Added: 5 years ago
From: ejhoffman
Views: 65,464
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (191)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • And Sisley will never never compare to Carah's lovely voice. Who in their right mind would get rid of their lead singer after the success that ( we are pilots ) had?

  • Carah is cute as a button. What ever that means.

  • I'm actually glad Carah's not in the band anymore. She's too good for STG, even more so when you factor in the crap that STG has turned into. Well, at least that's my opinion.

  • D: My life was ruined when I found out Carah left STG :'(

  • @xtokioxbillx  Then go to her band, youll probaly wont miss her anymore!

  • @Samlai123 her band doesnt play the same STG songs...i meant i miss her in stg...damn.

  • @xtokioxbillx Mine 2!!!

  • @PuNKprInCeSs656 WELL SHES BACK!!! YAY

  • 2:11 carah's fuckung voice made me melt. WHAT A GODDESS O_O

  • I fuckin' hate how they got rid of Carah :( She was the reason I even listened to STG.

  • I like the drummer the best

  • prime live performance. she is the sweetest famous person in the world, i'm sure of it.

  • carah ROCKS. nuff sed

  • she can sing good

  • she's so hott

  • I know right!!!

  • CARAHHHHHHHHHH

  • UHG i miss carah, but o well VERSANT, her new band is good enough for me.

  • Comment removed

  • I know you already got answered but its Versant and they are great!

  • 3:11= amazing.

  • need...carah...back!

  • Carrah with eyes like diamonds

  • I LOVE CARAH

  • i really dont think it matters whether you like sisley or not, shes here to stay so everyone should just chill i guess

  • @mintmage

    Oops...she's gone. haha

  • They all have cool hair style!!

  • I am madly in love with Carah.

  • I freaking LOVE Carah

  • Carah's best performance. Sisley is fucking amazing live with 'When Did This Storm Begin' :)

  • Comment removed

  • I loved Carah, but I just saw STG tonight, and Sisley is really, really amazing.

  • agreed. i will always love carrah but no need to pit the two against each other!

  • oh my goodness.

    that scream gave me chills.

    loveloveloooove carah. <3

  • I really miss the old shiny toy guns I don't like Sisely

  • she sounds brittish!

  • Yeah she sings this song in a British Accent. Sisely tries to do that but fails epically.

  • ey sorry ich hab euch nur 4 strene gegeben mein aber 5!!!!!!!!

  • she is fucking hot

  • PLEASE don't yell @ me for this, but why isn't she in the band anymore?

  • i like them both

  • EVERY ONE chaeck out her new band Versent..

    im always going to miss the ols shiny toy guns..

    i LOVE we are pilots.

  • dude they are awsome but im dissapointed carah left D: she was such an awsome singer too

  • they said she rly didnt leave

    they kicked her out

    both rumors

  • Was that seriuosly live? Because it was awesome!!!

    Sucks Carah's gone, she was gorgeous and had a great voice

  • She has just the right amount of sensuality and peforms these songs so damned well...well "performed"...:(...it fit so well with her!!...Without her?...Dunno if STG will continue moving up...

    Oh God and the way she MOVES!...I LOVE IT!!!

  • CARAH'S FEIRCE!!

    =D

    too bad she's gone

    ):

  • sexualsexualsexualsexualsexual­sexualsexual!!!!*drooling*

  • that's the coolest bridge in a pop song in ages...

  • What happened 2 Cara? she has an awesome voice (and name)

  • It's Carah...

  • their good live!

    i want to go to one of their concerts really bad

  • yeah but unfortunately carah left the band

  • dannnggg!

  • there good , she sound mega time english lol

  • wow that waz awesome! they're really good live! :)

  • wow they're really good live !! :D

    i love Carah's voice <3

  • hey you do know carah isnt in shiny toy guns anymore? They got another singer.

  • she has such a cute voice.<333

    :D

  • PS

    she screams nicely :K

  • Hmmm isn't this weird

    isn't she American?

    cause she sings like

    an Aussie or British

    girl but i really

    like the song ^^

  • i luv this song

  • great song :>

  • i just LOVE carahs voice!

