@siegeartifact I saw them for the Fragile tour in St. Louis at an outdoor arena. APC opened, right in the middle of Judith a giant storm we had all been watching roll in just opened on is all.
Basic seating was in the open on grass (quickly mud) and the pricey seats were covered.
I've never seen a more compassionate fan base in my life. As soon as the rain hit, the pricey seaters let the cheap seaters share the cover. Trent actually praised the audience and vowed to play as long as we were comf
Robin's vocals are amazing at the end! I guess after years of NIN boot camp and touring as well as his little bout with G'n'R, that dude has some serious vocal chops. As well as guitar, synth and style points... I see why Trent wanted him back.
wow...to the earlier comment about Timebomb...I have much respect for Sully Erna, but the verse of Timebomb is a near flagrant rip-off...even the vocal inflection...also to the earlier comment about Last v. Timebomb...Last in my opinion is clearly heavier, was written first, and clearly better
It's really sad that what's needed these days for crowd to move is tits and drugs. People should kinda wake up a little. Or a little more than that. I mean, isn't tits all over the internet already enough? This is art ffs... even tits should be only in the context of art, only. Listen to the lyrics and enjoy the music...
Crowd getting old is a lame excuse. I've seen Bad Religion and Slayer in the last few months and their pits were some of the best I've been in for years, people were going bonkers.
@Idkfawin32 You must've misunderstood me. I'm A HUGE NIN fan and I can listen to the songs for hours and hours on end. All I'm saying is that when you have a band that's been around for a relatively long time, long enough for its initial audience to age considerably, it's normal for that audience not to behave the same way they did 20 years ago. Does not moshing, not throwing stuff around and not flailing your extremities like a hummingbird on crack constitute a boring person in your opinion?
HEY!! PROOF, REAL PERFORMING ARTISTS EXIST!!!!! THIS SONG SOUNDS BETTER IN QUALITY AND ROCK STANDARD NOW MORE THAN THEN........ LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, OUR NAILS ARE HAMMERING ON....
this is awesome, my dad saw these guys on the pretty hate machine tour when he was stationed in japan in the late 80's and i got to see em in 2008 when i was 13. glad i got to see them before they stopped touring
WITH BEATS THIS HEAVY. WHO NEEDS TO MOSH?? AND THE SOUND IS A STAMPEDE CAUSED BY THE EARTHQUAKE SHAKING THE DEMONS FREE FROM NIN....nuff said?? AND WE NEVER GROW UP....THANKS TO THE MUSIC.....
@abstractconclusion Seems to be a common with a lot of NIN shows in the states, or any shows in massive arenas around the globe. The shows they've had in the UK in the smaller venues in '05, '07 and '08 were all pretty fucking mental, I can put truth to that. Also worth bearing in mind that a lot of NIN's crowd consists of the older generation who were fans from the begininng, who don't necessarily want to go mental like us young'uns.
Either way, Nine Inch Nails live is one hell of a show.
@abstractconclusion agree. i was at their concert in Poland and then i felt my bones for two weeks - at NIN's gig you must jump, kick, scream, FEEL THAT ENERGY!
grab anyone who steps outside the line. For example I saw a guy down the row from me throw a bottle of water. Not that he should be allowed to throw anything, but two security guards came and apprehended him. Anyway, the point is, given the type of venue, the most movement anyone in the crowd can do there is stand up. Thats pretty much it. Maybe jump up and down a little lol
I was at this show and the crowd was going nuts the whole time. As far as moshing goes its virtually impossible at this venue (PNC Bank Art Center) because the seats (which are not removable) lead all the way up to the end of the stage. There's no pit to mosh in, plus even if one made some sort of poor attempt at slam dancing, besides the fact that theres no where to do it, its a live nation owned arena and at least at that peticular one, they put security at the end of every row, ready to (con)
How in the Hell could anyone just stand there during this song like the fucking dead and not feeeeel this!???? When this shit came out in the early 90's I would play it in my car and almost fall out the window freaking out over it's awesomeness.
