Red is the Rose 1.wmv

[rotwiler50]

thanks brian, this was just a silly moment l recorded and for fun l posted, l,ve got some great celtic music l need to practice, Peter

[grandplans]

man I love this song. I love celtic music. I was hoping to hear you sing the words, but the whistling was excellent.

[NEWoceanflower2008]

This is a wonderful song and your whistle is amazing...your performance is full of emotions...Congratulations, Peter!

Warmest regards,

Andreea

[rotwiler50]

@NEWoceanflower2008 thankyou so much Andrea,that,s a lovely comment from someone with such a beautiful channel as yours, Peter

[tootsieblues]

wonderfull...... best wishes Val .

[rotwiler50]

@tootsieblues thanks Val, Peter

[veroniquereedy]

You have a lovely whistle. I couldn't whistle like that if my life depended on it. Haha. Great video :)

[rotwiler50]

@veroniquereedy ,thanks Cristina ,i remember i think when you wanted to learn how to yodel,i bet you could if you set your mind to it, Peter

[veroniquereedy]

@rotwiler50 Sorry for the slow reply. I havent been on youtube in awhile. But yeah I actually did practice it alot and I finally could do the break thing (but not all the time) and then I just kind of stopped practicing. Haha.

[laysonambrose]

love it!

[rotwiler50]

@laysonambrose thanks for your comment Kimberly,

[rotwiler50]

@laysonambrose thanks for your comment Kimberly,

[rotwiler50]

@laysonambrose thanks for your comment Kimberly,

[NinuszkaPietruszka]

this is a nice version :-) but why didn't you sing it? :-)

I like it.

[rotwiler50]

I guess I was just lazy,ha ha, thanks for visit,bless you ,Peter

[uracil91]

WOW

I have to thank for sharing ;)

Thats brilliant ;)

[rotwiler50]

danke, thankyou so much,Peter

[Bidyyy]

SUPER !!!!

************

[rotwiler50]

thanks Ernest and Sarah, appreciate your input ,Peter

[CountryBoy749]

Good job Peter! Just one small point - Loch Lomond is in Scotland!

Keep 'em coming!

Bill

[rotwiler50]

dear Bill, nice to hear from you, and thanks, but I don,t understand your reference to Loch Lomond? I looked at the words again and found a reference to Killarneysgreen woodland, so I,m sure it,s an Irish song, and it,from an Irish songbook,,so let me know your thinking behind the comment as you,ve got me guessing now, all the best from Spain, Peter

[CountryBoy749]

Hi Peter

The tune is the same as Loch Lomond - I've never heard the Irish version before.

"By yon bonny banks and by yon bonny braes ..."

I enjoyed listening to it anyway :)

Bill

[rotwiler50]

oops i sent a reply to the wrong person, anyway ,yes i listened to them both and they are so similar, bless you ,Peter

[deskyles]

Peter,

I enjoyed your whistling. You did a great job. 5 *****. I think it was beautiful.

Darlene

[rotwiler50]

thanks Darlene for such a lovely comment, best wishes from Spain, Peter,

[rotwiler50]

hi Bill, do you know I,ve never noticed how closely the tunes match one another, but now i do, all the best , Peter

[deskyles]

Peter,

I am not BILL. You sent this to me in my inbox. LOL

Darlene

[rotwiler50]

no Darlene you most definitely are not Bill. I,m so sorry, bless you a million, Peter

[rotwiler50]

thanks Rupert ,value your comments, just thought i,d try something different, peter