Added: 3 years ago
From: lumajs
Views: 970,071
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (2,186)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • We aren't even sure there's a supermassive black hole in the center of our galaxy let alone receiving any signals from that area(sagittarius A).

  • Space is a vacuum and sound can't travel through a vacuum so is this real??

  • Is there a train in the black hole ?

  • Черная дыра не может издавать звука, так как из нее не может вырваться даже свет)) Не несите хуйню, долбаебы)

  • Space doesnt not have air.. therefore NO sound

  • @TheNatureFilms Radiofrequency man, learn before says anything lol, the sound that you know requires materia to travel, the radio dont need anything exept space lol '-'

  • @TheNatureFilms Well someone on another video said it's energy converted to frequency

  • Wait..? Isn't it impossible for there to be sound in outer-space since there is no air..? idk, im pretty sure space = no sound.

  • tie a rope to a gopro and throw it into a black hole

  • @peacefulanarchist92 btw there are gas clouds in space what do you think creates stars and in regards to the vid black holes are soundless and near invisible

  • A black hole is soundless. not even light can ascape from it. so why should sound can?

  • @04TherafF11 true

  • @04TherafF11 It has something to do with converting vibrations into audible noise. I imagine some vibrations would escape. But then again, I'm not an astronomer. I'm just one of dem' hill folk

  • @04TherafF11 i agree, sound is only like what, 800 some miles per hour or something like that, while light is like a million miles per hour(i'm guessing), so there's no way sound could escape

  • yeh, no air or other gases in space (gases are only found in a planets atmosphere) the vibration (sound vibrations) that a black hole would create would never be heard because they have nothing to travel threw

  • stop with the really unintelligent comments. Make Earth feel civilized in front of the universe now.

  • Pinball?

  • Since nothing can escape a black hole you can't hear anything. UNLESS its a quasar! So this can be a real video

  • @ martyn347

    You need to be learning some science, son. Radio Waves and light both travel at the same speed (299,792,458 m/s) in a vacuum. They're both just electromagnetic radiation. The sound you're hearing (the X-rays being generated) are basically just very high frequency radio waves. As is light. You're right in that this radiation can't escape once beyond the *event horizon*, but as long as radiation/matter etc does not pass beyond that point, it can theoretically escape (as it has here).

  • @darknight991 he didn t say that sound in this video is x rays sorry my bad

  • lol this is fake, first black holes have gravity so strong that light can t escape from it, and radio wawes are slower than light waves (they can t escape) so you can t hear anything from black hole cause waves can t escape from it, unlike from stars and nebulas, and it s sad how this fake video has so many views and likes.and i know why this video is most popular in us! and since 90% of us citizens think europe is a country it s not anything new for them to think this video is real XD

  • Comment removed

  • Theres not a sound of a black hole cuz nothing can escape it not even light so this is fake

  • in space cant be noise

  • wait a minute space has no oxygen -___-

  • @TheJames1233 Plenty of oxygen. 3rd most common element in the universe although I fail to see how it's abundance is relevant...

    Anything other than a vacuum can propagate sound-waves but, since the description clearly states that the sound here is translated from the X-rays given off, it doesn't even matter that the black hole is in space (a vacuum)

  • This is what my character in DBZ sounds like charging his chi

  • So this is what black noise sounds like? hmmmm.

  • that was cool

  • Such a SHITTY movie got this many thumbs up

  • NASA faked the moon landings. Here's a link to some of the evidence.

    spurstalk (dot) com/forums/showthread (dot) php?t=144487

  • NO Matter how many times u guys explain there will always be some FOOL asking

    and saying * fake, sound cant travel through empty space*. And as someone said

    ITS NOT about sound, actually its about Radio waves.

    Apparently some ppl never heard of radio astronomy..

    PS. since i was 6 i wanted to study universe, Physics & Astronomy :D.

    Unfortunatelly, my stupid country, does not provide this kind of education.

    So, im stuck at medical college ( tho isnt that bad, u gotta love science no matter what)

  • sound waves dont travel through space so whats the point of makeing this video?

  • @Andres72126  its not sound waves,but radio waves,that travel through space like when you catch radio signal and listen to your favorite music

  • @Andres72126 Radio waves can be converted into audio...

  • My Rofl copter goes soi soi soi soi soi soi soi soi soi soi soi soi soi

  • @JL3Wind I think most of us are on iPods and/or mobile devices :/

  • People are so dumb, do you not realise that just because there is no air, there is no sound, there are still electromagnetic vibrations which can be recorded with specialised instruments. You get the sound by the interaction of electromagnetic particles from the solar wind, ionisphere and the planetary magnetosphere.

