One of the most beautiful songs I've ever heard. Made me cry so many times ... sometimes in a good way, sometimes in a bad way. But it always reminds me of one thing: True love exists ... and that's no stuff and nonsense. :)
Coming from someone who remembers Split Enz performing this very song and someone who loves Eddie Vedders voice .... I'll say this:
"Stuff & Nonsense" is a beautiful song and both artists here sing beautifully ... but I'm not sure about Tim's harmonies and I'm not sure about the middle 8 ... sounds a bit dodgy to my ear.
But isn't it great that Eddie Vedder considers Split Enz as one of his all time favourite bands ... kudos aplenty :)
I have never heard the original version and obviously have respect for it. But from where I stand, if you are calling this ruining a song, then that's what I pray to do everyday of my life. Ruin songs like Eddie is doing right here. I would give anything to ruin a song like this. Wish I could ruin things like this. Wish I could be a ruiner.
Finally! I tracked it down! :P I heard this version of the song while I was at Borders today :P haha, I was like this song sounds familiar...hey! stuff and nonsense, except not Missy Higgins' version...gotta track it down :P Love it, amazing voice :)
When i hear music like this, i know the worlds alright eh and coming across it as a kid, wish i liked the audiences more haha or they me, it's kinda like wat r u doing here but that fades with grand sounz and kudos 2 Eddy 4 his reaching through and thanx Tim! oh all u's utha fullas and fullesse's
Its Tim Finn. He wrote it. Ed accompanied him on it so its not a "cover".
I was there on the Monday night and Friday night.
It was at the the St James theatre in Auckland.
Its a small traditional theatre venue, capicity of about 1,200.
When Tim and Ed played this song, the crowd was simply struck silent as Tim and Eds voices and the piano honestly filled the air and everbody there completely-the word can only be beautiful.
It a was privlege to be there with Neil and his invitational band.
Desobediciendo mis propias decisiones empecé a amarte hace más de un año, sin embargo tú decidiste q no fuera para siempre. Hoy empieza el proceso de olvidar, asi q por última vez te dedico está canción y t escribo: te amo mucho mi amor..
Stunning! Absolutely beautiful! He takes the music to the heart and is deep inside of the song! I can't handle all this great heartfelt song....pressure on the heart and brain! Eddie transcends into the abyss and feels his way around in the dark....music first! The image appears much later.
Eddie is great!, i love the way he lives his life and the way he express himself through his music, even though this is a cover... it´z amazing how he interpretates it!
not to slight any artist but take jimi hendrixs' guitar, take keith moons' drums, and take geezers' bass...give me eddie vedders' voice as the greatest rock and roll instrument of all time
ED HAS THE ABILITY TO TAKE ANY SONG AND MAKE IT SO POIGNANT , BEAUTIFUL, HE IS A TRUE TALENT, I FOR ONE WILL GIVE HIM MY PRESENCE, NOW AND FOREVER, HE ROCKS MY WORLD, WTF IS WITH MY CAPS? grrr
I would third that(or 4th that?),but I think gndcd already knows my appreciation,since I've expressed it too many times to count.Nice vid,great quality,the better to appreciate Ed's beauty!Thnx for another great one,you rock!!!
God blessed my life ever eternally when he allowed my ears to hear the magnificence of Eddie Vedder's voice .. life would be incomplete otherwise.
KhrysalisFly 2 months ago
Wicked Ive been looking for this song for years. Kia Ora Kautou katoa . XXX
jadescape 6 months ago 2
magic
unclesam21 8 months ago in playlist For work
i am pearl jams number 1 fan
number1pearljamfan 11 months ago
zero dislikes...so it should be!! If you don't like this you need your ears checked :)
wceazza 1 year ago 2
viva la vedder!! gives me goosebumps everytime
wceazza 1 year ago 3
One of the most beautiful songs I've ever heard. Made me cry so many times ... sometimes in a good way, sometimes in a bad way. But it always reminds me of one thing: True love exists ... and that's no stuff and nonsense. :)
Elbereth84 1 year ago 7
Coming from someone who remembers Split Enz performing this very song and someone who loves Eddie Vedders voice .... I'll say this:
"Stuff & Nonsense" is a beautiful song and both artists here sing beautifully ... but I'm not sure about Tim's harmonies and I'm not sure about the middle 8 ... sounds a bit dodgy to my ear.
