i was looking and hopping that this song would sound goos in another language. but i gave up. it s just not the same. this is perferct, so i been practicing for few weeks.. so i love the good vocalization. it helps me to do the best i can. from california, thanks for posting.....this is so great... Arianne.
Well, norisv, after years of training with several professionals, I decided my talents were better used professionally on other instruments. Who cares about your experience? NS is one of my all time interpreters, so I don't care what she calls herself. Can't believe you have nothing better to do than answer a months' old post. Go back to practicing voice.
@TheMsMezz: Glad that you've switched, I guess you do know your limitations. Bravo! Who cares what you think anyway? It's Stutzmann's voice and she can call herself whatever she wants. I just came back from practicing, so thank you!
@TheMsMezz: It seems that you like controlling what others do. You're the one who keeps coming back to this and make comments. Anyway, have fun practicing & break a leg, my dear instrumentalist! LOL!!!
I´ve listened to some other singers doing this song. I love alto´s voices and I love this one, so it´s been quite a surprise to find a video of her singing this song. Wonderfull rendition. Thanks for posting
Como dice "las contraltos somos como los dinosaurios" razón tiene también cuando expresa hoy que las mezzo por lo general hacen de contraltos, magnífica voz
Cant you just shut up your mouthe and scandalous commentary ? so Christa Ludwig,Lotte Lehmann and so many many fantastic women singers, singing those lieder, were just stupid cows and wanted to be mens ??? !!! just go away and let people on youtube be happy to listen marvellous interpretations like Stutzman does !
I've watched them yesterday and the day before yesterday in Brazil, at Sala São Paulo. They are both AMAZING, and brought me and all of my friends to tears. No wonder they're this unbreakable team. It was one of the most satisfying concerts I've attended in my life... not to mention they were most kind to us in the autograph session that was arranged after the concert. They are both examples of TALENT, EXTREME MUSICALITY AND KINDNESS. Wonderful!
I cant uderstand wny a woman singing this or what ... for example, do people know that Schumann's Diechterliebe was first sang by a dramatic soprano? ... why cant people just sing ...?? I may not like her voice or anything ... but she is free to sing whatever takes her fancy ... and actually I like her a lot!
I had to laugh at this arrogant and stupid comment. I know Stutzmann personaly, which is much more than you could say, and your statement, not comment, is completely wrong. Nathalie is one of the very few real contraltos we have nowdays. You seem to be a mezzo(by your nick) not with a bleak repertoire but a bleak IQ.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Get serious, honey. I'm not a singer but a professional instrumentalist. Even at that, I can sing lower than Stutzmann. What's your definition of contralto? I am a great fan of Nathalie's but facts are facts. And just exactly how do you know that I don't know Stutzmann personally? You're the stupid, arrogant idiot.
TheMsMezz: You're NOT a singer, so you based your judgment on your personal experience such as you can sing lower than Stutzmann's. I can sing down to the D below middle C in straight tone and produce weird cracking sound on a B/Bb an octave below middle C. I'm a contralto and this is based on my voice quality and where my voice sounds its best. Some sopranos can sing down to an E below middle C, does this make them a contralto/mezzo? What do you know about voice production?
fantastique que cest beau helas le seul default elle n insiste pas assez sur la fin des phrase elle devrais rester sur les notes finale de chaque phrase
genialna
remixAG 2 months ago
DAMN! She rocks. She's an absolute rock star
ghostofdayinperson 6 months ago
WOW. BRILLIANT!
2241322 9 months ago
Compliments et respect à vous Madame Stutzmann, vous "servez" la musique . En ce sens, vous êtes un exemple .
Merci Lepetitprince73 pour le post .
francesca7564 1 year ago
i was looking and hopping that this song would sound goos in another language. but i gave up. it s just not the same. this is perferct, so i been practicing for few weeks.. so i love the good vocalization. it helps me to do the best i can. from california, thanks for posting.....this is so great... Arianne.
perlitablanca 1 year ago
Well, norisv, after years of training with several professionals, I decided my talents were better used professionally on other instruments. Who cares about your experience? NS is one of my all time interpreters, so I don't care what she calls herself. Can't believe you have nothing better to do than answer a months' old post. Go back to practicing voice.
TheMsMezz 1 year ago
@TheMsMezz: Glad that you've switched, I guess you do know your limitations. Bravo! Who cares what you think anyway? It's Stutzmann's voice and she can call herself whatever she wants. I just came back from practicing, so thank you!
norisv 1 year ago
@TheMsMezz: It seems that you like controlling what others do. You're the one who keeps coming back to this and make comments. Anyway, have fun practicing & break a leg, my dear instrumentalist! LOL!!!
norisv 1 year ago
I´ve listened to some other singers doing this song. I love alto´s voices and I love this one, so it´s been quite a surprise to find a video of her singing this song. Wonderfull rendition. Thanks for posting
Ivanbelastegui 1 year ago 3
Como dice "las contraltos somos como los dinosaurios" razón tiene también cuando expresa hoy que las mezzo por lo general hacen de contraltos, magnífica voz
carrillon345 1 year ago 2
Merveilleuse Nathalie Stutzmann!