@maddogsmile This is true... But a huge problem in this is that the ampitheatre has a bunch of chairs unfortunately. But hey, at least they're standing.
i'm sorry but that is the most boring crowd ever to such a kick ass song! I am so glad I saw this live at the Metro in Melbourne, Australia and I was screaming the lyrics whilst holding my wife! Great times and an unforgettable experience, the only NIN set list which deviated from the "Pinion, Terrible Lie, Sin" routine....
video should be renamed to "NIN the only thing ALIVE in Holmdel, NJ". Did the audience think they were in an audition to play the part of the brainwashed, zombie kids in Pink Floyd's "The Wall"? NIN should have played in front of the Chinese terracota warriors, they would have gotten a reaction out them! What an embarrasing audience...
The front row in the audience looks all lost in the dear with the head lights like this is the first time they're heard this song or something. Just lame and goes to show they are a bunch of fake NIN fans. Trent should of yelled at them and said "Bang your head and get all crazy you fuckers or go in the back row if you're not into this you fuckin posing douche-bags!" Ha ha ha!!
Seriously, I was in this crowd too. Unfortunately I was waaaay in the back, but I still rocked out and had a good time. The people up front disappoint me. I would've killed to be where they were.
I love the lack of care that camera person has! They put the video first and it looks amazing! Many times when i recorded, the crowd was first and the camera men almost had to be invisible! Love this kind of camera
Look up the info for Boston Garden 12.3.94 show on ninwiki.com. Trent freaked out and walked off stage because everyone was in seats. The place went nuts and RIPPED the seats out of the ground. Trent came back out and rocked the place into the ground.
I remeber one of my sisters friends thought he was singing "This is a metal ass, and it is full right now." I was like your a dumb ass, however when you think of it and humor it, it kind of sounds like that.
Look at how static people are in the front!!! They do not deserve this fucking amazing performance.. if I were there I would be tearing limbs and chopping bodyparts off out of excitement.
@smokelakes i've seen a few vids from around this time and his voice is a bit deeper and just sounds strange, you don't hear that? like he's sick or something..
@Huitzel well yeah, but i saw him in 05 and he sounded fine, and the vids of concerts AFTER this he sounded fine. IDK... i actually thought maybe a short stint on 'roids changed his voice, to be honest.. hoping not
@Rosstacular PNC is the coolest fucking venue, but everybody who goes there just stands, meanwhile me and my friends are up in the lawn or up front freaking the fuck out! It's really a sad thing. Craziest it's ever been was for Green Day, and even then it wasn't much.
@CriticsConfession I was just thinking the same thing dude, its NIN for fuck sake!! every time i've seen them live the crowd go nuts! But in this vid everyone's just standing still. WTF! its not Coldplay lol!
@Bennyboy138 HAHAHAHAHA! I appreciate the Coldplay insult, hahahahaha! I love in the video of NIN playing Wish live with the Dillinger Escape Plan and Trent is all like "Well, every once in a while there's a band that just blows us out of the water....and that band is obviously Coldplay (to which the audience boos) and we invited them tonight, but they didn't show, so we settled for these guys...get out here, you pussies!"
@Rosstacular this is what happens when a bands fans all grow up and have kids and jobs. I went to Metallica in 1996 and was like "Wtf" when everyone was in button down shirts and baseball hats and the guy behind me told us to sit down
@MesoAsian the thing about nine inch nails is that their songs grow better and better with each tour. especially the older ones. they have a chance to really feel out how the song should sound and go with it.
why do you think songs from the downward spiral are still getting radio play? the songs have grown up with their audience and it is wonderful
@TakingBackSam Yeah, I guess you're right. The more you play a track the more it get's tweaked just right. I just thought it was odd to change the notes altogether, the whole track is like a couple of semitones off. Maybe it's cause Trent has a deeper voice compared to when it was written? Who knows, still loved the performance ; )
@stunningslug i was there the reason nobodys moving is because its all chairs which is bullshit\ i wish i could of seen nin somewheree else where i could move around and pit n all that plus it also sucked because they played really early because they opened for janes addiction but other than that nin is awsome and sounds great live just wish i went and saw them at another place
Criticize all you want, but Trent Reznor is a musical genius and if you don't appreciate that, well, then you'll live you're life without his magic. For the rest of us, we are blessed :) I love this song and have always loved the beginning solo. I blast it all the time in the car
Wow, I am surprised to see this.. I was at this show, and Trent was very sick, could barely sing, at least by his standards. I also don't know how the hell they filmed this, I dont remember seeing anybody on stage with a camera. Hurm.