  • @snotbrain Radio waves are not sounds,because they vibrate at frequencies out of the hearable range.What we listen to in these videos is the product of a demodulation of the waves in the hearable range,as happens when we receive a radio channel on Earth. No sound could be heard or even produced,anyway,in the empty space,as no air or any other medium is there to allow the transmission of it.Radio waves,instead,can travel in the empty spaces.Demodulation is just a way to make them more "concrete".

  • if you upload a lamo video in space does it make a sound?

  • No Air = No Sound . Easy !

  • do us all a favour

  • @swaktor There is sound you absolute complete mug. Electromagnetic vibrations exist in space, which thus equal sound.

  • @swaktor No air no sound... but still you can get sound with radio from space :D

  • @swaktor This isn't conventional sound, silly person. Sound as we hear it is waves of high and low pressure transmitted through air. What videos like this are doing are taking radiation a solar body is producing, such as Jupiter's famous radio radiation, or probably X-rays in the case of a Pulsar or Black Hole, and converting them into audible sound.

  • no sound in space, they use radio waves, vibrations. too bad there sint any sound. can you imagine!!!!

  • it'd be nice if this upload was higher resolution. it is too low of a bitrate.

  • thats really fucking scary.....

  • its realy scary, isnt it? and this exist aand its gonna screw us all!? omJEESUS?!!

    

  • God are people seriously so retarded that they don't notice the annotations in the video, the description or the comments explaining how the sounds are produced?

  • Space has no air therefore not allowing sound...

  • @sayinwolf Electromagnetic vibrations = Sound... FUCK YOU

  • To the idiots who can't read: It's x-ray's converted into sound

  • fucking creepy

  • There is no sound in space...

  • DAMN its a Dyson!

  • its funny cause sound is made of particles and particles couldn't exist in the vacuum of space let a lone a black hole

  • Black hole= God Anus :D

  • @xXPBSXx1 Does your anus suck all things, including light, in? Because that's not normal

  • @EnglishDrums1

    Yes :S

  • oooo that's a scary sound ! :D

  • it sounds very hungery

  • Alot of uneducated people replying on here... Some of you are right, you technically cannot see (or hear) a black hole. However what you can see is the highly energetic matter outside the event horizon that spins in an accretion disk/cloud as well as the whatever the black hole chokes on and spits out.

    This video is not what you would see with the naked eye if you could look at it.. Some of the largest black holes are located at the center of galaxies.. that's what you'd probably see.

  • The question is, if there is no air in space or in scientific terms, a "medium" how would they hear it?

  • @xScottayBx

    radio waves

  • I was expecting a rick roll.

  • When you fart, that's the sound of a black hole.

  • @GodOfUnbelief =))))))))))

  • @GodOfUnbelief you mean when your momm queefs,outta her spoon

  • wait wait wait wait WAIT!

    Light cant escape a black hole....Sound cant escape a black hole, how did you get the sound?

  • @BadVoodo0 In laymans; The "stuff" in the accretion disk near a black hole emits radiation, radiation such as X-rays. So someone (from NASA apparently) turned the X-rays into sound waves and changed their pitch.

  • @meloveoasis ohh lol thanks for explainging it to me

  • @BadVoodo0 Light can't escape the event horizon of a black hole. The accretion disk around the event horizon gives off radiation, which was recorded and translated into sound.

  • sounds like a vacuum cleaner!

  • @geobenne dahhh it is a vacuum cleaner but its bigger and more destroyable :D

  • @MyPitMind Sorry, don't mean to state the obvious. By the way, the onomatopoeic word is spelled "duh, " and the form of the other word your trying to use is "destructive."

  • @geobenne sorry if my english are so bad but thnx anyway i like space :D

  • OK OK wait just a darn freaking second.In space there is no air and sound needs a medium to travel through such as gases,liguids,or solids.Air is a gas and sound can travel through that but sound cant travel through space.Thus to my counclusion FAKE AND GAY.

  • @coolpepper101 Not sure if trolling, or just very stupid.

  • Black holes do not emit radio waves, or any types of waves for that matter. So it doesn't matter how much you divide the "frequency" of these so called waves so that it can be heard with human ears because no energy is emitted from a black hole.

  • @VEVOemployee VEVO SUCKS!

  • @TheEmperorNothing Wow that was really enlightened we should listen to some shitty 90's alt-rock together sometime bro

  • @johncusackdeathcult 90's rule!!!!! lol

  • @VEVOemployee

    Black holes typically have a silver ring around them because of the radiowaves and radiation being sucked in. The Black Holes swallow the objects, do you eat without burping? Same principle.

