What a recording! The fidelity is marvelous. At 31" into the song, you can hear a train siren in the background! This was truly music of its time; not sanitized for your protection.
@CDonches Wow! Never heard that before.... I mean I've heard birds singing outside the hall on recordings but that train....I love the "something" that 78s have. it's not just "presence" ...... It puts the music there in front of you ...... dream medium would be 78 rpm LPs.....
Well, folks . . . when is some brave jazz historian going to tackle what remains one of the most explosive--and censored--episodes in the history of the music we all love? I'm referring to the "relations" (WHATEVER they were) between B.G. & B.H.
Now, someone has sent me a query asking, "Who is B.G.?"
You know, folks . . . at one time those initials were almost as famous as, say . . . FDR.
Of course, B.G. stood for . . . Benny Goodman . . .
The most predominent musician on the recording was Teddy Wilson on piano not mentioned. All of those great recordings of the thirties with Billie were under the Teddy Wilson group with Buster Bailey, Lester Young and Buck Clayton being most notable.
Billie sings with true pain, unfortunately that true pain was her downfall as well. Makes you think how much can a heart really endure before you cross the line of no return...or worse stop feeling all together. Billie you are and always will be the definition of feeling. You felt with the core of your heart.
Where do these guys come from? Sounds like the 20's? player piano? Do they have ears. Reminds me of the classical stuff. e.g., Clara Haskil can't play! What? Horowitz lost it when he was in his 80's! What? Any love for music here? SWe all have to be so smart, don't we? alkuhn1
@MsTWEEKIE you rock - Billies stuff when your Dad was playing and the rest of the band around this time - it's the best - it's music that will be adored forever - man you are lucky - bless your Dad
@MsTWEEKIE VERY cool. I think it's fair to say her best work was during the years prior to the 40s, perhaps some of the early 40s, but at some point during that decade her voice became disturbed from the substance abuse, yet remained beautiful and unique at the same time. Nonetheless, a legend she will always be.
@tristramshandy3 Hello, stream of consciousness! I should've qualified meaning in music. Yet I'd like to point out that those were the days for our talented tenth. You'd be surprised how many people of color were living quite a distance from the poverty line. Philadelphia, for example. Economically viable enclaves well before the end of slavery.
It is about Heroin.
dbrice71 1 month ago
This was actually from 1938
coccxo 3 months ago
the beat reminds me of the song "everybody wants to be a cat" from the aristocats XD
Darlagirl101 3 months ago
What a recording! The fidelity is marvelous. At 31" into the song, you can hear a train siren in the background! This was truly music of its time; not sanitized for your protection.
CDonches 5 months ago
@CDonches Wow! Never heard that before.... I mean I've heard birds singing outside the hall on recordings but that train....I love the "something" that 78s have. it's not just "presence" ...... It puts the music there in front of you ...... dream medium would be 78 rpm LPs.....
tubemagpie 1 month ago
Well, folks . . . when is some brave jazz historian going to tackle what remains one of the most explosive--and censored--episodes in the history of the music we all love? I'm referring to the "relations" (WHATEVER they were) between B.G. & B.H.
Now, someone has sent me a query asking, "Who is B.G.?"
You know, folks . . . at one time those initials were almost as famous as, say . . . FDR.
Of course, B.G. stood for . . . Benny Goodman . . .
Gary in Arizona
garysaddleback 5 months ago
Comment removed
garysaddleback 5 months ago
Comment removed
oldstock1607 5 months ago
The most predominent musician on the recording was Teddy Wilson on piano not mentioned. All of those great recordings of the thirties with Billie were under the Teddy Wilson group with Buster Bailey, Lester Young and Buck Clayton being most notable.
Jubalz2 6 months ago
Incomparable Miss Holiday to you!
gratefultiger 7 months ago
its Awesome with a capital "A" BABY!!!!( dick vitale)
ahanfman 10 months ago
Billie sings with true pain, unfortunately that true pain was her downfall as well. Makes you think how much can a heart really endure before you cross the line of no return...or worse stop feeling all together. Billie you are and always will be the definition of feeling. You felt with the core of your heart.
dirtybirdmorningstar 10 months ago
No doubt this is classic. Back up band makes the song what is is as well as Billie's interpretation. Thanks
casilet 1 year ago
has anyone seen the billie holiday story ..i watched it when i was a kid ...a little white girl ,i was amazed by her ..
diamondmg 1 year ago
ah I wish I had an ounce of this womans talent.
