South African Idols 2009 - Saddest Audition Ever!! Shame

[TheNettie25]

How can you do that?...very unprofessional and immature....shame on you judges!!!

[TEAMxEPICxSPACE]

Shit.... It's a cold world

[MyTwilightfan2010]

ek dink sy is goet ! lol  dit is 'n bietjie snaaks !

[beamprimary]

i love the way at the end there was some good music lol

[GymnastClan]

that was really messed up she is a really good singer curse you judges and your loss

[bouse23]

in fairness the girl deserved some respect

[123skyball1]

i hope the judges tripped (or died) on their way out

[ElizabethJae]

Now that's fucked up... But honestly an "idol" in SA was a bad idea period.

[alexvanderstarre]

okay now THAT'S fucking rude

[TheMschellybaby]

With some vocal lessons she could be really good. I see the potential there.

[mirehman]

This is not fair... they should have said something... judges suck!!!

[Solja88]

They were able to leave cos she closed her eyes, lol.

[Divajacqui]

very immature of adults who should be acting like adults! seriously 4 idiots!

[Bradhadair11]

lol that was fantastic!! Well done Judges!! She couldn't sing to save her life

[CheeseChuckie]

no she should try pursue a career in singing if anything they did her a favor.

[carly11000]

she was like meh!!! ill live!!!

[SincereKouture]

lmaooooooooooooo 

[MzLisha1443]

SHE WASNT EVEN THAT BAD

[MzLisha1443]

oooooooo!!!!THEY WRONG FOR THAT

[MissBiguk]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!! OMG The judges are deep!!!

[capitnox]

Firstly, anyone oUTSIDE of south africa stereotyping and calling all south africans rude should go jump. Secondly, anyone iN or OUTSIDE South africa who thinks this girl can sing is completely deluded...we have standards (Or at least I do)- that rendition was completely cacophonous. Thirdly, this video is utterly hilarious- the Judges did her justice by leaving coz the comments that could have come out of Randall's (one of the judges) mouth would have rendered her catatonic. So stop hating.

[TheBlackoutCiircus]

stupid whore

[britneyspears8838]

She doesn't know the words.

[itsmorrgan]

that was so mean :(

[DJmusic4life900]

That was very mean but shhhiiitttt funnnnnnnnnnnnnny

[avatar572]

LMFAO !!

[UniqueMonique513]

sorry....BUT AFRICANS JUST CANT SING!! (Noted OBSERVANCE)

[iceeyx3]

@UniqueMonique513

stfu bitch u cant sinqqqq

[UniqueMonique513]

@iceeyx3 Either can u..SO SUCK A COCK! FAT WHITE ONE!

[AjTazz1]

@UniqueMonique513 You're an idiot for saying that!!

[UniqueMonique513]

@AjTazz1 U cant be saying someones idiot..WHEN ITS THE TRUTH! (Duh)

[AjTazz1]

@UniqueMonique513 Well I said it, you're an IDIOT!!!

[UniqueMonique513]

@UniqueMonique513 Ok ..since u wanna smart..Where besides on HERE ON YOUTUBE Have u seen 1 VIDEO THAT HAS ONE african person singing a NOTE IN TUNE!??..Besides on African/American Idol or whatever u wanna call it..Dont worry I'll wait

[TheMelodyMusic177]

@UniqueMonique513 --we are african and we sing in tune.. :/ what you tryna sayy?

[rotazchik1]

@waterpolomaster11 haaaaaa cunt bag you're a funny bitch. Assholes like you're dumbass take criticism tooooo seriously....I'm on about the judges, get your facts right before commenting you're bullshit to me or keep you're elephantitis mouth shut....biiiiaaarccchhhhhh

[b4life1994]

They only did that because she kept her eyes closed and wanted to see if she was ever going to open them. So it wasn't a big deal she should open her eyes while she sings.

[rotazchik1]

simon cowell tells it like it is, in a funny but honest way, that's why he ROCKS the world of Idol shows, keep your head up girl & fk those judges, ignorant rude cunts

[waterpolomaster11]

@rotazchik1 wow you are defaintly not from South Africa you arrogant cunt bag!!!!!

[csportmaria]

dis is fucked up

[Pinkcookielove100]

this was soo funny lol ............. but sad because of her voice and left lolz

[Ray101990]

this was so mean guys especially becoz she wasnt that bad at all

[fineguh]

I actually like her voice for some reason but those judges need to stop it

[arschgeige1978]

childish, ridicolous judges!!!

[hundredotilo]

so poor

[tammynikify]

HAHAHAHAHA!!!!!

