Added: 2 years ago
From: aminovjosh
Views: 79,005
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (159)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I did!

    

  • Anyone else ever think about how the show would have turned out if Shannen never would have left? The show never was it self after Prue died.

  • Even after seeing this episode so many times Holly Marie Combs can still bring tears to my eyes with her performace.

  • And you are?......

    I'm her sister.

    Touching!

  • Comment removed

  • @princesskagome100 Thanks I didn't know that. :)

  • @ghlover3.. Can I give you a hug through the internet! You rock!!! Thank you so much!

  • "Im trying to do that orb thingie... i cant-get the hang of it!"

    cole: "BAHH!!!"

    "eppe *orbs*"

  • in which episode does Prue dies? I've seen everything of Charmed but seem to have missed that episode :( 

  • @Cordoba2610 It's the season finale of Season 3. It's called All Hell Breaks Loose. Type in Charmed All Hell Breaks Loose Part 1 in the search engine on youtube and you should be able to find it.

  • @Cordoba2610 "All Hell Breaks Loose" it's the last episode of season 3. Season 4 starts with Charmed Again, so you're just left with the cliff hanger of "All Hell Breaks Loose", then in Charmed Again you see them dealing with the aftermath.

  • The ending was so emotional.... I just love this episode because of its ending... such an optimistic atmosphere...

  • PHOEBE ROKS

  • we will orb, we will levitate, we will juggle knives if we have to !!! R O F L @ phoebe

  • This was probably among the 10 best episodes of Charmed. Very well put together.

  • i really want that sweater she is wearing in her final scene.... anyone know where I can get it?

  • what i love about this episode is that way they combined comedic moments with more serious/emotional moments. i felt so bad for piper, not only did she have to deal with the fact that her older sister had died she also had to deal with the fact that she was now the oldest sister and had a new half sister all at the same time. they can't be an easy thing to deal with.

  • Pause exactly at 1:45 when she kicks them and you can see that's not Alyssa Milano :p

  • @sesamecherub i think it might be 1:44 actually....

  • @12sexie it's actually not alyssa milano

  • Piper had just gotten her blowing up power, phoebe isn't the strongest witch, and paige just realized she was a charmed one. So the charmed are still very vulnerable As Prue was pretty much good at everything she did. That's why Phoebe is so scared, and Piper so mad.

  • I wonder if Holly Marie Combs had lost a sibling or some really close to her during this time. The emotions expressed during the "crying" scene were magnificient and life-like. She most certaintly deserved an Emmy!

  • @Kiickzfeen In one of the Commentary of the dvd, Holly said that she acted these episodes effortlessly because to her she really did lose Shannen and missed her; both of them were and still are best friends, before and after Charmed too, so Holly really missed Shannen

  • " Im her sister" best line in this episode.

  • :'( 

  • Comment removed

  • who are you? im her sister.. awwwww<333

  • piper looks really pretty as fury:)

  • This episode is just brilliant .. Everything about it .. So unexpected in every way .. It makes you laugh, it makes you cry, it makes you love charmed even more .. I personally think this is one of the best episodes .. in this episode everything changes and the change is very real and very well written .. Love them all -3

  • It still breaks my heart everytime to see Piper sob in front of Prue's plaque. Her cry is just agonizing and so well done by Holly Marie Combs.

  • I cried so hard at the Piper scene with Prue's tomb, I cried so hard I guess because I miss Prue as much as Piper does, I loved Prue. She was always there for her sisters. she was a beautiful person, an incredible witch and an amazing sister. I miss her.

  • Such a great episode I just loved it. I almost cried when she cried at Prue's grave. Btw I love the final song.

  • "Im her sister" best line in the whole episode.

  • Omg I don't miss Prue Im like w.e she died piper has to get over it but I just saw the pain in holy marie's eyes like it was real like she was feeling it ..I cried really bad I don't remember the last time I cried like that :'3

  • My FAVORITE Piper episode!!! -3

  • Anyone else cry when Piper yelled at the tombstone?

  • @ilyniley4ever i cried also...cried so hard...coz i miss Prue as much as Piper miss her. =)

  • @ilyniley4ever I did, eventhough i f*ckin hated Shannen Doherty, you could feel the closeness of the 3 sisters

  • @ilyniley4ever Yes I Did.

