Can someone tell me what the demonstration where late Pavlik died, was about? Have searched the wonderfull database of knowledge called internet but only found that he died but never the reason (of the demostration).
As a pianist who has studied this piece to some extent, I must say that I am not impressed by the quality of the interpretation. It seems that this performer has disregarded all of Janacek's deliberate and careful markings and treated this as though it were an outline of what was intended. I'd recommend looking at a better recording.
Nobody on youtube does the rhythms right, they go over the duplets as they were triplets, I don`t get it, it doesn`t make the music more exciting, it makes it inaccurate and untrue to the composer`s intentions.
@krazyman84 Hey there. I decided to learn this sonata and just got the music yesterday. I was surprised to find that the time signature is (2/dotted quarter). Are there any easy explanations/hints to help while learning the piece? I've never encountered anything quite like this. Thanks!
Can someone tell me what the demonstration where late Pavlik died, was about? Have searched the wonderfull database of knowledge called internet but only found that he died but never the reason (of the demostration).
DhrKlaasma 2 months ago in playlist Janáček, Leo - Sonata 1.X.1905
@turmlicht It is so beautiful, absolutely sublime.
salubrious 4 months ago
As a pianist who has studied this piece to some extent, I must say that I am not impressed by the quality of the interpretation. It seems that this performer has disregarded all of Janacek's deliberate and careful markings and treated this as though it were an outline of what was intended. I'd recommend looking at a better recording.
davidwhorton95 5 months ago
@davidwhorton95 Can you point me out to a recording as you mean, please?
DhrKlaasma 2 months ago in playlist Janáček, Leo - Sonata 1.X.1905
AMAZING!
mlandowski92 1 year ago
the ending is amazing!
newgeorge 1 year ago
perhaps the most under-appreciated composer of his time. Maybe second to Bartok?
waltts 1 year ago
amazing! truly a great work of art.
rbob200 1 year ago
As already mentioned, I'm moved to tears by this. But it is so beautiful, I can't get away from it.
turmlicht 1 year ago 3
is this Firkusny?
markrevelle1 1 year ago
Nobody on youtube does the rhythms right, they go over the duplets as they were triplets, I don`t get it, it doesn`t make the music more exciting, it makes it inaccurate and untrue to the composer`s intentions.
krazyman84 1 year ago
@krazyman84 Hey there. I decided to learn this sonata and just got the music yesterday. I was surprised to find that the time signature is (2/dotted quarter). Are there any easy explanations/hints to help while learning the piece? I've never encountered anything quite like this. Thanks!
MsPianob 1 year ago
Great post! Thanks for the extensive piece description as well
TheShredworthy 2 years ago
I had never listened to anything by Janacek before.. This is magnificent!
ThePhilosorpheus 2 years ago
I thought it was rushed.
morvensky 2 years ago
I think the tempo suited the piece quite well; it has a nervous flow that fits Janacek's music.
alvinkuo777 1 year ago