INSPIRATIONAL,UPLIFTING WITH HARD EARNED DEDICATION IS APPARENT IN THIS BRILLIANTLY PLAYED WORK.I WAS DEEPLY MOVED BY THE PASSION OF IT ALL THANKS FOR SHARING GROS MERCI
En este tiempo es muy raro encontrar una joven pianista que hace su trabajo con tanta seriedad, realmente estoy sorprendido de su sonido es espectacular, su "touche" es incomparable, es la versión mas fuerte que he escuchado, y se que tocarla requiere una madurez interpretativa profunda, felicidades, esres una gran pianista y el mundo te escuchará como una de las mejores intérpretes del piano, nunca me gusta hacer comparaciones pero eres heredera de Martha Argerich, solo que con más carácter.
very serious and deep, but the fugue for me is to nervous(to organlike). compare f.e. with a fazil say, his developping of the theme out of an almost schubertsche "himmlische länge" to a overwhelming finale- never heard this before (you can forget the original organ composition!)
She is just Fast Perfect To play Piano,(wy Fast?, because only the Infinity is 100% Perfect),and specially J.S.Bach and his cosmological Music for all Times.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Distinctively, one of the most overestimated pianists ever seen in public! There are several 10 year old children, highly talented or trained, who are able to so much more!
Molto brava questa giovane pianista, ma anche molto responsabile nella stratificazione dei piani sonori, nella combinazione del timbro con il fraseggio. Un lavoro enorme e difficile con questa composizione. Lise de la Salle merita un ricco carnet di concerti e tournées, anche perché ci sono tanti ragazzini già gonfi di megalomania, e tanti vecchi intepreti che si sono persi per strada nella loro lunga carriera ! Tante congratulazioni e buona fortuna Mademoiselle !
OK tout n' est peut être pas parfaitement exécuté, n'empêche que l' on sent une véritable musicalité et sincérité dans son interprétation. Et quand à ceux qui dise que son jeux est trop romantique (d' ailleurs celui d' Hélène Grimaud l' est beaucoup plus) pourquoi ne le serait-il pas? Je suis un fanatique de Glenn Gould et même plus encore mais cela ne m' empêche pas d' avoir envie d' entendre Bach sonner différemment. Lise de la Salle est à mon avis une pianiste qui fera beaucoup parler d' elle
~ Wow! That was absolutely beautiful! Any naysayers criticising the lovely woman's technique for not being true to Bach's interpretation could consider the naysayers of the mid 1850's or so. There would have been those who would have thought that this could/should only be played on a harpsichord. Lise de la salle, you obviously have the expertise to make this piece work with your incredibly clean pedaling technique as well as your overall mastery of the keyboard. Brava to you!
Wonderful to watch this after an extensive look at the strange goings on at 4chan. Goes to show how beautiful the human "soul" is, that such wonderful artworks can be created. What an amazing sound! She has true skill :D
I've never watched a classical music video, but this just completely relaxes me. Happiness in musical form to be delivered here!
Whatever bad might come of people, there's always the good; the light at the end of the tunnel, no matter how problematic we people are.
Yup - she does all the "right" things. Fluctuating tempi, subtly placed pauses, accented down beats to maintain meter...yup - all the "right" things. And somehow I am left cold. Is it me?
Mlle de la Salle a réussi à transformer la composition du maître de Eisenach (bien que filtré par le génie de Lizt) dans un chef-oeuvre romantique! Dieu, il me semble que Brahms joue le piano par ses doigts! Contrôle absolue de la dynamique, rien ici dans son interprétation n'est par hazard. Avec de la Salle cette oeuvre acquiert une dimension propre, détachée de l'original. Bravo.
@MYRHAH Elle est encore relativement jeune ce qui explique son côté réservé. Il faudrait une fois qu'elle prenne le temps de venir jouer cette magnifique pièce sur un grand orgue, et peut-être qu'ensuite, sur un piano, elle serait un peu moins discrète! En tout cas, c'est très bien joué!
Well this is certainly the most musical, fully detailed, nuanced, and pianistically controlled version I've heard yet.
I take issue with her super lyrical interpretation of the fugue, but she has such excellent command of her own intentions one can't but admire -- even if one disagrees with -- her realization of this tremendous work.
I would love to hear her Brahms-Handel Variations and Fugue. I imagine it would be spectacular.
I agree, her playing is so well thought out, one may not agree her interpretation but one has to respect the execution of her ideas. She is definitely a pianist to watch.
I think she is playing consistently with the fact that this is Liszt's transcription, not the original. Re the remark about the piano above, the piano does matter - there are very few pianos that have a decent bottom A, and this isn't one of them. That apart, I loved it (and her).
Poentinen takes too slow a tempo, which perhaps is suitable if you play on the organ. Lise de la Salle's tempo is the right one for piano with this transcription, in fact she succeeds in being much more dramatic than Poentinen's performance is.
This language it's Serbian, and it says: The girl is beautiful, but too many smells bad in the Bach boredom. Smor! - Which would Belgraders said... I must admit that I don't understand what he means with "many bad smells" PDA: you should try the google translator it's really awesome!!!
