i love how the kung fu guy is tiny compared to the boxer... yet they put them together in the same 'scientific' study... in order to run a scientific study you need to limit as many differences as possible, which they clearly didn't do lol but i'm not arguing that boxing probably has some of the most dangerous punchers in the world... it's all they train, but still... get people the same size with the same amount of experience.
God damn what is this crap... it's physics morons the stronger the muscles,joints and bones and a good technique makes a powerful blow... what the fuck.. I'm not even gonna bother with explaining...
the boxing guy only threw a straight punch not a power punch dumbass. if he would of went all out that would of been about 1400psi maybe higher. mike tyson hit 1800 psi with a glove on when he was just a kid so obviously they cant hit harder thant 1k psi.
That`s all bullshit.!! Muay thai, taek kwon do, karate punch wtf?! It`s well known that the bigger you are the harder you punch, and that boxing dude was almost twice as big as kung fu guy. I know that boxing punching techniques are best among all martial art styles, I just want to say that if the contestors were at the same weight the difference wouldn`t be that big.
Mike Tyson was the best strong puncher in the World: his punch was about 1750 lbs... Earnie Shavers's punch was 1680 lbs and George Foreman's punch was around 1600 lbs...The punches that I see in the video are effective but non fatal!
This is kind of silly, they look all intelligent and they've got loads of high tech specialised equipment for these never before done tests, and they completely overlook the simple fact that they only tested ONE person from each art AND they were all completely different sizes weights and builds.
I mean, that boxer was pumped in comparison to the others, the kung fu guy was by far the smallest (though im not convinced by his way of punching looking at that. Whatever works for you i suppose)
Yeah, they should have used fighters of equal size, weight, and strength. They also should have had each fighter use all the different punches. That would have been interesting data. Still, I'd bet on the boxing punch for a knockout.
This was such a joke... so many flaws. At least they should have used the same person using different styles of punching, then you could have measured the power coming from the technique, not the individual fighter. Some guys are just stronger than others... and of course boxing has the strongest punch... that's what they do.
Evryone from MMA to Bruce Lee Says and proves that boxing is extremly effective in fighting. Bruce Lee says its quick and more dirrect. MMA artist study boxing to incorperate in their fight style. Are you a fighter at all or what?
it official boxing is not the best punching since lol look at the vid again the dude jet forward like he was dashing and punched. The asian stood still and didn't even use his whole body to punch which is the core of the one inch.
well if u have to argue look at the facts bruce lee actually fought a champion boxer and won it was a ko. Plus his one inch punch did seem to look a little different from wushu guy alex. It was suppose to be straight punch not upper punch
Cannot people accept that the TKD guy was better? and every sport has different punches which are some stronger and some weaker. remember, every sport depends on the player, not the game ;p
I don't know about the other stuff but i do know for punching power you can't top a boxer thats all they do is work on punching every one else is just good all around I'm sure.
exactly, i was soo surpirsed, like its TKD, they are known for terrible punchs. my shotokan karate sensai himself would be able to generate a punch that powerful, and hes 130 pounds. i didnt like this test because they practitioners were different weight classes.
uhmmm..... taekwondo do have some quite powerfull punches. i train it, and some of them are extreme, while others are just bull sh*. TKD isn't know for terrible punches, but everyone thinks that because in olympic sparring, only kicks are allowed. so everyone thinks that we dont consentrate on punching. but thats wrong ;p
uhmmm..... taekwondo do have some quite powerfull punches. i train it, and some of them are extreme, while others are just bull sh*. TKD isn't know for terrible punches, but everyone thinks that because in olympic sparring, only kicks are allowed. so everyone thinks that we dont consentrate on punching. but thats wrong ;p
uhmmm..... taekwondo do have some quite powerfull punches. i train it, and some of them are extreme, while others are just bull sh*. TKD isn't know for terrible punches, but everyone thinks that because in olympic sparring, only kicks are allowed. so everyone thinks that we dont consentrate on punching. but thats wrong ;p
lol..true but the boxer didnt even make it seem like he wuz using full force...the others made yelling noises n pushed foward..the boxer stood in his spot n just threw it like nothin
True. That karate guy was shit, probably a sport karate guy. He just threw his shoulder. If you've ever been hit by a strong karate-ka using his entire body, you'll know it. Sensei hyro, a 7th dan here on the east coast, was tested and his punch was so strong that taking it to the shoulder was considered lethal.
not very scientific. they are not all the same weight and musculature, and they only give them one punch. better Idea is to let multiple masters from the different style to take multiple punches and see who has the highest average. but even then it could not account for the differences in techniques that are used by different practitioners.
