Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,074)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 14 people are not going to get happy one day.

  • Like if Glee brought you here.

  • Wow! What else is there to say.

  • I get chills everytime I watch this

  • Cool!

  • Two legends, one amazing song the world must hear!

  • amazing...two of the greatest voices of all times together!!!

    

  • I cried watching this. It's just too amazing.

  • I literally watch and sing this video everyday after I get home from school :) they make everything fabulous, and just give the inspiration to keep doing the music I love. and it's totally a gay man's wet dream (now I understand XD even as a lady)

  • Beautiful

  • my goodness I've stumbled upon a GEM of a video. :)

  • One of my all time fav duets! Cry each time I hear it! Judy gave so much happiness and got so little in return.

  • ONE MORE TIME!

  • @exoticwierdo11 They may not be auto tuned for the live concert, but the show is most definitely auto-tuned. It's not necessarily a bad thing though, they have the natural ability to sing without assistance but the TV show needs to be perfect. But they are VERY auto tuned in the show.

  • Oh my goodness. This gave me chills. I never knew they sang together. What a dynamic duo! Absolutely exquisite.

  • Hey, I love Glee, but their rendition, compared to this original, sounds like a snot bubble popping. Effortless sounding.

  • glee DOES NOT FOR THE 100TH MOTHA FUCKIN TIME auto tune any bodys voice they ACTUALLY SING GOOD IS IT HARD TO BELIEVE SO MANY TALENTED PEOPLE COULD BE ON THE SAME SHOW!!!!! GO TO A FUCKIN CONCERT AND STILL TRY AND SAY THEY USE FUCKIN AUTO TUNE!!!! THEY DONT

  • @exoticwierdo11 I admit they are talented singers, but they just sing songs that are already legendary. I would respect them more if Glee wrote their own music and performed it, rather then performing every popular song that's already been written. Chris and La singing this song sounds forced. Judy and Barbra singing it sounds organic.

  • @millers3888 I think that's tha whole point of Glee to show wat show choirs n all that actually do.. lol they perform songs n compete they only did one or two episodes where they wrote their own songs but that was it

  • i wish i could sing like them.....

  • Does anyone know anywhere i could get the sheet music for this? it would be a massive help :)

  • A gay man's paradise.

  • :O

  • barbra streisand not cochinadas

  • Also it's nice to point out that this medley was Judy's idea. Her mind was so sharp. She also wrote "What is a boy" for "Dirty Hands Dirty face". The woman's IQ was so high. It is said that she only had to read the script of "SIB" once and had it in her beezer. We shall never see her likes again. Ty for the post!

  • I love both this and the glee version! :)

  • Shed Tears Everytime I Watch This

  • how old is barbra? dame she must be old as hell...

  • Its not just the sound of this that is beautiful, but the happiness that is expressed throug the connection they both have through this song.

  • I lOVE YOU BOTH! Truly genious

  • Judy Garland is the cutest lady that has ever existed. And Barbara looks so young!

  • JUST REMEMBER ........this was simply a TV SHOW!!! ALL THAT AMAZING PURE TALENT........NOW 1000 CHANELS AND A REMOTE THAT KEEPS FLIPPING AND STILL NOTHING EVEN CLOSE TO THIS

  • The absolute BEST of the best.

  • this song gives me goosebumps so much. yuuafbaja

  • I can hardly hear what Judy is saying because Barbra sings so loud. But still, it's beautiful.

    R.I.P Judy Garland;*

  • I swear.... she sounds so much like Liza.

  • @JasmineDuthie You mean Liza sounds like HER.

  • This is perfect!!!!!

  • two of my favourite singers, so great to see them singing together !

  • i really love barbra streisand soooo much and it is amazing that she is hmmnnnn how will i say? she never change like cher. from black n white to 3D,,, maybe they know where the fountain of youth is...

  • A month after I posted that comment, I still watch this every day...words can't describe. I love these ladies!

  • who else just got chills?

    

  • Gay? No, its beautiful...you mistundestand. Anyway i think Judy Garland is representing the old and Barbara is representing the new and its fabulous. What do you all think? The glee version is fantastic!!! Ken.

  • This has to be my favorite duet .....i love it.

  • It's the Rachel Berry outfit!!!

  • @pinkvespa95

    Well, not originally. Rachel Berrys outfit was designed to look like this one. (:

  • @kimmois was that really necessary? if you don't like it, don't watch it. simple.

  • @kimmois1 ok as the hottest teen on this site i can say this song is not gay at all troll and quite frankly i just wanna see justin get fucked gblt alday......

  • @hmorgan45 And you say this isn't gay?

  • @kimmois1 If great talent is gay, then it's gay! YAY!

  • @kimmois1 How can anyone get mad at Kimmois comment. It was a very funny comment -- and that's coming from an old lady who adores these two singers. He gave me a laugh -- it was a very comment -- one of the funniest I ever read on this site.

  • @ColumbiaPerna Thank you Columbia, some people seriously need to chillax a bit.

  • @kimmois1 Sorry to say, but only gays can have it so acurate !

  • waouh Judy éternelle Judy la grande Judy et Barbra comme son élève...les 2 plus grandes chanteuses américaines...émotions à son comble...

