Added: 3 years ago
From: BoAmusicUSA
Views: 59,394
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (184)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • estos cabrones, pinche manager de mierda, como se atrevio hacerle eso a BoA, para entrar al showbussines americano no era necesario si quiera cantar en ingles, y estos pendejos que le hiceron todo lo que tiene que ver con el video vestuario coreografias solo la estafaron ello aplaudiendo sus pendejadas ellos bien chingones por que ya cobraron, para eso tenian que a ver pedido el apoyo de Emilio Estefan el si sabe del negocio yo soy fanatico de BoA y no es justo lo que le hicieron putos culeros

  • @naraksan09 totalmente de acuerdo, le pusieron una imagen muy sexual que no tiene nada que ver con ella y una producción muy mediocre, hasta las canciones son muy equis, hubieran echo algo bien impresionante,pero el equipo falló.

  • BoA is hands down, the greatest female dancer I've ever seen. There's only ONE person above her on my list. . .(sorry folks, but Michael Jackson will always be #1 in my book) X-D

    But MJ is one of BoA's main inspirations anyway, so it's all good ^_^

  • well that just took the BoA out of BoA and turned her into another American wannabe... BoA is so amazingly unique but they were still trying to integrate her into the American style... not cool

  • @jinpitakki33 I agree. I applaud BoA for trying to breakout and make a name for herself here in the U.S., but in all honesty, American music (lately) hasn't been the sh*t in a long time, so for her to try and "adapt" to the music market here (to me) is just selling out. BoA will still have plenty of American fans, even if she never releases another album here. As far as I'm concerned, American artists could learn a thing or two from her. . .

  • @CxHxRxIxSxTxIxAxN exactly! what makes BoA so attractive as an artist is that she is squeaky clean and marketed solely on her raw talent. There's no point of her trying to imitate what's already out there, because nobody's gonna take notice of a newbie that's trying to imitate somebody that's already very established. i think she would have done way better in america if she had brought something new to the table - if she did what she personally does best.

  • she's look great when do choreography of misha gabriel, i love when she dance w/ kenny !!! but on this mv, pheewww ~~ BOA and misha should be cooperated again later, to make a great choreograph mv ^^ BOA Fighting

  • haha i like how this version doesn't even pop up in the suggestions are to view.

  • ,...thumbs down to her boy back up dancers..one of them couldn't wear dancing attire...whew!

  • hahaha when her hat came off and she kept dancing xD

    so adorkable

    her body is so flexible during her solo :P

  • the us version made her dance alittle girlier,but still good.

  • i love how she doesnt dance very girly. shes tomboyish and yet still so sexy

  • she should be the main person in the Step up movie =']

  • ........ Please rate this video from A to C

    A: BoA - ball of Ape.

    B: BoA - bitch of America.

    C: BoA - Beat of Asia.

  • @zuduzeye Oh gosh..Its look like B in the usa version..But she is C and very stunning in asia version..'West thing' is just too 'heavy' for asian,believe me..So, just stay in asia and be ourself,Its more better..There is so many of artist in the west are very popular even they are not too talented,let them live in their world and we either..^^

  • @LydiaMunro

    Hello :D

    i think so  =D

    Meeeooowww..!!!

  • The dancing was cool but that's all it should have been - the added special effects made it look like a 3rd grade high school project. They should have just left it with them dancing in a real world location.

  • The winter backdrop was so badly edited my god like so amateur. Who are these guys?

  • I WISH I CAN DANCE LIKE HER!!!!

  • i really dont like this version....the asian one is better

  • i don't know what the heck but it seems like the lady just totally killed the moves that she originally created and it seems so wack and it doesn't seem to represent boa as much iono sucks alot

  • the back dancers cant even keep up with the moves lol, Korean version please!

  • america sucks

  • 0:36 would be a cool ending to the new version

  • Yeah.. this video was crap.

    Show us the Korean Eat You Up video (making of) please. Not this, because literally 99/100 comments say that this is crap and the other one owned.

  • it's ashame if it was better vid effects and stuff i couldve been cool with a cooler theme and no brittney stuff in the begining

  • Thank god she scrapped this one, no offense but the other version was so much better. but yeah i agree i like her outfit in this one.

  • yeah i agree with u guys that other version was way better...and the clothes she had in there were awesome^^ ..personally i dont like the golden hat :)) anyway...whatever she wears she still is beautiful

  • ugh...BoA deserves better like really. i think they kinda put too much pressure on her... =/ kinda feel disappointed.

  • the US version sucks majorly compared to the Korean version and I'm from the US.

