mrcowboy888 is trying to say that 學友 is an old singer, his been singing for a long time so people call him 歌神 but in fact he is 虛有其名, meaning that he doesn't sound good. And i TOTALLY disagree with that 學友 is not 虛有其名
Hes so much better than some singers now adays that needs auto tune, i miss the old days where the music industry was filled with good singers and less technology
The music arrangement and the singing are boring. they sounded like that the music was from the 70s or even the 60s. Raymound Cheung sang this song much better .
@hksecreetgarden123 not only your breath is stink, your ears and eyes for sure do have problem, go for check up pls and stop talk rubbish about Jacky's singing cos you don't qualify.
haha~ only several people say raymond sing this song this better... totaly not agree with many people... compare with this,... talk about singging.. very and still FAR FAR away from jacky
eason is not bad too la, same with justin lo, rubber band, and like khalil fong. they are all pretty good la. but out of all jacky still the best of course =D
I really think Jacky is one of those very few rare singers who actually is better while performing LIVE. Not to say his CD isn't good, but DAMN during concerts you can really heart him sing his heart out.. He is on the top of my favorite singers list. I love nearly ALL his songs. I'm really disappointed with the HK entertainment now a days.. be it singing or acting, all TERRIBLE!!! While Jacky can do FREAKING AMAZING IN BOTH!! LI XIANG LAN LIVE by Jacky is one of my ALL TIME favorite performance
LOL but it wouldnt be right for simon to comment on it--he idnt familiar with eastern styles of music, especially chinese singing and music styles. simon wud proly say it was 'boring' blablahblah but thats cuz he doesnt even get the lyrics--how can he understand that jacky's voice and song style is this touching?
10 can't even sing it on guitar hero
bnssapp 1 day ago
真的好愛學友! 怎麼連吹口哨也好聽過人 !
SURVIVORo3o 6 days ago
graceful melody
zhangxiannan 2 weeks ago
田馥甄
s27945 1 month ago
開頭第三句我就眼眶泛淚了....唉!
coke0074 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i feel sorry for the 10 death people.
ninjagaru 2 months ago
Comment removed
ninjagaru 2 months ago
怎麼我會覺得學友連口哨聲都特別的好聽?
是我的問題嗎?
samhang39 2 months ago 10
好心痛..
coke0304 2 months ago
我真的受伤了、
StevenMrsun 2 months ago
張學友的面相好有帝皇格, 2:03-2:11 好像獅子相, 難怪連周杰倫也要尊他為歌神!!!
bingodavidng 2 months ago 3
我好想按100讚!!!!!
denaprincess 3 months ago 6
還是學友的版本最能打動人....
sinyan1120 3 months ago 6
He is finally coming to Vancouver in Jan /2012.
1935844 3 months ago 4
[一直盯著鼻子上那紅色星星看30秒左右,然後轉向牆壁或一片白色的地方,一直眨眼睛,就會有彩色的Hebe出現。]
s27945 3 months ago
聽了好多個版本,只有張學友唱的讓我馬上哭出來,我是真的受傷了.......
hisher097 4 months ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
張學友 棒
TheErinfriends 4 months ago
那8個dislike的耳朵長在哪兒呀!
whathellus 4 months ago 7
那8個人的耳朵真的受傷了
24783130 3 months ago 42
This has been flagged as spam show
我哭了,我真的受傷了..
jojosan3068 4 months ago
喔~天啊...升級版的~~~真的是歌神!!! 華人的最高驕傲~翻唱的也能唱出自已的味道,更何況是自已的歌~有誰能不愛他啊!!!永遠的歌神~一輩子的歌神~~~
sj13cat11021984 4 months ago 7
還記得~國小那時候張學友的吻別跟祝福最紅!
當時並不喜歡張學友! 不懂事的那時! 才8.9歲左右
現在25.6歲了 能治癒人心唱到心坎裡的歌 首選真的非張學友莫屬!
20年後還是如此!
legolight 4 months ago 8
@legolight
一萬年後也是如此!!!
