Added: 2 years ago
From: TheMadonnaCN
Views: 214,840
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (142)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Badass song ;)

  • Amazing song from an amazing album. So underrated, but it makes me happy seeing other people commenting on this video saying that they love this album, happy it's not just me!

  • MADONNA (QUEEN OF POP)

  • @debfan74 - i believe alot of her fans were expexting her to stay the same as before. us real fans know she does not do that. i think this portrait of songs may be her best work. let people who dislike this sit on the side. it means more room on the dance floor for this grrl :)

  • This song took a long time to grow on me....but not sure why so many disliked the album?? Anyone got a good answer?

  • i just LOVE the theme of this album!

  • memories of when i was going threw the darkest part of my life 2002 to 2004

  • Memories when I was in third grade... <3

    My mom also loves this album and used to play it every day!

  • Fuck Bush Fuck America

  • That's verry deep song

  • This album didn't deserve anywhere near the criticism that it received. I loved it the first time I heard it, and still love it just as much now. I was watching an interview with Madonna where she said it was one of her favourites. After discussing the reaction to the album, Madonna smiled and said she picked her crown up off the floor, put it back on and kept going!! THE QUEEN!

  • Most people (music critics, music fans, and even Madonna fans) don't understand the importance of this album; they dismiss it as a bad joke, call it a failure, and career suicide. In years to come, people are going to change their minds about this LP and realize its underlying genius, but only time will tell...

    Out of all her albums, "American Life" & "Ray of Light" are the 2 that I come back to the most because they're the most genuine representation of Madonna as a human being.

  • No matter what critics say this is a BRILLIANT album! nuff said!

  • ah fuck ah fuck

  • QUEEN OF POP

  • This is SO good! I used to listen to this song a lot in 2003

  • Comment removed

  • best song ever. k bye.

  • Release some generic pop single: Goes straight to # 1. Release some generic pop Album: Goes straight to top 10. Release a song about the reality of society that everyone ignores: ''Stupid artist!'' ''Censor that shit'' ''Boycott that god-awful song and album!'' ''Fail artist!''

    Welcome to the real world.

  • the only reason this song and madonna did bad at the time it was released was because americans couldn't with the truth.

  • Rap Madonna ! <3

  • Ok Madonna did not actually write this song, just so you know.

  • @mjkingofmusic Wrong! go to ASCAP writers registry where Madonna is registered. You will find Madonna & Mirwais are the co-writers collecting royalties on this song. You might want to check out the rest of her impressive list cause she has written about 99% of her songs. Next ;)

  • @mjkingofmusic Yes she did dumbass.

  • @justsomekid33 Ok whatever, asshole. Calm down, geezz.

  • @mjkingofmusic of course she did,check her wikipedia

  • You all american people should value the beautiful country you have!!! If you don't please go to any other country and I'll go to yours!

  • Good new music now is just hard to find, this is why I download a lot of Madonna's songs and it reminds me of good music.

  • this is my fav song ever!!!! I jam to this every day in my undies in the morning

  • Excellent production

  • I love the rap break

  • love madonna, i like how all her albums are compelty different - legend

  • note the symbolism on the cover if you can

  • @tokersrule what symbolism ?

  • @invisibleboyyy she's dressed like some guy who did some thing

  • @BananaSandwich1 still don't get it ,but anyway thanx

  • "AMERICAN LIFE" is one of the most favourite album in my opinion!

  • Comment removed

  • This album is so amazing, am I the only who like Erotica, Bedtime Stories and American Life...

  • My absolute favorite album of hers. I can listen to this entire album.

  • i like britney spears but i have to say that madonna is a real artist britney is just bubblegum pop

  • Damn this song is the one

  • Nice lyrics,fuck it

  • fuck it...lol

  • I actually would rather be CANADIAN!! At least their peaceful and never get into trouble and no one hates them. CANADA ROCKS!!!

  • never get old... 

  • listen to the Carbon 77's Oakenfold Downtempo Remix it sounds awesome too lol

  • oooh! fucking! ohh! fucking <3!

  • @LittleMonster4407 *fuck it

  • I really respect her because of this album.

  • THIS ALBUM IS AWESOME , I LOVE HER FOR MANY OF THE SONGS OF THIS RECORD, LOVE MADONNA!!