  • i will want a to see making of eat you up ( KR ) instead.

  • i think i prefer the other one... - the korean version is so much better.

  • Holy crap. There are some amazing parts that they just totally edited out... anyone with half a brain knows to take advantage of BoA's dancing ability but they just tried to sell her as some stereotypical American slut of a celebrity. Its totally pathetic.

  • Damn, the other version is so much better.

    This version turned out so bad, I mean, BoA deserves better. What would people who don't know her think if they saw this. "Oh, just another slut". But BoA has so much talent in singing and dancing but they stick her with some crappy director who didn't realize her potential, and stuck in some crappy graphics I could have made with Windows Movie Maker and Paint.

    Come on Diane, BoA deserves much better than this crap.

  • I am a big fan of BoA, And i totally agree with you.

  • I'd like to see a making of the better version video :p

  • whoever said she was japanese.. is not informed she is korean however she did move to japan after her debut in Korea. and Now she is here to take over america.. The best of luck im sure she can do it

  • BoA is so cool

  • she dances so cool~

  • Hm....maybe she should play the grudge lady lol omg she's so awesome LOVE BOA!!!

  • DAMN!

  • i want to ask why i can't watch the part three! it shows that my country can't watch=.=

  • I love all the choreography they make for her & I love BoA! but their putting to much pressure on her =/

  • I wanna hug her , too :( !!!

  • the directure screwed the video.. the version A (?) with the dance is sso much more explosive... as much as i love BoA this version of the vid is Yuck.

  • she's so coool

    Ilove her outfit

  • I wanna learn the dance so bad!!

    I Love korean ver better

  • Comment removed

  • i knew that

    what i meant was

    i love the Korean vers. of this song better

  • she's korean

  • She isn't japanese get your facts straight. She is just amazingly fluent in japanese hence why she became a hit in both korea and japan.

  • So this is the director who screwed it up. Seriously, that fake background in the actual video is just fake.

  • I really liked the choreography they did for this vid, but I agree they should've kept the Korean version. That one was WAY more fun to watch.

  • I think they scrapped a lot of her harder dancing to support the "storyline" bits, which is BRUTAL. I'm thinking they should have just stuck it out with the KR version of the routine, but eh.

  • So the resulting video is an enigma... the dancers could dance, she did do some amazing dancing for this video and there were some very sexy scenes, so what on earth went wrong with the editing - looks like they glued together all the worst bits. I don't think that woman director is right for BoA, she is quite a tough American woman and so I guess resistent to selling someone like BoA who is very feminine. SM need to hire someone else to re-cut this video.

  • I didnt know there was more to this video until seeing this. And you are sooooo seriously RIGHT. They should recut it, go through all the footage and make a fresh version....although, i suppose it's too late now. But maybe for like the dvd special or something

  • Yeah they could find an excuse to recut the video - dance remix or something!

  • I think no matter how BoA does a video it's going to be good regardless b/c 4 some reason they r good videos but i like this one more

  • Well actually I think that the Korean version would play well in the American demographic. But I think that's just me.

  • No you're absolutely right.... well at least i think so.. :p

    There's actually something going on in that version. thats what we like to see in a music video..

  • Well I just think that it actually has a theme running through. I HATE Hollywood-ization of videos. There's no point. It's just beauty shots and fans blowing the singer's hair. It drives me nuts!

  • I feel the exact same way...

    I mean they're the same videos over and over again, and its just tiresome...

    idk how to explain it.. but those videos just dont show the artist's potential. if that makes sense..... :p

  • fuck the U.S version

    they made her look like a fuckin slut

  • KR vers is better. BUT!! the American music market is NOT going to adapt to her, so SHE must adapt to it. That's just reality. To us fans, she is a goddess, but to the rest of America, she's just some girl with a rep in East Asia.

    if you MUST compare this video, put it in context. compare her music video to other artist's videos in AMERICA, you'll see that it's alot better than other artists' even if it's not better than her KR vers. at least try to support her American debut...

    BoA FGHTING!

  • I agree, they needed to change her a bit, but when they cut this video they screwed up big time, went too far and removed a chunk of the goddess factor and tried to replace is with the American slut factor (although obviously even 1/2 a BoA = 40,000 Britneys).

  • 後ろの黒人のがへたくそ

  • dude the dance moves are like so COOL

  • This version is to bad ! Korean version i smore good !!

  • her version sucked so much. the korean one rocked

  • The director which Im assuming is Diane Martel sucks too....I know Im no director, but Im pretty sure I can do better....

  • I don't think she sucks she's directed some of the biggest names out there like Ciara with her new song love sex magic and that vid was awesome!