Divine. I especially like her opening statement of the fugue. Looks easy on paper, but deceptively difficult to produce this kind of tone and sensitivity. For me the hardest part of the fugue is that it is long thus hard to keep the audience with you til the end. Bravo to you!
I was always taught that if you cannot say something nice, then do not say anything at all. There is never any reason to be rude, especially to omeone who you may not even know.
I find her interpretation of this transcription was well thought out and played quite beautifully.
She play's so fabulously the pianoforte, but regrettably she is incredibly ugly. I really can't look at her when she play's I would not be able to evince her genius for that. By the way, have you ever managed to watch Mitsuko Uchida without laughing?! =P
Maybe I exagerated someway my laud for Mrs. de la Salle. But, I mean, her technique isn't bad at all! Even if her interpretation leaves a lot to be desired her playing, in this video at least, is beautiful. However, concerning her air, there's no accounting for taste =P, personnaly, even if it's harsh, I can't bear her face.
Can you figure out that I needed three days to understand who the second genius you mentionned was?! Your sentence really obsessed me xD! Anyway, was a nice one!
A mon avis, il s´agit d´une belle, feminine et charmante interpretation de cette magnifique maurceau de Bach. Je crois que la conception religieuse et fortement poétique de YUDINA est insuperable, evidement. Toutefois, c´est trés, trés beau, j´amais beacoup! Bravo!! Il y a beaucoup de lirism aussi e j´adore. Merci, mademoiselle, Vous étes une excelente jeune pianiste.
She is a great pianist,no doubt but I have to say that the instrument she is playing on it is just great amazing!The sound of this instrument helps the pianist a lot.I think it is Steinway,I love Steinway!!
Wonderful performance. It is refreshing to hear a pianist break away from crowd of Bach purist (this is a transcription after all). Bach is great music no matter how it is played. This performance is well worth listening to. A pianist to watch.
I enjoyed this.-The playing does resemble Chopin, doesn't it?-I believe Liszt envisioned his transcription of Bach's organ fugue for piano(romantic instrument par excellence) with the performer bringing out a BIG SOUND (as one creates with a pipe organ) suitable for concert halls but where the tempo remains steady with few deviations. I play both these, and understand their challenges and their opportunities for individual interpretation which are what make them such magnificent pieces. - EdB.
I dont said that.The piece is bach.Nothing changes that...But because the transcription made by Liszt the piece has romantic colours. As you said Liszt tried to stay true to Bach.And something else.The piece sounds very very good but the piano is not organ. I think you mean the last section at the end with the bass notes. Anyway amazing transcription.
Liszt didn't change anything of relevance. He mainly trancsribed the notes played with the pedal on the organ into bass notes on the piano (listen to the organ interpration or check out the sheet which is free on the internet). It remains an orchestral baroque piece throughout. Whatever traits of "romantism" you might find in this work were already there (this is very different of Busoni's "transcription" of the Chaconne). Nothing justifies playing this prelude & fugue in a romantic way.
Too romantic? Do you ever heard liszt?? This transcription made by liszt!!!! The piece is bach but the transcription belongs to great romantic piano genius FRANZ LISZT!!! Read books!!!!!
Je vous découvre pour la première fois. Grâce au partage,de "izox29" que je remercie... Je voulais vous dire que j'apprécie votre sensibilité et votre talent.
jaloux de koi ? jouer ds des eglises et faire 40 concerts par an .. ya rien a envier , je crois ce ke je vois et ce ke j ecoute.
De tte facon ,bravo aux conservatoires de maintenant ou les professeurs ne sont mm pas des musiciens mais des arrivistes voulant faire carriere ds la musique.
Je comprends que cela vous dépasse, mais passons. De toute façon, vos précédents commentaires disqualifiaient votre capacité d'écoute; je préfère encore votre argument des 40 concerts: il nous dévoile pour le même prix votre niveau dialectique.
Tu as raison, on ne peut pas jouer les études de Liszt si on est un amateur. Mais comment appeler un professionnel qui enregistre ces mêmes études comme premier disque? Avait il quelque chose à prouver ? Lise de la Salle elle n'a rien a prouver, et ses disques en témoignent.
je dirais plutôt que c'était un grand culot de la part de Chamayou de faire cet enregistrement magnifique, qui soutient très bien la comparaison avec celui de Cziffra. Il y a très peu d'enregistrements des études de Liszt...
Quant à Lise de la Salle, je ne connais pas ses disques mais l'extrait est posté ici me paraît trop romantique pour une oeuvre de Bach (même transcrite par Liszt, qui est ici absolument fidèle à l'original). Les ralentis cassent la pulsation fondamentale de l'oeuvre.