Fat Man & Little Boy had only a fraction of the power of this.....
MythicShot 4 days ago
Comment removed
ryodistributor 1 week ago
in a world of mindnumming pop and moneymakers without souls...... there is still light at the end of the tunnel and its name is Trent Reznor!!
SuperTrentreznor 1 week ago
fucking amazing.
thedariocotti 1 week ago
its either the audience is stunned or is full of deaf people
TyphoonHubert 1 week ago
TRENT'S VOICE IN AMAZING!!!
TheMetamaxNIN 2 weeks ago
Audience sucks but this song is fucking HEAVY!
kiikarikotelo 2 weeks ago
It must be tough being so heavy
StoriesForMoney 3 weeks ago
The audience is deaf or what the fuck is this shit? amazing band, amazing song, amazing sound and they don't move!
Kordakov 3 weeks ago
dissapointed that drummer ended up with angels and airwaves. whatever pays the bills i guess. talk about a downgrade! waste of talent.
cjk310 3 weeks ago
Hell yeah, so heavy! Great quality too
jhunterhenson 3 weeks ago
@siegeartifact I saw them for the Fragile tour in St. Louis at an outdoor arena. APC opened, right in the middle of Judith a giant storm we had all been watching roll in just opened on is all.
Basic seating was in the open on grass (quickly mud) and the pricey seats were covered.
I've never seen a more compassionate fan base in my life. As soon as the rain hit, the pricey seaters let the cheap seaters share the cover. Trent actually praised the audience and vowed to play as long as we were comf
jayb3ta 3 weeks ago
Robin's vocals are amazing at the end! I guess after years of NIN boot camp and touring as well as his little bout with G'n'R, that dude has some serious vocal chops. As well as guitar, synth and style points... I see why Trent wanted him back.
jayb3ta 3 weeks ago
awful crowd.typical for the us shows.
musicusaddictus 1 month ago
NIN in daylight? Things have changed for the worse.
SiegeArtifex 1 month ago
Comment removed
Scoffman5150 3 months ago
awesome! One of my favorite NIN songs from Broken
Scoffman5150 3 months ago
that mics his bitch.
mefeman1 3 months ago 2
wow...to the earlier comment about Timebomb...I have much respect for Sully Erna, but the verse of Timebomb is a near flagrant rip-off...even the vocal inflection...also to the earlier comment about Last v. Timebomb...Last in my opinion is clearly heavier, was written first, and clearly better
seltzer30 3 months ago
Fucking sick. I'd kill to see NIN live. Why does the crowd seem so still and mellow though?
minglis88 3 months ago
fucking sick. I'd kill to see NIN live.
minglis88 3 months ago
Stadium has nothing but seats so it's pretty hard for them to mosh/go crazy. (read it from previous post.
Knobend420 3 months ago
It's really sad that what's needed these days for crowd to move is tits and drugs. People should kinda wake up a little. Or a little more than that. I mean, isn't tits all over the internet already enough? This is art ffs... even tits should be only in the context of art, only. Listen to the lyrics and enjoy the music...
dddux 3 months ago
Comment removed
Reptilectricful 3 months ago
Alright!
Steffffest 4 months ago
no one's playing bass here??!!
ianvery78 4 months ago
ut most respect for nin, they are bad ass no question. sounds the kinda the same as timebomb godsmack which blows this song away
teclec 4 months ago
@teclec Last was made in 92 and Timebomb around 96!
Harzku 4 months ago
@teclec Time Bomb is a tribute to this. I equally enjoy both.
Salerwhoa 3 months ago in playlist Videos from ninofficial
ააააააააააააააააააა!