  • That's really AMAZING! Interesting that, IMO, Barbra always seemed to be a lady... while Judy always seems to be a girl...

  • This makes me happier than anything else in the whole wide world.

  • This is a real performance! I hate Glee. Don't get me wrong, I think all the singers on Glee have good voices, but I never feel any emotion in their singing. Judy Garland had one of those voices where you felt the emotions she was singing right along with her.

  • @craigjeffries why do you have to make a negative comment on such a wonderful performance - this has nothing to do with Glee

  • Amazing duet. Does anyone know how old both of them were during this?

  • @xGoldenSnitch - Barbra was 21 and Judy was 41.

  • Is this cathartic to to anyone else? nothing like those voices...

  • Can anyone "belt" a song better than these two? I doubt it. Amazing, yes! Simply amazing!

  • OMG!! it´s a amazing performance!!

    Bravo!!

  • this was done on my birthday! granted, it was years before i was actually born, but stiil :)

  • God! what a performance!

  • They were both beautiful and incredibly talented. We are lucky to have these videos now.

  • wowo Ms.Barbra was only 21 yrs old in this video!!!

  • my head is exploding from the amazingness

  • this never gets old!

  • we need 14 condoms and a time machine.

  • Lloreeee y lloreee q lindo, esto es simplemente hermosooo!!;0)

  • DAMN these ladies are so fabulous. I just watch this every day. And I don't mean listen, I mean WATCH. The world is better because of them!

  • wow this is a different version of barbra.she was pretty .what the hell happened???

  • @Lovett19991 Nearly 50 years happened.

  • Comment removed

  • @LimpsMcGee how old was she in this video??

  • Judy garland looks very cute to me

  • I want this for my ring tone...I'll never answer my phone

  • one more time...(after listening 20 times) Love Love Love Love

    Two wonderful voices...ok 1 more time and that's it.

  • Love Judy Garland. Love Love Love...

  • Rachel and Kurt do look very similar :)

  • I probably listen to this 5x a week...true talent never gets old.

  • How old was Judy Garland here? I thought they had colored video by the time this was released...

  • @CoryGuinn She was 41 here.

  • @millers3888 That's so weird. When she was in "The Wizard of Oz" they had just been getting around to colored video. It makes me wonder why half of the videos of her in older performances are still black and white.

  • @CoryGuinn Yeah I mean most of her movies after the Wizard of Oz were in color (Meet Me in St Louis, The Pirate, Till The Clouds Roll By, Easter Parade, A Star is Born etc.), but not a lot of people had color TV sets, so it was probably easier to film in black and white, and much cheaper too.

  • @millers3888 Makes sense, hahaha. Yeah, I knew all of those movies were in color, hahaha. That's why I was so confused. She's so talented. And so is her daughter, and so is Barbra Streisand.

  • Absolutely ADORE this!!!!!!

  • Q_Q Judy's voice makes me so sad and filled with nostalgia!!! I wish she had lived longer :(

  • @ToxicElegance Judy never had a chance. If you're familiar with her life from birth, you'd see she was doomed from the start. It's actually amazing she was able to live till 47.

  • Wasnt judy on an episode of glee??

  • @Asc82491

    no... judy passed away a while ago....

  • @Asc82491 she died in 1969??

  • 21! Barbra was 21 when she did this!

  • Are these not the two best voices of the 20th century? So sad we lost one.

  • is this about the great depression?

  • Judy Garland just got more beautiful with age.

  • respect ....

  • This song is not "cool", but no matter what you like or what age you are, you'd have to be a tone death idiot not to love this! These are the REAL "divas".

  • After this Judy said "Barbara was one of the last great belters." If only Judy was around to see Christina Aguilera. She has enormous talent too.

  • When they hit that high note together at 1.30 - OMG, my heart almost stops every time, it is just sheer pefection.

  • perfection.

  • Total Perfection!!!!

  • OMG!!! Why didn't i know about this before? I was watching some Barbra to cheer me up after a shitty week and i stumbled across this :O

  • God, I love them. <3

  • haha they actually look like kurt and rachel

  • Ive loved this for years but GLEEs choice of technology didn't affect the warmth,entertainment and vocal ability of those two singers. Epic this is, very very good GLEE's version was

  • love love love love

  • Judy is the TRUE Legend here but Barbra held her own ..xo

  • Just beautiful

  • I LOVE Barbara's hair!!

  • .......I think I just died.

  • boy did i adore that performance

  • Streisand is the only one who can sing in the same room as Judy and not look like a fool. :)

  • @RobertEllis2010 Hahahaha,totally..

  • @RobertEllis2010 Julie Andrews!

  • Shout Hallelujah

  • The emotions in this amaze me! At first Barbra is nervous and tense but Judy and the performance loosen her up and then it's like they try to out sing each other at the end.

  • @applelover09 She's not nervous, that's just the way she sings. When that voice comes out, I don't care how she acts.

  • @DrugsBeBadMkay1211 I love her voice too however it is a widely known fact that Barbra has stage fright.

  • Good luck not getting blown out of the water, there, Babs. Louder does not necessarily equal better.