10827208 4 months ago
我一開始不知道誰唱的 想說怎麼那麼好聽
之後知道是張學友唱的後 發現歌更好聽了
MrB8306271 5 months ago 8
現場唱的比CD還好聽的除了歌神還有誰
bsb10122000 5 months ago 7
how can there be 7 dislikes, haha. this dude is legend..
doggyd112 5 months ago
@doggyd112 They are just jealous he's that good.
maine89757 5 months ago
515spark 5 months ago 6
完全折服于口哨声中! 歌中之王! 舞台下,一片寂静,全都醉心于他的歌声中!
nicolecassiopeia 5 months ago 8
我真的受傷了...但是,你在意嗎...你不會在意..
zens0427 5 months ago 5
Comment removed
mas41318 5 months ago
點解, 點解一個人唱歌可以咁好聽?
nashfung 5 months ago 6
就算是我現在喝啤酒喝的想上小號但是聽到學友哥的口哨聲,我還是感動遠遠大過於尿意,口哨太強了
holyquken 6 months ago 77
帥!!
L0V218 6 months ago
天王果然是天王...
badtat2002 7 months ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
耶穌基督愛你們!他是道路,真理和生命造成的生命和永恆的天國!這是真的!
ANDYKAT1001 7 months ago
口哨聲都比我唱得好聽了= ="
kim80326 7 months ago
口哨聲 讓我雞皮掉滿地 聲音讓我疙瘩了全身
s8704290 7 months ago 5
歌神,,請你教我口哨震音法!!!!!!!!
VIPVICT 7 months ago 11
@VIPVICT 緊張的時候:p
msbimbo1000 6 months ago
口哨也是這麼好,歌神是當之無愧
asdgg1234 8 months ago 5
Love this song so so so much!!!!
gunongrapat 8 months ago
Love this song so so so much!!!!
gunongrapat 8 months ago
讚阿~
joe910031 8 months ago
Comment removed
cheah5091 8 months ago
Nice song
Kityeongc 8 months ago
超厲害的演繹...比CD 還要好聽.
foon0925 8 months ago 4
口哨也有震音,神
26565116 8 months ago 4
真的聽完之後會有感動的~~~~~!!!!
beelihayami 9 months ago
真系真系好正,,特别是慢的时候,,!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ttee66666 9 months ago
I like Jacky add the whistle in the song. It allure the quiet and lonely atmosphere.
emilylee4u 10 months ago
A very beautiful unplugged version of the song.
Jacky can whistle really well too.
So many other singers have sung this song
but Jacky's original version is still the most touching one!
ozalice96 10 months ago 2
有5個人係justin bieber既fans
man26252626 10 months ago 7
聽了,我的心真的感動了。
naomifujiki 10 months ago
學友唱live真的超正^^
kengch 10 months ago
那五个dislike 的一定是不懂欣赏音乐的粉肠。 xD
HolyKiller43 10 months ago 4
@HolyKiller43 是没有耳朵才对
mangoxp36 5 months ago
好聽,佢支TAYLOR的DOYLE DYKES都好好聲!
pkfox 11 months ago
口哨也有唱功在!
EriceShek 11 months ago 2
怎麼感覺自己也有那麼一點心碎
dattente 11 months ago 5
心好痛...
a83911123 11 months ago 3
有誰聽了不會落淚.....
bosco2056 11 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
歌聲一般﹐但唱功很好。
jack94123 11 months ago
田馥甄 - 超級瑪麗 (HQ官方版MV)
s27945 1 year ago
this is what i call, SINGING.
upaa83 1 year ago
现在的很多歌手都爱唱花腔,耍技巧。学友反而不屑乱用,收放自如,把简单的歌唱的让人心跟着抖,这才是歌神
peterlin1984 1 year ago 12
淚流了~~
tamoustw 1 year ago 2
真的會聽到覺得自己也跟著融化了,然後就不知不覺的落下淚
超愛吹口哨那邊,好有fu~
x4697590 1 year ago
哎呀 ~ 怎麽來了5個棒棒堂的粉絲~
Jacken666 1 year ago 85
@Jacken666 WHERE?
sanokuo 4 months ago
原來聽學友的歌真的會醉
laochifai 1 year ago 8
田馥甄
s27945 1 year ago
學友這個才是歌神,( 年齡大的那個歌神 ),虛有其名。
mrcowboy888 1 year ago
哪一個是年紀大的歌神??你指的是誰呢~~
syf19840803 1 year ago
Comment removed
sheaks1987 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
mrcowboy888 is trying to say that 學友 is an old singer, his been singing for a long time so people call him 歌神 but in fact he is 虛有其名, meaning that he doesn't sound good. And i TOTALLY disagree with that 學友 is not 虛有其名
ahaugotit 1 year ago
感動到想哭....