Trors 4 months ago
amazing!
FRealityProductions 4 months ago
NININININININININININ!
BlackPirat007 4 months ago
"GO!"
MikeSU98 4 months ago
Nin fans like to enjoy the show by watching.
Nin Live is mezmorizing great shows!
C0RPSI 5 months ago
@C0RPSI definitely professionals
everythingstakensux 4 months ago
@everythingstakensux Fuck yeah!
C0RPSI 4 months ago
what the fuck version of last is this? what the fuck happened to reznor? who is this band? because it sure isn't nine inch nails
spites1 5 months ago
@spites1 wtf are u talkin about?? are u deaf or something??? this performance fukin rules.
Reptile0183 5 months ago 15
@spites1 what?!? how
seldomme14 5 months ago
@spites1 reznor is NIN
mikedarkhawk 4 months ago
A panzer division could creep up on that gig and no one would hear them !
MythicShot 5 months ago
Crowd getting old is a lame excuse. I've seen Bad Religion and Slayer in the last few months and their pits were some of the best I've been in for years, people were going bonkers.
mamtor9 5 months ago
"Gave up trying to figure it out but my head got lost along the way"
C0RPSI 6 months ago
Fuck. If this was played at the concert I went to, I would've gone mental.
brainysod 6 months ago
WTF some comments here make me question if some of you guys where ever NIN fans.Damn have some respect for the band.
antipopboner 6 months ago
@therecoveryroom. lmao. indeed rip nin. where did the angry trent go. hes all soft now. what a nub.
smatter022188 6 months ago
Thank god!...that was a horrible tour. his voice is roached....cmon....cmon.....what the fuck is thatt........R.I. P NIN
TheRecoveryRoom 6 months ago
its like Dawn Of The Dead, the crowd I mean (you cant hear the zombie groaning noises over the awsome music)
Diarm0 6 months ago
@Diarm0 That's what happens when your core audience grows up.
Artem1sEntreri 6 months ago
@Artem1sEntreri Does growing up mean you have to be boring? I'm going to love this song until I die.
Idkfawin32 5 months ago
@Idkfawin32 You must've misunderstood me. I'm A HUGE NIN fan and I can listen to the songs for hours and hours on end. All I'm saying is that when you have a band that's been around for a relatively long time, long enough for its initial audience to age considerably, it's normal for that audience not to behave the same way they did 20 years ago. Does not moshing, not throwing stuff around and not flailing your extremities like a hummingbird on crack constitute a boring person in your opinion?
Artem1sEntreri 5 months ago
@Artem1sEntreri
yap,maybe:)
NTVRDfmv 5 months ago
37 people shud go watch other videos if they dont like NIN (crazy right? not liking NIN)
Diarm0 6 months ago
SHITTY CROWD
hippotoast 6 months ago
@hippotoast No they just don't know how to react to that level of awesomeness, their brains are frozen...
kpgpwi64 6 months ago
one can only hope the crowd are not zombies, but just stunned into silence by the sheer awesomeness of this show
BlueHoboMeltdown 6 months ago 2
Pigs =)
ermac59 6 months ago
Robin Finck is a beast.
frootloopwarriors 6 months ago
HEY!! PROOF, REAL PERFORMING ARTISTS EXIST!!!!! THIS SONG SOUNDS BETTER IN QUALITY AND ROCK STANDARD NOW MORE THAN THEN........ LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, OUR NAILS ARE HAMMERING ON....
GinoTimes 6 months ago in playlist Nails
this is awesome, my dad saw these guys on the pretty hate machine tour when he was stationed in japan in the late 80's and i got to see em in 2008 when i was 13. glad i got to see them before they stopped touring
meatwad13666 7 months ago
Comment removed
meatwad13666 7 months ago
Comment removed
meatwad13666 7 months ago
YEEEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHH!!!
alfonsoskid 7 months ago
I came, in 1080p.
TalesfromtheCradle 7 months ago
I'm hard!
Xt3RM1n4T36 7 months ago
I really want them to cover "Safety Dance" for some strange reason.