But isn't it great that Eddie Vedder considers Split Enz as one of his all time favourite bands ... kudos aplenty :)
trampismat 1 year ago
I have never heard the original version and obviously have respect for it. But from where I stand, if you are calling this ruining a song, then that's what I pray to do everyday of my life. Ruin songs like Eddie is doing right here. I would give anything to ruin a song like this. Wish I could ruin things like this. Wish I could be a ruiner.
MrNigelPreston 1 year ago 13
beautiful...
shanerouqui 1 year ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
how to ruin a great song......Tim should have known better.
youdube01 2 years ago
Finally! I tracked it down! :P I heard this version of the song while I was at Borders today :P haha, I was like this song sounds familiar...hey! stuff and nonsense, except not Missy Higgins' version...gotta track it down :P Love it, amazing voice :)
twilightermhtskrpn 2 years ago 5
One of the great songs, one of the great voices.
shagawze 2 years ago 9
please please please sing this November 27 when Pearl Jam rock Auckland NZ!!! Love it!! F'n love it!!!!
Crrrazytim 2 years ago 4
His voice is so beautiful here, imagine that singing you to sleep..purr..great kiwi lyric's btw..
jandals01 2 years ago 7
i can't .... i tried, but i can't forget you.... I still love you ... eres mi gran amor Gullig
blackatia 2 years ago
When i hear music like this, i know the worlds alright eh and coming across it as a kid, wish i liked the audiences more haha or they me, it's kinda like wat r u doing here but that fades with grand sounz and kudos 2 Eddy 4 his reaching through and thanx Tim! oh all u's utha fullas and fullesse's
ampallang7 2 years ago
Awesome version, you can hear the passion in his voice
HellHammerX 2 years ago 7
Its Tim Finn. He wrote it. Ed accompanied him on it so its not a "cover".
I was there on the Monday night and Friday night.
It was at the the St James theatre in Auckland.
Its a small traditional theatre venue, capicity of about 1,200.
When Tim and Ed played this song, the crowd was simply struck silent as Tim and Eds voices and the piano honestly filled the air and everbody there completely-the word can only be beautiful.
It a was privlege to be there with Neil and his invitational band.
oodaks 2 years ago 4
+1 its Neil's older brother Tim playing the piano
Tim wrote and sang this song on the Split Enz album "Frenzy"
yellofury 2 years ago
..and how can it be a 'cover' when the guy playing and singing at the piano wrote the song!!?!
jerryfalwellsociety 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
..and how can it be 'wondeful' when eddie vedder is totally screwing up the song?!
RealMashira 2 years ago
Who said it was 'wondeful'!?
jerryfalwellsociety 2 years ago
Its probably been mentioned before, but this is TIM Finn not Neil Finn - may be correct your description for what its worth..
Great version of a great song BTW.
jerryfalwellsociety 2 years ago
My favourite song from one of my favourite bands with my all time favourite singer. EV, you rock!
bindi22 2 years ago 2
Desobediciendo mis propias decisiones empecé a amarte hace más de un año, sin embargo tú decidiste q no fuera para siempre. Hoy empieza el proceso de olvidar, asi q por última vez te dedico está canción y t escribo: te amo mucho mi amor..
PankraziadeInka 2 years ago
Stunning! Absolutely beautiful! He takes the music to the heart and is deep inside of the song! I can't handle all this great heartfelt song....pressure on the heart and brain! Eddie transcends into the abyss and feels his way around in the dark....music first! The image appears much later.
This is the real and good stuff!!
Thank you!!!!!!
toolooselitrek 2 years ago 5
1:55 wow
ogre1213 2 years ago 2
A beautiful and haunting song.
justaphasebizarre 2 years ago 3
Beautiful! Ed's voice is perfect for this type of harmony. I wish he would do duets with women like this.
