Added: 2 years ago
From: RussiaToday
Views: 204,871
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (6,105)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Here you have the ancient situation of good jews, and the bad jews.

    Too bad one had always to suffer from the consequences the other evoked.

    Finkelstein is an amazing character. A splendid upright person.

    As a German, I would LOVE to have him with my people. Heck I would be even proud if he would be family. He, and Chomsky are the most sympathetic people I can imagine to be with.

  • I've yet to see anyone stand up against Dr. Finkelstein's FACTS!

  • Norman Finkelstein speaks the truth.

  • The middle east is in a mess

    It would have helped if the Palestinians would have said yes to a state of their own in 1948.

    I know they disliked Israel

    but......

    it would have helped.

  • Norman Finkelstein is full of shit. Both sides israel and arabs have their faults, but Norman Finkelstein seems to see only one side of fault.

  • @sokolel

    why don't you point out the faults of both sides

    these are Dr Norman finklesteins qualifications

    Binghamton University (B.A.)

    Princeton University (M.A.)

    Princeton University (Ph.D.)

    what in the fuck do you know dear illiterate scum bag

  • @sokolel he does not. AIM is right.

    Finkelstein does what he does, because their is a disproportional amount of influence and conciousness. Palestinias rights become violated on a daily rate, they also die daily - noone hardly recognises. If jews were to die in the same conditions, or even got a croached glance, countries would become uprooted and trialed, medias would be filled, films would get produced, lies and propaganda spread, masses brainwashed. Within days it would be paid back 20 times

  • @000000AEA000000

    Yeah u are right, now are dying more palestinians than jews, But if you speak of everyday hatred, discrimination and racist idoctrination arabs beat jews hands down. By the way, ask arabs where are their women. If you ask of breaking walls of separation, then ask arabs why they don't permit their women to marry non-muslims.

  • By Raanan Gissins logic...indians could claim entire USA as their land..because they lived there and their culture and holy scripture claims it.

  • If jews came with the peaceful intention to "live side by side with the palestinians" then why did Israel annex east jerusalem?

  • I am by no means a zionist but I feel sympathy for the zionist guy. I know what he is talking about. Everybody in the world is doing war crimes, and Israeli neighbors would do it no less than Israel. It's just a rough region. The first one who started acting nicely and dropped arms would be annihilated. As simple as that.

  • @ididete its all because the muslims hate jews and want them dead. its nothing to do with israel or any of that shit. if it was up to the jews they would just sit in israel and live. but the arabs will never let israel exist, so they have no choice but to fight for their lives

  • @mikesomething Not entirely. The problem is -- everyone is against everyone in the world and there is no such thing as a true notion of international community. There are only particular states fighting for their private interests. And that goes especially for the big players on the international scene, NATO and the UN-- they do no more than promote the interests of their most powerful states - members.

  • @mikesomething actually arabs and jews lived side by side for centuries...but after the holocaust the jews decided to annex east jerusalem and claim the entire city as theirs.

    Dont watch FOX BBC news so much :D

  • @syntaxed2 half my family is muslim, i know exactly what they think of jews. i dont get it from your news

  • @mikesomething and half my family is jewish :D

    They want to steal the land from the arabs.

  • @syntaxed2 lying fuck, your a white cunt who never been out of the states

  • @ididete What are you talking about? Two wrongs don't make a right. Jew's are evil.

  • Comment removed

  • so this zionist is citing his grandfather and thousand year old claims he read in his bible to legitimise israel's presence in palestine? do they not see the ludicrous, illogical nature of their claims? he's so evasive and uses ignorance and slander to win the argument - yeah, maybe on planet zion.

  • No matter how much anti-Jewish propaganda there is they will never Defeat Israel because the our Creator will never allow another holocaust from past anti-Jewish Propaganda.

  • @satancreatedallah

    i agree that the host is biased a bit, but you can't deny finkelstein's arguments. it's not propaganda, it's common sense

  • May Yahweh Bless Israel.

  • timewilltell7 ...  I'm afraid you need to do your home work....or rather you are getting it from the wrong school. Being duped by Zionist. Oh, I can assure you I'm not annoying at all. Indeed, I find most others this way. I do not find you if you are pondering. An open mind and heart who is getting misinfo. it happens but we must try to go around them. Though it can be very hard at times with some informatin such as in your case of believing nazi [Germany] owns the EU. Search more; wake up!

