Added: 5 years ago
From: kalelo91182
Views: 217,201
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (191)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Hey, check out my new videos

    I hope you like them, please comment, thank you

  • You bastard! Tears from here,and now I have to watch all 7 seasons again for the 4th time

  • glad you liked it. awesome

  • For some reason this song always makes me think of a solitary person standing in a cemetery in the middle of a driving thunderstorm.

  • Great Vid.

    pywacket12, one would think if you are willing to correct someone on their spelling of 'Donatella,' then you would at leas check your own posting for the error in 'Versace,' NOT 'Vercaci.'

  • My crush said he was playing this song on the guitar and now I have to watch this video.

  • cool except she'd have no draped casket

  • Comment removed

  • Wow, I forgot what a great show, cast, song---thanks.

  • what if donna dies? Josh could have some sexy time with Joey Lucas and Kenny!

  • not kenny.

  • how's Josh going to know how to please Joey without Kenny whispering her sweet-nothings in his ear

  • this song is sung by Jeff Buckley (sp)

    it was used very very nicely in the series. like alot of people here it's how i leaned of and loved this song

  • This was the song they played when CJ's Bodyguard was shot and killed at the War Of The Roses Play in a Store that was being robbed by thugs. He apprehended one suspect but was shot and killed by the second suspect then both suspects fled and as CJ is crying walking down the NY streets they play this song while sceens of Shrief's murder by the order of the President is also played out. That murder leads to the kidnap of The President's Daughter. The West Wing was awesome.

  • Who sings this version of Hallelujah? I know the versions by Leonard Cohen and Rufus Wainwright. This is also chilling and beautiful.

  • I don't know but if you like this song look at BATWILL's version on YouTube you'll like it.

  • thanks for changing it!!

  • I think you should call it WHAT IF DONNA DIED - you had me really scared - I had to go looking up stuff on the internet which then spoiled loads of other stuff!!

  • same here...

  • Christ, that was a great series.

    Many thanks for the video kalelo91182

  • Excellent compliation of the many scenes between Josh and Donna. It was clear from the first show that the characters had an undercurrent of affection for each other. Thanks. I love the music too.

  • did she died?

  • no, she didn't

  • A "What if" Donna died. What the f*(: is the point? How about "what if" your father spilt his load on the sheet instead of giving birth to you kalelo91182? that would be good

  • What season is the bombing in..?

  • it happened in season 5 the aftermath was in season 6 remember at the end of season 5 Donna gets wheeled in because of a blood clot.

  • I AGREE!!! This clips of all the deaths/funerals of West Wing. The various characters dressings for a funeral, the funeral of LEO McGARRY; CJ on the sidewalk crying, the death of Secret Service agent Simon Donovan; Bartlet walking down the cathedral aisle, the funeral of Doris Vanlandingham. Josh by Donna's bedside is when she awakes following the bombing. (and her name is NOT Donna Tela Moss, it's Donatella Moss, like Donatella Versaci). So come on, kalelo91182, fix things!

  • its just a what if, and excuss my spellings, thank you for the comment non the less :)

  • @pywacket12 Along the same lines, her last name is NOT Vanlandingham. It's Landingham.

  • @pywacket12 FFS Stop it with these spoilers I'm only on season 3 and you're talking about Simon Donovon - I take it that happens in the finale!?!?!?!? Idiots on youtube ruining my favorite Tv shows 4 meeeeeeee.

  • @Shaftsus GOOD GRIEF! Spoilers??? This happened over 6 YEARS ago! And no, Simon Donovan doesn't die in the finale!

  • @pywacket12 Simon Donovan did die in the finale and it was really gayyy, not the way I expected it I thought he would've taken a bullet for CJ - poor Simon, he would have made a great long term character : P And I'm starting to watch it for studying purposes for Skoolz (US Politics) all season box set was only 60 dollars....

  • DONNA DOESN"T DIE IN THE SHOW!!!!!!!!