judy1689 1 year ago
Hes so much better than some singers now adays that needs auto tune, i miss the old days where the music industry was filled with good singers and less technology
xacezkillzx 1 year ago 2
@xacezkillzx I agree with you
gyman978 1 year ago
這個版本是我覺得最好聽的~!
koloyao 1 year ago 2
The music arrangement and the singing are boring. they sounded like that the music was from the 70s or even the 60s. Raymound Cheung sang this song much better .
hksecreetgarden123 1 year ago
@hksecreetgarden123 not only your breath is stink, your ears and eyes for sure do have problem, go for check up pls and stop talk rubbish about Jacky's singing cos you don't qualify.
erichoo10 1 year ago
haha~ only several people say raymond sing this song this better... totaly not agree with many people... compare with this,... talk about singging.. very and still FAR FAR away from jacky
unitechtu 1 year ago
@hksecreetgarden123 this is the kind of song that's missing nowadays, it doesn't sound boring, you just don't have a heart to listen to it.
noraacmw 1 year ago 2
口哨 好恐怖阿!!!!!!雞皮掉拉
ptor121 1 year ago
學友 very good!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
superzxz 1 year ago
good...........................
whiteheadleung 1 year ago
天啊-_- 如果有這樣的一個男人跟我唱歌我死也要嫁給他
實力派真是實力派, 就這樣簡簡單單沒有和音沒有花巧沒有勁舞,
也能把每一位觀眾的注意力抓得緊緊的.
我在這裡也replay了好幾次, 可以聽live的人真幸福~_~
kobiansilly 1 year ago 5
@kobiansilly ~~~~~唱给你听听~~哈哈:)
bforbfour 1 year ago
听到哭了。T.T 好听啊~
dragonkean 1 year ago
Oh thank you for the information.
Because I want to buy the DVD of this concert.
protocl 1 year ago
nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice
gordonfong91 1 year ago 4
陶醉在它的音樂氣氛中~
tsww33shaw 1 year ago
口哨還會抖音 超殺!!!
iflaba 1 year ago 8
does anyone know what concert?
protocl 1 year ago
@protocl this is on the concert of Jacky 2002-2003 Music Odyssey Grand Finale
chenzhihaochanchiho 1 year ago
@protocl Jacky 2002-2003 Music Odyssey Grand Finale
chenzhihaochanchiho 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Jacky 2002-2003 Music Odyssey Grand Finale
chenzhihaochanchiho 1 year ago
好爱。。。
linfulong 1 year ago
王菀之定是王羲之的七十世後人
所以可以寫下這麼好的詞典 讚!! 能交給阿學友唱 這才是真是絕症不能遺..
chinesehelicopter 1 year ago 9
@chinesehelicopter
王羲之好像是書法家 和作詞好像...
不過詞真的填得很好
ssuuppeerrrttt 1 year ago
@ssuuppeerrrttt
您是开玩笑的吧。。。。。
xuehuichao 1 year ago
@chinesehelicopter 一定係...
r053032 1 year ago
神就是神
VascoAu 1 year ago
好好聽呀!!!!!!!!!!!
ken95503 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
真不知道為啥有人會不喜歡,實在是太好聽了
tong4014 1 year ago
Comment removed
tong4014 1 year ago
Comment removed
tong4014 1 year ago
哨神
sanovii 1 year ago
深情配口哨
口琴背景很優!
神就是神
好聽!!
wesley0513 1 year ago 6
Great......!
jornessim83 1 year ago
吹口哨果段 真係勁好聽!!!
唔明點解 吹口哨 會吹到咁好聽...
maxli929 1 year ago 2
最後的一個尾音 簡直是情感大爆發
令人感動 深情至極...
goshan0812 2 years ago 7
心目中永遠的神!
go51evo 2 years ago 3
歌神, 我愿意用我一生的积蓄卖他的演唱会门票.
mtvcctvma 2 years ago 10
為甚麼連口哨都能轉音!?