  • Gissen: "You come to Israel...you see Arabs who have freedom of speech more than they have in their own respective countries"

    What the hell?...that is their respective country!

  • @meeter he meant Arabs living in Israel have more rights than Arabs living in respective Arab countries. I know it was awkwardly worded.

  • @meeter this is the typical nonsense you jews keep spouting everytime you get the chance, people dont even dare to come out their houses, what freedom are you talking about? You fucking terrorists, we know jews invented terrorisme you fucking cunt

  • @5jama Are you on crack?! The words I wrote were a QUOTE from the speaker from this video, THEY ARE NOT MY WORDS and if you knew how to fucking read you would understand that i was pointing out how ridiculous he is I wasn't supporting him. Next, I'm not Jewish, but Mr. Finkelstein (among many Jews who defend the Palestinians) so fuck off with your racism and stupidity.

  • @meeter fuck you how am I supposed to know, what you meant? fucking retard, then dont use ridicilous quotes like that if you dont meant it..I'm not racist but to jew zionists and to dumbasses like u I could be.

  • @5jama Excuse me?!! I clearly wrote his name and then quoted from him. How can you not see that? I think it's pretty clear here that I'm not retarded and I think you're embarassed because you made a mistake.

  • @meeter Well its obvious I made a mistake, but I dont know anyone named Gissen, so thats why I didn't see it,,

  • @5jama Everyone makes mistakes but you don't have to be rude or swear at people. I mean I make mistakes all the time, and I just acknowledge it and move on and I don't take it out on others because that's not fair. Norman Finkelstein would just tell you to be civil and courteous if you didn't understand. I think he sets a good example.

  • Wowza. It was hardly worth Finklestein saying a word to discredit the Israeli's viewpoint - just allow him to speak and he'll do it himself

  • @DavidByrne85 Exactly, we have to face this twisted logic everyday.

  • Comment removed

  • Dr. Finklestein, is really one of the only few people in NY is that are exposing the the colors of the those Criminal jews in the middle east

  • @5jama Actually, Dr Finklestein is the most hypocritical Jew with regards to this issue, he uses the statement on international law to demonize Israel but he refuses to come to terms with the fact that Goldstone himself discredits his own commission's findings. Moreover, he gives carte blanche to the Palestinians to continue terrorist activities and does not merit the provocation of war through acts of terror.

  • @Yaronthegreat He doesn't use it but its just true, why re talking to me? go and complain to him,,I agree with him,, the zionist regime really are demons. Israel is a real terrorists state that needs to be wiped off clean from the world map...the only good jew is one that distances himself from it. the jews are the scum of the earth, in every way possible..

  • The first man who,having fenced in a piece of land,said "This is mine,"and found people naïve enough to believe him,that man was the true founder of civil society.From how many crimes,wars,and murders,from how many horrors and misfortunes might not any one have saved mankind,by pulling up the stakes,or filling up the ditch,and crying to his fellows:Beware of listening to this impostor;you are undone if you once forget that the fruits of the earth belong to us all,and the earth itself to nobody

  • Science is hard to defeat!

  • Only 6000 homes were destroyed in Gaza? The British destroyed 10 cities in Germany in WWII and no one complains, Why ? Because the Nazis were the perpetrators, Not the Allies!

  • Finkelstein:

    Muhammad admitted that Israel IS the land of the Jews and that the Jews have a right to live in their own land besides the fact that Islam was created in the 7 century!

  • Finkelstein speaks very slowly because of the effect of Excessive smoking of Marlhuana. LSD has affected his braincells in a massive way. Lunatic state HA HA HA

  • @Carl9449 you don't really have a point. 

  • This Israeli guy can't catch his breath trying to defend a wrong. How pathetic !!! It would be so much better to admit to a fucked up massacre. Even to a mundane wrong, the first step to any sickness is to admit to a wrong. This Wissle guy says that Norman had already made up his mind. On the contrary, it was the Weaselman . Norman had put forth facts, but this guy from Israel was talking about his promised land & Normans' answer was so right on that the wheezle could not answer.

