I saw this movie because I love and respect Bryan Singer - talented director. "Valkyrie" was ok but I didn't feel the atmosphere of that period in our history. "Enemy at the Gates" (2001) and "Black Book" (2006) were much better films. I actually enjoyed Tom Cruise's performance but he did not take the lead as strongly as he should have. His non-German accent was not an issue it was the strength that he displayed in his performance that was disappointing to many. The supporting cast was superb
Come on . Tom Cruise is Tom Cruise . I don't care about his personal life . he is free to do whatever he wants . what interests me his career in actin' he Rocks !! as every one said he is a very talented !!
Stfu you bitch. You don't even get the point of Valkyrie. Look at how many English actors played German actors, they even said it's not the point. The point of the movie is the outcome, and to descirbe history. You don't know shit about movies.. or actors.. so just quit, because you're a terrible critic. Talking shit to one of the best actors out there. If I were Tom, I'd sue your ass, let's see you fill in the shoes of some actors, and see how easy it is.
@linuxguru1968 by that nature, you'd find ANY movie based on history to be void of entertainment. By your comment I'd guess you hated Hearl Harbor as well(cause you know how it ends.....), but thats just a guess derived from your comment. I loved Pearl Harbor, and Valkyrie. Just because you know how it ultimately ends, doesn't mean it can't be an enjoyable movie. There is the chance you just don't like documentaries. If you don't like 'em, don't watch 'em. Otherwise, try to enjoy, if you want.
I do like V. Its just that could have had more of a "punch" more background on the underground movement to kill Hilter. From what I understand, it took decades for the Germans to reflect on the WWII/Holocaust era and admit that they were lead into supporting and evil regime. BTW, I did like Pearl Harbor, but more could have been done to make the period more alive - like Japanese brutality that ultimately justified the use of the A bomb.
iespinty: Valkyrie is a term in Norse mythology and means Chooser of the Slain, sort of female spirit warriors who choose amongst the ones that died in battle, if they are brave and worthy the Valkyrie let the dead warrior to go with her and enter Valhalla, Hall of the Slain to remember the glory in the afterlife in presence of Wotan (Odin).
i think this would have been a great movie if there was no CRUISE. great idea for a movie but bad actor should have been played by someone less self centered. sould have had an accent :) and should have been assassanated.
and why have accents? i mean just think of it this way, all the actors in the movie are actually speaking in german, and you understand and fluently speak german. i mean i dont see what the big deal is, i think its better that they didnt have "accents" because it would make it seem fake..because why would they be in germany speaking english with a german accent lol
I grew up in Germany and people here certainly would`t understand what sort of a problem you guys have with that "accent thing".
In all of the movies on tv the characters ( Western,indians,caveman,frenchmen,knights,... ) of course speak german.Everybody is used to that and actors like Cruise,Pitt,Willis,... keep their same german voices as long they are performing.
So it is sometimes disturbing for some people to listen to their "real" voices ,since the dubing on german tv is very good.
So of course Cruise speaks english with no german accent,since this is an american movie,made for an american audience,cruise is american and everybody in this movie speaks english as they will speak japanese in Japan,frensh in france and so on.
There used to be a seventies show with toni curtis and roger moore.Apparently it was very dull and boring in the originell version but it became a huge success in Germany through it excellent and very funny dubbing.
why would you want cruise to use a german accent? thats just stupid, im sure they chose for cruise not to have an accent for a reason..i saw this movie a couple days ago and thought cruise did a
GREAT job in this film. dont review it if you havent even seen the movie ignoranus. over all this film was a great film for people who are interested in war and history.
Fuck you tom cruise,I am tired of this motherfucker,he thinks he is the best actor in the world,if you want to watch great WWII movies watch downfall and stalingrad,both german movies,not fucking tom cruise
ill admit it started out a little slow but i mean if you didnt like this movie its because your ignorant and are not interested in history. And how the hell does someone not know the story leading up to this July 20th plot -_- pretty easy to figure out if youve heard of hitler.
lions for lambs was huge. and enough with the American accent bashing's! if people would have actually watched the movie they would have known it was in German! we were just hearing it in English! this was all done at the beginning, and EVERYBODY else had an American accent too. we're hearing nothing about Kenneth Branagh, with an English accent in Germany! like jesus, it's not just a Tom Cruise fault. i'd give this movie an 8 at least. you have to be into this history to enjoy it, so it's 50/50
very good movie. just had to pay attention. kind of a sleeper but all out good movie. not lots of action like people thought. but in my opinion i give it a good 8 out of 10.
