Really, really, really cool. This version swings, and the pitch is lower, sounding right out of the late 50's (rockabiliy/skiffle, Everly Bros/Buddy Holly influenced). The sound they played a major role in inventing hadn't arrived yet.
I used to listen to this alot when I was younger. I could never figure out the lyrics in the chorus. Does anyone have their own interpretation? Especially that last line. I think it goes:
WHOA! at the end their playing Red Hot by Robert Johnson. Great stuff, hard to make out but you can hear "My girl is red hot" and "I gotta girl shes long and tall, sleeps in the kitchen with her feets in the hall"
@TheBeatlesShop Saw them in Hamburg, Germany in 1962 while I was in the U.S. Navy. Then again in Liverpool in 1963, when my ship took President Kennedy's helicoptors over there when he spoke at the Berlin Wall. By the way...my last name is McCartney. Same first name as Paul's brother. Middle initial P. Pauls real first name is James. My Dad and brothers middle name is James. I'm left handed. Play guitar right handed though. Go figure. :D)
I agree, if its not Paul, it could have been. But the Driving rythem guitar is typical of John on his Ricky and the lead has the very tentative notes of George.
Folks...this is actually the Beatles playing around 1960! This song is actually heard briefly on the first episode of the Beatles Anthology and the one that follows also.
I am neither agreeing nor disagreeing with you, but how do you know it's false. What research did you do? At least give us some info about your ahem..."insight" into this song's origins. Step up to the plate. Don't just swing you bat around like a witless monkey.
Awesome. It manifests raw natural songwriting and vocal talents. Even the melody of the dropped bridge is a natural fit. It was a good day looking through the lace curtains on Forthlin Road..
Actually, the original is by Billy Emerson. This arrangement of the song was first recorded by Billy Lee Riley & his Little Green Men in 1957 with Jerry Lee Lewis on piano.
As a Beatles fan I loved it. Never had heard it before. However I like the final known version much better. We can clearly see how fast they developed as musicians and also how important George Martin was for this development.
I think they should have kept the original bridge though, I like the message it brings to the context of the song, which is one of my fav.
way cool... Lennon always gets the nod for being the poet (and yes, he was for sure) but McCartney was there as well in the best tradition of the surrealist poets... his songs like fixing a hole, junk, et al are in a league with cats like Duncan, Bly, Thomas and Gascoyne...Surrealism as international Modernism will always out last the superficial... but having said all that, good rock and roll just feels fucking good... so i'll follow the sun...
it's no the Beatles! it's a new tape of early years.
Carlettyno 1 year ago
it's no the Beatles! it's a new tape of early years.
Carlettyno 1 year ago
Si sente da lontano che questa è una bufala, è solo una nuova registrazione fatta adesso da qualcun altro e di scarsa qualità audio.
Carlettyno 1 year ago
kewl
luvumo2day 2 years ago
Great early version!
jgentleman07 2 years ago
Really, really, really cool. This version swings, and the pitch is lower, sounding right out of the late 50's (rockabiliy/skiffle, Everly Bros/Buddy Holly influenced). The sound they played a major role in inventing hadn't arrived yet.
jgentleman07 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this sucks!!!!!!!!!!!!
kike0190 2 years ago
I used to listen to this alot when I was younger. I could never figure out the lyrics in the chorus. Does anyone have their own interpretation? Especially that last line. I think it goes:
Don't leave me alone my dear
have courage
and ["blank"...sounds like follow me my dear.]
dodeka 2 years ago
WHOA! at the end their playing Red Hot by Robert Johnson. Great stuff, hard to make out but you can hear "My girl is red hot" and "I gotta girl shes long and tall, sleeps in the kitchen with her feets in the hall"
Laughingman120 2 years ago
Paul wrote this song when he was 16 years old.....Do your homework before you post shite
bushkini 2 years ago 4
This was one of the first songs written by John and Paul. Please listen and watch my version in my Video Response.
:) Eric
STUDIOCHINCHAN 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this aint the beatles. paul mccartney has a much softer voice than that
shanenorberg 2 years ago
shitty quality, who knows
Steezie430 2 years ago
I agreed at first, but I heard some paul at
0:52. I couldn't even detect an accent.
smillar98 2 years ago
The Quarrymen (Lennon, McCartney, Harrison, Sutcliffe, with M.McCartney) May 1960. Paul's house!
Outstanding!
TheBeatlesShop 3 years ago 13
omg! I can't believe someone else actually knows their beatles background! this makes me smile.
xxxsweettartxxx 2 years ago
@TheBeatlesShop Saw them in Hamburg, Germany in 1962 while I was in the U.S. Navy. Then again in Liverpool in 1963, when my ship took President Kennedy's helicoptors over there when he spoke at the Berlin Wall. By the way...my last name is McCartney. Same first name as Paul's brother. Middle initial P. Pauls real first name is James. My Dad and brothers middle name is James. I'm left handed. Play guitar right handed though. Go figure. :D)
mpm111144 1 year ago 2
@mpm111144 Wow. That's great to hear. Lots of history. And all your family names!!