    And, what is a gamma ray burst then? That would be a black hole emitting UNBELIEVABLE amounts of energy sometimes with the radius of our entire Galaxy. I don't know why you think you can destroy energy, it is neither created nor destroyed.

  • n way....:)

  • Comment removed

  • TO be honest, before hearing this I was sure that a black hole sounds like that....like a nightmare.

  • in fact black holes make a noise that is 3 billion trillion times lower than what our ears can pick up. crazy shit out there

  • Not a bit professional, just a amateur clip.

  • sounds like goku went super sayian 3.......

  • @freemywillie94 and its goku ...

  • change the wavelegth to see WW II from tv! It should make time go backwards with the speed of light and gravity thingy.

  • to all you people who do not believe this is "real" sound. One comment, lack of education is the mother of all ignorance.

  • It just hungry.

  • Comment removed

  • it shouldn't have a sound if it can suck light in it can suck sound in 

  • @bewhite08 reading the description always helps before you comment "the sounds are X-RAY data translated into audible pulsations"

  • This has to be the most pathetic piece of crap i've seen in a long time. First off the idea that this video gave of what a black hole is is completely and utterly fake. The black hole doesn't have a size or shape, it's unvisible to the human eye. Second off, the black wholes have got to be hundreds if not thousands of sound speed years away, and I really doubt that a black hole would make a sound as if you're blowing someone.

  • Pew Pew Pew Pew Pew.

  • Sounds like my wife, on a good day.....

  • suck on that james dyson.

  • XXDD the funny thing is that black holes are black because they are so strong, they suck in the light.... now how the fuck would sound still exist there? a black hole breaks down the molecules, by the force its pulling shit in.. the only time you would hear a blakc hole is when 1 blows up, but if u hear that, than thats the last thing ur ever gonna hear :D

  • @megvagyimmartizenyol Energy, radio waves, converted into sound, not microphones hooked up to satellites.

  • @ASpaceofCrazy yes, and by waht i said, its obvious that it sucks in radio waves as well :)

  • @megvagyimmartizenyol l2science they emit radio waves which can be converted to sound so there is no actual sound but there is radio waves with we convert to sound.

  • @reveiwthis2 i know a lot of science compared that i was never good at it, and i know what ur saying, radio waves can be converted into sounds, but there isnt an actual sound if u could listen with air. thats what i meant.. sorry, i cant explain things that good :)

  • @megvagyimmartizenyol

    could you not say the same thing about regular sound? Its just waves being converted with the tool that does it on in our head, i.e. the inside of our ear, its all just waves. no ears means no sound (as we know it), waves are still there, just like in this vid!

  • @adriandecleir well i gues... ur right :D

  • OH!

    SO THIS IS WHAT SPACE HELL SOUNDS LIKE!

  • i thought sound didnt travel through space or did i leave my dyson switched on?

  • Mm .. violation and sucking. Am I being educated?

  • Sounds like the vacuum cleaner upstairs. Sucking my concentration away...

  • you cant HEAR in the universe thers no air particals for the vibrateing particals to traval on DUH

  • sounds like my friend in deep focus

  • A blackhole in space are not there for a human being going thru it you fall in you're in God's hand!

  • Hey idiots the sound emanates from things being suck in a blackhole! daaaa! rocket scientists!

  • black holes are badass to me for some reason

  • hahahah, u know in the space there is no sound -.- so .... only in the planets with atmosfere

  • sounds like somebody is running bath water...

  • Gosh, if you get sucked into those things in a ship or a cruiser invented in the inventions yet to come. God be with you

  • Sounds like that vacuum thing from the Teletubbies show... Space is amazing.

  • Cant black holes suck in sound too?

  • @phaneric14 sound can't get sucked in.

  • Darn, this sound is incredibly frightening!

  • It sounds like a giant vacuum hitting my ear drums =( I don't like it.

  • Black Holes cant makes sounds. In space sound waves dont travel.

  • @blue11554 It's possible to pick up on certain radio waves and then convert it into an audible format.

  • @blue11554 Radio waves can be converted to audio,and black holes emit radio waves.

  • but we dont even know if black holes exsist

  • @halossis2 How do you know they emit radio waves? Were you there hearing one?

  • @blue11554 Radio waves travel in space...

  • @TalentedStranger Yeah I know that. What I was trying to say was "sounds" dont come from blackholes or anything else in space. -_-'

  • Sounds like Lou Reed's Metal Machine Music.