"No country.." is a "10", I think the "Curious case of Benjamin Button" is a "10"...Valkyrie compared to these movies is realistically probably a "6" ....sorry!!!
yea you're thinking in a good way. im just giving a half assed opinion because i pratcially slept the whole movie. XP but one that looks good that is coming out is gran torino. i think that would be a good one.
This movie is typical of Hollywood rewriting history . Hitlers generals tried to assassinate him so they could conduct the war properly . Hitler micro-managed the war to complete ineffeciency to the allies benefit . Our best option was to keep Hitler in power so he could keep throwing wrenches in the works . Its quite possible that if Hitler were to be assassinated the death toll would have been even higher that the what is was . Hitler was his own worst enemy .
I thought this movie was great! It was very historicaly accurate from the piano wire hanging, to all those men being killed, and when the bag fell and the man moved it all of this happened. Also that the second charge wasent there, and how close they came to taking Berlin. It was very good, it was well done by all actors including Cruise. Also, it was definetly egde of the seat action the whole way thru from beggining to end. I have no idea how that little guy with the moustache fell asleep. lol
I can't wait for those movies either! 2009 is going to be awesome - Star Trek, Wolverine, Watchmen (if Fox and Warners come to an agreement), Harry Potter, and more!
iam from argentina and i think that tom cruise is one of the most intense actor in this time, he gave great performances: magnolia, last samurai, collateral, jerry maguire, interview with a vampire, etc. I dont understan why the people judge a person for his personal life and not by their performance. Dont watch garbage tv please ( sorry for my english)
Yes, that's true for his recent work. Back in the 80s and early 90s, he was the big man on the block. Put Cruise in a movie, instant hit. But now, more than ever, he carries too much baggage. I heard that, at early viewings of Valkyrie, people were laughing at unintentionally funny scenes. I'm not seeing this movie, and Cruise makes me laugh whenever I see him sporting the eyepatch. They should have cast Ralph or Joseph Fiennes. Cruise is too well-known to disappear into a role.
I don't really think Cruise is too good of an actor. However,I love some of his movies like "Jerry Maguire", "A Few Good Men", "Minority Report" and "Mission: Impossible" part 2 and 3. As for his religion, I don't care if he follows it, but I think he should stop promoting his religion. Whenever he talks about it he sounds foolish. As for "Valkyrie", I think it looks OK, but I'm pretty hesitant about it too. I'll probably wait for DVD. Great episode though!
I don't think it should matter that much if Tom Cruise is a scientologist, if tjere's a good film to be enjoyed, then might as well enjoy it. I wouldn't mind seeing a film with a muslim actor, so how is this different?
Excellent point, however I personally think it's different with Tom Cruise because he uses his acting career to promote his religion. The Church of Scientology also gets involved in Cruise's career, talking to studio executives etc. To me, Tom Cruise is the new Michael Jackson - I still appreciate his work, but he's just gone too far with personal issues.
Tom speaks about scientology in a very irritating and crazy way and that's what's bothering me. But I don't care for Tom trying to promote his religion through his movies cause hollywood is basicly one big propaganda factory :)
This has been flagged as spam show
I saw this movie because I love and respect Bryan Singer - talented director. "Valkyrie" was ok but I didn't feel the atmosphere of that period in our history. "Enemy at the Gates" (2001) and "Black Book" (2006) were much better films. I actually enjoyed Tom Cruise's performance but he did not take the lead as strongly as he should have. His non-German accent was not an issue it was the strength that he displayed in his performance that was disappointing to many. The supporting cast was superb
Magnolia296 11 months ago
Come on . Tom Cruise is Tom Cruise . I don't care about his personal life . he is free to do whatever he wants . what interests me his career in actin' he Rocks !! as every one said he is a very talented !!
sweetNado123 1 year ago
Stfu you bitch. You don't even get the point of Valkyrie. Look at how many English actors played German actors, they even said it's not the point. The point of the movie is the outcome, and to descirbe history. You don't know shit about movies.. or actors.. so just quit, because you're a terrible critic. Talking shit to one of the best actors out there. If I were Tom, I'd sue your ass, let's see you fill in the shoes of some actors, and see how easy it is.