  • @ilyniley4ever Every time!

  • @ilyniley4ever Every time... :(

  • @ilyniley4ever i did

  • @ilyniley4ever I did and i'm a guy

  • @ilyniley4ever Me :(

  • Lol..paige shes so funny about the war wound and talking about piper nd leo and phoebe and cole... Its funny because i had just got done crying after that scene and that kinda put a smile on my face :) Now im all puffy XD

  • Holly is magnificent that part where she ran 2 prue's grave and started 2 say those things 2 her she really makes u believe that she is lost without her. Take note people if an actor or actress can make u tear up like holly can in this part they have done their job and their truly believable. Your brilliant holly u rule!!! (:

  • The scene where Piper made me tear up inside. It's been a long while since I've watched this episode, and I'm just getting back into the series. There are emotions that are stirred up more easily nowadayds than when I first saw them years ago as a teen nearly obsessed with this show.

  • i miss prue alot,she was my favorite charmed one the most powerful of them all,i cried alot when she died:(...i feel so bad for piper aslo bec.i think they were much closer to each other than phoebe and she had a hard time coping with the loose:(

  • omg. i started crying over this and prues funeral. i loved prue so much. then she died. it took me a long time to watch season 4 and the rest of the seires. RIP Prudence Halliwell, u will never be forgotten.

  • i wish piper to be my mom...cute :P

  • God i love holly she is truly my idol Your the best Holly (:

  • @TheIamwitch23 Dame straight!! Lol :) 

  • Oh, someone pass the tissues!

  • wow that scene waas just just emotional if i was alone i wud hav cried :(

  • i like Paige cuz she really pretty... and acted like the youngest one...

  • sorry about the last comment i forgot i coment

  • wow piper such good acting RIP prue x

  • ive just started watching this show and i dont like pheobe. shes really selfish and only cares about cole. I seriously hope they arent together the whole series lol

  • @BadTClub They aren't together the whole thing, just for a long while, but I really like who she does end up with. :)

  • i dont know if its just me, but i think piper looks hot as a fury

  • awwwwwwwww poor piper i cried inside so much

  • oh wow piper really acted really well in that sence

  • the whole scene would be perfect if it wasn´t for paige... she doesn´t know a damn about piper, yet she´s such an expert on what she feels and how it´s right to hate prue... I wouldn´t mind leo telling her this or even phoebe, but not paige for god´s sake... I like some later episodes with her but at this point I just wish leo let the fury-piper strangle her

  • @TarAncalyme She has a right to say it b/c she's experienced the same thing with her parents and she still blames herself and them for their deaths the same way piper does herself and prue for her death. Had it not been for paige, piper still woulda been a fury. esp since everyone had no idea what piper was really mad at

  • @harrypotter799 I´d say leo had a pretty good idea considering he took them to the tomb in the first place... you´re right about paige´s experience with her parents but I still hate her being such a smartass in what like fourth episode?... i´m sorry, i´m probably a bit biased here, I guess i´m one of those people for whom paige was never good enough... not that it´s her fault, poor thing, having to replace prudence and all... :)

  • @TarAncalyme Im sure he did too but i still think he didnt truely know until paige said it. I wish prue was still there too but hey, what can ya do? shannon's a bitch like always

  • @TarAncalyme No one but Paige could have understood & confronted Piper...Leo and Phoebe thought Piper was mad at them, & Cole was focused on trying to make sure Phoebe didn't get hurt. Meanwhile, Phoebe and Leo were still grieving their loss.

    Paige had the advantage of being outside of the situation, while having had a similar experience, & also having moved on (to a large degree) from that loss. Sometimes an "outsider" can see things better than family, & she wasn't a smartass about it at all.

  • I absolutly love this episode .. I always tear up and i absolutly love piper .. And i also love it when she says "after everything weve gone throu, pain seems like an invitation for more pain ."

    CHARMED IS THE BEST SHOW IN THE WORLD :)

  • it really is emotional when piper cries...i have to admit that's the only scene that'll make me cry openly...the rest i jsut suck up and be a man :P

  • That shirt Phoebe's wearing at the end is so weird

  • i hate phoebe and cole omg cole don,t die omg pheobe don,t die yukkk

  • i cant believe i cry every time i see this episode

  • @Mzspectacular926 me too trust me

  • ", well, they can just summon Prue's spirit.. they did it with their gramps..