  • @zEropoint68 Good thing she's better than.

  • Comment removed

  • This makes me cry, in a good way.

  • I love listening to real music. I would say our standards for music have fallen over the years but that would imply we still have one.

  • Beautful! My all time favourites!!

  • 1930

  • Wow! BOTH on the SAME STAGE!

    I love Judy and Babs!

  • This is real talent....these women are legends.

  • Woww ! Thats Beautiful Talent,Noww A Lot Of You Compare The Two,Dont Do That They Are Different In Many Ways-You See Barbara And Judy Dont Sing The Same Type Of Songs But Also Barbara Sounded Louder Because She Was Younger And Her Voice Was Stornger ,Thats Natural Ndd Judyy Although She Still Had A Strong Voice Was Older Nd Her Voice Was A Little Lighter There Should Be No Comparison They Are Both Beautiful And Wonderful//

  • I Adore Barbra , don't get me wrong but no one , not even HER can compare to Judy's Brilliance and Talent as a singer ....Judy is in a class all by herself ..xoxo

  • Google+ brought me here, but i really enjoy that Glee is letting another generation enjoy the wonderful music made by two amazing ladies!

  • Amazing. Barbra released her new album today! She's still terrific!

  • Great!!

  • The best of the best! It just can't be beat...Love those ladies.

  • LEGENDS......no talent as this ANYMORE

  • I love judy <3

  • barbra, larga vida

    

  • Thumbs up if you know about this before Glee.

  • @hughmonstah yep. YEARS before Glee, and I'm pretty young.

  • I think Barb tried to out voice her LOL

  • This is fabulous. I can't believe 11 people dislike this. What are wrong with those people.

  • Does anybody know where I can get the midi piano music for this? I can't find it ANYWHERE!! Plz message me if you do!

  • Barbra is sexy and cute here and just at the start of her unparalleled career. And, of course, Judy was divine. Love these gals!:)

  • outstanding! 

  • My god, two of the greatest voices combining to create one of the most magical songs ever sung...Thank You Judy so much for what you gave us while you were here...We love you for it and we will never forget you =)

  • This is literally the gayest thing I've ever seen. Having said that, it's awesome!

  • @ds28690 Usually anything gays appreciate is either awesome or ahead of it's time:)

  • @billyboylb hahahaha...preach it!

  • @LittleMonsterMan93 LOL..I know, right!? I love me some Gaga too!! Would love to see her do something with Barbra!

  • You can only imagine how many years ago this video was made and I'm born in the year 1983 yet it's been repeating numerous times.

  • i just love listning to this

  • I love how much Barbra is trying not to crack up.

  • OMG! Babs is 20ish, Judy 40ish. GIVES ME GOOSE BUMPS HOW WELL THEY GEL!

  • Two beautiful and insanely talented, iconic women doing their thing. No need for commenting; just sit back and enjoy.

  • Lifelong Judy fan who is glad that Glee is bringing people here, as long as they do come here and see the original and BEST! Judy was the greatest performer ever (IMO) and Barbara is an icon. The magic they created will never be equaled.

  • Beautiful, the best voices the world will EVER EVER EVER EVVEERRRR KNOW!! :)

    Streisand♥Garland

  • I got goosebumps listening to this. I'm happy I got the chance to hear it, a beautiful performance.

  • Remarkable performance.

  • Divas of their time....NEVER to be topped. That is talent

  • i love it!  :D

  • I love these, watch the one with Peggy if you haven't seen it

  • shouldn't barbra streisand be dead by now??

  • @PinkyAnnie123 Lol wth she's 69

  • @misheru910 oh hahahahaha

  • @PinkyAnnie123 why don't u go first?

  • @zalman595 what's ur problem it's a question jeez

  • @zalman595 durant and bab's .........what a pair

  • @PinkyAnnie123 your pretty rude

  • Epically amazing. 

  • So incredibly, wonderfully one-of-a-kind!!! Cant think of 2 women of this calibre in this day and age who could do this with the same magic!

    MAGIC!!

  • 10 dislike? Wtf?!?!?!?!?!?! They did a beautiful job!!!! I ADORE their voices and wish i had a gorgeous belting voice like them!!! Music today has nothing. Its empty. NO meaning! These Women, evidently have meaning in thier words and are trying to reach people. They arent sing crap about wanting to screw people and get drunk. They truely did an amazing job.

  • @rushofblood994 great comment! I think the same thing all the time, but nobody ever says it. Spot on!

  • BRAVO~BRAVO~BRAVISIMA !!

  • There will never be another Judy Garland!

  • I think Barbara is hot here!!!!!

  • What I love about this is the simple way in which they sing. That's not to detract from their stellar talent .. what I mean is, they don't warble and try to fit twenty notes into one line like the singers of today try to do. They sing the word 'again' not 'hhuuugain' which we hear today. It has that live, raw edge unlike the super-polished autotuned songs in the charts. It has character and meaning. <3

  • Don't count Glee, who uses film to do retakes to get it right. What Judy and Barbra do here was "live" and extremely difficult to do. Totally professional, and more importantly, beautiful and entertaining.