...with the horribly junky sonics it is sort of hard to say what is going on...Kapell was some kind of a natural "Prokofievian"...but he was damn near "natural" anything...
@fredericfranc Old is not the same as junky. For its time this was high quality sound, and the remastering brings out everything that was there. If you care about piano performance, though, the old sound, monaural and all, is totally irrelevant.
@mujerado ...in a recording like this, for elementary scientific and engineering reasons, much musical information is inescabably and inevitably lost...whether this "matters", or how much, is, perhaps a matter of personal "taste"(?), but between the way Mr.K sounded in the actual sonic event and the way he sounds here, yes, there is quite a difference...
Tremendous spiritedness and symbolism packaged into this performance. William Kapell hangs onto every note, never overpowering the orchestra. To me he is the James Dean of piano, too short a life but had a good enough output to keep him in the spotlight of main contenders. Thank you for this excellent set.
The best recording of this concerto I know of; it has been a favourite for many years. Madly electrifying, insanely passionate, yet infernally controlled and structured - as it should be.
WOW thanks!!! This piece was stuck in my head for past week, I could not figure out who was it by.. now i see this video! THANKS AGAIN for great post!
This has been flagged as spam show
The best performance there is:
Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra conducted by Daniele Gatti
Yuja Wang, piano
Sergei Prokofjev: Pianoconcert nr.3 op.26
Concertgebouw Amsterdam
vonde113 4 months ago
he and this piece were the tightest of lovers...
nadejbaptiste 4 months ago
...with the horribly junky sonics it is sort of hard to say what is going on...Kapell was some kind of a natural "Prokofievian"...but he was damn near "natural" anything...
fredericfranc 7 months ago
@fredericfranc Old is not the same as junky. For its time this was high quality sound, and the remastering brings out everything that was there. If you care about piano performance, though, the old sound, monaural and all, is totally irrelevant.
mujerado 2 months ago
@mujerado ...in a recording like this, for elementary scientific and engineering reasons, much musical information is inescabably and inevitably lost...whether this "matters", or how much, is, perhaps a matter of personal "taste"(?), but between the way Mr.K sounded in the actual sonic event and the way he sounds here, yes, there is quite a difference...
fredericfranc 2 months ago
I beg your pardon, you said C major? :)
animumaurarium 1 year ago
The orchestra is not very good.
a6282 1 year ago
Still the finest performance of this piece on record.
jdmiller71201 1 year ago
Tremendous spiritedness and symbolism packaged into this performance. William Kapell hangs onto every note, never overpowering the orchestra. To me he is the James Dean of piano, too short a life but had a good enough output to keep him in the spotlight of main contenders. Thank you for this excellent set.
tHEnOOSEsWING 3 years ago
Thanks for posting, this pianist makes a lasting impression, love it.
suzettegm 3 years ago
The best recording of this concerto I know of; it has been a favourite for many years. Madly electrifying, insanely passionate, yet infernally controlled and structured - as it should be.
ManlioGiordano 3 years ago
This is a great post of a great composition. Thanks for the post. It's this kind of post of yours that made me subscribe to you in the first place.
gerryrains 3 years ago
WOW thanks!!! This piece was stuck in my head for past week, I could not figure out who was it by.. now i see this video! THANKS AGAIN for great post!
NoxNoctisUmbra 3 years ago
powerful ,outstanding and very very impressive
tkdoliver 3 years ago