    WHAT IS THIS SUPPOSE TO BE. Maybe its- Josh and Donna, Finally or Josh and Donna through the years- but no the death of Donna! SHE DOESNT DIE!! And the funeral you used was leo's! At least pay some respect to John Spencer and one of the saddest parts in the series. THIS MOVIE IS SO AGRIVATING!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • This song was much more effective when it was used for the ending of "Posse Comitatus" when Secret Service Agent Simon Donovan was killed.

    Actually, Donna and Josh getting together was the best thing about the final season of this series.

  • You use Hallelujah - you realise this song is about sex? It's not some soppy goodbye song.

  • Uh annny reason people voted my message down when it was completely true?? Or have I just further proved the ignorance?

  • I don't mean to sound sour, but I don't think this is "The Death of Donna" I think this is clips strung together.

    Period.

    Six minutes and twenty-nine seconds of my life I'm not going to get back.

    Look, it's a nice clips reel, but it's not the Death of Donna and it certainly was nothing original. Change the title and maybe I wouldn't be so harsh. heck, maybe i wouldn't have even watched it. But I certainly wouldn't have been misled.

    One star.

  • Love this show & Donna is a hottie !

  • the produce of this show must've been pro-israel - depecting sweet donna almost getting killed at the hands of terrorist arabs when she was only there to make peace. great way to represent the palestinian movement. if you're an pro-israel.

  • Written by Aaron Sorkin.

    I mean, seriously, you do know how to take a hint, don't you?

  • Yes, because Arabs are so peaceful. What a hatchet job!

  • Soooo glad this doesn't actually happen in WW. Well put together little video though, at least in my opinion. Well done.

  • does she really die??!

  • She almost in Gaza but when she comes back she works with will on the bill russell election

  • Comment removed

  • Please watch my other west wing or other videos to see better editing,

  • an amazingly gifted writter and share in the love pain and tradgady of our fav family of the white house and no not just the first family but the staff of one of the most amazing presidencies in history, in a fictional world of course,

  • yeah i 100% agree i sat crying at this and leo's death and the time bartlet had an arguement with leo and leo's heart attack

  • this is just a what if video, relax really, its just how this tradgady may effect the people who love Donna, and tell me who doesn't, i am one of the biggest WW fanatics, sad i know but for a while id nothing better to do then share in the wonderfully written world of the ww and the imagination of sorkin,

  • hmmm, i'm not really sure about the point of this. the jeff buckley tune was used in a different episode and the editing was mediocre. not to mention the odd topic, is there a hate of donna?

  • um, i think this is kind of a video fanfic ... don't take it seriously.

  • GodDAMN. I only just started watching this AWESOME TV show and I fucking crapped it when I saw the title.

  • Beautifully done. Made me cry.

  • Faget? Your ignorance is showing. I think your wet asshole tells us all we need to know about a twat like you. Thanks for sharing.

  • Okay, now that I've seen the video...

    What a beautiful, bittersweet story. You deftly used these scenes to create a story of your own and it was quite touching.

  • It might help if you label this video as AU (alternate universe), but honestly, people shouldn't be this upset.

    The show has been off the air for several years now and it's been enough time to know what happened on the show.

  • Well I just started watching the show, so yeah the title of this video freaked me out for real !!! Glad it didn't really happen (I'm on season 4 right now).

  • I have to give you credit for a nicely edited video, and even a beautiful soundtrack, but come on! Your title and video are so misleading!!! Those funeral scenes are from Leo's funeral, and the Gaza bomb incident and Donna in the hospital are from an old episode from which Donna recuperates successfully!! Come on! Don't mislead people like this. Donna is such an amazing character. You certainly got me watching though. However, it'll only be watched by me this one time.

  • Miss the point much?

  • this is stupid!

  • This is really really mean!!

  • You're a prick

  • you idiot!

    I just finished watching the entire show for the first time (it actually took about 2-3 months to see all 7 seasons). And like a months ago I saw this title on youtube. And I thought SHE WAS ACTUALLY DYING.

    so thanks for the mislead, jerk!!!

  • COMPLETELY the same mind you had a lot o time on my hands only took me a month 2 watch it all

  • this is great, dont listen to the idiots, if they cant grasp the concept of a "What if" video, and appreciate good editing to a good song then there clearly mentally retarded and we should feel sorry for them

  • This is the single most pointless thing I have ever seen.