Je pense plutot que les tempi choisis sont beaucoup trop eleves... elle semble prendre ce morceau comme une epreuve de virtuosite plutot que le moment d'inspiration et genialite Bachienne qu'il est (a mon avis). Du coup elle est obligee d'ajouter des ralentis pour ne pas trop melanger les idees musicales. L'oeuvre est magnifique et d'autres pianistes ont capture son essence de facon plus logique, a mon gout.
small hands, big sound! the fugue is well-constructed, she knows how to bank her fires...excellent dynamic contrast and precisely put together. She will go far, amazing ability for one so young. As for the nasty criticisms---a lot of sour grapes from the un-talented whiners!!
re PS pour Bs2K6 : une petite visite chez un spécialiste de l'audition me semble s'imposer, tu dois ( à ton insu comme souvent ) souffrir de troubles auditifs majeurs...
re PPS : et pourquoi ne pas nous avoir dit plus tôt que tu étais dans la même classe que Lise de la Salle (au début, au tout début en première année de solfège... Pourquoi n'avoir pas continué la musique ?? )
Look people, she is trying to make it sound like an organ. It's not Romantic Bach, it is Liszt's transcription of an organ piece. That said, the interpretation is dull and this kid is way too immature a pianist for her to have a major recording contract. She plays like a talented student.
Nous sommes si aveugles que nous ne savons que quand nous devons nous affliger et non nous réjouir : nous n'avons presque jamais que de fausses tristesses ou de fausses joies. C'est vrai pour vous!!!!!
You hope I get blown up in Iraq? Fine. I hope your Algerian and Moroccan slaves blow you up next time they decide to riot. While your police stand around with their hands raised of course.
Il arrive parfois qu'une pianiste et un piano êtres cette impression de se retrouver sur le chemin de la Vie. Comme s'ils n'avaient été jusque là que provisoirement séparés. Comme si l'un et l'autre s'attendaient. C'est vrai pour Lise et son instrument..Love
Quand je revois cette video je ne comprend toujours pas le choix qui a été fait aux précedentes victoires de la musique classique de nominer cet amateur de Bertrand Chamayou, qui s'était présenté avec un programme on ne peut plus raccoleur ( valse de chopin entre autre), a la place de cette jeune génie qui a su présenter des oeuvres non banales, et qui joue avec une telle ferveur et un tel respect de l'oeuvre que l'on ne peut douter que Bach et Liszt s'en réjouissent de là-haut...
While you are spouting off your list of supposedly "authentic" pianists, fortepianists, and harpsichordists, you should know Bach wrote this piece for the organ. Learn something before you pontificate.
wow, she plays very good, but the pedal makes some sounds a little bit unclearly, and she should take some passages a little bit more piano. even when its liszt.
SAAALLE!!!! alles klar?
Onkelz0307 1 day ago
Tellement parfait! magnifique! merci Mme. de la Salle
1862Debussy 3 weeks ago
INSPIRATIONAL,UPLIFTING WITH HARD EARNED DEDICATION IS APPARENT IN THIS BRILLIANTLY PLAYED WORK.I WAS DEEPLY MOVED BY THE PASSION OF IT ALL THANKS FOR SHARING GROS MERCI
AllanDavidRock 2 months ago
She's amazing, her music is so beautiful and full of emotion etc...
AND I would totally do her.
stmaur0 2 months ago
L'esprit de l'orgue et le plus du piano!
graverol1 2 months ago
Epoustouflant !!!!!!!!!!!
graverol1 2 months ago
Can somebody tell me where to find tgis music sheet? Thank you ;)
FranciscaB15 2 months ago
@FranciscaB15 Try imslp.org I found it here
MelomanETP 1 month ago
@FranciscaB15 imslp.org
guigodoipiano 1 week ago
En este tiempo es muy raro encontrar una joven pianista que hace su trabajo con tanta seriedad, realmente estoy sorprendido de su sonido es espectacular, su "touche" es incomparable, es la versión mas fuerte que he escuchado, y se que tocarla requiere una madurez interpretativa profunda, felicidades, esres una gran pianista y el mundo te escuchará como una de las mejores intérpretes del piano, nunca me gusta hacer comparaciones pero eres heredera de Martha Argerich, solo que con más carácter.
Multieduardo1962 3 months ago
extreamly GOOOOD
djnikok1 3 months ago
very serious and deep, but the fugue for me is to nervous(to organlike). compare f.e. with a fazil say, his developping of the theme out of an almost schubertsche "himmlische länge" to a overwhelming finale- never heard this before (you can forget the original organ composition!)
flutetravers 3 months ago
She is just Fast Perfect To play Piano,(wy Fast?, because only the Infinity is 100% Perfect),and specially J.S.Bach and his cosmological Music for all Times.
I love the Way she plays classic Music.
Keyhan37 4 months ago
Comment removed
Keyhan37 4 months ago
Comment removed
Keyhan37 4 months ago
This is a highly personal interpretation for sure but I think both Bach and Liszt allow for that. I find it convincing and beautiful.
lamazopa21 4 months ago
can't wait for her concert in Dallas on November 20th.
wisdomleader85 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Distinctively, one of the most overestimated pianists ever seen in public! There are several 10 year old children, highly talented or trained, who are able to so much more!
Abraeumer83 6 months ago
@Abraeumer83 So you've said on other Lise de la Salle videos. Now go back to sleep.