[krumpchik]

i like how she kept singing even a few seconds after she opened her eyes..

[capitnox]

@krumpchik lol as if she wasnt sure if she was imagining the absence of the judges...

[capitnox]

Respond to this video... lol as if she wasnt sure if she was imagining the absence of the judges...

[onein1]

fuck you four of u. you should consider psycological mater as well. dam asses. people like you make things down the life and future of other. small minded fucken Judges!!

[MsSexyCarmel]

They walked out because she kept her eyes closed the whole time, not because of her singing. I would have walked out too. I bet she wont close her eyes during her next audition. 

[asichel1]

THAT IS MEAN SHE WASN'T THAT BAD!!!!!

[thesharon2106]

THAT WAS SO EVIL!!

SHE IS OK, JUST NEEDED A BIT MORE CONFIDENCE, BUT EISH THOSE JUDGES ARE MEAN! OUCH.

SORRY BABES

[ittech24]

She forgot that she had an audience.

[Nadimbaig]

Thumbs up if you dont think she will come back next Year ?

[nocchimuzik]

the chairs were probably thinking "Awkward....."

[1ma4ighter]

@nocchimuzik

if the chairs had wheels, they woulda rolled outa there, but they oviously couldn't have

[kayliegh84]

Should I enter Idols 2011?? Watch me video :)

[LYDIA21LOVE]

wawww !!!

[physics2878]

The idea behind the judges leaving was for the mere fact the girl had her eyes closed the entire song!!! But it was a bit mean of course......

[karren83]

I am not even going to Laff... Those they should walk out on they didn't... Poor girl, she sounded better than most... If I was her I would shoot them all then say " walk out on that now mother fuckers"

[getchizzled]

wow that was fucked up, she wasnt even that bad

[Dee2WICE]

lol...ahahahhahhahahhhahahahha

that was cold....lol

[Saronaist]

omg, she was closing her eyes.. When she opened them the judges were all gone. that was so mean and surprisingly funny.

[Queenweezy1]

Lmao.. SMH

[daniachughtai]

That was so mean.

[saffa4x4]

They all wankers!! That is so fucking rude!! Typical south African!

[LadyTamWam]

@saffa4x4 just calm the eff down:) south africans aren't rude:) don't hate:)

[morenahotsteppa]

this was too funny...yea so it was a little mean, doesn't matter....she can't sing anyway

[TheWolfofDarkness91]

WHAT! BULL CRAP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[eeass5]

There fucking dicks.

[uniqueangel4816]

she has a good voice just bad english so it makes it squeaky x

[MrMadHatterh]

It's wrong, but you know it's funny!!!!!!!!!

[MsKawaiiGirl]

Oh, no, she's GOOD...but she needs to improve herself a bit. You know, they're crazy for doing THAT! In American Idol, she'd get a chance, I swear.

[merkeju]

And they got paid millions for such stupidity,they are judges,they left their working area they should have been fired,its not funny,it must have been her dream to perform in idols after years of apartheid but still discrimination persist,see who is leading the walk out

[09shannyboo]

lmfao that was so damn wrong... but i can't stop laughing i was like i know they not inna just get up and leaven she not notice

[MissJazzyBaby64]

Shame...

its funny tho...

but wrong! haha

[cutechickzoe]

THAT WAS FUCKING RUDE! she wasnt even as bad as the others ive seen!

[DaR3dD3vil]

HAHA! Only in Africa

[Shellerjc]

That was MEAN !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Sies man

[jnyerere]

OMG......some people are so fucking mean and heartless....her voice wasn't even that bad. It just needed some improvement. But KARMA always does its job in the end!

[gviviff1]

omg thats brilliant!

[forja1229]

DAMN!!! I thought that I was mean, but this beats my meaness by a long shot!!!!

[marvintheatre]

So funny she didn't know they all left.

[SamGr4evr]

That was actually mean...poor gal!

[Lexutron]

Hahahahaha kak funny!!!!!! And she can't sing to save her live. Too high pitched!

[KeylainePro]

she'll know to keep her eyes open the next time....

[09shannyboo]

@KeylainePro i agree how she gone sing that whole song wit her eyes closed

[ama00010]

that was a very mean thing to do. If she can't sing, then tell her....but to walk out on her like that is crazy. She wasn't that bad, i've seen worse, but no one walked out on them.

[xxxTwilightSagaxxx1]

i'm gonna start shooting if that happened to me... :/

[UncleTito72]

This is so cruel. Just be straight up with the girl, man.

[Munki6]

swak man. She wasn't even THAT bad. Shame!