  • @MpchermidafilhoA That was exactly what I thought the first time I heard it XD

  • Where we're going, we won't need eyes to see. Our ears shall suffice.

  • stay away D:

  • How do the radio waves even esape? I thought black holes devour EVERYTHING

  • @randomdude581 Black Holes emit radiation.Mostly, X-Rays.

  • @randomdude581 Some times things can escape. For the most part, your right, everything that enters the Event Horizon is essentially lost. However, Some times things are flung out. Black Holes are weird like that.

  • @randomdude581 A "Black hole" in this vid's sense prob. is the event horizon + the accretion disc around it.

    If you will,look at it like a drain in the bathtub as an event horizon for water. If there's no water in the tub, the drain is just there and does nothing.

    But when you let some water in it'll instantly start going down the drain and even make some noise circling around. And what you hear in this vid is the EM noise of electr. charged matter circling around the "hole".

  • Just so you know, in space, their is no sound, cant hear a thing

  • @VideoManiacify Moreover in space you can't breathe, so wouldn't be alive. But, light beating off a space suit would vibrate the air inside, and a person inside a space suit could hear the electromagnetic waves vibrating the outside of their suit, provided it was in appropriate frequencies for human hearing. Most people don't notice it, but the electromagnetic radiation of the sun is actually audible, it's just we live with it all our lives... You can feel it as pressure on your skin too. (try)

  • You can hear farts in the background :D

  • How do they know, that it's the real sound of a BH? I think, these sound are fake.

  • no the blackhole doesnt make any sounds since it sucks in anything including light or sound waves trust me, im asian

  • @domino764 there are no sound waves in space.... its a vacuum... so no it doesn't 'suck them in' duh

  • Comment removed

  • Sounds like a shot-vac. Which I guess is an appropriate comparison...

  • Sounds like my aunt amy farting

  • Look, black holes can't sound. There is no way for sound to travel in space. It could be radiation waves, or even some type of energy, or even matter that we have not discovered yet that could possibly make the "sound" waves.

  • i'd say u couldnt hear this in space. sound waves dont travel in space but there are still waves traveling, which u can convert to sound waves and hear the sound, but how u gonna get da sound? idk, jus felt like posting this, dont hate.

  • sounds like something dying, along with radio interference, and a shower running in the background

  • Sounds like chuck norris fart =)

  • ssszzzhhhhhhhh soi soi soi soi soi sssszzzzhhhh soi soi soi

  • pew pew pewww

  • i thought space has no sound

  • @StanOfGB This wasn't recorded with a microphone you uneducated fuck. It's been converted via computers. THe x-rays carry radio waves which can be converted to sound ba aspeaker.

  • @BloXboX37 x-rays carry radio waves?... and I'm an uneducated fuck. A black hole does not make this sound. The end.

  • @StanOfGB Read the most thumbed up comment on this video and stop playing the Internet Tough Guy card you nigger, go back to elementary school. You haven't gotten further then 6th grade have you kid?

  • @BloXboX37 LMAO a racist person interested in science! 1st of all, they are sound waves not radio waves that the "sound" is recorded on. 2nd, this is not the sound of a black hole, the distance from it is too great to obtain the actual sound. 3rd, I'm already an economist; are you still stuck in school "tough guy"? See ya, I don't talk to racists.

  • @StanOfGB actually since its a black hole, these are most likely x-rays being converted into sound.

  • @StanOfGB actually since its a black hole, these are most likely x-rays being converted into sound, not sound waves or radio waves

  • @MechaShadowV2 how can xrays be converted into sound? They have the same properties that are required for it? Even if they do, wouldn't it be far from what the actual sound sounds like?

  • @StanOfGB well its basically like how a radio picks of radio waves and converts it to sound, there are some differences but the principles are the same, also fyi sound waves and radio waves are not the same, sound waves is the projection of sound bumping against molecules, radio waves/x-ray waves is a type of electromagnetic radiation, and thus can move in a vacuum much like light, as for the distance, they actually have equipment that can amplify these wavelengths like telescopes can with light

  • the sound is a million stars being ripped to their fucking doom

  • To the dumbasses who keep saying no air=no sound:

    Light frequencies can be turned into sound frequencies. Radio waves are light waves, they just have a longer wavelength than visible light.

  • Sound energy is emitted by motion and air, air allows sound to travel. Since no air is in space, there is no sound energy. And anyway, nothing escapes the force of a black hole, not even energy.

  • @DJRetroTrance see the top comment