Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (200)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Not only an amazingly magical voice! This woman is a lyrical genius! Out of this world!

  • AHHH She said on twitter that she made a video for this song way back then, but it was never released and she doesn't know where it went!!!

  • DAMN!!!! her voice steals my heart over and over

  • I wish i could have been in a Mariah concert back in the day, i still want to, but i know it will never be like this

  • 2:02 "So shy, a bundle of butterflies!!"

    I love how she sings this part, so beautiful!!

  • Lord... her whisper register is out of the World!!! She might have a third lung!

  • NO ONE CAN COME CLOSE TO THIS !!!!

  • omg who out of there right mind would have the audacity, to push that dislike button!! smh

  • @ihcob XTINA FANS!

  • @jameld55 ugh can't stand them. lol!

  • @kandykay1992 Lol Me Either!!!!

  • siento como mi vida tuviera un sentido mas alla. esta cancion me hace sentir muy especial y porsupuesto de la encantadora Mariah carey..esos tiempso eran Admirables..es cierto la misma sociedad hace cambiar a las personas y ella fue sometido a ese cambio..vuleve pronto Mariah

  • Simply Beautiful! <3

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • 2:06 - Mariah pregnant!

  • Comment removed

  • after watching this performance, i decided that this is gonna be my wedding song <3

  • amen to that!! God Bless the Japanese taste~~

  • Literally the best vocal performance ever, and not just among Mariah's.

  • OMG this song is beyond beautiful and it has a sort of sensual sound  to it!! I LOVE Mariah especially during this period in her life!! :D

  • Best Ever!!

    

  • My favorite

  • :(

    

  • Mariah and Whitney The best vocalist to ever walk this earth

  • @khylajade1 Mariah, Whitney, and Celine.

  • so much control.. wow.

  • Brings tears to my eyes every time

  • I listen to this song ever day!!!!!

  • IM FLOATING ON AIR

  • i have CHILLS!!!

  • so memorable... so gorgeous and 'down to earth' performance :)

  • 3:16 - 3:20, one of the best moments in music history

  • Love thsi performance! was lucky enought to see her sing this that same year at MSG in NYC! Hey check out my rendition of "Underneath The Stars" on my page and rate. =-)

  • no one would ever sing it the way Mariah does/did it..... this song sounds easy but very difficult to perform it

  • 3:16-3:21...driftinnnnggggg...­..!!!!! oh my God, i was really drifting when she hit that note!!!

  • @vladtam24 amazing isnt? :) I keep repeating the "drifting" part. haha

  • @rayreyes2009 yes it is!!! :)

  • I wish her tits would go back to normal. She looked awesome back then.

  • wow I love this song, reading and listening to the lyrics, really makes you enjoy this song to it's fullest... so "sublime" xDDD Ahhh i feel my own memories of young love :)

  • So beautiful. And with all that was going on in her personal life at this time.. if only we had known

  • the way she sings 'sublime' is sublime

  • Wonderful and flawless voice ever heard

    an it's the best song from this concert (for me) ^^

  • THAT VOICE!!! Soooo beauitiful!!!!!!!!!!! Ahhh i loveee heerrr!!!

  • in this era..she never never never never lipped a single performance..thats why they called it her peak..well...even the year 1990-1994 she never lipped..and actually people wanted more her live performances than listening to her songs from cds because she sounds like the album..and she adds more high notes and beauty while singing

  • @MrDjoleen Technically this was 1996 and she lipped Fantasy everytime except the AMA's in 1995. (but only that song, none of the other singles from Daydream)

  • @hunt44 Wrong. :)

  • Comment removed

  • @MrDjoleen yes you are so right, why should mariah lipsync when everything is o.k... she started lipsync in 1998, because vocal chords were so overused... she had every single a number one or more and is the fastest selling artist of alltime ( male / female ) she did what celine/whitney in 30 years in just 20 years and toped them with own lyrics, she is the best of best! whitney/celine lipsynced in earlier then mariah, beginning he 90´s... ^_^

  • @zanaomusic yah..she developed her vocal nodules when she was i think in 5th grade, her voice is naturally in an alto voice,its raspy and low,but because of those nodules,she gained the ability to go higher,from chest voice, to head voice, to whistle register,but they got worst in the daydream world tour, and it affected her chest voice abilities,but i don't care,still she can hit high notes,she can still sing, and mostly she can still write musics that can touch peoples lives, and hearts..:D

  • Also, now we know where that 1 dislike came from.