[miksirikoitsen]

that was sooo funny! All you haters stfu and enjoy the ENTERTAINMENT!

[nanganaxion]

hahahahahahahahahahahaha...i sure she tot she was dreamin ykrkrkrkrkrkrk

[Phronesis7]

Yiiii! That was soooo mean! I feel bad for laughing!

[TheBlamus]

Thats... thats... not okay

[1BlessedMale]

smack the judges!!!!!!!

[MrBushyboy13]

shed a TEAR 4 HER!!!!

[NostradamusPages]

lol the funniest thing about the vid is that she jus walkes away

[afankulo]

she gud men

the judges fucked up

[samurai20003]

I cant believe them!!! that was like one the most rudest and cruelest things i have ever seen :(....and she waznt even that bad.

[dipocarew]

love this first hing I learnt when singing was nevr close your eyes.. real funny but mean hahahaha

[navec15]

oh poor thig...those judges had it all down..pfff they suck!nobody can and will ever be like Simone Cowell...

[joseneto9393]

THEY FAILLED 4 ATEMPTS TO BE SIMON!!!!!!

[Tinevie]

LMMAAAOOO DAT WAS SOOOO MEAN!!!!! WHY NOW??? I DNT THINK SHE SOUNDED THAT BAD!!!!!

[suuuuuppppplol]

that was so mean omg she was pretty good if i was her i would cry

[MAGREAT5]

those judges sucks!! they ain funny at all they should fuck off if they can't listen to pple. fuck em all!!!

[TheSuperArio]

I'm sorry, but I can't stand these judges. I know that their job is to tell people like it is, and stuff, but more times than not I've seen them be nothing but unprofessional. There's a nice way to reject people, and I know they're only doing this to be funny but I don't find it funny at all. These are real people with real feelings and sometimes the judges just take things too far.

[dctrojanz19]

OMG THAT JUNK HAD ME ROLLIN LOL

[mymymy091]

i almost cried

[beatboxguru7]

its not that bad....they should have walked away/// how stupid....she want great and didnt deserve to be an idol.....but that was sooo gay on the judges part.

[Mixman77]

That was tacky Idol ...the girl had the courage to try so she deserved to be treated better than that. You Suck!

[Giant1991]

THATS FUKERY!!!!!

[fvis]

Yes she should be motivated... To never sing again and I think the judges did that perfectly.

[fvis]

They were right to walk away. Not only her singing was terrible, but she didn't even look at the people she was singing to. How did she ever think she had a chance? She learned her lesson. She should never try to sing again.

[threecrown3]

Judges are meant to listen and judge, this judges were unprofessional and not qualify enough to be judges. They have just played with someone emotion and their action could damage the girl confidence cycological for a long time. She is young person who is still growing and she still have a lot to learn, she should be motivated rather than to be humiliated, how would they feel if this were to happen to their own daughter. This is really bad..... bad......and one more time BAD

[mangomixpromotions]

I was disappointed to see your response to this young lady regardless of what you thought of her singing...  I think all the judges behaved poorly.... Shame on you.

[hieipantera]

infinity!!!

[Yumzo1]

wow that was sad though, but eish i dont blame them at all, it gives you a lesson, never close your eyes wen you audition or sing for that matter

[MyJamstar]

That Was Just Damn Rudee They Should Be Sacked For That Serously Kmt !!!!

[khwanslay]

Oh I hate them for that!!!!!!!!

[mahakj]

my heart actually hurt for her O MAN THAT WAS RUDE!!!!

[melgin14]

very rude... who do they think they are ...i hope this would happen to them too....

[lilkalanadiangirl31]

Well that was rude.

[guitarlawyer75]

that was cruel! She had a good voice!

[summwerbrizz08]

I really feel bad 4 this chick! poor thing

[sarahisthebomb123]

LMFAOOO they just walked up and left when she wasnt looking!! lmfaoo hahahaahahha

[hoodblazin23]

so mean :(

[magoolenkind]

what a africanlosers

[Ollie1949]

ur a twat... she is bad but dont asy that u prat

[magoolenkind]

@Ollie1949 i can say what i want ,and i know it SA SUCKS!

[blackcat13fox]

@magoolenkind ok they were mean, bt dont blame it on SA...

[cut13g1rl091]

such mean pl she kinda soundede good

[1DoubleMproductionS1]

@cut13g1rl091 omg..

[VivaLaBaditude]

DEEP!!! lol

[Khanyiification]

That was so uncalled for. She deserved constructive criticism not that. How freakin rude. ~shaking head~

[christellekapapa]

those judges are so mean

[hasrettimsin]

i fuck the mother of the judges

[AKA1Z]

those judges are rude!!!