沒道理阿!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
=口=
ten7671541 2 years ago 141
@ten7671541 口哨之神阿=口=
tam1234hk 2 years ago 7
@ten7671541
抖音啊~~~~~~~~~~~太扯了
jacky04170286 5 months ago 3
勁!!
chan3824 2 years ago 4
God of God...
iXenomorph 2 years ago 6
好鍾意吹口哨果部分
koloyao 2 years ago 7
i personally think hes the only singer in HK...that can sing in live as good as in CD...he really deserve the name 歌神
cai123456789j 2 years ago 6
eason is not bad too la, same with justin lo, rubber band, and like khalil fong. they are all pretty good la. but out of all jacky still the best of course =D
thesaru 2 years ago 3
嘩‥真係超好听~ ^^
kingrock23iwgp 2 years ago 6
He performed even better than in MTV.
sheakinsang2001 2 years ago 6
GOD OF SONG !!!!!
funnybunny9396 2 years ago 4
在這首歌
展現完全的功力
歌神
當之無愧!
thegodim 2 years ago 18
My all time favorite!! 讚!
jlngan 2 years ago 7
better than his KTV
jeffreyyou3 2 years ago 2
I really think Jacky is one of those very few rare singers who actually is better while performing LIVE. Not to say his CD isn't good, but DAMN during concerts you can really heart him sing his heart out.. He is on the top of my favorite singers list. I love nearly ALL his songs. I'm really disappointed with the HK entertainment now a days.. be it singing or acting, all TERRIBLE!!! While Jacky can do FREAKING AMAZING IN BOTH!! LI XIANG LAN LIVE by Jacky is one of my ALL TIME favorite performance
G2IntegraDA 2 years ago 27
it is very hate when someone u love don love u.i truely understand it..
bulletsim 2 years ago 5
i think jacky is still the only person in this world who can realise my opinion abt music:
Music should embody emotion, feelings and sometimes tucked away memories, not dumb entertainment orso-called music
yellowfellow83 2 years ago 14
This comment has received too many negative votes show
演繹得有點像玉置浩二 哈哈
locyedwin 2 years ago
''HE'' makes me cry...
grandymui 2 years ago 6
一絕...
在我心中永是四大天王之首
hmtamalex 2 years ago 115
@hmtamalex 一直以來也是=]
jw941104 1 year ago
不愧是歌神 今天的喉音非常特殊 但超有感情 很好聽~.
口哨技也是一絕啊
ticwhang 3 years ago 109
佢唱到好有feel
chantinyu 3 years ago 15
agree with you all. 張學友 is one of the best, if not the best artist from Asia.
nathanliang 3 years ago 12
excellent!
g8mao 3 years ago 2
What would Simon Cowell say if Jacky could have a chance to perform on American Idol?
jasonng86 3 years ago 2
LOL but it wouldnt be right for simon to comment on it--he idnt familiar with eastern styles of music, especially chinese singing and music styles. simon wud proly say it was 'boring' blablahblah but thats cuz he doesnt even get the lyrics--how can he understand that jacky's voice and song style is this touching?
BlueBear26 3 years ago 3
Can never get tired of watching his love performances.. I wish I could be there .. ahh goosebumps
esosgurl 3 years ago 2
i wish i was there
kirilenko 3 years ago 3
超有感覺好聽
judo0209 3 years ago 4
I very much agree Jacky is one of the best live performer from hk, if not from the world.
All his live performances are better, in a way, than his studio versions. That's my opinion though.
Gamenoobic 3 years ago 6
agree his live performance gives me a unique feeling everytime
VIPVICT 3 years ago 12
Ive been to 3 of his concerts. Never fails to amaze me and he is much better live, in my opinion.
jfungsf 3 years ago 15
好聽^^
porktt 3 years ago 3
i was there. cheap seat. but wt a show. in my book, jacky is the best live performer from hk.
mcdamike 3 years ago 3
T_T my heart is full of tears
yanxia8468 3 years ago
what a nice performance Jacky..never know that u can play a guitar..I always like ur style...always do..
jwkuswandi 3 years ago
在現場看的話我一定會忍不住哭.....
GoldbergAC 3 years ago 5
great!!!
LionelHUANG 3 years ago