  • Comment removed

  • 3 people are whale crap now for hating this song

  • who ever hates this song can eat whale crap

  • I am not concerned about the american dream, but this song describes perfectly the social crisis of the rich countries and I feel really concerned by it. I Love. =)

  • Comment removed

  • the song has its moments, haha

  • american dream??? look to the middle east and see what the america to the world.i hate american life.it makes people the same,put people in a same shape.

  • :D

  • This song ? Awsome !

  • I don't understand why the critics didn't like this album

  • @lazy132 they probably thought rap wasn't her thing

  • *without

  • it'd be better with the rap.

  • @b0x3s with or without?

  • I LOVE THIS SONG!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Bush is a disease. 

  • @CorruptionData So is Obama

  • @bbeboutuaa Definitely.

  • i love her "fuck it" in the song.....you really feel her bitchy side.....perfection <3

  • This album ruined Madonna because radio stations afterwards doesn't play her new releases anymore.

  • This song is shit, now I understand why this album was so unpopular... specially after Music, that it's a great album.

  • 3:11 RAP <3 I LOVE THAT SOOOOO MUCH! xD

  • oh dark priestess of the Illuminati. Your music is so good.

  • This album was absolutlyunder-rated. Its definitely one of her better albums. I perfer Ray Of Light a little better though.

  • def. her best album!

  • 1 person don't live the American dream.

  • Love it 

  • I have been a Madonna fan since she came out in the 80s. I have all of her albums. This one by far is the worst.

  • I wanna talk about AMERICAN LIFE. I went to HOLLYWOOD, where NOBODY KNOWS ME, but no one could really understand me. My MOTHER AND FATHER used to tell ''NOTHING FAILS'' if you try really hard, but i didn't listen. I thought Life was just an EASY RIDE. I don't know, maybe, I was in an X-STATIC PROCESS. However, I realise that I'M SO STUPID 'cause their INTERVENTION was for good reason. My extreme point of view: we all just need LOVE PROFUSION.

    Those who laugh at Madonna- just DIE ANOTHER DAY

  • @Cyberstationful your comment is by far my fav. nice formation of track names....almost as if she did it for this reason

  • Fucking kick ass song.

  • a song that shows how reality overcomes ficcion

    greetings from spain

  • The best album of Madonna!

  • I never thought I would be in love with this song, but I am.

    Amazing song, great Madonna

  • funny how this is considered an extreme point of view like she expresses, and the real extremists pass as "politycally correct".

  • wow awesome message, clever and witty lyrics. Some say humans think they are going forward when we are really going backwards. human race is becoming shallow, apathetic, blind and sadly inferior, not the superior and discerning creatures we pride ourselves to be. Madonna realizes this.

  • Great album! Erotica is my favortie, then American Life, and then Bedtime Stories. Go Madonna!

  • Best Madonna album ever

  • this is her best album right with RAY OF LIGHT

  • i dont like Madonna in general but this album was rad i love this song and Hollywood

  • like Bedtime Stories and Erotica, American Li(f)e is an honest and beautiful marker in time for everyone. Madonna is an International music treasure whom will never be forgotten and will always be loved. I'm glad She has finally moved in to the digital era allowing for much more visual possibilities and ways of personal expression, forever young, forever rich, forever loved, what more is there?

  • I've seen so many times this photo with that smile and her look that really stares directly at you! And i really love it! If you carefully notice, the lipstick on her face (the kiss) has a shape of gun (the upper lip)! WOW, that woman is Really Genius!!! The Absolute Perfection!

  • does anyone notice what she say at 2:51 besides the lyrics. Whoa I didn't pick tht up until now .

  • @silikya Brings back childhood memories for me too :)

  • Lololol

  • This song is amazing in all areas. It's musically and lyrically unique. I'm not alone in my confusion regarding why this song was poorly received. This album is like a follow-up to Ray of Light, in a lyrical sense. I love it!! I like Intervention, I'm So Stupid and the rest! :D

  • @Kaskade2009 Clap Clap Clap. It's maybe the best sarcastic song ever in pop music. But critics are ignorant and didn't understand the purpose of the song.

  • No one dislike this song O_° !! Brings me childhood memories ♥♥

  • so not the album that the majority thinks it is. severely underrated.

  • This was my first album I ever bought. memories, SUCH UNDER APPRECIATED! This is the madonna I grew up on, (that and confessions on a dancefloor)

  • one of her best albums ever!!!

    

  • I love how the electronic sounds are mixed with a realy acoustic music in this album. And I also love how the lyrics are true, and absolutely the definition of Freedom.