  • i just love how Carah and Jeremy look back at Mikey @ 3:20!

  • oh my GOD 3:11, everytime I hear her do the scream I want to try it! and the ending of the song! DAMN Carah is hot!

  • my god carrah is so dam hot!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    expecially when she screams!!

    i would sell my left nut to be with her

  • i tried that.... but turns out u gotta give both......

  • LOL

  • would she want to be with a man missing a left nut?

  • I love Carah's scream in place of the YEAH! at 3:11. STG rules!!!

  • They really are great live.

    when I saw them in November, they were super hyped. Carah even jumped off the stage and somebody stole her shoe, HAHAHAHA.

    too bad the audience was a bunch of assholes.

  • great version.

  • shut up syaz

  • oh yeah her accent too!

  • she doesnt really have one. it just sounds like she does when she sings this song.

  • i <3 all of them they're all so hottttt

  • pretty good :D

  • damn shes hot....

  • her and the music

  • my fav band

    i love the song

    and i love her hair!

  • I LOVE EVERYTHING ABOUT THIS BAND!!!

  • i love Carahs hair soooo much!

  • Shiny Toy Guns is my favorite band EVERR !!

    they are amazing live !! & Carah is the hottiest girl i have ever seen in my life ! <3 mmhm. (;

    keep rOckin' ! <3 xoxo

  • i love how Carah owns and puts in her own "spazz" to the song. she has that rele cool accent when she sings, its so COOL!

  • =] most bands when they play live they dont sound rlly well

    but im amazed hopw good they sound when they sing live i love all their songs and carah faye is aweesommeee!!! they r so kool oone of mah fav bands

  • no..you are not the only one

    :D

  • Awesome Performance.Just amazing.

    Oh, and am I the only one who thinks that Mikey Martin is incredibly hot?

  • it's a great song

    <3

  • It's their best song! =)

  • she has a slight accent. it sounds cool!

  • She DOES have an accent and i agree it sounds soo cool!

  • i saw them live sunday. they were be best(out of Starting Line, Coheed and Cambria and Jimmy Eat World) but shes soooo hott and they were so good. the had a weird setup; the drummer was on the far left.

  • Her voice is amazing. They are fantastic live. It just makes me love them more. My favorite band by far.

    <3

  • they really are one of the greatest bands of this generation.....and their live performances are superb

    wow does any1 know what guitar chad has right there he always uses it its freakin tight

  • omg i luv shiny toy guns and it sounds great live.! XD

  • awsome awsome awsome ! great live performance ! i love the way carah moves to the music ! OFFT ! lol

  • I love this video, she sounds even better live!

  • YES! im seeing them 2nite in austin =D

  • my favorite video of them!

  • wow she sounds exactly like the recorded version

  • I'm not much for this band but, when she sings "Now hold onto me pretty baby"

    may be the sexiest thing i've ever heard someone sing. It drives me nuuuuuts

  • her scream at 3:11 is amazing

  • hell yeah!!!

  • This still my favorite live video of Le Disko...ever...kool.

  • Chad plays the geetar different now for this song!!! I love seeing them live, it's a whole another level than the CD!

    :D

  • my favorite band ever! amazing live and on track.

    Good job Shiny Toy Guns.

  • cant wait to c them in hawaii!!!!!

  • Ha ha... People lying to look cool on the internet is awesome

  • its true. why would I lie on the internet? Its not like you get any satisfaction from it if people balive you. I dont care as long as I know its true.

    If you must know it happened at the stone pony in jersey when they apeared with Flogging Molly.

  • You dont care if I believe you, but you give more detail to prove it, even though I didn'tsay that I "must know"

  • What happened?. Just curious that's all.

    Anyway on a musical and artistic level Ladytron are much superior to this lot!.

  • word ahahah

  • she has more of an accent thing than on the album but it is still awesome

  • damn shes hot!!!! i like this song

  • Hey, hey, hey! Fierce or not. Carah Faye=Hottness~~

  • it sounded pretty good..the only issue i have is carah doesn't sound as fierce as she does on the album.

