Wow, no idea why this video is getting so many negative reviews. If I'm not mistaken, this is a live multitrack performance. I never knew so much depth could created live with just 4 people. Granted a lot of effects were used, but still this is very impressive.
@TheTubaMonkey Indeed. If they were Straight No Chaser or a larger a cappella group, they wouldn't need the multitrack effects. But it's still just as impressive.
Cover this song in a vocal arrangement without losing power and intensity is almost impossible, plenty of great composers tried to do it and all failed. The Gudrun tried to do their best and, despite of massive use of effects (echoes and reverbs), the result is nice.
i dont see the point why so much people are flaming here. they dont sing out of key or without rhythm. most of the time at least. i just think the constant melody the guitar plays in the original is missing a bit in this version. and the hall is WAY too much. except for that its not that bad...
NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO
This is great. Everyone who doesn't like this probably are the people who hate anything by Metallica that came after the 80s. This is a different interpretation of the song. This is what music is about, taking good songs, and reinterpreting them in different ways. This was great, anyone who says different doesn't know what real music is about.
@fatclown101 anyone can cover a song, but you really need to know something about music to be able to sing acapella .. I think that they did a great job. This is an unique cover, not just another one. ;)
I would say the difference is that a cappella groups can sing without mics, but gudrun relies on mics plus they are using an instrument which is their loop machine. I suppose that without it they wouldn't be able to perform their songs a cappella. again, don't get me wrong, they sound good and I think especially the male vocalists have an incredible voice, but in my point of view it's not a cappella
it's similar to what Naturally 7 does, though I have to say that they should be careful using the word "a cappella" because I think they might make some "real" a cappella groups angry. they are using lots of effects and a loop machine. it's a different style and i think it sounds good, but it is not a cappella
They`re using theyre own voices without instruments, that´s what a cappella means. All the " real" a cappella groups are using a whole range of effects! Using no effect means standing on a stage without a microphone. But then they have to sing opera.
Dang, that would be hard to do a metallica song acapella....thumbs up to this group despite what everyone else is saying.
clint4Now 8 months ago
Wow, no idea why this video is getting so many negative reviews. If I'm not mistaken, this is a live multitrack performance. I never knew so much depth could created live with just 4 people. Granted a lot of effects were used, but still this is very impressive.
TheTubaMonkey 11 months ago 2
@TheTubaMonkey Indeed. If they were Straight No Chaser or a larger a cappella group, they wouldn't need the multitrack effects. But it's still just as impressive.
TheUltimateNoob001 9 months ago
It's horrible. Gudrun please do not sing Metallica's songs.
And nothing else matters
agnusdei1983 11 months ago
Cover this song in a vocal arrangement without losing power and intensity is almost impossible, plenty of great composers tried to do it and all failed. The Gudrun tried to do their best and, despite of massive use of effects (echoes and reverbs), the result is nice.
Summarizing: wrong choise, but good performance.
trekneno 1 year ago
Not that bad~:)
dlkrdlkr 1 year ago
Did Hetfield just died? Coz this is depressing... NEM is about being in love but not being there. This sounds like a funeral song... :(
86HairMetal 1 year ago
It's a very unique take on the song and overall, it's not that bad. Just have to open your mind a bit is all.
Dime6String 1 year ago
How come u'll didnt kill urselves after hearing ur own record????????
paragpep 1 year ago
i dont see the point why so much people are flaming here. they dont sing out of key or without rhythm. most of the time at least. i just think the constant melody the guitar plays in the original is missing a bit in this version. and the hall is WAY too much. except for that its not that bad...
Fuffzehn 1 year ago
oh fuck who can go to watch this
drummer9559 1 year ago
Come on guys give them a break... This is Live and thats hell of a lot harder to do than when youre singing in a studio...