  • im sorry but the two guy dancers suck so bad....I can dance better way BoA is awesome though! check out my channel ppl subscribe

  • her name written in kr-jp-chn and the tiger with the cap on the wall is so cliche...

    The asian version was amazing thought

  • Woooaw. She's such a great artist, yet she gets stuck with bad directors and backup dancers? Please stick with the directors/dancers of the 'Asian Version' Cha I think it was? You deserve better :)

  • BoA is too nice, that lady is a bitch. This video was a slap in the face, clearly low budget. I could have done better x]. Get yourself a new director.

  • What a mess. Everything about it screams LOW BUDGET! Even that crappy grafitti. BoA, you're such a great dancer, you deserved better. I Did it For Love is so much better than this load of shite.

  • that woman is retarted she knos like nothing boa should have directed her own video it would have came out fuckin SWEET

  • the director lady is so... agh!

    BoA made the video look half-decent.

  • she is so so good dont you think man i love her songs

  • grrrrrr! focus on her dancing skills not how hot she looks! she's already pretty enough and if you try too hard she'll look like a try hard...stupid director person.

    She's better than her back-up dancers... damn this is low budget.

  • I almost can't believe this happened. -_-

  • This woman knows nothing about making a good music video

  • i think the dancing in this vid is on par with that of the other one, she's still technical in her tutting. even if i really loved the house steps in the other vid. i just think everything beyond the dancing in the american video was horrible and gaudy.

  • The thing i hate about MVs in US is that they focus on *Sexyness* and *hot* TOO much

  • that is soo true

  • the other video is better you can she her talent more. i think they were just trying to make her look "hot" in this one

  • yeah... i think they trying to make her sexy to sell her first debut... they should have showed her powerful side, dancing and singing... sigh... i don't like that lady screaming -_-

  • i hate that white lady so muchhhhh. she doesnt know jack shit of whats hip in the industries these days

  • The other version is way better no cheesy graffics just pure genious and u can see BoAs talent if they really want her to be succesful here in the US they really need to do more things like that and NOT MAKE THE CD IMPOSSIBLE TO FRIGGIN FINE(I'm still bitter bout the last part they didnt make enough of em and their like sold out everywhere :(

  • You're clueless fool!

  • don't get offended. I just thought that BOA deserves so much more than just being stereotyped into a typical asian artist. it really does her no good that way.

  • there is much effort

  • Do they realize that BoA has been a trained dancer since she first joined SM at the age of TWELVE.

    -____-

    I like the other version better...the one where you can actually see her talent in dancing.

  • Yea this woman is an idiot

    "She's a better dancer then dancers"

  • i mean, BoA's an awesome dancer. she shouldnt have toput up with any of this crap.

  • the guy dancer in the black tshirt and hat looks cheap

  • It's not the best but Korea version beat this one 100x

  • you can tell she is not enjoying this

  • personnaly i think the Diane version of Eat you up is crap compared to the other version. it looks like they dont care if she makes it. its like "here we go again a foreign artist trying to make it big in america, lets get it over with!" i mean bitch please!

  • what diane did besides eat u up video.

  • I like the other version better! The choreography and everything about the other video was so much better!

  • she's really really Awesome !!!!!

    love you Boa <3333

  • SHE GOT THE MOVES! XDDD

  • i just saw her new video for this song on MuchMusic this morning. i'm glad they made the change in both look and choreo from this clip.

  • i think she's better than the dancers behind.

  • God awful director. God awful editing.

    Look at those false cheering and accolades. What a bunch of assholes.

    "Niceeee~!!" "Yeah!!" WHOOOO~~.. shut the fuck up.

  • hmm gladfully she was doing her best

  • Good god, I know D:

  • I totally agree.

     And they had the nerve to pop open a bottle of bubbly like they accomplished something.

    Plz. It turned out horrible.

  • When I watched the video, I was scream and when I'm not screaming, my mouth was open!

  • at least she can dance! wow she CAN dance

  • tiger is funny..doesn't match it..Go BoA!!!!!!!!!!

    sorry..but i think she needs a better team to shoot her mv..maybe next time....

  • Wow, her dancing is just awesome!

    Although the Korean version is sooo much better in my opinion, the only cool parts you can see in this Making Of don't even show up in the finished US-version. -.-.

  • hahah it had boas korean name when she was doing the solo dance

  • her dance looks kinda fun..and i love the hat boa

  • ...they edited all the good parts out of the video...

  • I agree 100%!

  • did i hear the words sex for everybody some where in there?