    What a waste of bandwidth and time...the author of this clearly has no life

  • Really aren't you as excited as I am to have yet another fanvid to Hallelujah. Honestly a West Wing fan should know better.

  • Why???

  • Why would you title the video "The west Wing Donna dies"? Donna never died in the entire seven seasons of the series.

  • It's a fictional scenario.

  • no he absolutely did NOT. he died of his massive second heart attck. he 2 heart attcks in his life, nad they were fit into the show. if u dont know the whole story, dont put false shit up here. john spencer is an amzing actor and he is missed. so shut up u man whore, cuz obviously u dont know wht ur talking bout!!!!!!!!

    *west wing 4evr*

  • Great study in editing. I think the real ending is better with Donna and Josh having the transition from repressed affection to our having to imagine what their love in the long term would be like.

  • compiliation of the deaths of secretary, chief of staff and the body guard, glad Donna didnt die she was a favourite

  • what a totally and utterly pointless editing exercise.

  • I agree, what a waste.

  • Comment removed

  • the song is called 'Hallelujah' and this version is by Jeff Buckley

  • its originally by leonard cohen

  • its on youtube

  • i like it even if it did not happen i think it works well I love AU stuff

    Thank for making it

  • I believe this is an experiment in ALTERNATE REALITY/Alternate History. Of course it didn't happen in the series. Nice work on this vid.

  • This is so misleading/pointless because Donna does not die, in the series she ends up being the new (Helen Santos). first lady's chief of staff

  • NO SHIT

  • This is so retarded.

  • this video is decent but it's so pointless

  • The part at 3:40 is of leo's funeral.

  • Ahem... it's Donnatella Moss

    Thanks

  • OMG! Even though I could pick out where the clips come from (yeah, seen the show a bit too much!) I still found myself tearing up! this was a great AU video. Excellent job!

  • Erm Dona doesn't die...I totally freaked out when I first saw this vid, I was like "omg have I missed something?!"

    It's a good vid though!

  • yea, the fellow fooled me too. good that i started reading comments within 10 seconds ;-) thanks

  • Donna does not die dumbass.

  • Spectacular labelling i feel like my head my explode. Have you ever watched this show? Donna doesnt die and the clips are so sporadically placed throughout the series I cant tell if this is a joke or not.

  • i love how you can see donna what attending what i can only assume to be her own funeral at 3:39

  • Why do you wanna kill donna? hehehe you like it for yourself huh? give her back to JOSH....hehehe

  • Ahhh dont do that to me :O:O That was pictures of mrs lehningham the presidents secreaty :@

  • mrs. landingham.

    don't quit them night school classes.

  • lol never went sorry to dissapoint ull never see me theire XD

  • lol never went sorry to dissapoint ull never see me theire XD

  • Jeff Buckley

  • Jeff Buckley

  • Who is the singer?

  • It's "Donnatella". John Spencer, the actor, died December 16, 2005, necessitating writing that his character, Leo McGarry, dies, heart attack. Donna died briefly (heart stopped), but was brought back on the table. Most funeral stuff from Leo's funeral, some Mrs. Landingham's, most CJ's grief from death of her Secret Service body guard, Simon Donovan. Yes, a West Wing nerd, but it's all on imdb.

  • psht. amateurs, Donna was hurt, she didn't die. Well I am sure she died sometime, but not in the show. good montage tho.

  • seriously with the economy down, a war with no end in sight, and debt so high that our countries dollar is at its lowest. . .really you are going to make this comment. . .It saddens me. . .

  • As the fictional President Bush might say, "I'd thank God for my re-election, but I really think Diebold deserves more of the credit."

  • Ha! Beautiful! You are so right. If you can't elect it, put it on TV. I look forward to to "Ozzie and Harry" the All American gay family prohibited from realizing their dreams of marriage ... etc.

  • Brilliant video.The best series of television of all the times.From SPAIN,Congratulations.

  • Geez alot of west wing nuts here on the ol you tube, watched every episode 5 times, thats cool get a hobby or a job.....i liked the show alot also but it is only a show....wake up find a real life.....westwingrocks.....

