....

  • im not feeling henry but emily would make a good bella =)

  • kristen looks right for Bella, but she isn't good at ACTING like Bella; Rob is alright, but he needs to work out more :|

  • lol

    these two people are the people stephanie myers personally requested for the roles.

    emily turned down the offer to audition, because she was exausted and needed time with her family. it was right after her movie, the uninvited.

    no news on this henry cavill.

  • @omochii123 Henry was busy doing the show "Tudors" =(

  • Sheesh, I thought Kristen did a great job being Bella. And how can someone think she can't act, especially after seeing her in that ballet studio scene?!

  • I think that Emily Browning is a very pretty girl. She has all the Bella qualities and isn't too old for the role. She's also a VERY good actress in dramas or roles which require emotion (ie. New Moon).

    Too bad they cast Kristen. I mean, she's not THAT bad but she's so drab! She's good at playing troubled teens and stuff which doesn't really fit in with the movie considering that Bella is very 'ordinary'.

  • @kittykat720 actually Emily rejected it they didnt turn her down

  • yeah, Henry Cavill for Edward!! :D

  • Just throwing this out there.. But in the Movie did either of the Characters say "I love you." Like they were SUPPOSSED TO! I mean for fucks sake I took my friend who hasnt read the books there and she fucking asked me if they were suppossed to be in love!!! .... God I hate Kristen..

  • @L00zzeerr you are SO right.

  • kristen is not like bella in the book!

  • rob is ugly, can't act and looks notta like edward... he ruined my fantasy of edward who had broze hair and actual muscles... he ruined edward :(

  • If you like Twilight go to RoseAndRudys channel and subscribe to them and look at their re-enactments! :)

  • i totally agree katsan88

  • Emily has the sensitivity that Bella demands, Kristen is too rough when she plays this character. Bella is madly in love. Teen love with a vampire is suppose to be dramatic, romantic, and intense!!! Kristen just talks her lines, she does not act them.

  • who is Henry Cavill??

  • she would be a good alice, since you say she is pixie like....

  • emily browning looks like a fairy

  • she's pretty pretty^^

  • Movie or no movie this is still my favorite video and these are still who I go off of when I pictue Bella and Edward (seeing as they're the most accurate according to the author)

  • is it just me or does she look asian?

  • she would have been a great bella. she's beautifully awkward. i could not think of anyone else but robert pattison as edward though. i think henry would have been a great emmett though. as soon as i saw him i thought of that... he seems very athletic and of course handsome

  • i wouldnt have liked her as bella

  • i agree w/u

  • lol.i think shes ugly

  • what about as alice?

  • nope.the alice they have is gorgeous and fits her character perfectly.emily just doesn't have the look to be one of twilights characters.maybe if the book called marked a house of night series was a movie,she seems like the lead character in that by the way she's described

  • If you would've said Robert Pattison as Edward before this movie came out, I would've said no way because I don't think he's that good looking (as his normal self), but the way they made him look in the movie turned that around for me. I think he was perfect for Edward.

  • Henry and Emily are my perfect Edward&Bella. Love them!!

  • wow, lol i used to love this video and was like AMAZING it was my fave video over the summer! Memories!!!!! and I still love it!!

  • i really dont think that this video is "awesome" but its okay

  • i agree w/u

  • wow this brings back memories for me too! i remeber the days when twilight was my thing, and almost nobody else knew about it. i was in love with emily and henryy. especially since they were stephenie's own picks, i know this'll sound crazy but it almost makes me wanna cry. i cant believe this is what twilight has turned into. now its all over the media and i hate the people they picked. they did ok but they'll never be emily or henry. ): i remember i watched this video like a year ago.

  • i dont picture emily browning as bella...she looks kinda preppy...in my opinion...but henry kinda looks like edward....but i love Rob and Kirsten..

  • I don't think you can replace Rob & Kristen but these r gd

  • henry wouldn't make a good edward.

    I think emily and rob would be perfect

    fuck the cast peeps/

  • WOW, this brings back memories

    back when twilight wasn't so crazy!!

    i love henry and emily

    they will always be my edward & bella <3

  • how can i watch this version of Twilight on the internet?

  • she was a better choose as bella

  • im sorry, but i think robert and kirsten are perfect for the role of bella and edward. Everytime i see Emily Browning i see lemony snickets :S

  • dont say your sorry this had been up for sooo long. i used to watch this a year and a half ago. nobody even knew robert and kristen existed. this was how twilight used to be. almost everyone wanted emily and henry. while some had there own ideas.

