Genesis? This music I was listen when I was young so I really appreciate expirience which took place, nether, the less polish music like grechuta, skald owie, niemien. You have your own stars as we have! Lets enjoy the music !
How amazing!...never heard before...powerful there, thanks a lot YOUTUBE, as I discovered MO'SEAN too with "Give You My Soul", I'm waiting 4 the Album in a few weeks, thanks YOUTUBE...You're the very Best...this is an intense day...Listen to this estonishing music!...an what a voice!!!
he (roy cooper) would say play basketball in our backyard. im pissed off running off the the rails as it is. ok. i dont know what he thinks, i know what i think.
I think he sang it wrong here at the beginning. Its "I can't see you mama, but I can hardly wait" and he sings "[...], but I know you're always there".
The the following "uh to touch and to feel you mama" doesn't make much sense.
Great song anyway ;) But that's not the best live version
Well, it's hard to believe that Phil would sing his own song WRONG. Live versions are, of course, usually different every time. You can't expect them to be EXACTLY THE SAME as the studio versions.
Bei diesen " Mütter- Gefühlen " sind wir uns einig !!! Tut mir ja leid für alle " Mütter - Söhnchen " hier im Forum: Aber mein Hass auf meine Mutter wird erst enden, wenn Sie 2 Meter tief liegt ... HaHa Ha !!! "
Can´t you feel my heart, mama?
Now listen to me, mama! Diese miese Drecksau hat mir "alles" genommen...
This song in particular saved me from my own heartache instead of feeling sorry for myself I adopted a kick ass attitude. Thank you for this music. It still sends me into a tailspin. Can't you feel my heart Mama?
Phil Colins is the greatest, this song is cathartic to me. my mother is gone, and through this song i reached peace from my own childhood. This album is the only thing that got me through my childhood and the things that I endured Phil saved my life and I am thankful that his words kept me going....
But it is sad he will never play the drums and piano again because of the spine injury and his singing career may also be over.But glad he left us with lots of great music.Get well Phil.
is it just my ears (which are admittedly ringing a bit due to some dire straits), but, at 5:46 does the drummer do "the drums bit" from in the air tonight?? i do know his name, just right now i've forgotten it...
There is a drum machine and live drums being played together here. The drummer is Chester Thompson....and no that's not the famous "In The Air Tonight" fill. To my knowledge (and I know a lot about Genesis and Phil) it has only been used in 2 songs....of course, "In The Air Tonight" and "Thru These Walls".
phil collins had a great vocal range in the 80's. on this one you could tell his voice was deepening. still good though. i wonder if he has a bit of falsetto left
PINK FLOYD/GENESIS no contest. MAMA and HOME BY THE SEA no contest. Every band today state that they listened to Genesis and Pink Floyd for instrumental inspiration and talent. I agree. YOU RULE GENESIS. YOU ROCK GENESIS. YOU SET THE MOLD!!!!! i humbly bow before your genius!
A legend for all time..Amazing creative musical artists..
SuperSpiritoflife 8 months ago
This from the soundboard?
jaggass 8 months ago
amo o genesis !!! Phil Collins é um monstro !!! meus parabens !!! lindo, lindo,lindo !!! Marildo Pietroni
guispietroni 10 months ago
Schreib Deutsch Du blödmann die Muke is voll Geil
Harrybaerle 1 year ago
gta4 4ever!
lendarion 1 year ago
perfect singer, amazing musicians, live-performance is great ... love them!
kleinesschaf01 1 year ago
Phil Collins is the most underrated performer in rock.
GARN3240 1 year ago 4
@GARN3240 AMEN BROTHA!!!!!!
youmarley 1 year ago
Genesis? This music I was listen when I was young so I really appreciate expirience which took place, nether, the less polish music like grechuta, skald owie, niemien. You have your own stars as we have! Lets enjoy the music !
Puhaal 1 year ago
How amazing!...never heard before...powerful there, thanks a lot YOUTUBE, as I discovered MO'SEAN too with "Give You My Soul", I'm waiting 4 the Album in a few weeks, thanks YOUTUBE...You're the very Best...this is an intense day...Listen to this estonishing music!...an what a voice!!!
980graziella 1 year ago
he (roy cooper) would say play basketball in our backyard. im pissed off running off the the rails as it is. ok. i dont know what he thinks, i know what i think.
theratfarmer 1 year ago
if you walked on up cooper. the aterygeneral of NC
he would say play basketball in my backyard.
theratfarmer 1 year ago
you pay my water bill. its 260.00. pay it you dumb fuck.
theratfarmer 1 year ago
i used to play baskrt ball i n the back yards of. who gives a care?
theratfarmer 1 year ago
fuck off
theratfarmer 1 year ago
if i had all the answers. i would tell you.
theratfarmer 1 year ago
Finds das geilste Lied von Genesis!!! Hörs heuete noch gern!!!
tobaxyz35 1 year ago
look to the right. bruce springsteen??
theratfarmer 1 year ago
So geil ich liebe dieses Lied hab Phil Collins auch schon live erlebt das Konzert war einfach großartig!!!
100piroschka 1 year ago
mein gott wie geil ist dieser song...
isabella6366 1 year ago
To jest piękne!!! Super!!
marjana68 1 year ago 2
live = shit
maarten833 1 year ago
Great song. Great version.
Someone please could tell me which drum machine is used in Mama studio version? I really appreciate any help.
Thanks in advance.
Eddie.
emoraz 1 year ago
this man, in this band and on his own is a pure genius
appygaz 1 year ago
Liberty City Rock ROCKS!!!