Kataalysts 7 months ago 2
I can tell you why no one is moshing... it's cause they're all in shock thinking "holy shit!! they're really playing Last!!!", I know I would be.
Chuckiegoodactor 7 months ago
WITH BEATS THIS HEAVY. WHO NEEDS TO MOSH?? AND THE SOUND IS A STAMPEDE CAUSED BY THE EARTHQUAKE SHAKING THE DEMONS FREE FROM NIN....nuff said?? AND WE NEVER GROW UP....THANKS TO THE MUSIC.....
GinoTimes 7 months ago in playlist Nails
they're moshing in spirit
:p
graphx311 7 months ago
This was a rad show. . . I'm really happy I was there. >:)
threethousandwords 7 months ago
The audience looks like they're watching a Vivaldi concerto.
abstractconclusion 7 months ago 39
@abstractconclusion Seems to be a common with a lot of NIN shows in the states, or any shows in massive arenas around the globe. The shows they've had in the UK in the smaller venues in '05, '07 and '08 were all pretty fucking mental, I can put truth to that. Also worth bearing in mind that a lot of NIN's crowd consists of the older generation who were fans from the begininng, who don't necessarily want to go mental like us young'uns.
Either way, Nine Inch Nails live is one hell of a show.
enterrossman 2 months ago 2
@abstractconclusion I dislocated my knee seeing them in 2000 in Australia, and cracked a rib in 07.
Crowds here are fucking insane.
tyroneblackman82 2 months ago 5
@abstractconclusion agree. i was at their concert in Poland and then i felt my bones for two weeks - at NIN's gig you must jump, kick, scream, FEEL THAT ENERGY!
MrPandino 1 month ago
Ilan Rubin is a freaking beast.
jumeau1 8 months ago
LAST but not least need more NIN
yeahyeahyeah298 8 months ago
36 people just got out of the closet xD
manof30 8 months ago
THIS IS RIGHT NOW! comecomeco...
bgtelevizor 8 months ago
i was at this show, nin kicks ass, i'll miss seeing them on tour!!!!
mary7trent 9 months ago 2
grab anyone who steps outside the line. For example I saw a guy down the row from me throw a bottle of water. Not that he should be allowed to throw anything, but two security guards came and apprehended him. Anyway, the point is, given the type of venue, the most movement anyone in the crowd can do there is stand up. Thats pretty much it. Maybe jump up and down a little lol
fucktard360 9 months ago
I was at this show and the crowd was going nuts the whole time. As far as moshing goes its virtually impossible at this venue (PNC Bank Art Center) because the seats (which are not removable) lead all the way up to the end of the stage. There's no pit to mosh in, plus even if one made some sort of poor attempt at slam dancing, besides the fact that theres no where to do it, its a live nation owned arena and at least at that peticular one, they put security at the end of every row, ready to (con)
fucktard360 9 months ago 2
@fucktard360 Such a sad place exists...
thehornypuppy 8 months ago
Hop into my time machine. You need your own weapons and safety is not guaranteed; I have only done this one time before!
2fookinwasted 9 months ago
Just burned this and others to bluray...... hope I don't spend the next month in the house haha.
ToddDtown25 9 months ago
wtf this is nin
ryotbryant 9 months ago
0:49 is so badass
xxgogsxx 9 months ago
How in the Hell could anyone just stand there during this song like the fucking dead and not feeeeel this!???? When this shit came out in the early 90's I would play it in my car and almost fall out the window freaking out over it's awesomeness.
2fookinwasted 9 months ago
@2fookinwasted Let's go back in time and wake the suckers up!
midairman 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@midairman Hop into my time machine. You need your own weapons and safety is not guaranteed; I have only done this one time before!
2fookinwasted 9 months ago
I have never seen such a boring crowd to a kick ass song like this
aaronjfornarino 9 months ago
I love Nine Inch Nails with all of my twisted fuckin' heart. But the song doesn't sound right with the guitars drop tuned to C.