  • remember back then too but still i hated henry....he just wasnt my edward

    what should i say about emily/bella......she does look preppy in a way and her face is fat j/k i dont

    like kristen either as bella but rob is a better edward than henry tho i really wanted it to be Gaspard.....:((

    and u have to admit there are people like me who read twilight the 1 st month who came out who like the movie and the cast(not only new twi-pplz like rob and kristen i do too) and i also like emily and gaspard

  • i know shes violet to me not bella

  • same! xD I want to watch the movie so bad, my bro was scared xD

  • i wish emily and henry had gotten the parts! they r persfect! i hate kristen and ribert...blah!

  • Why must you use her as Bella? She is better. Bella is a whiny bitch.

  • ich find Henry Cavill zu alt .. wenn er

    edward cullen geworden wäre würde man den

    nich auf 17 schätzen .. Rob is the BEST !

    <3

  • ja rob is perffekt findi hc auch..aber in breaking dawn is er schon 25 oda so weißte und edward darf sich ja net verändern...

  • i love this movie it is the BEST ever!!

  • lets chat

    someone want to chat LS

  • I love Robert as Edward, hes adorable at it

    But im not sure if i really like Kristen as Bella

  • BLEHH!! i HATE kristen and rob!! HENRY AND EMILY ROCK!!

    THE MOVIE SUCKED!! it would of been sooo much better if henry and emily were casted as edward and bella!!

  • Henry Cavill will always be my Edward <3

  • I agree, absolutely

  • I agree with Tinkleneko and Grantscoolio below that HENRY CAVILL in the super best Edward Cullen. They said its becoz Henry is a little older already like 24? Why did they underestimate what make up/camera or even diet can do to create a 17 yo look! Robert Pattison and Kirsten really sucked in the movie. It was predetermined that the movie will make it...

  • i think Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson r the best for Edward and Bella. Robs gorgeous and really played the part well, u couldnt help falling in love with him

    and as for Kristen, she played Bella pretty good 2 because she really looked like an ordinary girl and i really saw her as Bella and their chemistry was perfect <3

  • oh they changed the ppl

    i honestly didn't kno that

  • they would have been so much better!!!!!

  • The best !!! Henry Cavill and Emily Browing !!

    Yeaah !! I love Song !!

  • i think R.Pattz is perfect for edward but not sure about Bella

  • I like Emily Browning better as Bella. I think she should have been Bella in the real movie.

  • i like rob as edward.

    but henry would have been really good too.

    ugh i dont really like kristen as bella

    it should have been emily!!! D:

    or someone else

  • Amen! Kristen's a bloody man! I watched the trailer fot the film and the scences like all sweet and itamate..until she opened her mouth and a mans voice came out..her voice is a turn off to the movie. Emily Browning was exactly the way the author saw it and the same as I saw it. As for Rob well...his head is shaped abit wierd and anyone who was in Harry potter should not be playing edward. Nor should anyone under average in looks should play him either. Go HENRY!!!

  • I'm sorry but I can't really imagine these 2 as Edward or Bella.

    I think Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson are a perfect in my opinion. Rob has that vampire look you can grow onto after looking at him a couple of times and realize how gorgeous he is and Kristen i think is perfect for it except that her voice is a bit of a monotone. I kinda hoped a little more higher and more emotion but other than that they're both perfect.

  • i dont get why people are looking at them as bella and edward? were they gonna put them as bella and edward before they found kristen and rob. im confused.

    kristen and rob are exactly what i pictured bella and edward to be, i am so happy-but ofcoarse other might disagree.but whatever!(:

  • Stephenie Meyer said that Henry Cavill looks like Edward the most, in her mind. This was wayyyy before the movie was being made. Not sure about Emily though. :3

  • they were the original "Edward and Bella" but the movie got re-casted and now they have sucky looking people for the parts...=(

  • i think kristen's okay for bella but henry cavill looks better than pattison for edward's part.

  • too bad its robert pattinson playing edward and kristen steward

  • Diddo:(

  • OMG, henry cavil is the perfect edward!!but too bad he got older. he could have played carlisle though. Rob is aight cmpared to henry

    k.thanks

  • worst cast ever.

  • it should totally be them...but i think the others will do just as well. her face is a little too soft to be bella anyway...

  • I totally agree that Emily Browning should have been Bella, but I totally think that Jonathan Jackson should have been Edward, personally I think he could have played that part so well.

  • umm no kristen and robert are the ones that really should be there!