  • I think France was the only place that really understood and appreciated the album, it also did exceptionally well in sales unlike the rest of the world!

  • @cyberaga20 Well maybe because they mostly listen to the melody and mostly of french people don't understand a word of english x)

    For my part, I quite understand what says Madonna in her songs, and I like the lyrics (at least for what i really hear!), and I also agree with some comments here that this is an excellent album especially for the texts!

  • American Life is truly one of Madonna's greatest Masterpieces <3

  • She's laughing just right now... stupid and ignorant critics, that didn't understand the lyrics of this song... go back to the school!

  • This was released during the time before everyone realised how dangerous bush was, everyone hated her for this, how stupid they look now

  • I really love this song. Every time I hear it, it just makes me realize how stupid and phony this country really is. A lot of people crap on this song, but if you actually listen to the words, they make a lot of sense.

  • Most of the Billboard songs are bullshit.

    I cant believe a fool singer like Mariah Carey has 18 # 1 in USA.

    Madonna is too sophisticated for mainstream USA.

  • by far her best album

  • The greatest madonna

  • one of my fav albums released in 03. so underrated and very special. You rule Madonna

  • I agree with everyone. I checked this album out from the library because I'd heard from everyone that it was Madonna's worst album. From the very first synthesizers on this song I was hooked. This album is nothing short of a masterpiece in its genre. It is every bit as good as Madonna's best--surely just as good as Ray of Light. I listened to this album non stop for several days in a row, trying to understand why no one liked it. I'm totally buying it now.

  • good lyric ! and i love the song

  • Madonna <3

  • I remember when this came out, anything that wasn't in line with the obsessive fearmongering and hyper patriotism promoted by the Bush administration was completely ignored, or hated. (this was the time of freedom fries...) I never did get why people didn't like this song, other than for the poor timing around the Iraq War. It's well composed, exciting and bold, with a real message. I hope and assume that this will become more appreciated as people realize how brainwashed they were back then.

  • I mean you hit that on the complete head! Here here!

  • I totally agree with you!

    i'm french and In France we did not understand the reasons of the boycotting

    of this magnificent song by the americain people or britanique...The frenches journalists said that americaines radios refused or were contraines of refused to broadcast this song.(sorry for mistakes i am french)

  • your so right, i see so many right wing people actually going against what America is about: freedom

  • @NewWaveArch90 Like Robin Williams said, we were on the Fukitol pill. ;-)

  • @NewWaveArch90 ... or how brainwashed they sill are!

  • @NewWaveArch90 She does pose some serious tantalizing questions.

    She's not asking the obvious question, is this modern life for free (DUH! It costs money!) she's asking are we truly free, or are we only as free as we've been lead to believe? Is modern life free of constraints? Or one full of the costly demands that morph us into a nation full of consumerism, shallowness, and one void of a backbone. (do i have to change my name? will I be a star? I just realized nothing is what it seems)

  • @NewWaveArch90 Obviously, people are still brainwashed, thinking this just all goes back to the bush administration

    farther than that, my friend

  • It was deserving to be included in Celebration.

  • :E girlz RULE!!! Beyonce is da queen of RnB and Modonna is da queen of pop

  • great song.

  • is that why she lives in the UK?

  • It's such a shame that this well in general this album wasn't madonna's most popular, if people weren't so uptight and opened up their perception they could realize that American Life is truly one of Madonna's greatest Masterpieces, and one of music's most provacative and genius albums ever, It's what make Madonna a genius! :P

  • I Totally agree! i love how in-your-face it can be while also being very personal and about her experiences and outlooks as a person. plus, no one else really sounds like madonna in this album. its very unique, american audiences are used to consistency and i think it blows peoples minds how she projects a different persona with each album

  • @sephyleader Are you serious? This song has to be one of the worst compositions of all time. Just because you make an unpopular statement by no means makes you genius, especially when the music sucks so bad.

  • @sephyleader jajjj de jóóó beszólás

  • @sephyleader Yes, you 'r right, we need open mind, this album is Perfect !! Perfection needs time, too much time to be recognised, co-produced and wrote with Mirwais, a french guy, known in 70, 80's with "Taxi Girl", sorry i ' m french : )

  • @sephyleader I totally agree with you, I'm so glad there's someone out there who appreciates this wonderful album :-)

  • @sephyleader agreed, and i'm not even a big madonna fan.

  • Good song!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more