I think I once had a different version of PDT by EM.. and her high G was considerably louder and she stayed up there longer than anyone else I've heard. Another difference is that the orchestra or the conducting on that CD I had was quite inferior to this.
@salmig99 That was the later of two recordings she made of the aria. The earlier version used to be up here on YouTube somewhere; dunno where it is now though. That was a real opus.
@forallyouknow Ah, thanks...! I will look for it.. I've had some success searching via google, adding 'youtube' as a keyword rather than using the limited capabilities of the built-in youtube search mechanisms, but no luck so far. The version I have in mind sounded very different, more like a female Lauritz Melchior.. I'll update this page if I find it.
you could have the high G's but you wouldn't have that volume :P!
SakumaRyuichiNG 1 week ago
how can peopole do not like this??die beste!!ich liebe Edda Moser!
Vincenzo2010an 3 weeks ago
@Vincenzo2010an i like edda better.....
Vincenzo2010an 3 weeks ago
Good, but Dessay's interpretation is waaaay better
Anyway, well done Edda
LacrimaLunaMortua 1 month ago
What CD is this from? I got her Mozart arias CD, and I think I much prefer the high G's in this recording over that one...
primohomme 1 month ago
Maravillosa y poderosa voz, simplemente una joya
isa70ful 3 months ago
Ive heard another recording of her singing this where the Gs are just awful, here theyre just soft which is fine
skitzo429 3 months ago
4 people can't sing a high G.
VintageHussy13 6 months ago 6
@VintageHussy13 They are 5 jealous people who can't sing a high G. :-)
mircavalcante 1 month ago
@VintageHussy13 how can people do not like this??
Vincenzo2010an 3 weeks ago
Marvellous! And it is one of the most challenging arias for a coloratura soprano.
latrociniOpera 10 months ago
I think I once had a different version of PDT by EM.. and her high G was considerably louder and she stayed up there longer than anyone else I've heard. Another difference is that the orchestra or the conducting on that CD I had was quite inferior to this.
salmig99 1 year ago
@salmig99 That was the later of two recordings she made of the aria. The earlier version used to be up here on YouTube somewhere; dunno where it is now though. That was a real opus.
forallyouknow 9 months ago
@forallyouknow Ah, thanks...! I will look for it.. I've had some success searching via google, adding 'youtube' as a keyword rather than using the limited capabilities of the built-in youtube search mechanisms, but no luck so far. The version I have in mind sounded very different, more like a female Lauritz Melchior.. I'll update this page if I find it.
salmig99 9 months ago
I don't like it at all
oscardegliorazi 1 year ago
brava!(for the italian too).
Vincenzo2010an 1 year ago 4
The G is so faint, but still can be heard, and really what a great soprano :D<3
VintageHussy13 1 year ago 8
@VintageHussy13 yes, the best ever!
Vincenzo2010an 3 weeks ago