This is a beautiful song. I was driving down the road listening to this song for the first time, and it was sung by a guy. When I heard "a butcher boy I loved right well" I thought... huh? Then he starts singing "I wish I was a maid again..." and at that point I was really spooked... and then there was the part about the rope and suicide. It sounded a lot like a song about a homo who became a tranny and left his woman to kill herself alone. Never let a dude sing this song by himself. Ever.
@squirell1952 no sadly they broke up because margaret o brien decided to get amrried and settle down to have kids, and im proud to say now that she is my grandmother :) she still sings in the dublin county choir but thats about it :)
Check Out Sinead O'Connor's Version Of This Song. It's AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!! It's Posted With The Lyrics, Which Slightly Differ From This Original Version . Sinead Recorded It For The Movie Butcher Boy That Came Out In The Late 90's. It Was Directed By Neil Jordan. Sinead Plays The Virgin Mary In The Movie- PURE GENIUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Absolutely spellbinding, my favourite version, she has such a beautiful voice for it and I love the male and female melody, such a beautiful sound and wonderful performance.
This is a beautiful song. I was driving down the road listening to this song for the first time, and it was sung by a guy. When I heard "a butcher boy I loved right well" I thought... huh? Then he starts singing "I wish I was a maid again..." and at that point I was really spooked... and then there was the part about the rope and suicide. It sounded a lot like a song about a homo who became a tranny and left his woman to kill herself alone. Never let a dude sing this song by himself. Ever.
JoshuaH688 3 months ago
as a kid my mom used to sing this to me...great memories
cuntzillamcgonigle 3 months ago
Beautiful song, it's a pity a lot of people I know hate Irish songs. They don't appreciate the beauty of this simple song
emmagrace1993 4 months ago
My favorite version of this song is by the Clancy Brothers.
CelticManoeuvre 5 months ago
This is an old english song. Everyone seems to think it's Irish. It's not.
CelticManoeuvre 5 months ago
@squirell1952 no sadly they broke up because margaret o brien decided to get amrried and settle down to have kids, and im proud to say now that she is my grandmother :) she still sings in the dublin county choir but thats about it :)
SophieGrimesX 7 months ago
WHERE ARE THE LUDLOWS TODAY? ARE THEY STILL IN SHOWBIZ?
squirell1952 8 months ago
brilliant
madfortrad5958 1 year ago
no gimmicks,just lovely harmonies,beautiful.
Teddyb1939 1 year ago 2
Subdued and harmonic performance.Thanks to previous poster for the melodramatic lyrics! I'll teach my grand-daughter them.
redoler 1 year ago
Check Out Sinead O'Connor's Version Of This Song. It's AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!! It's Posted With The Lyrics, Which Slightly Differ From This Original Version . Sinead Recorded It For The Movie Butcher Boy That Came Out In The Late 90's. It Was Directed By Neil Jordan. Sinead Plays The Virgin Mary In The Movie- PURE GENIUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
whillyem 1 year ago
I first heard this in '66 as a young boy on holiday in my mother's county of Kilkenny. it has haunted me ever since.
SeldomSheBoredMe 1 year ago
Absolutely spellbinding, my favourite version, she has such a beautiful voice for it and I love the male and female melody, such a beautiful sound and wonderful performance.
Shindai 1 year ago
such a beautifully sung, tragically sad song :(
musicfreakme91 1 year ago
Lovely sweet singing !
josparkes1 1 year ago
Comment removed
SeldomSheBoredMe 1 year ago
Lovely stuff!!
jilicker 2 years ago 2
This song would bring tears to a glass eye; but I love it! The Ludlows did a beautiful job of it.
George
pastore0506 2 years ago 11
very good,good singing, simple accompaniment,how some of the english folk revival could learn from this,Dick Miles
dickmilesmusic 2 years ago 5
you tell them.
handsomevision 2 years ago
Comment removed
steamboatsblues 2 years ago
like yesterday! where did the years go?
beautiful - thanks bannerman
tongiorgi 2 years ago 2
Yes.. but, OMG-- how Morbid can it get?? LOL....Toal music t islit wrists by...
onelasssttime 2 years ago
Wow-- THAT was crappy typing.. but you get it....(???)
onelasssttime 2 years ago
actually very sweet... x
madnotbad44 2 years ago 2
sweet!!!
madnotbad44 2 years ago
Lovely voice
BestPerformers 2 years ago
A childhood fav of mine.
WestLondonDroog 2 years ago 2
Thanks so much for posting this great song and video of the Ludlows. Do you have any other songs of theirs you can post?
Do you know how long they were together as a trio & how many albums they released?
folkmusicgirl 2 years ago
Beautiful version♥......what a tearful song!
Wanderwd 2 years ago 2
This is a beautiful clip of a beautiful song. Thanks so much for posting this!!
teresa9029 2 years ago 2
Thank you for posting!
jtls8 2 years ago
Golly, I remember my mom singing this to me as a nipper. What a beautiful voice.
♫♪♫♪☺
RussellK9 2 years ago 3
I remember the Ludlows as a kid. Thanks for posting.
cocklesandmussels 2 years ago
This song brings back old childhood,
memories... and was sung alot by folks
around here [Co,Antrim] in those days Too!
Mike thanks for the Post -- 10X10.. jim,,,,
fiddle4u 2 years ago
You don't see many recordings of The Ludlow's, that was a wee Gem, great thanks for posting it.
machree01 2 years ago