  • Finkelstein: 1 Israël: 0

  • i think we can all agree, all sides, that the hatred between everyone is getting exhausting and people have started to reject this orchestrated religious hatred and start chillling

    its such a huge conspiracy against mankind our eyes are wide shut

    we are all one and the same and we think because of their imposed system that the "muslims" are going to get bombed in iran - there is no such thing as a muslim or jew - they're just words

    what we need to do is learn to let go of history

  • @tikkunolam613 So true. No wonder these brainless idiots mark you as spam.

  • ZIONIST PEOPLE (PIGS) HATE YOU........

    PROUD PEOPLE RESPECT AND ARE ON YOUR SIDE.

  • "...except when you cross certain red lines that put at jeopardy the very existence of your own people." That comment wreaks of Kosher pig scrotums.

  • Finkelstein, the Zionist Assassin.

  • @AmeroRockStar the truth hurts eh?!

  • boy check out the zionazi comments on here!

  • That is one crazy Israeli

  • finkelstien got owned

  • @worldbattle39

    yes, you are right. Hopefully he will soon will "get owned" by Mossad as well :)) LOL

  • @ZionIsInMyHeart i wouldnt be suprised they are bastards.

  • @worldbattle39 what were you watching?

  • Ranaan Gissin is a self-deluding, hysterical liar.

  • GISSIN; his general disposition would not seem out of place coming from a Nazi sympathiser......and to think that he is the best Israel can do in providing a spokesman....disgraceful

  • Traitor to his cuntry

  • every time you accuse Jews of something current, they always bring up the past like the Holocaust. Do they not understand that Hitler is dead?? We are not Hitler, yet they talk to us as if we are

  • @lelo819

    ..Everyone seeking the destruction of the jewish state and thus, as a consequence of this, the destruction of the jews as a nation/people ....and everyone who supports our sworn enemies, who stop at nothing (including slaughtering unarmed Israeli men, like in the Ramallah incident or slaughtering whole settler families including their babies - e.g. Fogel family) is like Hitler, is Hitler and is even worse thatn Hitler. Because in modern times, they do this in disguise of "scholars".

  • To me it seems ridiculous that Israeli academics and politicians still cling to the 'historical narrative' argument, claiming historical RIGHTS to a land according to what was written in the Bible, a piece of literature which suffered processes of editing and censorship like all others. Colonialism is a dangerous thing...

  • zionism=nazism

    Pissrael sucks!!!!!

  • I, may be an atheist. but if there ever was a god, this man, Dr.Finkelstein is, and has to be the man of god.

  • There naever has been a "Palestinian" people and they will never wxist. They are immigrants from Egypt and Syria and can go home if they don't like it in Israel. and Finkestein can commit "suicide against Israel"...what a fucked up self-hating twat

  • @ZionIsInMyHeart ; You're a racist bigot...what a diswgrace you are to your Jewish heritage....shalom

  • @Chirostenotes

    Not really. Finkelswine is a disgrace to the jewish heritage specifically and all mankind in general. On the one hand, he claims that Hams is a legitimate government, because they were elected by the "Palestinian" people. On the other hand, he calls Israel's government "terrorists" and "illiegitimate". The government of Israel was elected by the Israeli people. So in what way is it different from Hamas in his perverted logic? It is simple: he hates Israel and jews. He is a liar.

  • @ZionIsInMyHeart Hey ZIMH, I have a question,who said besides yourselves that the land of Israel belongs to you?

  • @vascone315

    Our history is clear, no need to try to falsify it ;) the "Palestinians2 migrated to this are anolgside the first jewish settler in the beginning of 19th century.....they are, in fact, Egyptians and Syrians...the Balfour Declaration of 1928, which is international law, provided the legal basis for the State of Israel. What is called "Jordan" today, was supposed to become the muslim part of the British mandete of "Palestine". but the arabs were not contented with this....

  • @ZionIsInMyHeart Zionism is in your heart my friend, but is it in your head? :)

    I think the Balfour Declaration you refer too was in 1917, is it not? I'm going for the answer that Zionists give way more that this mistimed reason you just gave. Let me re-ask the question of I may? WHO declared this ;land yours, in ancient times as I hear so often. For e record, I am Christian, a leaf from the same branch. The floor is yours my friend.