  • this is a ridiculous performance. and yes haters, IT IS LIVE. ; I also thought it was lipsync in the beginning because she sounded just like the cd but on listening closely to the rest of it you can here subtle differences. and not so subtle ones like when she says heady and sublime at 2:22 and drifting at 3:15-3:21. also the drifting close to the end is different. but hey, the fact that she came so close to the record on a live performance only reinforces how great she is. great track & album.

  • F**king haters she did not lip sync thys song. if she did she wuda lip synced her whistle notes dont u think?

  • 1995-1996 vocal prime!

  • is wondering who the one idiot who disliked this video is...this is a vocal masterpiece

  • @stevieshithead This is a great song... But she is lip syncing here. Can't call it a vocal masterpiece if she's not actually vocalizing ,, lol

  • @Boobalopbop this is live.she sang it all live in daydream tour.

  • @Boobalopbop Do you have any idea how incredible her voice was in 1996?? This is completely live, watch the whole concert. It was FLAWLESS from start to finish. The lipping accusations can be considered from 2000 on but these years absolutely not. All live. Why do you think she's THAT famous for being a regular singer?? She's the best. After seeing her Christmas performances , mm she's still the best in 2011.

  • @initochanchan I don't think she's a "regular" singer. She was a phenomenal singer... A near perfect voice. But this performance seemed lip synced. I could be wrong. I'm just sayin'. She usually ad-libs and changes up the runs slightly, but this song sounded straight off the cd. I know because I listen to that song on a regular basis.

    But like I said... I could be wrong.

  • @Boobalopbop I am a fan since day 1 and know her voice better than my own. Believe me when i say this is completely live. God bless.

  • @Boobalopbop The track from the CD is actually faster. There's definitely a lot of differences between this performance and the one from the CD version. And she never did lipsynched any performances during her tour in 96 and years before.

  • @AngelVII77 She ought to lip sync more these days... Her most recent live performances were just awful.

  • @Boobalopbop Her recent Christmas song performances were pretty good.

  • @AngelVII77 Yes they were. Amazing :)

  • @Boobalopbop I've been looking through your posts, another Madonna fan jealous of Mariah's godly vocals. Don't really blame you, listening to the old hag's music can screw your ears and eyes.

  • Mariah CArey is a great star!

  • These "whispery" vocals here are VERY different than the baby whisper voice she uses now but, whatever gets you through the night. SMH. She overuses the baby whisper sh** as well. That's why I didn't buy her new Christmas album. I prefer her CLASSIC one where she wasn't afraid to use her full voice. Not, tiny whisper voice, BELT, tiny whisper voice, BELT.

    Let the angry attacks begin.

  • Mariah Carey is the best selling American artist in Japan i think

  • @aUszTin yeah she is, well best selling american aritist hahahahhaha that's how much of a beast she is hahhahahahah

  • this sound like fourth of july part 1!!! love it!!

  • @gangstaladie yes you're right about that.., fourth of july is the sequel for underneath the stars :D

  • so pretty! awww.. shes so cute here.. OMG ! I like her hAIRSTYLE. !

  • @ 3:54 - Background singers.... looks like Gospel Artist Melonie Daniels..(I know she used to be a back up for Mariah... and then to the far left -R&B/Gospel artist Kelly Price.. (who used to be her back up as well) In my opinion.

  • @neetrab yes that's her! she's amazing!!!

  • one of the best live singers, amazing

  • i love the small change from the CD at 3:15

    mariah needs to get back to singing live always. sometimes not always being perfect is the most endearing. <3

  • @cowensheba You should have heard her newest concert she sounded pretty good!

  • @cowensheba No one is perfect.but i agree she should try harder.but remember Mariah has to take care of her voice,she can't go around over singing all the time.

    I don't like lipping either,but if it helps preserve her voice then i doesn't bother me as much.besides lots of good artist lip synch sometimes.

  • This song makes me speechless, its like the reason I dont do drugs Mariah's songs get me high enough!

  • I used to skip this track in my Daydream CD. But after hearing this "LIVE", it is now my fave. =)

  • the days, when mariah sang better live  than in the cds

  • nobody else sings so flawlessly Live like Mariah. She is a complete LEGEND.