PvtPlatypus 9 months ago
@PvtPlatypus Are you kidding? It makes the song sound so much heavier... IMO
remsouille 9 months ago
if "Last" can't make a crowd move, it's a sign that this people must be forgotten by humanity.
maddogsmile 10 months ago 37
@maddogsmile This is true... But a huge problem in this is that the ampitheatre has a bunch of chairs unfortunately. But hey, at least they're standing.
MismoEnfermo 6 months ago
@maddogsmile I think I was the only fucking person moving and screaming like an idiot in that crowd.
CriticsConfession 5 months ago
Why was the live video of "burn" removed?
starstruckstarfuck 10 months ago
Tough Crowd
TheDefaultRemix 10 months ago
You guys rock!!!! I love you all.
bellarina1294 10 months ago
Nine inch fucking nails !!! longer than your dick!!!!
MireBandMusic 10 months ago
at the very least, would someone please introduce NJ to moshing?
msjeffam 10 months ago
Song. Kicks. So. Much. Ass. :)
modernlover0rosalyn 10 months ago
he really upped his ante on the vocals for this. i knew he still had it in him :)
cory927 10 months ago
N I И
nastierpogo 10 months ago
The best crowd was in poland, anyone agrees?
mrB0DYmassageMACHINE 10 months ago
i'm sorry but that is the most boring crowd ever to such a kick ass song! I am so glad I saw this live at the Metro in Melbourne, Australia and I was screaming the lyrics whilst holding my wife! Great times and an unforgettable experience, the only NIN set list which deviated from the "Pinion, Terrible Lie, Sin" routine....
aaronjfornarino 10 months ago
video should be renamed to "NIN the only thing ALIVE in Holmdel, NJ". Did the audience think they were in an audition to play the part of the brainwashed, zombie kids in Pink Floyd's "The Wall"? NIN should have played in front of the Chinese terracota warriors, they would have gotten a reaction out them! What an embarrasing audience...
aguantepinamarcarajo 10 months ago
The front row in the audience looks all lost in the dear with the head lights like this is the first time they're heard this song or something. Just lame and goes to show they are a bunch of fake NIN fans. Trent should of yelled at them and said "Bang your head and get all crazy you fuckers or go in the back row if you're not into this you fuckin posing douche-bags!" Ha ha ha!!
RussX5Z 11 months ago
FUCK YES!!!!! This is badass!!! NIN FOREVER!
Bennyboy138 11 months ago
Trent Reznor is now one of the few Post-Industrial Hard rock bands that can say they are an Academy Award Winner.
XMDinx 11 months ago 2
I want to be Trent's pants.
blursx 11 months ago
Seriously, I was in this crowd too. Unfortunately I was waaaay in the back, but I still rocked out and had a good time. The people up front disappoint me. I would've killed to be where they were.
And this is one of my favorite songs too.
NinjaKitty4Justice 11 months ago 2
Comment removed
NinjaKitty4Justice 11 months ago
Alguien sabe donde puedo comprar unos pantalones como los de Reznor? Son de lo maaaasssss ! ! !
nicolasleiva100 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Video is good, sound is awesome, crowd is FUCKING SHIT...
Learn to live while you can maggots.
jtb32k 11 months ago
Videos goos, sound is awesome, crowd is FUCKING SHIT...
Learn to live while you can maggots.
jtb32k 11 months ago
2:35 It's like they're caught in a field of digital distortion.
True Industrial.
xXSythenXx 11 months ago 2
jesus we are all went crazy during this song, but we livin' in europe!!!! :D
Gerike7 11 months ago
I love the lack of care that camera person has! They put the video first and it looks amazing! Many times when i recorded, the crowd was first and the camera men almost had to be invisible! Love this kind of camera
XMDinx 11 months ago
Does this song not have a bassline? JMJ plays the bass but he has the 6 string guitar in this.
joshwords 11 months ago
wait a second, where is the bass player? Does this song not have a bass line?
joshwords 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Que banda del carajoooooo ! ! ! Rompen con todo lo establecido
nicolasleiva100 11 months ago
Que banda del carajooooo, por Dios ! ! ! Rompen con todo lo establecido
nicolasleiva100 11 months ago
5d mark ii black pixel problem at 00:10.
enjoyjared 11 months ago
fucking crowd is dead WTF!