  • @vascone315

    Yes....correct, it was made in 1917. But it has serious amendments made to it in later years, esp. in 1928 (which was even better then the original text) and then afterwards, in 1937, the tragic decisions of the Peele Commission. They actually gave our land to the arabs, this what was called "Transjordan" back then and is the Kingdom of Jordan now...well, the British gave then land to us, easy. As they gave Egypt to the arabs or the French gave Algeria....

  • @vascone315

    Muslims own 66 countries worldwide (including the terrorist rogue state of Kosovo)...many of these were artificially created after the end of colonialism and are big...Sudan, Algeria, Pakistan...all artificial countries, uniting different tribes and old kingdoms. So, what is the problem with us having a state made out of colonial mandate land? We own only this tiny stripe of land and the arabs are still not happy, they want the next piece of it.

  • @vascone315

    3. The case of Kosovo is a dangerous precedent, as the gypsies in Gaza might decide to declare a state of their own as well. Why did no one stand up to help the Serbs, who were systematically raped, murdered and brutalized by the albanian muslim invaders? Europe even bombed a Christian country in the heart of Europe to save....muslim terrorists and their offspring. So they are not the ones who will preach morals to Israel. They are the bitches of the arab terrorist petrodollar.

  • @ZionIsInMyHeart Points taken and understood, But you refer to it as "our" land.. as in the Peele Commission statement... as it stands today, Israel was inhabited by these different Arab cultures for centuries until It was 'gifted" after colonization by an empire who basically didn't have historical right to claim ownership in the first place. I go back to my original question, Who (?) Instilled the notion it was land Land strictly for Jews in the first place?

  • @vascone315 Historically and even Now, I hear argument over and over again that "GOD" awarded and gifted this land to them (us) Millennia ago, after all, that is what the claim to the land of Israel actually boils down to, doesn't it my brother/sister?

  • @vascone315

    Not only G-d gave the land to us, but the Balfour declaration of 1917 did. ;) and this is internaional law.

  • @ZionIsInMyHeart The 'Balfour Declaration' and the British Mandate in Palestine which ensued did not correspond to 'international law'. They were measures undertaken by British colonialists over the heads of the indigenous people of Palestine, the Palestinians.

  • @ZionIsInMyHeart One more thing my brother, I see you cite "International Law", Is it Not also "International law" that settlements are not to be built and indigenous people are not to be driven from their existing homes such as in gaza? Is it not also International law to sign the Non Proliferation act? Im NOT saying you directly, but It's that kind of double speak, that CREATES antisemitism and endangers peaceful Jews around the world imo.. ( I'm actually enjoying this discussion, so far..)

  • @vascone315

    No, in the case of Gaza it is clear. We withdrew from there in 2000, and these idiots started firing rockets. My city Sderot was under constant attack for more tha eight years, so was Ashqelon and also BeerSheva. Which country in the world would tolerate such terrorism? I might also bring to your attention, that Israel is in fact an antijewish state....it has demolished settlements and demolished even synagogues. The arabs have no right to complain, they started the hostility.

  • Comment removed

  • @ZionIsInMyHeart I also find it ironic you call people who have remained in their land since their existence began, Gypsies, Vs Jewish, who wander and settle all over the world......

  • @vascone315

    I call them gypsies due to their physical appearnce. My family is of Austrian/Slovenian herigate, we are blond and blue-eyed. And ask yourself why my ancestors had to wander and settle all over the world...because they were persecuted and oppressed. Now, that we finally have reestablished our state after 2000 years of diaspora existence, people like you want to tell me, that it is a good thing to give our land away to radical muslim terrorists....this is not going to happen...

  • @ZionIsInMyHeart Are you saying that in 2000 years your ancestors transformed from the dark skinned dark eyed indigenous Semitic people who actually originated in that area? ( therefore making them the original owners)... But Ok, God gave the original Israelite's this land, on the premise they keep with his covenant and obey all his laws,and commandments, correct? They would 4ever be his chosen people, Correct?

  • @vascone315

    I am happy that I don't look like an arab. btw there are many other Israelis who look like me.although about 60-70% of Israelis are rather dark,not to speak of the Ethiopians, who are Africans..so the answer to your question is yes.Dark-skinned people can turn into blue-eyed noridc people within 3-4 generations ;) Look at the West Indian Islands, you find black people with blue eyes and blond hair over there.Still, they have black ancestry, the same way i have semitic blood in me.