BelieveYouMe 2 years ago 4
Eddie is great!, i love the way he lives his life and the way he express himself through his music, even though this is a cover... it´z amazing how he interpretates it!
xeineze07 2 years ago 3
im in love with this song (:
latinbabexoxon 2 years ago 2
not to slight any artist but take jimi hendrixs' guitar, take keith moons' drums, and take geezers' bass...give me eddie vedders' voice as the greatest rock and roll instrument of all time
kdog314 2 years ago 3
agree 200%
darceyensor 2 years ago 5
it is sad, but oh so true, i think this kind of thing has happened to all of us at some point.
great song, brought to life by a beautiful voice, with feeling and integrity .
colletgrad 2 years ago
Speechless....
Damn, this is beyond great.
Holyjammer 2 years ago 3
i can just listen to this over and over....
actually i do :P
colletgrad 2 years ago 5
I know what u mean
rdj218 2 years ago
whoops mistyped...
ED HAS THE ABILITY TO TAKE ANY SONG AND MAKE IT SO POIGNANT , BEAUTIFUL, HE IS A TRUE TALENT, I FOR ONE WILL GIVE HIM MY PRESENCE, NOW AND FOREVER, HE ROCKS MY WORLD, WTF IS WITH MY CAPS? grrr
colletgrad 2 years ago
lovely , poignant and so true byut with ED singing even more beautiful.
colletgrad 2 years ago
So beautiful!
I never heard this song before, but it's lovely.
"And you know that I love you,
Here and now, not forever
I can give you my present
Don't know bout the future."
Eddie, I will ALWAYS love you
sukiyaki113 2 years ago 25
will u always love me? ;)
gndcd402 2 years ago 6
Of course, Gary m'dear! ;)
sukiyaki113 2 years ago 3
yeah!
violistic29 2 years ago
this gets me in thee ol' ticker...love it.
rdj218 2 years ago 7
so beautiful :)
gndcd402 2 years ago
@rdj218 lol :)
vedderclone 1 year ago
such a nice cover.
gives me butterflies ^^
whats " i dilly dally down to duo" ?
latinbabexoxon 2 years ago
:O ohhh
simply amazing
(:
latinbabexoxon 2 years ago
lovely!!
Tangoedout 3 years ago 2
A truly beautiful song rendered in a deeply movement, poignant and utterly incredible manner. Just amazing.
KiwiZombie 3 years ago 3
I couldn't agree more!
serialk0299 2 years ago
Beautiful, the combination over the end is wonderful, thanks for posting mate.
jerinhom 3 years ago 2
What a lovely collaboration . . . especially the harmonies at the end.
And Eddie Vedder is a beautiful man. :)
NoRefillsLeft 3 years ago 4
yes he is inside and out he has the soul of an angel
colletgrad 2 years ago 15
yummmm indeed! simply delightful
rdj218 3 years ago 2
Magical. :)
AgoniadoStickMan 3 years ago 2
stuff and nonsense...realy great...the're both great...
lethe2008 3 years ago
Tearsss, thank you Gary xoxo
epw4edwards08 3 years ago
It's a great song and I like this version very much.
mrsjones14 3 years ago 4
prefer missy higgins cover
secondprize72 3 years ago
*splutters* how dare you even mention Missy Higgins anywhere near lords Vedder or Finn?? May you be stricken down with lightening!
tannedstamina 3 years ago
vedder just sounds like that guy from the carry-on movies. the one who used to say ohh matron a lot.
secondprize72 3 years ago
missy higgins is a real talent and there versions are different ....his is great
rockdat 2 years ago
Tim & Eddie? Sigh...
Insanely cool.
kcarp73 3 years ago 6
Comment removed
mobycat 3 years ago
Mobycat, it's Tim Finn on the piano. And he wrote it as well.
jezxk18 3 years ago
It's Tim. On piano, singing for the harmonies, and the lyricist. He and Neil don't look or sound that much alike, so it's very easy to tell.
Lammington2 3 years ago 2
ITS TIM!
camh888 3 years ago
I would third that(or 4th that?),but I think gndcd already knows my appreciation,since I've expressed it too many times to count.Nice vid,great quality,the better to appreciate Ed's beauty!Thnx for another great one,you rock!!!
michelledm7881 3 years ago
I love you
Moskieto 3 years ago
i second (or third) that...thanks for all the great stuff
kdog314 3 years ago
gndcd402 u are just unbelievable. :')
Thank u very much.
a2032006 3 years ago
gndcd402 u are just unbelievable. :')
Thank u very much.
a2032006 3 years ago