Br0LySsJ 1 year ago
Comment removed
Br0LySsJ 1 year ago
Not really much suspense. You know the attempt fails, the perpetrators get hung with piano wire and Hitler kills himself the next year....
linuxguru1968 2 years ago
@linuxguru1968 by that nature, you'd find ANY movie based on history to be void of entertainment. By your comment I'd guess you hated Hearl Harbor as well(cause you know how it ends.....), but thats just a guess derived from your comment. I loved Pearl Harbor, and Valkyrie. Just because you know how it ultimately ends, doesn't mean it can't be an enjoyable movie. There is the chance you just don't like documentaries. If you don't like 'em, don't watch 'em. Otherwise, try to enjoy, if you want.
wildside316 1 year ago
@wildside316 *Pearl Harbor
I hate typoes....
wildside316 1 year ago
I do like V. Its just that could have had more of a "punch" more background on the underground movement to kill Hilter. From what I understand, it took decades for the Germans to reflect on the WWII/Holocaust era and admit that they were lead into supporting and evil regime. BTW, I did like Pearl Harbor, but more could have been done to make the period more alive - like Japanese brutality that ultimately justified the use of the A bomb.
linuxguru1968 1 year ago
he is a good actor but will all still think hes a bitch
videomaker74 2 years ago
i agree with the guy in the scarf i fell asleep during valkatire i thoguht it was boring slow and confusing
molt2000 2 years ago
fuck cruise,I hate that motherfucker
kondurperufour 2 years ago
does anyone know what Valkyrie means
espinty 2 years ago
Valkyrie are warrios women from the nordic mytology,something like that
kondurperufour 2 years ago 4
its a plan to protect the nazi government in case of a take over using thee reserve army
ilikemewaffle 2 years ago
iespinty: Valkyrie is a term in Norse mythology and means Chooser of the Slain, sort of female spirit warriors who choose amongst the ones that died in battle, if they are brave and worthy the Valkyrie let the dead warrior to go with her and enter Valhalla, Hall of the Slain to remember the glory in the afterlife in presence of Wotan (Odin).
DocStrange0123 2 years ago 2
i think this would have been a great movie if there was no CRUISE. great idea for a movie but bad actor should have been played by someone less self centered. sould have had an accent :) and should have been assassanated.
5
SeldomShroom 2 years ago
fucking
kondurperufour 3 years ago
I am fucing tired if that motherfucker tom cruise,he thinks he is the best actor in the world,he is a motherfucker
kondurperufour 3 years ago
i like the ending the best
IRISHMOBSTER55 3 years ago 3
and why have accents? i mean just think of it this way, all the actors in the movie are actually speaking in german, and you understand and fluently speak german. i mean i dont see what the big deal is, i think its better that they didnt have "accents" because it would make it seem fake..because why would they be in germany speaking english with a german accent lol
nwrob12 3 years ago 9
I grew up in Germany and people here certainly would`t understand what sort of a problem you guys have with that "accent thing".
In all of the movies on tv the characters ( Western,indians,caveman,frenchmen,knights,... ) of course speak german.Everybody is used to that and actors like Cruise,Pitt,Willis,... keep their same german voices as long they are performing.
So it is sometimes disturbing for some people to listen to their "real" voices ,since the dubing on german tv is very good.
neumi107 3 years ago 3
So of course Cruise speaks english with no german accent,since this is an american movie,made for an american audience,cruise is american and everybody in this movie speaks english as they will speak japanese in Japan,frensh in france and so on.