  • @ZionIsInMyHeart #2, God himself intervened during the wars of Joshua, Jericho, reigned stones upon the kings of Canaan, Made the sun and moon stand still for the Israelite s (Its in the bible), He must have thought Joshua's people a worthy recipient of the land then, So then tell me why he allowed the Romans, and Assyrians to conquer the Jews in 721? Where was he then? Where was God during the Holocaust? I believe our elders, blew their chance, angered him and are No Longer "The Chosen Ones'

  • @vascone315

    I am Christian, as I said earlier. I don't believe in the teachings of Judaism, my ancestors were lucky to embrace Jesus Christ. Most Slovenian "jews" are nowadays deeply religious Catholics, this is our distinct cultural heritage, which we took to Israel. I never thought of myself as being "chosen" or "superior" to anybody.Even when I was in the IDF I have not a single time felt superior to the arabs..they however were throwing stones and using oscene language, not the soldiers.

  • @Chirostenotes

    2/ "Hamas", not "Hams"....oh, and I may add that he called the terrorists from Hezbollah (=Pissbolla) "Heroes" and finds their attacks on Israeli cities & civilian targets pretty much justified and okay ;))) Finkelswine even went to Tehran to kiss the arse of his muslim buddy Mahmood AhmadiJIHAD and to plan the destruction of Israel and his own blood together with the lunativc Mullah regime. Such a man can in no shape or form preach morals to anyone. He himself is a terrorist.

  • @ZionIsInMyHeart palestinian are syrians and egyptians???man you gotta be kidding..palistinians are the real owner of their land and they always lived there..once they were jews then the majority converted to christianity and then to islam..if you are a"natural"jew then they are your relatives..

    and we all know that your ambition is( from nile to euphrates)state..what would you say if you'd have it??that the original ppulation are immigrants from libya and turkey and they should go back???

  • 22:07 Villians? I wonder when these old hags will realise the truth like some of their children.

  • its not Israel its Occupied Palestine and we will get our Palestine back and kick this fake country ( Israel ) OUT ...... sooner or later

  • KLING KLING KLING......AAAAAND THE WINNER iiiiiiiis ......wait4it.......Norman Finkelstein

  • At this point Norman Finkelstein is just on autopilot. He's been dealing with Israel apologists for so long, and it's always the same nonsense.

  • Norman Finkelstein is a hero

  • See how the Isreal gets so angry also i beleive one of their tactiks when they know they are wrong is to laugh it off.

  • Dr Finkilesteni, God bless you. Please take good care. I would be devisted if anything happens to you, God forbid. May God bless you strenght and wisdom. rgds,

  • the guy on the right was overly defensive and reaching lol ... while norman was calm, clear and concise with 'facts'

  • Zionist are decieving which cock doesn't know that?

  • Zionists are killers and liars.

  • Why is the other guy laughing? Can't take him seriously

  • The fact that most of Dr Finkelstein's opponent's arguments are ad hominem or responses to Finkelstein's tone and he barely makes arguments, but goes in a loud rant over his grandfather's Bible and rifle.

  • rotten apples exist elsewhere why Jews be the exception ?

    finkelstein a sore jobless loser

    trying to make some money the only way he knows

  • at 25:00 He pretty much had a heart attack rofl

  • Q: "if i came with a bible in hand to your home, and knocked on your door, and said according to my bible, my family lived where your home is 2,000 years ago, would you pack your bags and leave?"

    A: 3,000...3,000!

  • @PersecutedCitizen even worse lol, less recent so more irrelevant xD

  • @PersecutedCitizen love it

  • sehionism orZIONISEM must die

  • this guy from telaviv is on some kind of drug

  • he burned him at 7:23

    Totally Burned Him and spoke the truth to do so

  • Comment removed

  • Israelis and/or Zionists perpetuate pure myth repeating it over and over, although Finkelstein has all the Aces in his hands, which is normal, it is absolutely futile and in vain because you are confronting myths and self-delusion not a facts and reason !

  • This Israeli spokesman is not "formidable", he's a joke and a lame one too!