  • I can' t stop listen this song, It's beautiful,,,,

  • 3:17-3:21 fuckin amazing i love how she singed "drifted" who voice is like no other !

  • God bless the Japanese taste!!

  • Mariah has used her whispery vocals since she started out. People need to realize that! Here is proof she used it in 1996 as well. Love this song!

  • @MissJayG To be honest I prefer her whispery melodic lower register, I think its much soother and nicer to listen to. It also shows that she can make nice music WITHOUT belting, her best songs have very limited belting.

  • That is so true! It's so annoying when people go like "Mariah can't sing right now, she just whispers" and I'm like "What the hell? Are you serious? She's been whispery since day one... Go listen to her older stuff and get a clue!" AND PLUS, since when does the fact that she's whispery mean that she can't sing? Hello? It means the exact opposite! People don't realize how hard it is to master those whispery vocal techniques... She is just so good that she makes it sound so easy when it's not...

  • @sadisticsoul69 OMG I totally agree with you. it's hard to sing those low and falsetto notes and stay in key. anyone who could master that has real talent.(Christina Aguilera is also good at this). I was also kinda frustrated when i heard a lot of the whispery stuff in the late 90s and after 2000, but realised that she was doing it all along on songs like can't let go, I'll be there, vanishing and love takes time. I got hooked on her 4 her belting & high notes but love the softer stuff too.

  • @MissJayG

    not only 1996 but also 1991. listen can't let go. :)

  • oh my god...the belting is great...her voice is so huge.....love her...

  • i will love and idolized mariah carey until the day i die!

  • i cant even bring myself to listen to the album version because ive heard this and it doesnt compare its on y ipod and everything lol

  • 4:19 !!! check that. She´s singing while breathing. LOL.Only she can do it.

  • Kind of reminds me of Fourth of July, but this is better.

  • This Version is better than the album's one cause she hit the belting note at the bridge of the song beautiful.

  • her voice is so amazing.like the part wen she changed the tone "drifted" part.... a lil bit,God's gift!

  • i love this song.

    I remember the daydream era she was a pop/r&b god

  • she was so cute when she spoke jap!!! X) & i can't believe i've nv heard dis song b4 i watched dis vid...

  • I love this song <3

    and of cource Maariiah :D

    my angel forever she sings so angelic

  • NB: this tokyo dome concert of Mariah IS on DVD, as well as that of Madison Square Guarden. I'VE HAD IT SINCE LAST JAN. It's ina the same format as the videos watched online!

  • She is jamming!!!

  • IKR!. She has such a groove going on LOL

  • 3:15 Wow!

  • Thats my favourite part!

  • This is her most magical and beautiful performance ever.

  • @AngelVII77 THAT S SO TRUE...makes me cry :(

  • @AngelVII77 i agree that this is her best performance of all time. I'm so glad , it's my favorite song of all time too.

  • Great Prize!

  • this song has reached my drreams lol!!!!i got in trouble at skewl for singing this teach kept tellin me to shutup i kept singing next thing ya know im talkin to the pricepal...its worth it!great song/voice!!!

  • YES! I agree! You GO!

  • She is pure heaven here!!!! This is what maed me fall in love with her music. From3:15 on is soooo beautiful. omg!

  • mariah carey underneath live= heaven

  • Mariah is the best singer songwriter and producer in the world. There will never be another Mariah Carey. Everyone go get her new Album "Memoirs Of An Imperfect Angel" it's her best yet! Cnady Bling from the new Album is the same style as this song but it's even better.

  • she try to do reminiscence of this, but this so much better

  • Most of her music and style of singing is similar to this song.

  • i wish she can get back to this size...she looks so amazing in the past!!!but she is still good now...

  • i agree with camcam Whitney can sing her ass off, but mariah has quality in her voice, and can evoke emotion, her voice can make u cry, dream and take you to another place! And to me thats what a Great vocalist is about.

  • @Mcvideos92 WOW best comment ive read on youtube about mariah! u are absolutely right! she defines great talents!

  • THE VOICE wooooooooooooooooooooooow so emotional, this performance make you travel to heaven and you dont wanna return. amazing amazing amazing mariah you saved my life

  • wow this song reminds me of sumone :')

    miss em but heyy i love this song xxx

  • where can i download this video? pls tell me........