MrMiguelito2494 11 months ago
EPIC video, but crowd sucks
MrGFIZ1 11 months ago
Look up the info for Boston Garden 12.3.94 show on ninwiki.com. Trent freaked out and walked off stage because everyone was in seats. The place went nuts and RIPPED the seats out of the ground. Trent came back out and rocked the place into the ground.
RyanReznor 11 months ago
There was more action on stage then in the crowd.
voices1 1 year ago
Good show! Crowd not so much. =P
TastyFive 1 year ago
You gotta look at the lawn section. We were going nuts
funkshiat 1 year ago
I always loved this song!
I remeber one of my sisters friends thought he was singing "This is a metal ass, and it is full right now." I was like your a dumb ass, however when you think of it and humor it, it kind of sounds like that.
1979Mothman 1 year ago
This crowd makes me think. When I saw NIN live, at first the crowd was insane. About five, six songs to finish, they were way more calmed.
But not me, sir. I was still insane, berzserk mode (or however the fuck you write it).
DraxZombie 1 year ago
Look at how static people are in the front!!! They do not deserve this fucking amazing performance.. if I were there I would be tearing limbs and chopping bodyparts off out of excitement.
xxermacxx18 1 year ago
That wasn't the last show right? It was just the song "last"?
rmc032988 1 year ago
nice to hear this, finally. getting my friends from the parking lot to the ampitheater was like herding sheep and we missed the first couple songs
loserbabysowhydontyo 1 year ago
Its just weird lol.
ThePredkiller 1 year ago
I know I was kidding but WTF is wrong with his voice he is not that good of a singer anymore unless it comes to the Fragile and his recent stuff )=
ThePredkiller 1 year ago
@ThePredkiller why would he need to work on his voice?....its perfect for his music. no one can match it.
i think the grit in his voice just makes it sound harder and more aggressive
smokelakes 1 year ago
what's up with his voice in this one??
prdgyair 1 year ago
@prdgyair what the fuck are you talkin about
smokelakes 1 year ago
@smokelakes i've seen a few vids from around this time and his voice is a bit deeper and just sounds strange, you don't hear that? like he's sick or something..
prdgyair 1 year ago
@prdgyair yea i know what you mean. i thought that was just him gettin older.
i think the echoplex show was when he got sick though
smokelakes 1 year ago
@prdgyair Maybe because its been over twenty years since this song was written and recorded? His voice is bound to change....
Huitzel 1 year ago 19
@Huitzel well yeah, but i saw him in 05 and he sounded fine, and the vids of concerts AFTER this he sounded fine. IDK... i actually thought maybe a short stint on 'roids changed his voice, to be honest.. hoping not
prdgyair 1 year ago
zombies are real, and they live in Holmdel, NJ
Rosstacular 1 year ago 56
@Rosstacular PNC is the coolest fucking venue, but everybody who goes there just stands, meanwhile me and my friends are up in the lawn or up front freaking the fuck out! It's really a sad thing. Craziest it's ever been was for Green Day, and even then it wasn't much.
CriticsConfession 11 months ago
@CriticsConfession I was just thinking the same thing dude, its NIN for fuck sake!! every time i've seen them live the crowd go nuts! But in this vid everyone's just standing still. WTF! its not Coldplay lol!
Bennyboy138 11 months ago
@Bennyboy138 HAHAHAHAHA! I appreciate the Coldplay insult, hahahahaha! I love in the video of NIN playing Wish live with the Dillinger Escape Plan and Trent is all like "Well, every once in a while there's a band that just blows us out of the water....and that band is obviously Coldplay (to which the audience boos) and we invited them tonight, but they didn't show, so we settled for these guys...get out here, you pussies!"