[trheiysieh]

Worst Judges ever, this is heart breaking, Actually that white RSA bustard is corrupt, for that matter this girl is maybe better than her... mxem I just hate it

[ionutxxdan]

what's the name of the melody at the end of the clip please, anyone know ?

[freighthaul]

Guru Josh Project - Infinity

[Likethat11]

aahahhahahahahahah

[Kriddy2000]

That was so mean, i thought she was an ok singer just needs to improve a lil here and there. But that was horrible what they did to her

[Sibdinho]

@Kriddy2000 lol if you guys think she is an OK singer you're definitely tone deaf. Her pitch was all over the place!

[tantjies]

That was the meanest thing ever! Every boy and girl dreams about this. She's also a young kid - singing not bad, but to shatter her dreams like that - no that is wrong. Talk about psychological damage!!! Geeeeezzzz man!!! C'mon judges, they all look up to you!

[TeeLadie]

hehehe lolzz

[MissOscar1]

loooooooooooool.....n she still crarried on wen she saw dey left...loooool...

[Qummyy]

shame on the Judges...there were horrible singers but the girl was good...she could have definitely made it...ass holes...the judges i mean..

[brunocesarmo]

Até que ela não cantou mal. Mas o vídeo mostra a falta de educação e arrogância que o povo americano tem sobre os outros países, se acham imponentes e erram por se acharem os maiores quando na verdade são os menores em respeito ao planeta que vive, somos um só, aliás somos um só, mas tirando o povo americano, eles regridem a imagem do ser humano.

Fuck, its suckers

[irmakaneli3]

WOW that was mean

[boeremeisie1]

ag shame, that was wrong. Sy kannie eers sing nie maar ten minste sy probeer het.

[SilverD1000]

Catastrophic... LOL!!

[TonyN737]

Is there ANY country that hasn't been cursed with this horrible "Idol" crap?

[j5689]

Probably only third world countries

[MissOscar1]

sweet heart south africa is a third world country and datz south african idolo...

[tantjies]

@MissOscar1 - You are only 17, never been to South Africa - what do you know? hahaha!!

[MissOscar1]

tantijies or tat ass wateva ur name is.....im 17 born and raised in south africa so next get ur facts straight b4 u go running ur sticky ass mouth and as for wat i would know well alot more den ur shitty little brain......fuck u preck.....masimba we nja.....haha 2 dat bitch....

[karuspery]

and out with the ghetto language-no class whatsoever.

[MissOscar1]

@karuspery yh thank you very much 4 butting in bt no thankz ur opioion aint needed , i'll ask 4 it wen i need it next tym yeah....oh and do me favour next time dont stick your noise were it dnt belong jst save us all da trouble......if sum1 startz on me i shuld alwayz shove them back were dey belong and datz wat i waz doin wid tat ass/ tanjies, putting him in his place mr think he new it all...

[tantjies]

@MissOscar1

useless gitt! marita ting ting, masipa magauw and also yamauw!!!! wateva houtkop!!!

[MissOscar1]

wateva it is dat u wer tryin 2 say showz da extent of ur stupidty......and DAMN DUDE U STUPID...wow...tat ass you aint got no levels you have crossed boundaries of stupidty....i salute u man...u such a flipin dog u even worse den dog sick bro a disgustin little cunt so go fuck urself or betta yet jst fuck ryt off....sick mothafucka..

[PencilsAre4Paper]

Omg she was awful.

[isabelblanco2cool4u]

thank you icdyl

[youngjamal]

that was quite mean.

[isabelblanco2cool4u]

aww that was messed. can you PLEASE tell me what that song is called at the end ive heard it before and i like it but i dont know what its called

[icdyl]

Song @ End:

Infinity 2008 - Guru Josh Project

[gursexy01]

WTF she sounded good off brand ass american idol judges awful poor girl.

[kudikudi1]

that was sad, they walked out on her.

dats not fair, the lady got upset as well.

[trece0]

mann i think dat waz fukd up if i waz ha i wud hve waitd fa dem 2 cum 6ak nd cussd dem xut

[xXiluvmusicXx1]

That was just so mean and rude!

really!

Many ppl do that while singing.

I feel so sry for that girl!

[JoLondonBurg]

Thats hilarious,

[Shular67]

The point is, it makes for great television. Now people are going to tune in not just for the performances, but to see what the judges will do/say next. Mean, yes...but no meaner than putting somebody terrible on the air where they can humiliate themselves in the first place. The whole premise of showing the bad auditions is mean.

[minimama103]

thats mean lmao