  • Simplismente lindo , maravilhoso *-*

  • Love the song. Love the performance. Love Mariah Carey (:

  • Mariah has THE greatest voice of any human being who has ever lived. Her voice can shatter a glass, make you cry, or stop your heart. NO one else EVER compares, EVER.

  • @camcam200008 Agreed. Nailed.

  • @camcam200008 EVER.

  • @camcam200008 thanks u just took something out of my mouth lol

  • esta cancion me encanta, es de mis favoritas, es una cancion para enamorarse y dedicarsela al chico de tu vida ;)

  • exerp from Scarface....."Every dog has it's day"

    Mariah has had hers, if i had the power to create a time machine i would travel to the mid 90's and fall in love with her all over again.....then i'd head back to the Seventies and Boogie down at a Soul Train :D

  • I woulod've loved to be at this concert...every song was perect.

  • this sealed it. she's one of the greatest if not THE greatest pop singer of all time

  • This definitely sealed it.. noone can sing this song like her. noone else has tones this rich.

  • People are so demanding of singers like Mariah. Jesus. No wonder they kill themselves half the time. " Oh i wish she was still like this, or like that.....blah blah blah." Just appreciate that if even once something spectacular like this performance happens it changes your life. Simple! Thats it!! Im sure that on your death bed you will be wondering why Mariah changed her image. Suck It!!

  • this song is amazing, i can´t stop listening it

  • she is super hot ..compared other artist ..during her age then ...i mean she is amazing ...

  • Mariah at her peak.

    Fantastic song

    Excellent performance

    Beautiful look

    makes me sad when i see and hear her today.

    nothing lasts forever.

  • until now mariah is at the top ..LOL

  • Don't be sad. Yes her voice is different now, but it some ways its better. Her voice has changed but it's not all bad changes, she does things now that she's never done before! :)

  • True but there's things she can't do now that were easy for her before. I like the vulnerability her voice has now but during the Daydream Era and even Butterfly her voice had vulnerability and power.

  • The song is amazing and this performance makes it even bettter. I miss this Mariah; the voice and the elegant look.

  • SHE IS THE BEST!

    WE LOVE YOU, MC... :)

  • she has a wonderful voice, her range is amazing but what its more amazing is the way she decides to use it, she is one of my favorite female singers

  • Mariah Carey is the world's most beautiful woman I think it is enough to listen and really brings me to the oasis with its songs that relax me and put me in tune with any of my senses. is not her style is her clothes and her voice, I have 9 years to hear. and I never stop doing

  • The greatest star of all time!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • mariah carey is hot as ever ! whoa !

    nice beauty .. :D

    brilliant voice baby !

  • I LOVE THIS SONG ! I LOVE MARIAH CAREY !

    this song makes me cry ..

    lead me to emote ..

  • better than some fatty birds/dogs wannabes from asia!!!

  • Mariah Carey is the best singer of all time. She has a fantastic voice and she is a fantastic person. Who cares what race she is! She is a very talented person. She looks so beautiful here.

    I Love you Mariah xox

  • SHE'S THE BEST SINGER OF ALL TIME

  • sweet

  • very nice..

  • to all the haters who say mariah only sang wispy in the late 90's when her voice had gone WATCH THIS! This is Mariah at her best (although I prefer vocals from 2001-2006) and she could do the wispy parts then too.

  • mariah is the best female singers .. and also celine D. .,, why they hate her ?

    they're perfect ,,

  • cuz they fucking envy them, cuz they don't have the vocal prowess as the two divas do~~

  • Don't forget Whitney too!

    MC, Whitney & Celine!

  • it's not all bad, but she is a shadow of her former self , even though the former self wasnt actually real...i still prefered the image Tommy Mottola created, it made Mariah the legend she is today, and is the reason why there will always be people buying her stuff....kinda like Michael Jackson too....

  • 200% agree!!!

  • I was actually thinking that the other day; if Mariah kept the image Tommy Motola wanted how would she hae ended up?

  • who knows how she would have ended up, there is only senarios i can think of....

    by keeping her orginal image and making more usual mariah ballads and pop songs she would have kept a loyal older fanbase, but wouldnt have broken into the urban pop/rap/rnb culture therefore negating all the profits there was in that sector at the time. so as a business standpoint, she probably excelled her potencial in the market share, but ruined her percepted integrity that the original mariah fans came to know

  • True Mariah knows how to stay current by making music for whatever works for the prevalent societal msses. I hope 1 day her voice comes back.