TheBeatlesShop 1 year ago
Definitely either Paul McCartney singing or the best impersonator I've ever heard.
unemployedfreak 3 years ago 11
And then John near the end?!
unemployedfreak 3 years ago 2
I agree, if its not Paul, it could have been. But the Driving rythem guitar is typical of John on his Ricky and the lead has the very tentative notes of George.
bgaudet3 3 years ago 3
Folks...this is actually the Beatles playing around 1960! This song is actually heard briefly on the first episode of the Beatles Anthology and the one that follows also.
madmanduck 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is not the beatles playing or singing.
rockshow21 3 years ago
It is....0:35-0:37 is heard on the Anthology series when they talk about the early recordings.
madmanduck 3 years ago
yes it is
BeatlesManiac45 3 years ago
well maybe it is.
lee8552 3 years ago
this isn't the beatles playing lol. its not a bad cover though...
lee8552 3 years ago
It is. This version is briefly heard on the Anthology series.
madmanduck 3 years ago 2
yes it is!!
BeatlesManiac45 3 years ago
I prefer this version.
LadyCayenne 3 years ago
It´s a real version, isn´t it????
thelmasss 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
THIS IS FALSE !!!
joseluisyago 3 years ago
I am neither agreeing nor disagreeing with you, but how do you know it's false. What research did you do? At least give us some info about your ahem..."insight" into this song's origins. Step up to the plate. Don't just swing you bat around like a witless monkey.
saltysalty67 3 years ago
no it is not this was a quarrymen rehearsal in liverpool. Some people think it was in hamburg but it was not
beatlefannumber1 3 years ago
Awesome. It manifests raw natural songwriting and vocal talents. Even the melody of the dropped bridge is a natural fit. It was a good day looking through the lace curtains on Forthlin Road..
dlawrick 3 years ago 2
ahh whats the name of the song after "i'll follow the sun"??
beatlesgirlyy6828 3 years ago
My Girl Is Red Hot. It's a cover. Original song by Ronnie Hawkins & The Hawks, 1959.
bigstripeydave 3 years ago
thank yoou! :]
beatlesgirlyy6828 3 years ago
Actually, the original is by Billy Emerson. This arrangement of the song was first recorded by Billy Lee Riley & his Little Green Men in 1957 with Jerry Lee Lewis on piano.
Lefthandbadass 3 years ago
bullshit much? lol
punkvictim 3 years ago
TERRIBLE. I'm glad they grew as musicians and polished that song into the jewel it is in the final version.
wwooddaaddyy 3 years ago
is this actually when the band were the beatles? or was it by the quarrymen? or the silver beetles?
whitedwarf13 4 years ago
I LIKE THIS ONE BETTER THEN THE NEWER 1!
BeatlesManiac45 4 years ago
I LOVE THIS SONG
BeatlesManiac45 4 years ago
omg how old were they?!
BeatlesManiac45 4 years ago
As a Beatles fan I loved it. Never had heard it before. However I like the final known version much better. We can clearly see how fast they developed as musicians and also how important George Martin was for this development.
I think they should have kept the original bridge though, I like the message it brings to the context of the song, which is one of my fav.
dsmar 4 years ago
wow thats amazing how old were they then?
JudLFC 4 years ago
This one appears to be another song where the bridge was supplied by Lennon. The bridge here is not the ...and now the time has gone...bit.
powergirl901 4 years ago
"Well don't leave me alone"
"Have courage and follow me my dear"
The original bridge didn't even rhyme.
IDLERACER 4 years ago
i met my partner in lennons bar in mathew st
050558B 4 years ago
LOVE IT! A wonderful example of a great Beatle song in its infancy.
Thank you so much!
Yose909 4 years ago 6
coool! thanx for sharing
santasxgirlfriend 4 years ago 2
That was great...baby Beatles cutting their teeth!
Pealsi 4 years ago
way cool... Lennon always gets the nod for being the poet (and yes, he was for sure) but McCartney was there as well in the best tradition of the surrealist poets... his songs like fixing a hole, junk, et al are in a league with cats like Duncan, Bly, Thomas and Gascoyne...Surrealism as international Modernism will always out last the superficial... but having said all that, good rock and roll just feels fucking good... so i'll follow the sun...
metricfoot 4 years ago 2
I'm so happy that I can listen to this song today.
Thank you very, very much!
kikansya2004 4 years ago
Thanks, and thanks for the info too!.
Crisstti 4 years ago
It's better than the version they actually made.
GingerGilligan 4 years ago
oh, come on ginger.
jx14aby 4 years ago
So bad it's good?
GingerGilligan 4 years ago
Love these tapes, really do. Signs of what was to come with this song ( somewhere! )
Joshua12345 5 years ago
thanks beatlejim64
lenmacharstar 5 years ago
Recorded in Macca's living room in April of 1960...
John Lennon...Paul McCartney...George Harrison..and
Stuart Sutcliffe. The baging you hear is Pau;s younger brother Mike...NOT Pete Best. He didn't join until August
of 1960...
"Red Hot"...The Beatles(with Ringo) taped New Years Eve
of 1962 at The Star Club in Hamburg Germany!
beatlejim64 5 years ago
I've got Mikes Album
ometec 2 years ago