    Keep going Dr. Finkelstein, teach the world, maybe one day it will wake up from its coma.

  • Alan Dershowitz is a fuckwit

  • wow 99 Israelis watched this video

  • In comparison to Israel, the third reich looks very moderate

  • just live with it. israel is a given nation

  • Comment removed

  • Venus Project only solution

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Dr. Bushy Brows is hilarious, although, quite scary at the same time.

  • @kileer7 Don't worry, his bark is worse than his bite. Notice how all he has are intimidation tactics (raising his voice like a spoiled child, throwing ad hominem attacks, repeated phrases and empty assertions). Not a single eloqeutly reasoned argument. Can't even focus on the topic. What a buffoon.

  • Norman Rockkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkks !!!! <3

  • @zionforreal Firstly, I suspect you are a troll. I do not believe any sane person would make the comments you have made, referring to Arabs as 'sub human'. If you are a troll, stop. It is a cheap and unfair way of engaging in debate. If you want to criticize Israel, state the facts.

    - Israel imprisons 1.5 million people in the Gaza strip.

    - Israel is the biggest importer of weapons in the middle east.

    - Israel is an imperialist, expansionist state.

    - Israel prefers expansion over peace.

  • He's hysterical and unable to have a serious discussion, it's also very obvious that he's lying.

  • I don't blame Israel, i blame Britain and the U.S, they were the one's who funded Israel and made it what it is. What elses are you going to learn from tw of the most evil empires in the world.

  • Basically the Israeli argument was that Finkelstein was parroting hate speech and that he denies the holocaust. I mean, seriously?

  • @fabioeoch When did he say he denies the Holocaust? Watch ''American Radical'' the documentary, to get a different outlook.

  • I think Isreal started this problem between shia and sunni jst to intervene and use it as an excuse

  • @MaanIfly1 as a muslim i can tell u that you are 100% correct they divide and conquer. not just with muslims but with christians s well. watch dr david duke on youtube called zionism how they divide and conquer.that will teach you much much more

  • u are an amazing person Dr. Finkelstein , may u prove Israel wrong with all their inhuman actions

  • Comment removed

  • not sure if i buy into all this "zionist" mumbo jumbo, but still huge respect mr. finkelstein for critiquing while maintaining composure and an empirical outlook.

  • Docotor Finkilesteni much respect to you. You are one Jew that i can call god chosen people without sarcasm. MUcxh MUch respect to you. THe zionist fear you!

  • @MrMrRiip my respect for Norman Finkilesten displays more courage then a 1000 lying zionists put together!

    YOU ARE THE MAN< NORMAN

  • @MrMrRiip ya wallah me too I really apreciate Dr Normans concern for Arabic countrys

    Im really proud and Honored to Have an American stand with Palestinian army

  • @MrMohammedabuali hes actually Jewish  :D

  • that israeli is in such complete denial that it's depressing, he is completely self-brainwashed

  • Norman Finkelstein got soooo 0wned... Dr Geseen is way too goood.. he is definitely the mosre smarter and confident one

  • OMG Seriously why are people even supporting arabs and muslims??? they're the worst people in the world!!

  • @ZIONFORREAL The worst people in the world, are the people who are breaking the laws.. And of course Isreal break all the laws and killing many children and crushing thier houseswhile Isreal drink and partying .. Palestian fight with rocks while Isreal using the best weapons . Isreal lives in high lexuray houses while they crush phelistinian houses. Isreals are greating thier familes while they are taking other families lifes . And now tell me who is the worst people in the world?

  • Guys, don't listen to norman finkelstein. We need to look at the bigger picture. First of all ... these people that the israelis are dealing with are the worst people on the planet. Their arabs aka muslims. These people are the most barbaric and hated people in the world! They do not share our values, our culture and our way of life. They do not advocate freedom of speech. Israel is doing the best it can with these sub humans

  • @ZIONFORREAL "sub humans"... Arabs descent from the prophet Abraham (peace be upon him) through Ishmael (peace be upon him). Almighty God praises Ishmael's offspring in the Old Testament. Where is it written that God praises fx the aryan and roman race in the same manner, since arabs are sub humans and they aren't? "Arabs are the worst people on the planet"? - It's not the palestinians who have broken international laws, killed dozens of civilians and tried to starve a whole people to death.