There used to be a seventies show with toni curtis and roger moore.Apparently it was very dull and boring in the originell version but it became a huge success in Germany through it excellent and very funny dubbing.
neumi107 3 years ago 4
why would you want cruise to use a german accent? thats just stupid, im sure they chose for cruise not to have an accent for a reason..i saw this movie a couple days ago and thought cruise did a
GREAT job in this film. dont review it if you havent even seen the movie ignoranus. over all this film was a great film for people who are interested in war and history.
nwrob12 3 years ago 2
The best cruise movie was born on the 4 of july,that one was epic
kondurperufour 3 years ago
Fuck you tom cruise,I am tired of this motherfucker,he thinks he is the best actor in the world,if you want to watch great WWII movies watch downfall and stalingrad,both german movies,not fucking tom cruise
kondurperufour 3 years ago
ill admit it started out a little slow but i mean if you didnt like this movie its because your ignorant and are not interested in history. And how the hell does someone not know the story leading up to this July 20th plot -_- pretty easy to figure out if youve heard of hitler.
Karkinelite 3 years ago
gran torino comes out firday nad i think it's gonna be awesome
robert72193 3 years ago
lol i didnt notice before but one of the guys sounded like he said i give it a 2 out of ten.
robert72193 3 years ago
He did give it a 2 out of 10! :)
BeyondTheTrailer 3 years ago
lions for lambs was huge. and enough with the American accent bashing's! if people would have actually watched the movie they would have known it was in German! we were just hearing it in English! this was all done at the beginning, and EVERYBODY else had an American accent too. we're hearing nothing about Kenneth Branagh, with an English accent in Germany! like jesus, it's not just a Tom Cruise fault. i'd give this movie an 8 at least. you have to be into this history to enjoy it, so it's 50/50
DesQueJteVois 3 years ago
very good movie. just had to pay attention. kind of a sleeper but all out good movie. not lots of action like people thought. but in my opinion i give it a good 8 out of 10.
robert72193 3 years ago
"No country.." is a "10", I think the "Curious case of Benjamin Button" is a "10"...Valkyrie compared to these movies is realistically probably a "6" ....sorry!!!
xman4un 3 years ago
yea you're thinking in a good way. im just giving a half assed opinion because i pratcially slept the whole movie. XP but one that looks good that is coming out is gran torino. i think that would be a good one.
robert72193 3 years ago
have you seen valkyie its great
stuwiitube 3 years ago
i fell asleep watching this movie in theatres twice XD
tmntyoshi 3 years ago
then why'd you see it... twice?
batmanunleashed 3 years ago
i didnt see it twice.
i was forced to watch it once and i fell asleep twice during the same showing of it.
tmntyoshi 3 years ago
I think we can all see why yourdickisreallysmall . Small brain=small penis .
antiochblade 3 years ago
This movie is typical of Hollywood rewriting history . Hitlers generals tried to assassinate him so they could conduct the war properly . Hitler micro-managed the war to complete ineffeciency to the allies benefit . Our best option was to keep Hitler in power so he could keep throwing wrenches in the works . Its quite possible that if Hitler were to be assassinated the death toll would have been even higher that the what is was . Hitler was his own worst enemy .
antiochblade 3 years ago
I thought this movie was great! It was very historicaly accurate from the piano wire hanging, to all those men being killed, and when the bag fell and the man moved it all of this happened. Also that the second charge wasent there, and how close they came to taking Berlin. It was very good, it was well done by all actors including Cruise. Also, it was definetly egde of the seat action the whole way thru from beggining to end. I have no idea how that little guy with the moustache fell asleep. lol
supernole100 3 years ago
This was a great movie.
CanadianPride8 3 years ago
these reviews are so funny
bpaj 3 years ago
that short man with the moustach must not have seen the real movie cause it was great!!
countjimmy12 3 years ago 2
never underestimate a fanatic" gahahahahaha
your hilarius!
Your show is awesome!
I can`t wait Terminator 4 and Transformers 2 :D
moviedirector88 3 years ago
I can't wait for those movies either! 2009 is going to be awesome - Star Trek, Wolverine, Watchmen (if Fox and Warners come to an agreement), Harry Potter, and more!
BeyondTheTrailer 3 years ago
iam from argentina and i think that tom cruise is one of the most intense actor in this time, he gave great performances: magnolia, last samurai, collateral, jerry maguire, interview with a vampire, etc. I dont understan why the people judge a person for his personal life and not by their performance. Dont watch garbage tv please ( sorry for my english)
joroelcapo 3 years ago
6/10
The Most interesting anticipation turned to be a uninteresting flop.
DrDMovieMadness 3 years ago
That dumb lady she asks is annoying, he has his arm, fingers, and eye at the begining of the movie!