  • by the way im 13 and i don't have a job. i havve baseball every night at the highschool feild house(i'm a pitcher for the travel team), i am a straight a student, and if you are trying to tell me that i need to get a life then i guess that is not good enough. Hey what is ol. I don't think it is a word. But hey I'm in accelerated English what do I know.

  • Still, a good what- if scenerio.

  • thank you

  • No problem.

    I waited SO long for Josh and Donna to get together. I always wondered what what happen if Josh lost her before that happened.

  • ok listen idiot. This is footage from Leo's funeral. Episode Requim. donna doesn't die. She was hurt. Then recovered and began working for VP Bob Russle. Then she went to Matt Snatos's campaign. SHE DIDN'T DIE! and even if she did why would she have a millitary service. Why would her coffin be carried by Matt Snatos. Pres Bartlet and Leo's son-in-law. Also Mallory Obrien was sitting in front crying. Mallory is LEO's DAUGHTER. Plus when they are carring the coffin they walk right past her.

  • i know all this, i know more about this show than you ever will.....

    this is a what if and as a tease you even see donna sitting at the funeral..... so am i really trying to depict her death??? hum who knows, but i have many other vids of the west wing check them, out

  • trust me i no more and by the way it might be nice if u put that it is a "What If Senario" next time. AND TRUST ME I KNOW MORE I HAVE WATCHED EVERY EPISODE 5 TIMES. Ask me any one and i can name wat happened

  • In that case, maybe you can help me... a friend of mine and I love the episode where they are discussing the president's return and trying to figure out the time difference when C.J. comes in and points out all the clocks on the wall... any idea which episode (season at least)?

  • I know for sure that it is in season three but I am not sure on the episode #. I will look for you. I will post it tomorrow.

  • You missed one thing though. As the coffin is carried in they walk past Donna.

  • No, Donna doesn't die in West Wing.

    This is a video cut together to portray a what-if scenario. "What if Donna died?..."

    And I like it. It's well-done.

    It just feels very much like West Wing.

    Of course, all that is mainly due to the actors, storywriters and directors of The West Wing. The source material is so good, but the maker of this video did use it well.

  • Buckley's version is my personal favorite...Cohen's take was outstanding also....

  • This is Jeff Buckley singing and was used when CJ Craig heard about her bodyguard; the character played by Mark Harmon, that she was just falling in love with, was shot and killed. They were in Ny watching the War of the Roses and CJ broke down in the middle of broadway.

  • Donna does not die... c'mon people. This is a video of Leo's death and ceremony...and then they show her hospitalized from the landmine...

  • Wow! This is one fX%@ked up piece of video right here. Why on earth would you take some of the most poignant scenes ever to hit broadcast television and twist them into some sick "Donna dies" fantasy? The actual plot was plenty traumatic as it was.

  • "Donna dies" ??? Mornon!

    Josh and Donna 'get busy' in the last series.

  • Donna didn't die she is in the show right until the end.

  • You shure she is dead?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?

  • Nice video but misleading title since Donna didn't die, Leo did. Why would you want people to think that Donna died? Seems weird to me and not in line with how fine the video is. You didn't show one of poor Leo alive in it either - very odd!!

  • this is a well made video, based on a slightly macabre idea! very nice all the same...

  • What?! Donna dies in Iraq from an improvised rodeside explosive? That's just silly.

  • Which version of "hallelujah" is this by / from? West Wing is what got me into this song, would love to find the original.

    Thanks!

  • I think it's Jeff Buckley's version.

  • donna didn't die, leo did, donna was in an accident, but lived

  • Well cut

  • i saw this video listed on youtube when i still hadn't finished the season. I didnt watch it, not wanting to see spoilers, but I thought that Donna was actually going to die. Now that I have finished the series, I am relieved that she didn't.

  • i hope you liked it,

    check out my others please i think ul like them.