  • OK, everyone getting on her case about her not sounding the same....Get off her back, try singing live all the time, you'll wear out your vocals too. Not to mention, yahoo is notorious for messing up amazing bands due to whatever sound malfunction they have during EVERY performance.

  • ya not very good live... better on album

  • How do you say that? They sound nearly perfect, if you ignore the small things that you can do in a studio and NOT live...

  • sorry...im a new fan to shiny toy guns so i guess i shouldnt be talking... but they're fantastic, period.

  • Hey..it's not your fault. Every band sounds different live or on a CD. Once you see them live it makes the CD sound so much different. That and STG live this year has been one awsome experience. My favorite song live is Chemistry of A Car Crash.

  • i have a girl crush on her.

    she's cool

  • i ello vee ee this song,like seriously

  • i love it when she screams.

    ..i mean...

  • she looks so amazing! so hot

  • horrible mixing

  • i luv shiny toy guns and this performance is probably the best...carah doesn't walk around too much and that part during the chorus when Mikey paused, raised his hand up and then smashed down was totally awesome!!

  • She doesn't sound nearly as good live. She sounds like a completely different person.

  • ohh,and i can't take my eyes off of jeremy

  • i <3 mikey

  • Carah is so hot, and I love this song.

  • Amazing song and performance

    starts with one is the best song on the album tho

  • i have a girl crush on carah and i heart this song.

  • oh my god i have a girl crush on her too! i thought it was only me. shes freaking hot.

  • damn she is fuckin hot

  • i have sweet pics with her...well a sweet pic myspacecom/nick_major

  • shes so damn hot

  • dood i know shes Fineeeee!

  • awesome song

    and i love her hair

  • It's so amazing liiiiveeee.

    My fave song everrrrr.^_^ <333333333333333333333333

  • panicking bout le disko now!

  • OMG She is soooo hott..

    this song kicks ass..

  • i love them!!!i just got their album

  • The album is so amazing!

  • CArAH itss so fucking sexyy

    i lovee her<3333333333333333

    by rene

  • i love this song

    Carah's voice is amazing

  • i'm in love with that voice...i can't hear it enough! i have to watch it again! and again! and AGAIN!!!

  • me2

  • I like this better that the Le Disko Music Video because she has a cooler accent and voice in this version, in the other one you can't hear in also the synths are better and I love that dudes GUITAR!!!

  • haha yeah, i like the dancing too. :P

    stg <33

  • can't wait to see them....i ♥ them

  • Her voice is so fucking sexy omfg :|

  • i agree with raniRAWR, her voice is waaaaaaaaaaay too sexy. especially when shes says "not hold on to me pretty baby". shes ballin outta control in my mind

  • carah is perfect

  • nice music

  • lots of bands do a fake british accent. its not anyhting strange, love this band

  • studio band

  • o0? I love this band in all, but why is she fakeing that acsent? In most of her interviews she just has a lazy voice... no british acsent. It's kinda funny the way she dances, it's like an epilectic sezure and like she has to go to the bathroom at the same time...

  • carahhhhhh is the best.<3

  • Ah, she has such a pretty voice :)

  • She doesn't sound like a boy! ur weird MyDarkBloodTears

  • BTW, that scream that nobody seems to have heard was in the background on their popular Explicit youtube version from 3:03 to 3:04. You hafta listen for it....

  • i love this her voice sounds so pretty.

  • My fava song. I like her Russian accient!=)

  • Great performance live, but the part I liked best about the recorded version is her scream.

    They should program that scream into the synthesizer and lip sync that one sound when playing live. I could handle the teeny bit of fakery :)

  • finally! i'v been looking all over to hear her voice like this... its amazing i love it! and they r all so hott.. looove jeremy =] best keyboardist ever

  • love this one most!!!=)

  • awesome, they rock

  • they are great live, she has a great voice

  • the band is very good! There live performance is good!

  • shes amazing live

    and gorgeous :)