Julien
PopoliDiTessalia 1 year ago 3
B R A V A!
Un contralto di primissimo livello. A voce piena e senza titubanze! Un vero piacere ascoltarla!
E brava anche alla pianista Inger Sodergren: un accordo perfetto.
Grazie per il post e grazie all'amica Fan che mi segnala sempre il meglio di YT
5 stars *****
jeanmolin55 1 year ago 5
Grazie Jean
Nathalie Stutzmann a en effet une très belle voix . C'est une artiste très professionnelle et discrète ...
Merci Lepetitprince73
francesca7564 1 year ago
Love the voice but could go without some of the straight tone. Good post though!
pikurmurf 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is what is called being stuck in a permanent Yawn position, this is not tone.
Webarton 2 years ago
Cant you just shut up your mouthe and scandalous commentary ? so Christa Ludwig,Lotte Lehmann and so many many fantastic women singers, singing those lieder, were just stupid cows and wanted to be mens ??? !!! just go away and let people on youtube be happy to listen marvellous interpretations like Stutzman does !
shakingguy 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
can someone please tell me why a woman is singing this
rexeterna 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
because she's a lesbian and has exhausted the women's repetoire
TheMsMezz 2 years ago
Are you looking for emotions ?
Just listen to Stutzmann Sodergren. AMAZING
shakingguy 2 years ago 5
I've watched them yesterday and the day before yesterday in Brazil, at Sala São Paulo. They are both AMAZING, and brought me and all of my friends to tears. No wonder they're this unbreakable team. It was one of the most satisfying concerts I've attended in my life... not to mention they were most kind to us in the autograph session that was arranged after the concert. They are both examples of TALENT, EXTREME MUSICALITY AND KINDNESS. Wonderful!
ligiamonteiro0 2 years ago 13
I cant uderstand wny a woman singing this or what ... for example, do people know that Schumann's Diechterliebe was first sang by a dramatic soprano? ... why cant people just sing ...?? I may not like her voice or anything ... but she is free to sing whatever takes her fancy ... and actually I like her a lot!
ARTUROPVIOLA 2 years ago 6
Je l'ai entendue hier soir à Genève. Elle a chanté des lieder de Schubert. J'ai été agréablement surprise : elle a une très jolie voix
jackylen57 2 years ago 2
I saw this couple doing Schawnengesang yesterday. Stutzmann's voice is really THE contralto.
asisecanta 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
well, not really. She's a mezzo who's pushed herself lower because the repetoire for mezzo is pretty bleak.
TheMsMezz 2 years ago
I had to laugh at this arrogant and stupid comment. I know Stutzmann personaly, which is much more than you could say, and your statement, not comment, is completely wrong. Nathalie is one of the very few real contraltos we have nowdays. You seem to be a mezzo(by your nick) not with a bleak repertoire but a bleak IQ.
DrGarri 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Get serious, honey. I'm not a singer but a professional instrumentalist. Even at that, I can sing lower than Stutzmann. What's your definition of contralto? I am a great fan of Nathalie's but facts are facts. And just exactly how do you know that I don't know Stutzmann personally? You're the stupid, arrogant idiot.
TheMsMezz 2 years ago
TheMsMezz: You're NOT a singer, so you based your judgment on your personal experience such as you can sing lower than Stutzmann's. I can sing down to the D below middle C in straight tone and produce weird cracking sound on a B/Bb an octave below middle C. I'm a contralto and this is based on my voice quality and where my voice sounds its best. Some sopranos can sing down to an E below middle C, does this make them a contralto/mezzo? What do you know about voice production?
norisv 1 year ago
Voz belíssima, com grande expressividade, sem contar com a forma elegante de cantar.
Brava!
pequenobaluarte 2 years ago 5
schoenen Text, schones Lied.
eddytel 2 years ago 3
fantastique que cest beau helas le seul default elle n insiste pas assez sur la fin des phrase elle devrais rester sur les notes finale de chaque phrase
letarnais81 2 years ago
De loin une des meilleurs représentations que j'ai entendu de Ständchen de Schubert. Un délice pour les oreilles...
chikaka289 2 years ago 8
Mon Dieu, que c'est beau !!!
JuanDiegooooo 3 years ago 18