he is a musician, it's just that the majority feeds the society that his way of music is right. but considerably wrong. these are just sound effects and not notably compositions.
"my opinion is that john cage wanted people to hear other sounds in life that we don't focus on.
For music is sound "
Go take a walk and pay attention to your environment.
Why do we need somebody to "help us focus on these" sounds? That's not what music is about, it's about using sound in a unified or organized manner to make something pleasing or moving.
Most people don't realize to go take a walk and hear sounds. It's suprising yeah but we need someone to literally spoonfeed them to get the other sounds out to them. Cage just made that more clear.
@laurion69: Oh, but there is space for debate. This is only one of very many compositions by Cage. Many of his other pieces used conventional notation and were skillfully put together. Like the several Constructions he wrote for percussion orchestra. Or 'Dream', a performance of which is in the Related Videos on this page. He is neither untalented nor unaware of the audience's reactions. He was just writing what his nature dictated to him.
You know, watching John Cage actually makes me violently angry. I can't help it, his work is just a living (dead thank god) embodiment of crap. Thanks to people like him, just about anybody can be an artist or a composer.
This might actually be more interesting than a performance -- an installation of "stuff" arranged as if something was performed on a stage, the performance and sound of which we can only imagine.
This might actually be more interesting than a performance -- an installation of "stuff" arranged as if something was performed on a stage, the performance and sound of which we can only imagine.
Before deciding whether you like spam or not, you will have to think carefully about it. Is spam nice? If you think it is nice, you will probably like spam. But if you think spam is unpleasant, you will probably not like spam. The choice is up to you.
What about the case in which one tastes Spam without preconcieved notions? Or when one has eaten Spam which one did not like, but later comes to like it, after eating it with a mind predisposed to dislike it?
he is a musician, it's just that the majority feeds the society that his way of music is right. but considerably wrong. these are just sound effects and not notably compositions.
UnforgivingCritic 2 years ago
"my opinion is that john cage wanted people to hear other sounds in life that we don't focus on.
For music is sound "
Go take a walk and pay attention to your environment.
Why do we need somebody to "help us focus on these" sounds? That's not what music is about, it's about using sound in a unified or organized manner to make something pleasing or moving.
largemoose 3 years ago 5
Most people don't realize to go take a walk and hear sounds. It's suprising yeah but we need someone to literally spoonfeed them to get the other sounds out to them. Cage just made that more clear.
lobzunpreston 3 years ago
Maybe, but if he can be considered a philosphist, a provoker, an opinionist... surely cannot be considered a composer.
I think there is no space of debate on this point.
laurion69 3 years ago
Comment removed
SphericalMiracle 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@laurion69: Oh, but there is space for debate. This is only one of very many compositions by Cage. Many of his other pieces used conventional notation and were skillfully put together. Like the several Constructions he wrote for percussion orchestra. Or 'Dream', a performance of which is in the Related Videos on this page. He is neither untalented nor unaware of the audience's reactions. He was just writing what his nature dictated to him.
SphericalMiracle 2 years ago
*philosopher* not philosophist
cerebroatmosferico 2 years ago
Phi`los´o`phist (fĭ`lǒs´ô`fĭst)
n. 1. A pretender in philosophy.
By learning this word I hope you understood what I meant...
laurion69 2 years ago
@largemoose Well, when was the last time you took a walk?
letsphilosophize 1 year ago
Ich kann irgendwie nur auf die Unterhaltung achten. Atmosphäre toll einefangen
Zisch2 3 years ago
my opinion is that john cage wanted people to hear other sounds in life that we don't focus on.
For music is sound
thelonerangers2 3 years ago
I could add my farts.
superiorgreyfox 3 years ago
interesting - would your instrument be considered vocal or percussive?
DoctorPatient 2 years ago 2
My grandfather actually wrote "4,33" when he was stuck in coal mine cave in. He was silent for 4 minutes 33 seconds (give or take a second).
marcvanderloo 3 years ago
You know, watching John Cage actually makes me violently angry. I can't help it, his work is just a living (dead thank god) embodiment of crap. Thanks to people like him, just about anybody can be an artist or a composer.
Thank god I am not untalented like he was.
revoltz7 3 years ago
This might actually be more interesting than a performance -- an installation of "stuff" arranged as if something was performed on a stage, the performance and sound of which we can only imagine.
iwanttowatchsomethin 3 years ago
This might actually be more interesting than a performance -- an installation of "stuff" arranged as if something was performed on a stage, the performance and sound of which we can only imagine.
iwanttowatchsomethin 3 years ago
Before deciding whether you like spam or not, you will have to think carefully about it. Is spam nice? If you think it is nice, you will probably like spam. But if you think spam is unpleasant, you will probably not like spam. The choice is up to you.
WiseWordsAboutSpam 4 years ago
Very wise words. I'll remember them for the rest of my life, I promise.
WonderfulWorldOfShit 4 years ago
What about the case in which one tastes Spam without preconcieved notions? Or when one has eaten Spam which one did not like, but later comes to like it, after eating it with a mind predisposed to dislike it?
GavagaiGuy 4 years ago
Thanks to you guys I could'nt decide whether I liked spam or not, and, as it was the only item in my diet I have consquently died.
Mogggpiano 3 years ago
Thanks to you guys I could'nt decide whether I liked spam or not, and, as it was the only item in my diet I have consquently died.
Mogggpiano 3 years ago
I would like it to be known that I only died once.
Mogggpiano 3 years ago
this is like a play of sorts?
eggory 4 years ago
when was this performed?
thanks,
testanton
TESTANTON 5 years ago