LouiseCerrutti 5 months ago
very nice tone... but it doesnt remind an organ!
good playing anyway
newFranzFerencLiszt 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WTF? I dont think women should play piano pieces written by men ! She deserves a kitchen, that lil ginger cunt!!
manupee 7 months ago
@manupee Computers were invented by a genius, so I think your kind of trolls shouldn't use it :p
mafiashadow 6 months ago
tiny tiny tinny tone
Webarton 7 months ago
Would it have been so difficult to upload the piece with the whole first bar?
Barbapippo 8 months ago
Molto brava questa giovane pianista, ma anche molto responsabile nella stratificazione dei piani sonori, nella combinazione del timbro con il fraseggio. Un lavoro enorme e difficile con questa composizione. Lise de la Salle merita un ricco carnet di concerti e tournées, anche perché ci sono tanti ragazzini già gonfi di megalomania, e tanti vecchi intepreti che si sono persi per strada nella loro lunga carriera ! Tante congratulazioni e buona fortuna Mademoiselle !
darkblueangel1956 8 months ago
like
philo152 8 months ago
OK tout n' est peut être pas parfaitement exécuté, n'empêche que l' on sent une véritable musicalité et sincérité dans son interprétation. Et quand à ceux qui dise que son jeux est trop romantique (d' ailleurs celui d' Hélène Grimaud l' est beaucoup plus) pourquoi ne le serait-il pas? Je suis un fanatique de Glenn Gould et même plus encore mais cela ne m' empêche pas d' avoir envie d' entendre Bach sonner différemment. Lise de la Salle est à mon avis une pianiste qui fera beaucoup parler d' elle
apuland 9 months ago
So beautiful, graceful, and elegant. Miss Lise is fantastic!
chobeethaninov 10 months ago
What a splendidly graceful style
TheLastYogurt 11 months ago
~ Wow! That was absolutely beautiful! Any naysayers criticising the lovely woman's technique for not being true to Bach's interpretation could consider the naysayers of the mid 1850's or so. There would have been those who would have thought that this could/should only be played on a harpsichord. Lise de la salle, you obviously have the expertise to make this piece work with your incredibly clean pedaling technique as well as your overall mastery of the keyboard. Brava to you!
Ron
( ;-} >
moonpagan 1 year ago 2
I always loved this fugue, but I loved it how it sounds in my head from the score.
She is the first pianist from whom I like as it sounds on piano. Really great!
sseerrgg14 1 year ago
A truly great performance. I can almost hear the organ sound from this.
4001TD 1 year ago
OMGWTFBBQ !!! O.O
NARUTOSHIPPUDENGEEK 1 year ago
OMGWTFBBQ !!!
NARUTOSHIPPUDENGEEK 1 year ago
Wonderful to watch this after an extensive look at the strange goings on at 4chan. Goes to show how beautiful the human "soul" is, that such wonderful artworks can be created. What an amazing sound! She has true skill :D
I've never watched a classical music video, but this just completely relaxes me. Happiness in musical form to be delivered here!
Whatever bad might come of people, there's always the good; the light at the end of the tunnel, no matter how problematic we people are.
tarkinfish 1 year ago 3
The part starting at 6:23 is really incredible!!! can't stop listening ang gives me incredible shivers!!!!!
Bravo Lise!!!!
Listend to other versions of this prelude and she is the only one providing this kind of effect!!!!!
MarijeanneMarley 1 year ago 2
my God..... Bach is amazing, liszt is helfpul and De La Salle is Magnificent!
ozielich 1 year ago 2
Absoluement splendide!!!
Bravo!!
MarijeanneMarley 1 year ago
C'est très très beau ... Bravo !
BellaBBCRR 1 year ago
wonderful - and v sexy - Bach in heels
lsbrother 1 year ago
Yup - she does all the "right" things. Fluctuating tempi, subtly placed pauses, accented down beats to maintain meter...yup - all the "right" things. And somehow I am left cold. Is it me?
lourak 1 year ago
@lourak
yes, it is you
lsbrother 1 year ago
@lourak I find it to be a very, very good interpretation. Which one do you prefer?
JEESherazi 1 year ago
@lourak Undoubtedly it is you - that was absolutely superb
chirpybee 8 months ago
divin !
Blezer77 1 year ago
Great playing I would give you 1000000000 likes but I can only give 1 ;(
Whos is that man sitting over there?
urbano277 1 year ago
Mlle de la Salle a réussi à transformer la composition du maître de Eisenach (bien que filtré par le génie de Lizt) dans un chef-oeuvre romantique! Dieu, il me semble que Brahms joue le piano par ses doigts! Contrôle absolue de la dynamique, rien ici dans son interprétation n'est par hazard. Avec de la Salle cette oeuvre acquiert une dimension propre, détachée de l'original. Bravo.
vaisvavata 1 year ago
To use a cliche, Lise de la Salle's Bach is so beautiful it hurts.
Her ecstasy, though, is never overbearing.
Within her, femininity and gravitas live happily side by side.