You can produce a knockout useing comparitivly little power with a well aimed strike to either the tip of the jaw, the temple, or certen areas of the neck.Also these style Vs style tests are complete bullshit.Search for long enough & you will find that no style is genuinely supiriour to another.Its about how skilled the fighter is, not his style.
The TKD guy is wearing heavier gloves than the rest of the guys and he also shuffled forward with his punch. The others guys stood still. Which would leave boxing and karate with the most powerful punches.
fuck that the one that done the kung fu punch was a fuckin pussy they should have put up the top dog from a showlin temple that dummy would look like it was in a car crash lol fair play great punch to the boxer nice streight through the head shot
it's quite stupid trying to find most powerfull martial art when the fighters have differnt weights, hights and muscle power... and I must say that as a Karateka, I have no idea what was that lame punch the Karate dude used... in Karate, all punches are thrown from the hip. what he did looked a lot more like a Taekwondo punch...
punches aren`t always thrown from the hip that is just a stance and a rubbish one too u have no defence for your head and stomach. when you spar, hold your left and right hands level with ur chest, one behind the other
lol if you wanna see who has the most force in pounches its fedors sambo pounches
bonds911 1 year ago
i love how the kung fu guy is tiny compared to the boxer... yet they put them together in the same 'scientific' study... in order to run a scientific study you need to limit as many differences as possible, which they clearly didn't do lol but i'm not arguing that boxing probably has some of the most dangerous punchers in the world... it's all they train, but still... get people the same size with the same amount of experience.
uckushtar 2 years ago
a kung fu master using dragon body properly has the potential to generate the most power of any1 to anywhere in his body
MDNSBS 2 years ago
The karate and tkd did the same exact punch. No style was better but bren foster (tkd) was just a stronger guy than the one that did karate.
BruceLeeKills1 2 years ago
ippo can generate more than that!
CimXeri 2 years ago
ippo could destroy it with UPPERCUTTTTTTTTTT
leslie88 2 years ago
@leslie88
国家地理杂志的，的这个实验；是根本，测不出寸劲的，劲道的。
要不然，李小龙，凭什么，寸拳闯江湖？
youhanktube 1 year ago
God damn what is this crap... it's physics morons the stronger the muscles,joints and bones and a good technique makes a powerful blow... what the fuck.. I'm not even gonna bother with explaining...
wxtrim 2 years ago
Face it Boxer dont generate enough force or damage as NINJustu
bunnylady1808 2 years ago
totally agree with u
leslie88 2 years ago
dude what kind of karate guy they found for this thing. look at his hips and form while punching. it is no karate punch. it is just "a punch"
midosi 2 years ago
i was thinking the same thing!
oblivion1717 2 years ago
The most deadly fighter, is a Jiu Jitsuka
bramosanna 2 years ago
Most lethal punch id say is boxing & the most lethal lower body attack would be muay thai's flying knee to the opponent chest.
akz2204 2 years ago
no. an mma fighter's slam is much more powerfull.