    BUT SINCE THIS WAS ADDED ON 2006 THAN OH WELL..

  • I think Emily Browning should have been Bella, and Hayden Christiansen should have been Edward. I'm okay with Robert Pattinson being Edward, I guess, but Kristen Stewart has absoutely NO emotion in her voice. Everything she says is dull and monotonous... I don't think she makes a very good Bella.

  • I agree (:

  • henry and emily are perfect for edward and bella!

  • WTF.

  • stupid thats not edward or bella retard whoever you heard that from they are idiots just like he person who made this video crystalxlollipop is right

  • actually you're a retard for not looking at the date this video was made. this was made years ago. and i believe this is just how the video creator wanted the casting to be.

    stop being an idiot and learn to READ!

  • the cast is robert pattinson and kristen stewart(:

  • what rating is Twilight.

  • this is cute! i like Henry, and before i was totally rooting for Emily, but i don't know now- i really like the one they cast. she seems to have a lot more of bella's attitude, and emily seems like she'd be a lot more sweet...

  • wait, so who do you think is a better person for bella??? emily or kristen??

  • who are the real singers of this song?

  • Robert and Kristen all the way.

    Sorry, no.

  • do you know what the title of the song in the video is?

  • THEY'RE PERFECT!!! but we'll see how kirsten and rob do.

  • como se llama la cancion?

  • Hands down

  • this is the first twilight video i ever saw. i'm so glad, so much later, i could find it again!

  • it was added 2 years ago of coarse they wouldn't know the actors of the 2008 movie... lol

  • um...u guys! rob and kristen ARE PORTRRAYING EDWARD AND BELLA!

    if fans wanna picture emily and henry or gaspard or whoever as edward and bella it is FINE!

  • Rob and Kristen are the real actors for it.... Why not use the real actors? But that was good anyway!

  • I imagined bella as a strong, tough and unlike other girls in the book. I prefer Kirsten Stewart! Emily looks like a normal girl you can find in the mall.

    anyway, why do you people keep suggesting who's to be who in the movie?? you make the movie then! this is so annoying. i already love the characters. RESPECT THE DIRECTOR. ITS HER MOVIE- HER WAY.

    childish.

  • EVERYBODY can think of whom they like as Edward and Bella. Besides, Rob isn't the one whom the author pictured when she wrote the novel. So, everyone who have red the novel can imagine anyone that they think suits the character. Why, can't you disagree when you think that doesn't suits it better??! Everyone of us have different likes and dislikes. So what if we don't like Rob as Edward??! Or Kirsten as Bella??! And that isn't being childish, IT'S OUR WAY! BE NICE.

  • And one more thing, Henry Cavil is not the one I like..

  • Geez-Louise!

    It's a good video so don't trash it, and if you'd notice it was made before the characters were picked!WAY before.

    Be nice, and get your facts straight.

  • WaylayDaGirl, it's a freaking book. people can picture WHOEVER they want for edward and bella. you are childish.

  • Really people chillax. Good vid and stop the fighting

    Im not hippie

    But i am like Jacob cuz he is my fluffly wolfie

    BUT besides the fact everyone chill out and take a deep breath

  • will you ppl PLEASE STOP CUSSING!?!?!?!?!?

    and i do think that emily should have played her but stop cussing about it!

  • chill the fuck out....

    it's JUST the internet.

  • i will ALWAYS picture them as edward and bella

    but i think rob and kristen are good too! [:

  • IKR?! Its like DO IT RIGHT OR DONT DO IT AT ALL MAN! AND EDWARD IS FREAKIN FROM CHICAGO NOT BRITAIN!!!(the guy has an accent)

  • true ik & everbody knows rob as cedric & will never think of him as edward i thnk he'll make a good edward but he has the accent & he is supposed 2 b a city boy

  • yeah ik. i mean its nothing against him and all he did good as cedric, but edward, he might do good, but he doesnt sound like hes supposed too. in the book hes from chicago. i dont think i could think of him as edward either. the accent is just something edward doesnt have.

  • Me2 I would have LOVED him as carlysle!!!

  • all i know is on one of the things i read they said Henry Cavill is too old.

  • WOOO TEAM EDWARD MUHAHAHAHAHAHAH >:D

    Love it! 5 stars

  • Yes yes im one of the edward lovers

    OMFG I JSUT LOVE HIM HES SO FRICKEN HOTT<33333

  • Are they realseing a new movie because there is already one out?

  • i wish emily was bella in the upcoming movie :( I don't think the actress they have now fits her :/

  • they dont fit.