BRONCOWEN 3 years ago
one of the best war movie ever made!!!!! DONT HATE ON TOM CRUISE!!! HE'S STILL DA MAN
310thegame228 3 years ago
tom cruise IS NOT the man and ever will be.he is waaaaay to dramatic
FireFart179 3 years ago
I watched it Grace and I loved it!
I think Tom always delivers.
Yes I dont care about what he does in his person life thats not my business but as an actor he makes the stories just a bit more real.
I give Valkyrie 8.5
mm*
p.s. TOM ROCKED IN VANILLA SKY!!!
djmixmind 3 years ago 6
Yea Vanilla Sky and Eyes Wide Shut
Suburbanenemy52 3 years ago
i got to see this movie last sunday in LA at a speacial showing it was awesome
luigithekid 3 years ago
This might sound really mean, but I think Tom Cruise ruins every movie he is in.
Ajvupj21 3 years ago
Yes, that's true for his recent work. Back in the 80s and early 90s, he was the big man on the block. Put Cruise in a movie, instant hit. But now, more than ever, he carries too much baggage. I heard that, at early viewings of Valkyrie, people were laughing at unintentionally funny scenes. I'm not seeing this movie, and Cruise makes me laugh whenever I see him sporting the eyepatch. They should have cast Ralph or Joseph Fiennes. Cruise is too well-known to disappear into a role.
mykalroze 3 years ago
He sure didn't ruin Tropic Thunder
CaptainRidley 3 years ago 2
I don't really think Cruise is too good of an actor. However,I love some of his movies like "Jerry Maguire", "A Few Good Men", "Minority Report" and "Mission: Impossible" part 2 and 3. As for his religion, I don't care if he follows it, but I think he should stop promoting his religion. Whenever he talks about it he sounds foolish. As for "Valkyrie", I think it looks OK, but I'm pretty hesitant about it too. I'll probably wait for DVD. Great episode though!
SCREAMfanatic123 3 years ago
jajaj the guy in the mustache was so funny.
an3033 3 years ago
i found her right away!
yeah.
:-D
wolfgar45 3 years ago
I can't seem to FIND YOU on Facebook, Grace! Can't find BeyondTheTrailer either... clearly I fail at this.
SivartAlappes 3 years ago
Just search for either "Grace Randolph" or "Beyond The Trailer" - both should come right up.
BeyondTheTrailer 3 years ago
I did. When I put Grace Randolph, I get 84 results. None of which appear to be you.
When I put Beyond the Trailer, I get 46 results. None of which are the show.
SivartAlappes 3 years ago
scratch that. Found the show now.. but still can't find YOU!
SivartAlappes 3 years ago
shes the cute blonde from New York, New York
fredbob777 3 years ago
lmao i like at the end were everyone behind you is staring at you
kerric123456 3 years ago
"You know what Cruise? SCREW YOU" That made me laugh.
rockinbrowneyedgirl 3 years ago
I would give it a 7/10.
It was a pretty good historical movie, screw what people think about what Cruise did before, you have to judge the movie not his other movies.
KIGENTS 3 years ago
Grace what happened to your tagline
'what movie did you just see'?
fredbob777 3 years ago
Well, I'd gotten some feedback that I should get straight into the interview - but if you miss the tagline, it shall return! :)
BeyondTheTrailer 3 years ago
Tom Cruise is good actor anyways i don't care about his personal life !
dothack200 3 years ago 2
I don't think it should matter that much if Tom Cruise is a scientologist, if tjere's a good film to be enjoyed, then might as well enjoy it. I wouldn't mind seeing a film with a muslim actor, so how is this different?
corsair773 3 years ago
Excellent point, however I personally think it's different with Tom Cruise because he uses his acting career to promote his religion. The Church of Scientology also gets involved in Cruise's career, talking to studio executives etc. To me, Tom Cruise is the new Michael Jackson - I still appreciate his work, but he's just gone too far with personal issues.
BeyondTheTrailer 3 years ago
Tom speaks about scientology in a very irritating and crazy way and that's what's bothering me. But I don't care for Tom trying to promote his religion through his movies cause hollywood is basicly one big propaganda factory :)
Aaster1n1an 3 years ago
cool
mrtvman 3 years ago