She has that big, glorious Russian sound without that big, glorious Russian inhibitions.
She cannot play Mozart.
God works in mysterious ways.
romangitlin 1 year ago 2
can't stop crying during this whole version ...
thanks liszt for having transcribed it in a perfect way.
thanks lise for playing it like if bach and liszt were inside your soul.
amidunet 1 year ago
Doskonale, młoda Damo
Doskonale !!
justap20 1 year ago
great, like glenn gould...
quetzalandino 1 year ago
@quetzalandino What Glen Gould got to do with it?
romangitlin 1 year ago
i think its wonderful :)
Squehz 1 year ago
John 3:16"For God soloved the world that He gave His one and only Son that whoever believes in Him shall not perish but have everlasting life"
It's your choice.
armyofgrace 1 year ago
I hate you
demiiiLovato1 1 year ago
4.2.10 in dortmund
werner99 2 years ago
cette pianiste est fine, précise, son jeu est clair, son discours bien conduit. Un peu réservée au début, elle sait finir avec étoffe.
MYRHAH 2 years ago
@MYRHAH Elle est encore relativement jeune ce qui explique son côté réservé. Il faudrait une fois qu'elle prenne le temps de venir jouer cette magnifique pièce sur un grand orgue, et peut-être qu'ensuite, sur un piano, elle serait un peu moins discrète! En tout cas, c'est très bien joué!
Brelaz2007 1 year ago
@MYRHAH cest le début justement que j'adore. elle est la seule à jouer ceci avec reserve comme tu dis, et c'est tellement beau
amidunet 1 year ago
ужасно.
edarjane 2 years ago
0:58, there's a mistake
(A G# that shouldn't be there i think)
Eddywards 2 years ago
Actually, it's a natural C, sorry.
Eddywards 2 years ago
She is playing so well;such a strong performance!
And yes it is a Steinway; but not a concert grand,upon which
she plays(maybe B model) Doesn't matter. She rocks the piano;and gets great harpsichord colors from it too.
Fantastic!
TheJmd441 2 years ago 2
c''st marrant qu'elle n'utilise pas la 3eme pédale pour tout le début........afin de tenir le "la " grave .......
papillondenuit1970 2 years ago
Comment removed
ChopRachma 1 year ago
Well this is certainly the most musical, fully detailed, nuanced, and pianistically controlled version I've heard yet.
I take issue with her super lyrical interpretation of the fugue, but she has such excellent command of her own intentions one can't but admire -- even if one disagrees with -- her realization of this tremendous work.
I would love to hear her Brahms-Handel Variations and Fugue. I imagine it would be spectacular.
Pischnaholic 2 years ago 33
I agree, her playing is so well thought out, one may not agree her interpretation but one has to respect the execution of her ideas. She is definitely a pianist to watch.
58pianos 2 years ago
I think she is playing consistently with the fact that this is Liszt's transcription, not the original. Re the remark about the piano above, the piano does matter - there are very few pianos that have a decent bottom A, and this isn't one of them. That apart, I loved it (and her).
gspaulsson 2 years ago
and mostly interpretation
TheManSAberi 2 years ago
this was good but poentinen's rips this apart in musicality. Je suis desolee :P
TheManSAberi 2 years ago
Poentinen takes too slow a tempo, which perhaps is suitable if you play on the organ. Lise de la Salle's tempo is the right one for piano with this transcription, in fact she succeeds in being much more dramatic than Poentinen's performance is.
Maspixxx 2 years ago
The sound recording is not very well, same goes for the video, but what a magnificant performance!
slempieh 2 years ago
But it's an steinway ! Just the quality of sounds is very bad.
Venoks 2 years ago
i cant believe its an steinway
stagesix6 2 years ago
In the recording she is excellent. I like it here a little less, but maybe is the instrument.
kikakon 2 years ago
Nice shoes beyond all.
leomulder 2 years ago
the final of the fugue ( 6:24 ) gets me every time , so sublim !
krone191 2 years ago
bach...toute la musique est la !!
lemusiclover01 2 years ago
Much movement
Few polyphony
Bahhh.........
lokopiano
lokopiano 2 years ago
who is the man watchinh her
marrieter08 2 years ago
her husband lol
diegobross 2 years ago
No. He is too old for her.
leomulder 2 years ago
The age isn't important to love XD
diegobross 2 years ago
Девојка је лепа, али ми Бах превише смрди на досаду. Смор! - што би Београђани рекли.
VizantOr 2 years ago
Traduction, please !
Traduction, s'il vous plaît !!!
Silvio823 2 years ago
This language it's Serbian, and it says: The girl is beautiful, but too many smells bad in the Bach boredom. Smor! - Which would Belgraders said... I must admit that I don't understand what he means with "many bad smells" PDA: you should try the google translator it's really awesome!!!
kirisuconductor 2 years ago
Wow!
leomulder 2 years ago
she is incredible,
barvo jolie demoiselle!!
cjbsexx 2 years ago
Divine. I especially like her opening statement of the fugue. Looks easy on paper, but deceptively difficult to produce this kind of tone and sensitivity. For me the hardest part of the fugue is that it is long thus hard to keep the audience with you til the end. Bravo to you!
frenchmusician12 2 years ago 8
Very good performance!