  • i think this version could hve been better but they edited out lot of the good stuff of her dancing because she was really good

  • shes soo good at dancing i love it.^^ especially when she did that sweep. i wonder why they didn't include the part where she pulled it back?

  • boa the best!!!!

  • great dance! but mv is sosososososo stupid

  • Is unfortunate how this version suck compare to the Korean one.

    Stop wasting Boa's time and energy.

  • yup i totally agree i mean wat was boa thinking i have nothin againts her but seriously the american version is so stupid

  • god I have a girl-crush on her now!

  • Umm... Yeah... this SUCK!!!!!!!!! Again...SUCK!!!!!!! Those guys can't even dance... Their arms and legs were everywhere... I'm sorry but I love the Korean version a WHOLE lot better. They make her look so trashy...

  • seriously

    "trying" to sync with BoA

  • this version sucks. the korean version is awesome!!!

  • CUTE

  • ViVE BoA!!! Je te soutiens!!!

  • Boa is an amazing dancer. She can bring it like the best.

  • O.O; Wow... Man, BoA can DANCE!

  • BoA FTW!

  • BoA es súper linda. Una súper cantante y bailarina, por eso me encanta. Sin duda la mejor.

    BoA Fan Club Peru.

  • amazing.

  • 0:58-1:02 wow,her waist is so flexible.

  • "Your first American record" Its the U.S.A not America...ugh that woman is annoying

  • Well, if you release a record in Canada, you would say "Canadian" record, and if you release a record in Mexico, you would say "Mexican" record, and not "American" record. You would not say, "Your first USA-ian record" when you are referring to the United States; the proper adjective would be American.

  • You could say your first record here in the States, Stateside, but the countries name is United States...of the Americas...its a nationalistic thing, but I get it. Thats why we say we are Texan, Californian, a New Yawker. Its P.C. nonsense and proves I have been in the Academia for far too long!!!

  • THE BACKUP DANCERS GOT TO GO. What makes them any good if they cant even keep up with the artist?

  • I was thinking the same thing.

  • Amen to that! The entire US version was terrible in my opinion. The choreography, the costumes, the dancers...ugh, I nearly cried!

  • you said it! when i saw the video, i was like wtf.........the whole video was just badly put together.......... like they didn't have the time to do a proper edit

  • This MV is based on her dancing.

    It doesn't suck. -___-;

    BOA IS AWESOME. wooo.

  • This is the piece of shizz video made for BoA. Totally useless.

  • かっこいいです(^v^)

    BoAはHipHopが一番あってると思う!

  • omg boA is such a cooool girl!! she's SUCH a good dancer!

  • At the end when the choreographer and BoA are talking, they talk about how they were being rush and that they needed more time.

    Well you can never expect quality if your rushing.

  • I don't think the choreography in this one is any less amazing than in the Asian version, and BoA is the best female hip-hop dancer EVER, imo (<3 BoA!!!), but the concept of the video was just crap. Plus, what's with the back-up dancers??? I know that one of them was the choreographer, but seriously, why just two random guys, not even wearing dance clothes???

  • i think it was all just the bad editing lol

  • Yea. and the effects were awful.

    They could've done better for her.

    That's why I'm glad they chose the Korean version for her debut.

  • You have now idea how happy I am that the Asian version is what's starting to show up herein America!!! I've already seen it on several sites, and I'm sure it'll be spreading to TV soon too! XD

  • The Asian Version is awsome, I hope the "USA" version gets booted...was not my favorite

  • she's such a fantastic dancer...seems to have boundless energy and spring. go girl!

  • The backup dancers should really learn more from BoA =D

  • im pretty sure those other two are instructin her =p but i think i know what you mean.

  • I look up to BoA :D I want to become a strong singer like her!

  • I LOVE U ~

    BoA~

  • cute

  • Wooooo ^_^

  • ohh so it's the vid by diane martel??

  • yup

  • hmm

    seems like all her fans wish her to not being too sexy or taking her clothes off or stripping, because she is not a type of woman like that.,

    i love her juat the way she is now ~_~

  • I prefer the choreography in this one ...

  • GO BoA Go!!

  • Go BoA! You rock! I'll be cheering you on when you come to North America! :D

  • I'm really wondering what they're going to do with this version. I still love this version. Thedancing is slick here also. I'm almost done learning the choreography for this one :D

  • WHOA nice cap 0:18

  • teach us dancing lessons plz :3

  • 보아누나 좋캐타... 미국에사라도 보고십다...

  • hey I seen michi in the video thst's cool love Boa

  • whoa so good at dancing