I thought this was good :)
Osteballer 1 year ago
NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO
tattoodfreeek 1 year ago
Wow, that was crap.
tobermori 1 year ago
especially with a girl singing.... so fail
xlph 1 year ago
It's not too bad...
dim435 1 year ago
WHAT THE FUCK!! this is such a fail
martin2009142 1 year ago
these guys can't touch Van Canto
flibbidigibbit 1 year ago 2
so. much. freaking. failure. goodbye
Avarice447 1 year ago
Amazing.
XxxxxXjuggaloXxxxxX 1 year ago
@XxxxxXjuggaloXxxxxX Amazingly bad
ctempleton3 1 year ago
.......... No words.....
Brustolino 1 year ago
This is great. Everyone who doesn't like this probably are the people who hate anything by Metallica that came after the 80s. This is a different interpretation of the song. This is what music is about, taking good songs, and reinterpreting them in different ways. This was great, anyone who says different doesn't know what real music is about.
kiltedboywonder 1 year ago
you should learn from them : AUDIOFEELS - Nothing else matters, they dont use instruments too but they do it much better!
oneFtwoFthree 1 year ago
OMG that video sucks so badly
95nobody 1 year ago
sorry, but it sucks!
oneFtwoFthree 1 year ago
This girl is a murderer... Find her, slaughter her for spoiling the song with her horrible voice!! :(
jaibeniwal 1 year ago
omg her voice is horrible!
celeldonn 1 year ago
This is awesome, amazing voices. I'm always up for listening to remakes of my favourite metal songs
mubutukinkeke 1 year ago
the voice is not perfect for the song :-/
but the rest sounds good
franstef88 1 year ago
Ich war gestern in Local Bar. Dieses Lied war echt super. Für You Tube bessere Aufnahme tun!!!!
Eda
Edda142 2 years ago
TOO SOFT VOICE FOR THIS SONG
now i know why Van Canto is still the only real a capella metal band in the world
Gabe1Gabe 2 years ago
pls let do Van canto the metal-acappella-covers. rly, they're much better.....and more AWESOME!
GefroreneSeele 2 years ago
sing como el pico
jackwilsontube 2 years ago
I tried to like it but wtf come on they fucken killed the song that was so shit....i beg them not to ever cover another metallica song again
fatclown101 2 years ago 17
@fatclown101
If u like Metallica, I have to admit its not really the same, but what they just did here. Nice version. Sweet!!
JRBdPL 1 year ago
@fatclown101 anyone can cover a song, but you really need to know something about music to be able to sing acapella .. I think that they did a great job. This is an unique cover, not just another one. ;)
ZuzuliciMiller 1 year ago
crap if there is playback behind this as it seems!!
Armakettu 2 years ago 2
im a big metallica fan, and i must say...the original is better, but hey ur good too, even without instruments :D good job
SirGeforce 2 years ago
i like it
tanteronse 2 years ago
WTF
mitchthekitch 2 years ago 18
its crap
oO1mmortalOo 2 years ago
It messed up a good song, it could be done very well...But these guys... They just doenst fit at this song
Stewerrvideos 2 years ago 2
they suck they fucked up the song
entersandman500 2 years ago
It's just very nice, don't care how they sang it...
wasserpatschi 2 years ago
I would say the difference is that a cappella groups can sing without mics, but gudrun relies on mics plus they are using an instrument which is their loop machine. I suppose that without it they wouldn't be able to perform their songs a cappella. again, don't get me wrong, they sound good and I think especially the male vocalists have an incredible voice, but in my point of view it's not a cappella
hachimitsukumakichi 2 years ago 2
it's similar to what Naturally 7 does, though I have to say that they should be careful using the word "a cappella" because I think they might make some "real" a cappella groups angry. they are using lots of effects and a loop machine. it's a different style and i think it sounds good, but it is not a cappella
hachimitsukumakichi 2 years ago
They`re using theyre own voices without instruments, that´s what a cappella means. All the " real" a cappella groups are using a whole range of effects! Using no effect means standing on a stage without a microphone. But then they have to sing opera.
sidschi 2 years ago
a microphones a fucking effect now since when?
CHICKMAGNET66666 2 years ago