CriticsConfession 11 months ago
@CriticsConfession lol i remember that part X)
StickyInADarkBlueCut 11 months ago
@Rosstacular its because they cant fist pump to this song
rb99 8 months ago
@Rosstacular this is what happens when a bands fans all grow up and have kids and jobs. I went to Metallica in 1996 and was like "Wtf" when everyone was in button down shirts and baseball hats and the guy behind me told us to sit down
graphx311 7 months ago
@Rosstacular lol!
robram818 7 months ago
@Rosstacular "live" lol
mrB0DYmassageMACHINE 7 months ago
fucking people ill give anything to see last live
sickolinokio 1 year ago
What's with the weird change in the root note? It doesn't sound anything like how it was written...lol
MesoAsian 1 year ago
@MesoAsian the thing about nine inch nails is that their songs grow better and better with each tour. especially the older ones. they have a chance to really feel out how the song should sound and go with it.
why do you think songs from the downward spiral are still getting radio play? the songs have grown up with their audience and it is wonderful
TakingBackSam 1 year ago
@TakingBackSam Yeah, I guess you're right. The more you play a track the more it get's tweaked just right. I just thought it was odd to change the notes altogether, the whole track is like a couple of semitones off. Maybe it's cause Trent has a deeper voice compared to when it was written? Who knows, still loved the performance ; )
MesoAsian 1 year ago
@MesoAsian theres actually a funny video somewhere on here where he makes fun of the difference between his speaking/singing voice
and yes it still was a great performance-all their stage vids are definitely the best
TakingBackSam 1 year ago
@TakingBackSam If you don't mind me asking, where did you find that particular clip, cause I'd like to watch it.
kjhfjkdshjkfhsdaiuhf 1 year ago
skinny trent was much powerful....still awesome though
SuperZdon 1 year ago
WTF is this? This can not be NIN, who the hell is that up on stage? That can not be Trent Reznor. WTF happened to him? Is he on drugs or something?
ThePredkiller 1 year ago
@ThePredkiller Don't tell me you expected him to stay a skinny angry goth boy his whole life. People grow older and change, deal with it.
indiemiller 1 year ago
No he's not on drugs anymore, and he got buff like five years ago.
CGBSpender1947 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
No he's not on drugs anymore, and he got buff like five years ago.
CGBSpender1947 1 year ago
the best live band ever!!!!
xStarfish85x 1 year ago
Trent + leather pants = WIN
circusfreak0987 1 year ago
this song is heavy . love the riff .
ryotbryant 1 year ago
he doesn't sound the same anymore :/ but god does he look hotter than ever! YUH-fucking-UM!!
BatteriesDead 1 year ago
what's wrong with the crowd?? People like this don't deserve to be there!
stunningslug 1 year ago 2
@stunningslug i was there the reason nobodys moving is because its all chairs which is bullshit\ i wish i could of seen nin somewheree else where i could move around and pit n all that plus it also sucked because they played really early because they opened for janes addiction but other than that nin is awsome and sounds great live just wish i went and saw them at another place
wardoekw 1 year ago
@wardoekw well that sucks. Didn't know there were chairs. But still i bet it was good experience right? :)
stunningslug 1 year ago
OMG, the crowd it's so bad.
1gui 1 year ago
this is a badass song
Gribbznezz 1 year ago
Criticize all you want, but Trent Reznor is a musical genius and if you don't appreciate that, well, then you'll live you're life without his magic. For the rest of us, we are blessed :) I love this song and have always loved the beginning solo. I blast it all the time in the car
SBettle 1 year ago
Best part of this sing, DRUMS + GUITAR.........
jtb32k 1 year ago
Wow, I am surprised to see this.. I was at this show, and Trent was very sick, could barely sing, at least by his standards. I also don't know how the hell they filmed this, I dont remember seeing anybody on stage with a camera. Hurm.
wallgazer88 1 year ago
@wallgazer88 Really??? That's interesting...
reyjll 1 year ago
I can't quit watching this
mikegollihue 1 year ago
That lead man needs to give up on the body supplements he looks middle aged! Great vid though. Great grunting :-)
bondbug73 1 year ago
@bondbug73
Um, his name is Trent Reznor, and he is middle aged........
egobrain25 1 year ago
@bondbug73 hes 45, and i think it looks badass haha
cheesemaker3000 1 year ago