PianoPlayer07 2 years ago
Wow!!! Incredible...
dale3858 2 years ago
I was always taught that if you cannot say something nice, then do not say anything at all. There is never any reason to be rude, especially to omeone who you may not even know.
I find her interpretation of this transcription was well thought out and played quite beautifully.
I also find her quite beautiful.
58pianos 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
She play's so fabulously the pianoforte, but regrettably she is incredibly ugly. I really can't look at her when she play's I would not be able to evince her genius for that. By the way, have you ever managed to watch Mitsuko Uchida without laughing?! =P
Vlaanderson 2 years ago
That was very rude. She is beautiful, but not the genius you claim she is at all.
parazsdavid 2 years ago
Maybe I exagerated someway my laud for Mrs. de la Salle. But, I mean, her technique isn't bad at all! Even if her interpretation leaves a lot to be desired her playing, in this video at least, is beautiful. However, concerning her air, there's no accounting for taste =P, personnaly, even if it's harsh, I can't bear her face.
Vlaanderson 2 years ago
you're both fucked
supermanifold 2 years ago 3
I see two great geniuses in this video, and neither of them are sat in a red chair.
Milligan1932 2 years ago 2
Can you figure out that I needed three days to understand who the second genius you mentionned was?! Your sentence really obsessed me xD! Anyway, was a nice one!
Vlaanderson 2 years ago
Wouldn't that make four with the transcriber ? ^^
Zinston 2 years ago
oh gosh,her fingers are exatcly like mine!
great performance!
niitac 2 years ago
Bellissimo!
giuseppedolce 3 years ago
There's a mistake at 0:57, but it's an excellent performance.
Nevertheless i prefer Fazil Say's one.
Eddywards 3 years ago
you'd have never thought that Bach was this intense, but thanks to Liszt, it really doesn't get any better than this.
Hats off to La Salle for a most exquisite performance.
supermanifold 3 years ago
This is really great. Great transcription and very well played! BachScholar approves!
BachScholar 3 years ago
listening to her play this pieace is truely amazing. she is and great pianist.
keymaster47 3 years ago
Elle a quel âge là ?
v4liumfrance 3 years ago
20 ans. Elle est superbe!
bernardocarmopiano 3 years ago
A mon avis, il s´agit d´une belle, feminine et charmante interpretation de cette magnifique maurceau de Bach. Je crois que la conception religieuse et fortement poétique de YUDINA est insuperable, evidement. Toutefois, c´est trés, trés beau, j´amais beacoup! Bravo!! Il y a beaucoup de lirism aussi e j´adore. Merci, mademoiselle, Vous étes une excelente jeune pianiste.
bernardocarmopiano 3 years ago
un pur bonheur également.
neuroblastome 3 years ago
Tout simplement génial.
Theodosius3308 3 years ago
An absolute new entry in my collection
of rarely performed bachian works.Thx,for posting.
I guess F.Liszt personally would appreciate
this rendition.I dont't like this work but I
did appreciate this performance.
indigoblue555 3 years ago
She is a great pianist,no doubt but I have to say that the instrument she is playing on it is just great amazing!The sound of this instrument helps the pianist a lot.I think it is Steinway,I love Steinway!!
go9zu 3 years ago
mi hai fatto venire i brividi, grazie mille
knodor 3 years ago
Wonderful performance. It is refreshing to hear a pianist break away from crowd of Bach purist (this is a transcription after all). Bach is great music no matter how it is played. This performance is well worth listening to. A pianist to watch.
58pianos 3 years ago
I enjoyed this.-The playing does resemble Chopin, doesn't it?-I believe Liszt envisioned his transcription of Bach's organ fugue for piano(romantic instrument par excellence) with the performer bringing out a BIG SOUND (as one creates with a pipe organ) suitable for concert halls but where the tempo remains steady with few deviations. I play both these, and understand their challenges and their opportunities for individual interpretation which are what make them such magnificent pieces. - EdB.
Edbrye2008 3 years ago
She uses to much pedal for my taste.
Rayek145 3 years ago 2
I dont said that.The piece is bach.Nothing changes that...But because the transcription made by Liszt the piece has romantic colours. As you said Liszt tried to stay true to Bach.And something else.The piece sounds very very good but the piano is not organ. I think you mean the last section at the end with the bass notes. Anyway amazing transcription.
INKOBITS3 3 years ago
Liszt didn't change anything of relevance. He mainly trancsribed the notes played with the pedal on the organ into bass notes on the piano (listen to the organ interpration or check out the sheet which is free on the internet). It remains an orchestral baroque piece throughout. Whatever traits of "romantism" you might find in this work were already there (this is very different of Busoni's "transcription" of the Chaconne). Nothing justifies playing this prelude & fugue in a romantic way.
jessedarvas 3 years ago
which BWV is it?
lebosurfeur 3 years ago
This is BWV 543 Preludium and Fugue in A, transcribed by Liszt Ferenc.
gergely06 3 years ago
Sorry, Preludium and Fugue in a.
gergely06 3 years ago
It's not romantic. Liszt tried to stay true to Bach. He wtranscripted it so that the piano sounds like organ.