SkSk920 1 year ago 2
i love her she the best
EmoneyBabay1Luv 1 year ago
she's got a very unique voice
easton233 1 year ago 2
1933 not 1935!!!
limeginger 1 year ago
Where do these guys come from? Sounds like the 20's? player piano? Do they have ears. Reminds me of the classical stuff. e.g., Clara Haskil can't play! What? Horowitz lost it when he was in his 80's! What? Any love for music here? SWe all have to be so smart, don't we? alkuhn1
alkuhn1 1 year ago
@alkuhn1 People HEAR what THEY hear. It's all in the EAR of the beholder. What? You ain't know?
CheckMate657879 1 year ago
Wow!!! This sure is 1935. This song has that dixie-land-pre-bee-bop flavor. That piano sounds like the pianos that used to play themselves.
CheckMate657879 1 year ago
@CheckMate657879 it's actually 1933 - the poster had it wrong. Billie was 18...her first recording session
limeginger 1 year ago
@limeginger Thank you.
CheckMate657879 1 year ago
My kind of music (y)
janhostdk 1 year ago
great, love the song
FancyShawl99 1 year ago
Comment removed
MsTWEEKIE 1 year ago
what a great song!
tristramshandy3 1 year ago
"Do you like Billie Holiday?"
"Uh, I LOVE him."
Clueless <3
groupiesrule 2 years ago 38
@groupiesrule Hilarious - LMAO!
CheckMate657879 1 year ago
@groupiesrule Yep- that's how I learned to love this song, too. Clueless was such a great film!
FaxanaduJohn 1 year ago
Comment removed
MsTWEEKIE 2 years ago 3
@MsTWEEKIE you rock - Billies stuff when your Dad was playing and the rest of the band around this time - it's the best - it's music that will be adored forever - man you are lucky - bless your Dad
kochista 1 year ago
@MsTWEEKIE VERY cool. I think it's fair to say her best work was during the years prior to the 40s, perhaps some of the early 40s, but at some point during that decade her voice became disturbed from the substance abuse, yet remained beautiful and unique at the same time. Nonetheless, a legend she will always be.
kgchris 1 year ago 3
CaRuCCi86, i love her LOL
lucaskarq 2 years ago
TI AMO!!!
Eliezer821 2 years ago
Do you like Billie Holiday?
I LOVE him!
CaRuCCi86 2 years ago 3
Huh?
BuckshotLaFunke 2 years ago
HAHAHAH clueless
pistolacola 2 years ago
LOL. I had a friend say that to me after I told him I was listening to Billie! My last name is Brown so I really love this song.
11clawedfrogs 2 years ago
Lol. Yea, Clueless
kjkilojoules 2 years ago
Clueless....yeah, loved that!!!!!!
camilasabella 2 years ago
I'm 28 and she is my favorite female singer by far, sorry Josephine hope you can forgive me. REAL MUSIC.
Portis1Luv 2 years ago
Josephine Baker had the looks and talent but Billie had the voice that just sets the mood. I'm sure Josephine will forgive you.
nenasworld22 2 years ago
I love this lil song. Its so happy and carefree a pop tune if their ever was one.
jahlaune 2 years ago
Billie Holiday was amazing in the 1930's. I bought this record back in 1935 when it first came out.
dianamaryflorence 2 years ago 17
Those were the days, weren't they?
ccaammiiittoo1 2 years ago
@ccaammiiittoo1 those were the daze? are you serious? yeah, the days of the great depression- what a happy time :)
tristramshandy3 1 year ago
@tristramshandy3 Hello, stream of consciousness! I should've qualified meaning in music. Yet I'd like to point out that those were the days for our talented tenth. You'd be surprised how many people of color were living quite a distance from the poverty line. Philadelphia, for example. Economically viable enclaves well before the end of slavery.
ccaammiiittoo1 1 year ago
@ccaammiiittoo1 Hey. I'm sorry- I shouldn't have given you shit- it was pretty clear you meant as far as music was concerned.
Have a great life.
Viva Montaigne!
tristramshandy3 1 year ago
Dam.. how old are u?
Proma203 2 years ago
A five stars record, if there ever was one. With Prez instead of Goodman it would have been five and a half.
BuckshotLaFunke 2 years ago
there was and i got one
geroin31337 2 years ago
my favorite by billie, never be another
playio 2 years ago
great old version of that wonderful tune
womamo 3 years ago
A very good quality recording of one of my favorites. Thanks also for the informative notes.
core281 3 years ago