92845756 2 years ago
the boxing guy only threw a straight punch not a power punch dumbass. if he would of went all out that would of been about 1400psi maybe higher. mike tyson hit 1800 psi with a glove on when he was just a kid so obviously they cant hit harder thant 1k psi.
mois2202 2 years ago 2
i agree if he would have threw a hay maker the numbers would have doubled
IsaIMember 2 years ago
isnt that afro ninja in the red?
maihan1989 2 years ago
That`s all bullshit.!! Muay thai, taek kwon do, karate punch wtf?! It`s well known that the bigger you are the harder you punch, and that boxing dude was almost twice as big as kung fu guy. I know that boxing punching techniques are best among all martial art styles, I just want to say that if the contestors were at the same weight the difference wouldn`t be that big.
arhvash 3 years ago 10
agree
shyuen 3 years ago
exactly, not so scientific afterall
Saddguy 2 years ago
Mike Tyson was the best strong puncher in the World: his punch was about 1750 lbs... Earnie Shavers's punch was 1680 lbs and George Foreman's punch was around 1600 lbs...The punches that I see in the video are effective but non fatal!
supersonicblastman 3 years ago 3
dont tell me all boxer can punch that hard. not all boxers has a knock out punch
freddiego60 3 years ago
This is kind of silly, they look all intelligent and they've got loads of high tech specialised equipment for these never before done tests, and they completely overlook the simple fact that they only tested ONE person from each art AND they were all completely different sizes weights and builds.
I mean, that boxer was pumped in comparison to the others, the kung fu guy was by far the smallest (though im not convinced by his way of punching looking at that. Whatever works for you i suppose)
pizzaboythefourth 3 years ago 5
Yeah, they should have used fighters of equal size, weight, and strength. They also should have had each fighter use all the different punches. That would have been interesting data. Still, I'd bet on the boxing punch for a knockout.
Ludlow889 3 years ago 2
Uhh.. No Muay Thai.. zZz wasted my time
lIIusionist 3 years ago
those masters only concentrate on one particular martial art dude
leslie88 3 years ago
This was such a joke... so many flaws. At least they should have used the same person using different styles of punching, then you could have measured the power coming from the technique, not the individual fighter. Some guys are just stronger than others... and of course boxing has the strongest punch... that's what they do.
kennygob 3 years ago
lol like a sledgehammer to the face
frostiesninja 3 years ago
actually the term being used should be Style of punching of different martial arts
but what I would like to see a shaolin master punching
the impact must be very very strong =D
leslie88 3 years ago
that is one of the most innacurate tests i've ever seen..kind of disappointing coming from national geographic
Dhragonfly 3 years ago
lol at the boxer, no screaming and jumping about, just business.
ThatEvilGuy 3 years ago
OK Im a boxer but I still love Bruce. Keep it above the waist man.
ChaosIadore 3 years ago
Evryone from MMA to Bruce Lee Says and proves that boxing is extremly effective in fighting. Bruce Lee says its quick and more dirrect. MMA artist study boxing to incorperate in their fight style. Are you a fighter at all or what?
ChaosIadore 3 years ago
boxing sucks! the punch may be the strongest, but it isnt the fastest nor the most effective!
orduni90 3 years ago
it official boxing is not the best punching since lol look at the vid again the dude jet forward like he was dashing and punched. The asian stood still and didn't even use his whole body to punch which is the core of the one inch.
thunder2rain 3 years ago
well if u have to argue look at the facts bruce lee actually fought a champion boxer and won it was a ko. Plus his one inch punch did seem to look a little different from wushu guy alex. It was suppose to be straight punch not upper punch
thunder2rain 3 years ago
Cannot people accept that the TKD guy was better? and every sport has different punches which are some stronger and some weaker. remember, every sport depends on the player, not the game ;p
daniel666333 3 years ago
I don't know about the other stuff but i do know for punching power you can't top a boxer thats all they do is work on punching every one else is just good all around I'm sure.
skysaccount 3 years ago
id like to see the boxer punch with out the boxing gloves.
irbb07 3 years ago
Yeah it mesures the power, but it doesn't really say which one is the better punch.
1- Depends on the practionner for the strenght and speed.
2- If the punch is very powerful, but it's the slower, you'll be able to deflect it.