Rayek145 3 years ago
Too romantic? Do you ever heard liszt?? This transcription made by liszt!!!! The piece is bach but the transcription belongs to great romantic piano genius FRANZ LISZT!!! Read books!!!!!
INKOBITS3 3 years ago
too romantic... that's not Chopin! don't like it anyway
komzomele 3 years ago
Je vous découvre pour la première fois. Grâce au partage,de "izox29" que je remercie... Je voulais vous dire que j'apprécie votre sensibilité et votre talent.
jacques de paris
lepaintre123 3 years ago
Peut être un poil trop "romantisé" mais elle a néanmoins une très grande variété de timbres apréciable.
Slava69 3 years ago
This is awesome, like the tone alot and very nice tempo! 4,75 stars --> will be 5
michieldpiano 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
t qui toi pour me critiquer ? t ki ? t koi ? t rien . un francais de + qui parle . honte a moi d etre francais et c est cela le + difficile ..
d etre francais en france !
bs2k6 3 years ago
jaloux de koi ? jouer ds des eglises et faire 40 concerts par an .. ya rien a envier , je crois ce ke je vois et ce ke j ecoute.
De tte facon ,bravo aux conservatoires de maintenant ou les professeurs ne sont mm pas des musiciens mais des arrivistes voulant faire carriere ds la musique.
bs2k6 3 years ago
Je comprends que cela vous dépasse, mais passons. De toute façon, vos précédents commentaires disqualifiaient votre capacité d'écoute; je préfère encore votre argument des 40 concerts: il nous dévoile pour le même prix votre niveau dialectique.
TONICOSWORTH 3 years ago
She looks thin, fragile. But her sound is great!
-----------------------------
Rolf, Netherlands.
I am a collector of classical 78's and lp's
Click "otterhouse" above to see (and hear!)
some of my collection.
otterhouse 3 years ago
How great isn't she?! She is borned 1990. ... No further comments.
Pianisteny2k 3 years ago
She isn't! She was born 1988! But anyway, she's great!
samsauter 3 years ago
she's great and she's my favorite. that's because i only heard her; a classical pianist. i recently know about her on kidteen news.
christinaxbaby 3 years ago 2
Tu as raison, on ne peut pas jouer les études de Liszt si on est un amateur. Mais comment appeler un professionnel qui enregistre ces mêmes études comme premier disque? Avait il quelque chose à prouver ? Lise de la Salle elle n'a rien a prouver, et ses disques en témoignent.
MoseMendelssohn 3 years ago
je dirais plutôt que c'était un grand culot de la part de Chamayou de faire cet enregistrement magnifique, qui soutient très bien la comparaison avec celui de Cziffra. Il y a très peu d'enregistrements des études de Liszt...
Quant à Lise de la Salle, je ne connais pas ses disques mais l'extrait est posté ici me paraît trop romantique pour une oeuvre de Bach (même transcrite par Liszt, qui est ici absolument fidèle à l'original). Les ralentis cassent la pulsation fondamentale de l'oeuvre.
jessedarvas 3 years ago
Je pense plutot que les tempi choisis sont beaucoup trop eleves... elle semble prendre ce morceau comme une epreuve de virtuosite plutot que le moment d'inspiration et genialite Bachienne qu'il est (a mon avis). Du coup elle est obligee d'ajouter des ralentis pour ne pas trop melanger les idees musicales. L'oeuvre est magnifique et d'autres pianistes ont capture son essence de facon plus logique, a mon gout.
nmaulide 3 years ago
Who's the guy in the red chair??
ghmus7 3 years ago 2
i've played with her :)
JuliaRilling 3 years ago
played...a game of whist?
kitsune11888 3 years ago
small hands, big sound! the fugue is well-constructed, she knows how to bank her fires...excellent dynamic contrast and precisely put together. She will go far, amazing ability for one so young. As for the nasty criticisms---a lot of sour grapes from the un-talented whiners!!
kallitype 4 years ago 4
re PS pour Bs2K6 : une petite visite chez un spécialiste de l'audition me semble s'imposer, tu dois ( à ton insu comme souvent ) souffrir de troubles auditifs majeurs...
re PPS : et pourquoi ne pas nous avoir dit plus tôt que tu étais dans la même classe que Lise de la Salle (au début, au tout début en première année de solfège... Pourquoi n'avoir pas continué la musique ?? )
MoseMendelssohn 4 years ago 2
Messieurs qui critiquez avec tant de verve
on attend avec impatience vos propres productions, vous qui de votre toute petite hauteur nous infligez vos pontifiantes critiques. A méditer
PS: merci de ne parler que de pianos et de pianistes
MoseMendelssohn 4 years ago 2
Look people, she is trying to make it sound like an organ. It's not Romantic Bach, it is Liszt's transcription of an organ piece. That said, the interpretation is dull and this kid is way too immature a pianist for her to have a major recording contract. She plays like a talented student.