  • Wtf is this another twilight movie?

  • i think emily could do a great job as bella, kristen is good too.

  • he's perfect for edward but she isnt. she's too pretty.

  • HE WAS PERFECT FOR EDWARD!!!!!!!

  • people who cant see emily browning as bella are on crack or something cuz emily browning and henry cavill were bella and edward not kristen stewart and rober pattinson their nothing in comparison

  • I love this song, good pick.

  • i second that. it fits endward and bella soooo well.

  • i think the totally went completely wrong when casting they could have done 1000X better!

  • okayy honesty would these not make perfect characters

    Bella--Kristen Stewart, Edward- Gaspard Ulliel, Alice- Ashley Greene, Jasper- Alex Pettyfer, Rosalie- Olivia Wilde, Emmet- Kellan Lutz, Carlisle-Peter Facinelli, Esme-Elizabeth Reaser, Charlie-Billy Burke, Renee-Sarah Clarke, Phil-Matt Bushell, Laurent-Jared Leto, James-Cam Gigandet, Victoria-Rachelle Lefevre, Jacob-Steven Strait, Billy-Gil Birmingham, Jessica- Anna Kendrick, Mike-Michael Welch, Eric- Justin Chon, Angela- Christian Serratos

  • Not on your life babe Kristin is such a..... she said this about the harry vs twilight books "They're fantasy books................But there....different...one's"

  • Yeah she really doesn't seem too bright in real life...

  • I agree, I can't picture Emily as Bella. I really love Emily in the other films she has done, but she doesn't have that "girl-next-door" look that I thought Bella had. That's my personal opinion. (I still love Emily, I'm not bashing her at all, she is really pretty and a good actress)

  • WAHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!! i don't know. i don't think i'm going to see the movie because it would totally ruin my visions of the scenes and characters in the book.

  • I totally agree with you... im not sue i wanna see it either. it def is going to ruin what i imagine when reading it. :(

  • yeah i know! ugghhh....hahh!!!

  • the book is much better

  • i wish those were the actors for the movie

    cuz the edward on the movie

    is

    u-g-l-y!

  • ok the girl is like perfect for the part, but edward, um not how i imagined him!! ugh

  • Life is fun life is good, but lets all face it life is misunderstood, life is what we hold so close life is what we love the most. Life is the girl in the red satin dress, life is the boy in the worn walmart vest, life is what we want to be life is simply you and me! ------ not the best poem but...---------

  • ok wtf is wrong withu this is the best twilight mvid ever made!

  • should**

  • she's ok but edward shoul be gaspard!

  • haha good point. not sure who agrees, but in my opinion....hayden christensen is waaaay better than robert!!! especially after seeing jumper, i could totally imagine hayden as edward. sorta. well....if that was even possible. :) twi-hards...rock on :P

  • This is not fair they arent supposed to look li9ke that Edward is supposed to be gorgous!!!!\Im so dissapointed

  • I love Edward Cullen...and the casting of Robert Pattinson made me choke on my breakfast! Henry Cavil is SO much more...gorgy and Edward-like! Ugh...the injustice of it all.

  • in the book edward sounds soooo dreamy and lovablei cant wait it will be soo cute

  • ican not wait for the movie to come out i am a huge fan of the book and every thing they have and edward is hot in this i dont care bout bella thou

  • Is the movie out yet?

  • stephenie meyer (if you've read the book you should be able to spell it correctly) had nothing to do with the casting of actors/actoresses for the twilight movie

    so stop blaming her

    if you would visit the website you would know that already

    i think all the characters she chose are perfect for the movie and book.

    except for jackson rathbone and the man playing carlisle (the actors name has alluded me)

    they are unattractive blondes

    but kellan lutz...

    perfect-o!

    =]

  • no offence... don't like either characters' actors/actresses.. they're both sooooo ugly

  • They are both WAY!!!!!!! better than the acctual cast of the movie. I would have much rather have them play the characters than the ones they have now. They picked the ugliest guy they could find to play edward. This are so much better. I'm very mad at the cast for twilight.

  • Me too!!!!! That's not what i pictured Edward to look like at all!!

  • they scarred my brain of edward with the cast...!!!!! it ruined my imagination... the only one that fits the description is the girl that plays alice!!!

  • are they making New moon into a movie?

    xX

  • i love ur vid. at first i wanted henry cavill f edward cullen but then i saw an episode of the tudors(sp?) and i rescinded that idea, so yeah. but ur video is still cool. lol