Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (29)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Wow, I never even heard about this. Thanks for the upload, just stumbled across it. Frusciante is one of my fave musicians ever, and JD one of my fave bands, this is a real treat ^^

  • im guessing john is on keyboards because bernard summers would play keyboard after the little guitar intro. but who knows

  • joy division is great..cover is nice.

  • who`s on the keyboards?

  • Love love love it .  Salude

  • did john know josh in 2000? i thought they met after trwfotd

  • i think they have known the other for quite some time...i know he's worked with john on some of his earlier solo albums..i have no idea..awhile though..& I know he's (josh) has worked with the butthole surfers and stuff as well...

  • @DimebagsLeftToe I'm thinking they met in 1999 or maybe even before. Josh was the musical genius behind one of John's friends Bob Forrest's band The Bicycle Thief. They released their only album in 1999, so they could've met before..

  • whoa! So similar to the original

  • They captured Joy Division's vibe on this one!

    This is probably the best Joy Division cover I've heard.

  • @sydbarrett5 this is really good, another good one is by a stone roses tribute band belive it or not there called the complete stone roses and its on youtube and spotify

  • i just started listening to joy division but i really like this song

  • still missing the credits for the keyboard player...want to know...

  • its probably john

  • I think it could be Josh K.

  • no, because josh is playing drums

  • they all are so multi talented, i mean, it's hard to say. i know they all are familiar with many instruments..lol..i'm sorry. i set myself up for dirty thoughts there!

  • either one..is fine in my book. both extremly talented..and not to mention Flea either, right? can't go wrong here! thanks though :-)

  • Yeah, probably. Thanks man! Nice to share this song which I just think it´s great.

  • cool, gotta say john doesnt sound too great vocaly though

  • perhaps he is just trying to emulate the deeper sounds of ian curtis' voice instead of singing in his usual higher ranges.

  • john always sounds great

  • i know what u mean, and usually i couldnt disagree, though i think this one of his only performances i don't think sounds too good vocally

  • do you like Joy Division rhcp27tom? i personally do myself, so being a J.D. fan AND a J.F. fan, I dig the distorted sound(s) But it's cool to read everyone's opinion to see what you guys think as well...so thanks for the reply :) I just love Josh K. as well..he's very talented..

  • I like his vocals here, they're a nice change from "typical John"

  • who's playing the keyboards?

  • josh i think he's amazing

  • @sugarbabydylan it's definitely john. im pretty positive josh is on drums, he plays on drums with john all the time

  • it's definitely john. im pretty positive josh is on drums, he plays on drums with john all the time

  • amazing. where did you get these recordings?

  • just updated the video info

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more