  • @falutak they cant cuz she left the serious. she didnt wanna work with alyssa milano

  • @falutak Actually according to the show they can't for a while an ajudstment period type of a thing

  • Holly Maire Combs definitely does not get the recognition she deserves.I watched over that seen of her by Prues grave (or plaque i guess) practically 10 times and still gets me. She is amazing

  • In a way, I can kinda understand what Piper is going through in this episode. If I ever lost one of my brothers or sisters, I don't know what I'd do.

  • why paige orb book like that her face lol

  • lol wen paige threw the lamp at the demons that was funny 1:59

  • '...Im her sister' awww :)

  • @holzmileyrocks Jeeehh that was soo sweet when she sayt that :)

  • @holzmileyrocks that was cute :) lol

  • im so emotionally....lol

  • rly sad aww piper :C

  • this is my favorite episode

  • good ending..i m her sister

  • how the fuck can Phoebe do that!

  • possibly one of my favorite demon transformations in the series

  • i love this episode. i love how paige helps piper deal with her supressed emotions and how piper calls herself paige's sister at the end. she's finally moved on and that's a big step in any loss. i wish when charmed aired theses episodes i was old enough to watch it and let alone understand it. i bet it would have been great.

  • if seen this ep many time's still i'm crying in the end

  • woohoo go phoebe shes good in a fighting scene aint she!!!!

    nearly cried when piper cried at 4:30 ;(;(

  • woohoo go phoebe shes good in a fighting scene aint she!!!!

  • phoebe's hair is awesome in this episode!

  • Paige: *groan* *groan*

    Phoebe: Honey, what are you doin'?

    Paige: I'm trying to do the orb thingy!

    Haha! As much as I loved Prue, I really love Paige as well, she's way more funny xD

  • Paige's hair looks awful!

  • i love this clip and the part where piper finely lets the pain of losing Prue out that reminds me of how i felt when i lost two of my best friends who i cared about as if they were my brothers and not a day gos by that i don't still have flashback's of the last time i spent with them and some people say pain builds character but how is pain good for you when you heart aches for the rest of your life .

  • How I remember a charmed episode when Prue was mad at the Angel of Death for her mom being dead. Death said "You mourn and then you go on." Looks like Piper learned that lesson without the Angel of Death

  • i love how piper turns back human it looks so cool

  • i miss prue i hate that she wasnt there in the final episode.

  • i tear up everytime i c this ep :'D

  • To me it never felt the same without prue i felt paige is there to replace prue and it seems to me she dosen't even care about learning the right things i say prue come backs prue always did the right thing and held the sisters together

  • Piper is so beautiful :)

  • @tmario2010  They all are

  • so emotional but kinda funny because of wut piper says, "I hate you! Please come back!" i loved charmed

  • @filipinachik4 i don't think she said "i hate you" i think it was "i need you"

  • @lovesaphira yeah it was "I need you."

  • i forgot how did pru die?and what episode?

  • @MultiMakeupfreak Prue was blasted through a wall by a demon. the episode was called "All Hell Breaks Loose" but her funeral wasn't shown until the "Charmed Again" episode. :)

  • Omg, I love this episode! Holly is acting sooo amazing!! She's the best!!

  • What I love is how Paige says, It is OKAY to hate Prue!" And when Piper says, "HOW DARE YOU!!" Everybody thought she was coming after Paige, only to run to Prue's tomb - the source of her "unexpressed fury."

  • @Mish1119 Because she wasn't full Fury yet (Having not made her first kill) I think her human emotions were still holding her down, and the sudden fear and grief at seeing Prue's coffin probably knocked her and made her forget what she was...

    I dunno, I'm just guessing :)

  • one thing i loved about holly is how well she always portrayed her characters pain or sorrow like the scene in all hell breaks lose when she died in the hospital with prue there

  • Does anyone know where I can find the background fight music that starts at 1:29?  Or any of the other background tracks? Thanks!