  • there is one shot though, where you can see Donna in the back (for one seceond or so): when the chest (Leo's chest) is being carried away, Donna is standing in the back

  • hello well this is the first time ever i have posted on you tube the vid is very very good

  • well thank you for taking the time. (",)

  • what's this all about?....I've watched all the way to the seventh season, Donna isn't dead~

  • i know

  • This music was used for after Special Agent Simon (Mark Harmon) was killed and the scenes where CJ was crying at the end after hearing he died in a robbery... i'm pretty sure unless i'm totally off track

  • no your right

  • yup. And I'd forgotten that too.

  • Donna doesnt die nimrod...

  • kalelo91182. keep posting, leave other comments alone, even I who knows less of West Wing than you can pull comment... please keep posting

  • my post was a reply, not test, which you failed...

    a) Josh never approved of Donna using DDCOS, she delivered joked to a friday night taping by POTIS, told Sam to watch.

    B) Will would never say "Bob" Russell for Pes, would say Robert.

    C) I did said Lou, thereafter Josh APPROVED, Yes, Lou hired her for special spot.. after Josh protested, she arranged for Josh interview Donna..

    D) I was aware of this.

  • please accept my comments as friend kalelo91182

  • Who hired Donna:

    a) No one - Donna Moss herself;

    b) Will Bailey

    c) Lou, thereafter approved by Josh

    d) the First Lady Elect.

  • season 1 was a) after josh approved for deputy deputy cheif of staff ha ha

    season 5 was B) will bailey for bob russel for president campaign.

    season 7 was C) again after josh approved (but lou wasn't asking him. she made that desision.

    and in season 7 its d) first lady elect for chief of staff

  • She is not the First Lady elect. she is the first Lady in waiting. she was NOT elected

  • i would like to see the 1 episode to the second season

    if someone could get that for me it would be great

  • I hate to break your bubble but Donna never acutally died. Although she did get injured while she was overseas on a fact finding trip. The scenes at the beggining are probably of the white house staff getting ready to attend Leo's funeral. If you watch on further in the episode you will see Donna put on a necklace. Finally the scenes with CJ crying, those are likely from when one of her bodyguards was killed.

  • the body gard being agen donovan, dont tell me west wing fact i know everything, this is my little vid and i make the rules and in this she dies, and if you watch my other vids on the west wing you would know all this.

  • And the fact that you fooled so many people into thinking that you thought that Donna died, means that your vid was very successful and its a compliment to your effort. So keep making up the fiction the way you want it to be, because if you can't play with fiction, whawt can you play with? It is sweet that they all thought you could have collected all the clips and not noticed that Donna hadnt died...they forgot that you edited the whole thing very carefully and rather cleverly.

  • thank you soooo much for that comment, that means alot. cheers and i believe your right about fiction.

  • Nicely done vid even though she does not die.The singing is outstandong.

  • so many real characters died on the show including the fan favorite Leo Magarry so why dedicate a video to something that never even happened when you can express real remorse for something that did? This video makes no sense.

  • check out my other vids....

    i have made a leo tribute as well as two other cast videos happy and sad....

    please watch them and comment.

    to anwser your question i was trying to strike a cord with fans who love the show and donna

  • Donna doesn't die she goes on to run against Josh in the next election but her candidate loses and she begs Josh for a job he rehires her and that's when they finally fall in love and end the show in bed :-) if she died none of that would or could have happened. This should be a tribute to Fitz

  • thank you however i know all this, and i hate to be a stick in the mud but josh does not hire donna, show me your a fan by naming who really hired her thanks, ps check out my other westwing vids and leave a comment, good or bad

  • It was Louise. The Santos Deputy Campaign Manager.

  • I still say it should be called "the left wing".

  • But that would imply that there actually is a left wing in American politics.

  • Now that would be scary! LOL.

  • OMG why would ANYBODY wanna make donna die?! talk about morbid!!!

  • im glad you like it, i think you do, i love donna on a personal note, but check out my new west wing vid

  • that's awful!! I nearly cried, as I'm only on season 6. so glad I read the comments!!

  • im glad you liked it and i hope you watch the rest, ill be making a new west wing vid shortly and it will be amazing. promise

  • You might want to fix the spelling at the end.. it's Donnatella.

  • Thnak you for taht :L:L

  • Tears for Fears "The Way You Are" 1984

  • i never saw the last season... what! she dies?!