So they mesure which is the most powerful, not which one is the best punch in a fight.
jaynunchuck 3 years ago
i think i got another version of this show which bas rutten and others are the sample =D
leslie88 3 years ago
boxing YEAH!!!!
biganime40 3 years ago
this is such a bullshit show...karate got beat by taekwondo??? lets see a shotokan karate master in this and he would take the dummies head off
bgmstr 3 years ago
exactly, i was soo surpirsed, like its TKD, they are known for terrible punchs. my shotokan karate sensai himself would be able to generate a punch that powerful, and hes 130 pounds. i didnt like this test because they practitioners were different weight classes.
brayden12345 3 years ago
uhmmm..... taekwondo do have some quite powerfull punches. i train it, and some of them are extreme, while others are just bull sh*. TKD isn't know for terrible punches, but everyone thinks that because in olympic sparring, only kicks are allowed. so everyone thinks that we dont consentrate on punching. but thats wrong ;p
daniel666333 3 years ago
uhmmm..... taekwondo do have some quite powerfull punches. i train it, and some of them are extreme, while others are just bull sh*. TKD isn't know for terrible punches, but everyone thinks that because in olympic sparring, only kicks are allowed. so everyone thinks that we dont consentrate on punching. but thats wrong ;p
daniel666333 3 years ago
however they are not testing the strength being generated but they are seeing the way/style the martial artist is using
leslie88 3 years ago
we can tell by looking at the tkd guy's body and not to mention that he dashed and punched the machine
leslie88 3 years ago
TKD guy is a powerful puncher? It's a silly joke? TKD has good kicks but their punches are very weak they do not practice punching a lot.
Walentinator 3 years ago 3
uhmmm..... taekwondo do have some quite powerfull punches. i train it, and some of them are extreme, while others are just bull sh*. TKD isn't know for terrible punches, but everyone thinks that because in olympic sparring, only kicks are allowed. so everyone thinks that we dont consentrate on punching. but thats wrong ;p
daniel666333 3 years ago
lol..true but the boxer didnt even make it seem like he wuz using full force...the others made yelling noises n pushed foward..the boxer stood in his spot n just threw it like nothin
BKzNumba1Killa 3 years ago
True. That karate guy was shit, probably a sport karate guy. He just threw his shoulder. If you've ever been hit by a strong karate-ka using his entire body, you'll know it. Sensei hyro, a 7th dan here on the east coast, was tested and his punch was so strong that taking it to the shoulder was considered lethal.
shoemoodoshaloo 4 years ago
I say get fighters the same weight, unless those were the same weight.
Gauntlets 4 years ago 2
not very scientific. they are not all the same weight and musculature, and they only give them one punch. better Idea is to let multiple masters from the different style to take multiple punches and see who has the highest average. but even then it could not account for the differences in techniques that are used by different practitioners.
batterieacid 4 years ago 4
are there any more of theese videos?
althebadmadman 4 years ago
You can produce a knockout useing comparitivly little power with a well aimed strike to either the tip of the jaw, the temple, or certen areas of the neck.Also these style Vs style tests are complete bullshit.Search for long enough & you will find that no style is genuinely supiriour to another.Its about how skilled the fighter is, not his style.
TheOneNo20 4 years ago 3
The TKD guy is wearing heavier gloves than the rest of the guys and he also shuffled forward with his punch. The others guys stood still. Which would leave boxing and karate with the most powerful punches.
Nimraud 5 years ago 3
lol if shaolin member, that dummy will break in a sight
you know shaolin members strength are extreme power
leslie88 5 years ago
fuck that the one that done the kung fu punch was a fuckin pussy they should have put up the top dog from a showlin temple that dummy would look like it was in a car crash lol fair play great punch to the boxer nice streight through the head shot
jimbob202019 5 years ago
what good is any of these punches when ill take your ass to the ground !! go bjj!
Johnf85 5 years ago
good vid but pointless. cos speed is more important than power.
autophobe2e 5 years ago
I've seen that entire show...
it's quite stupid trying to find most powerfull martial art when the fighters have differnt weights, hights and muscle power... and I must say that as a Karateka, I have no idea what was that lame punch the Karate dude used... in Karate, all punches are thrown from the hip. what he did looked a lot more like a Taekwondo punch...
Nemesis5215 5 years ago
punches aren`t always thrown from the hip that is just a stance and a rubbish one too u have no defence for your head and stomach. when you spar, hold your left and right hands level with ur chest, one behind the other
autophobe2e 5 years ago
lol haha
leslie88 5 years ago