  • Holly Marine Combs is a fantastic actress.

    My favourite line:

    "Maybe you don't start with love, just thanks..."

  • i can relate to how piper was feeling at 3:34 - 4:09 because when i lost two of my best friends who i really cared about as if they were my brothers .

  • Okay, here's a question I thought of -

    At 8:12, Paige says, "It's my first war wound. I think I'll wear it with pride." I thought they couldn't let people know that they were witches! How would she explain those scratches, without telling that she was a witch??

  • @knightryderrwn I don't think she was going to tell anybody,but she knew she got hurt saving her sister's life.

  • @vodkagal28,

    That makes sense. Of course, it still leaves open the question of what she would tell anybody else who asked her about the scratches....but, then again, I'm thinking WAY too much!! After all, it's just a TV show!! :)

  • true he was leaving by than,i just felt like she couldnt trust him it was like she didnt trust the sisters.

  • the orb that paige does in the first few seasons is really good you could tell it apart from the whitelighers but then later on they kinda messed it up and it was the same orb as leo's

    Paige's orb in these seasons goes in then out and disappear but in later seasons it just went up and the orbs were much bigger

    so they kinda messed up the orb thingy

  • I would hardly call that a mistake. Besides, Leo's orbs go up (or down if he goes to the underworld) whereas Paige's orbs are random.

  • exactly, thats what made her a half witch half whitelighter her orbs were different from whitelighters (random orbs) and when they put it all together it messed it up

    i like the small random orbs better... it works better

  • Wait a minute. It sounded like you said you didn't like that her orbs were different. Are you saying that you liked that her orbs were different? I'm confused.

  • yeah am saying that i like how her orbs are different from leo's in the first few seasons random

    i like her random orbs better

  • She is still new to all of this and never once explained to about the significance of her heritage.

    If anything I believe she truly is a Halliwell. She's really self sacrificing to the point of quitting her job, boyfriends, and even not having a life outside of magic for the sake of others.

    Now isn't helping the needing and being self sacrificing what being a Halliwell is all about.

  • Paige will never be a Halliwell.She is allways putting boyfriends,friends,job and basicaly anything over her sisters yet she thinks she has all the rights to the book and the magic of their family.Somehow,the power of three was never reconstituted after Prue died.

  • Paige wasn't the reason y cole left.n y r u idiots hatin jus over a tv show??????tsk.prue was my favourite n i truly miss her bt y hate paige?. she's here to reconstitute the charmed ones....not to replace prue.

  • lol,nicely said.

    agreed.

  • to join the conversation...

    Charmed is the 2nd best show.

    Xena is the First.

    Only reason its second is becuz the characters die alot,just to be brought back to life,if that didnt happen so often,it would have been #1.

    Give me a negative comment if u must,but this is my opinion.

  • :'(

  • i dont like paige,she was needed for the story,but becuse of her not liking cole,he is gone,i like the eppisode when phoebe is pregers with coles baby,and the baby keeps attacking her,and the phoebe says the baby did it.

  • He's not gone because of Paige,he's gone because he was always,and always will be evil :}

  • @XxSuzana95xX yes,but he tried not to be and most of all of them she never gave him a chance,or faith,to move on,heck even pru gave him a chance,paige didnt mind when she needed him to save her,or use him to farther her causes,but support him never,she evan turned the others more agnist him evan when he was trying.

  • my favourite part. :') it's when she's finally accepted. makes me want to cry.

  • @betts3985,

    What I love is at the end, when Paige's boss says to Piper, "And you are?" And Piper says, "I'm HER SISTER." And the look on his face...it's like he's thinking, "Oops!" And then Paige sits there thinking something like, "Wow. She called me HER SISTER!"

  • anybody else cry...

  • @harrishead ME Piper make me cry the worst then phoebe somtimes prue and billie

  • This show is AMAZING! Never in my life have i laughed so much, cried so much and learned life, THANK U CHARMED for all the memories!

  • they should have never ended this show its great!!

  • thats exactly how I felt, I didn't know that she was mad at Prue, but then after awhile it did make sense

  • It's one of the most emotional scenes of Charmed when Piper is taken to the mausoleum I think...

  • goodbye prue(RIP) hello Paige! ;)

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more