artie6666 4 years ago
Nous sommes si aveugles que nous ne savons que quand nous devons nous affliger et non nous réjouir : nous n'avons presque jamais que de fausses tristesses ou de fausses joies. C'est vrai pour vous!!!!!
loveforladyday 4 years ago
Va te faire foutre, frog. You wouldn't know sadness or joy if it bit you in the ass. Ribbit!
artie6666 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fils de pute de cow boys de merde. Va crever en irak
loveforladyday 4 years ago
You hope I get blown up in Iraq? Fine. I hope your Algerian and Moroccan slaves blow you up next time they decide to riot. While your police stand around with their hands raised of course.
artie6666 4 years ago
lol j'aime bien le contraste entre les 2 posts -)
dfd2020 3 years ago
Il arrive parfois qu'une pianiste et un piano êtres cette impression de se retrouver sur le chemin de la Vie. Comme s'ils n'avaient été jusque là que provisoirement séparés. Comme si l'un et l'autre s'attendaient. C'est vrai pour Lise et son instrument..Love
loveforladyday 4 years ago
Il y a des pianistes que l'on appelle grands, comme il y a des tisanes que l'on baptise champagne. A MEDITER
loveforladyday 4 years ago
ou est l utilité de faire de la musique quand on ne joue que les notes ?
à méditer !
vs voulez ecoutez de grands pianistes actuellement, tournez vous vers evgeny kissin , krystian zimerman , jean yves thibaudet , arcadi volodos etc..
bs2k6 4 years ago
Génie! Rythme magnifique, elle comprends tous ce qu'elle joue. harmoniquement et melodiquement, une FRANCAISE en bref. SUPERBE...........
loveforladyday 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
genie ? aucun rythme , elle ne comprends pas ce k elle joue harmoniquement et melodiquement , une asiatique en bref . honteux
bs2k6 4 years ago
K ELLE???
loveforladyday 4 years ago
totalement sourd, ce pauvre bs
ou alors pianiste raté bavant de jalousie
TONICOSWORTH 3 years ago
C'est vraiment bien, j'espère la voir un jour jouer le prélude et fugue BWV 532 de Bach par Busoni...
givemetime123 4 years ago
Oh my godness! If i am a piano...
loveforladyday 4 years ago
She has something attractive about her
bachkorea 4 years ago 4
DEESSE DU PIANO.MERCI
loveforladyday 4 years ago
I'm in love.
Only one criticism (of either Liszt or Steinway, not Miss Lasalle): I've never yet heard a piano with a good bottom A.
gspaulsson 4 years ago 2
CELA S ECOUTE SANS COMMENTAIRE....
niko34g 4 years ago 2
et ca se fait comment que t'en a fait un a la fin?
rrdforlowprices 4 years ago
LOL excellente question !!! ^^
Tazeruk 4 years ago
Quand je revois cette video je ne comprend toujours pas le choix qui a été fait aux précedentes victoires de la musique classique de nominer cet amateur de Bertrand Chamayou, qui s'était présenté avec un programme on ne peut plus raccoleur ( valse de chopin entre autre), a la place de cette jeune génie qui a su présenter des oeuvres non banales, et qui joue avec une telle ferveur et un tel respect de l'oeuvre que l'on ne peut douter que Bach et Liszt s'en réjouissent de là-haut...
MoseMendelssohn 4 years ago 3
Tous est dit.
loveforladyday 4 years ago
Bertrand Chamayou, un amateur??
Si vous connaissez beaucoup d'amateurs qui jouent les études de Lizst comme lui, il faudrait nous les signaler..
jessedarvas 3 years ago
This is a very good pianistic performance of an organ piece.
snaaptaker 4 years ago 2
While you are spouting off your list of supposedly "authentic" pianists, fortepianists, and harpsichordists, you should know Bach wrote this piece for the organ. Learn something before you pontificate.
snaaptaker 4 years ago
on n'en a strictement rien à foutre.
TONICOSWORTH 3 years ago
(c'était une réponse à snapptaker et son orgue
mais la réponse ne s'est pas inscrite comme prévu)
TONICOSWORTH 3 years ago
Let me note that what she plays here is not the original Bach, not Bach's Urtext. It's Bach in Liszt's transcription. It's not exactly the same.
Yes, the general title of the video is somehow deceiving.
letzteErinnerung 4 years ago
wow, she plays very good, but the pedal makes some sounds a little bit unclearly, and she should take some passages a little bit more piano. even when its liszt.
tastibasti 4 years ago
what BWV is this?
iaanwoo 4 years ago
The BWV number is 543.
seiko1982 4 years ago
thank you
iaanwoo 4 years ago
Magnifiquo!
Magnifique!
Magnificant!
:D
Dudette0007 4 years ago
great!
piano6861 4 years ago
I watch this video every day since one week.She plays so nice Bach,so much passion!I love her playing!
go9zu 4 years ago 2