StuLive312 1 year ago
@sweathanni
Dieser Stewie aus Family guy könnte dein Bruder sein :D
chinwildchicken 2 years ago
I think he sang it wrong here at the beginning. Its "I can't see you mama, but I can hardly wait" and he sings "[...], but I know you're always there".
The the following "uh to touch and to feel you mama" doesn't make much sense.
Great song anyway ;) But that's not the best live version
cnneo 2 years ago
Well, it's hard to believe that Phil would sing his own song WRONG. Live versions are, of course, usually different every time. You can't expect them to be EXACTLY THE SAME as the studio versions.
Larrylarp 2 years ago 2
OLD BUT GOLD!!!
UTKP5 2 years ago
This is on Librty Rock Radio in GTA IV... Great Song!! ^^
Lancer2884 2 years ago 4
Yea, that's how I heard about this song as well.
CobainStJohns 2 years ago
toller song! aber,Mütter sind das letzte!
ich hoffe,meine ERZEUGERIN krepiert endlich.
sweathanni 2 years ago
wtf?^^
ModuS93 2 years ago
Bin ganz deiner Meinung... @ sweethanni !!!
Bei diesen " Mütter- Gefühlen " sind wir uns einig !!! Tut mir ja leid für alle " Mütter - Söhnchen " hier im Forum: Aber mein Hass auf meine Mutter wird erst enden, wenn Sie 2 Meter tief liegt ... HaHa Ha !!! "
Can´t you feel my heart, mama?
Now listen to me, mama! Diese miese Drecksau hat mir "alles" genommen...
limbo10000 2 years ago
@sweathanni Ich liebe meine mutter und es gibt ganz tolle und liebevolle mütter.und Cenenis sind klasse. ist halt meine meinung.
manu8936 1 year ago
what is this version? year?? place??
MJevermore 2 years ago 2
Knebworth 1990
TheBestPhilCollins 2 years ago
@MJevermore WEMBLEY 1987
eddioarddio 9 months ago
Mama?
kjellking 2 years ago
Genesis are Great!
Hansolo60 2 years ago 9
abe jeden ein plus gegeben^^
Donschlumpfo1 2 years ago 2
one of the best forever - phil collins
mongoloidable 2 years ago 6
I've listen this on GTA4. Great music.
jakesteven1980 2 years ago 30
And don't forget about Anthony Phillips!
thecrimsonfloyd 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
luv this song
MJlover147 2 years ago 2
You know, these guys were a hell of a lot better with Peter Gabriel and Steve Hackett.
Swifdler 2 years ago 3
HAHA HA!
MAIJORproductions 2 years ago 3
Greatest Song ever from GENESIS !!!
Hardrockstorm 2 years ago 7
GOD BLESS YOU FOR THIS
kellskilleen 2 years ago 4
lembro dela ...
mineirobr2007 2 years ago
This song in particular saved me from my own heartache instead of feeling sorry for myself I adopted a kick ass attitude. Thank you for this music. It still sends me into a tailspin. Can't you feel my heart Mama?
vickycaptain 2 years ago 3
Phil Colins is the greatest, this song is cathartic to me. my mother is gone, and through this song i reached peace from my own childhood. This album is the only thing that got me through my childhood and the things that I endured Phil saved my life and I am thankful that his words kept me going....
vickycaptain 2 years ago 4
GTA4 for life!
JDproductions0903 2 years ago 2
The best
thomasbig1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
untuk Emakku sayang,telah berpulang ke rahmatullah..
sungguh aku sangat kehilangan..
tapi ini semua adalah takdir dari Allah
aku ikhlas
hanya dan suarat al Fatihah yang kukirimkan..
AKHMAD BISRI HSY
yang kangen sama Emakku.
mbrangkal 2 years ago
@mbrangkal
emufan23 2 years ago 2
Lets just stop the lists and accept that there's more than 5 amazing bands and musicians out there.
nicck 2 years ago 4
phil collins is fun to laugh at, although he does have a couple of good songs. this is the world's opinion and is fact.
jeffgorchynski 2 years ago
1. Genesis.
2. Phil.
3. Everything Else.
diegoid 2 years ago 5
..can u see Genesis
can u see great musics
Genesis is Genesis...
sarat0909 2 years ago
1. The Doors
2. Genesis
3.Metallica
4. Nirvana
5. Michael Jackson
..accept the truth.
OoKensaioO 2 years ago
1. Bruce Springsteen & e street band!!!!!!!!!
2. Genesis
3. U2
4. Micheal Jackson
5. Hip Hop
x)
rkem88 2 years ago
eines der schönsten lieder überhaupt...... gänsehaut pur.....
1968page 2 years ago
my top 5 is
Phil Collins
Genesis
Phil Collins
Genesis
Phil Collins
ilcarpincho 2 years ago 8
my top 5 is
1-Metallica
2-Thin Lizzy
3-Queen
4-Genesis
5-Bob Marley
ign6 2 years ago
You must be a fan of GTAIV.....
Jasontc2006 2 years ago 4
Que de bons souvenirs !!!! Trop bien le concert de Paris en 2007 ...le dernier :-( (sniffff)
Top 5 :
1. Genesis
2 . U2
3. Queen
4. Simply Red
5. Toto
Sooshi83 2 years ago
But it is sad he will never play the drums and piano again because of the spine injury and his singing career may also be over.But glad he left us with lots of great music.Get well Phil.
Isotec1 2 years ago
love the laugh
MJJKingdom 2 years ago 2
Top 5:
1.Queen
2.Guns'n roses
3.The Rolling stones
4.E street band
5.Genesis
999rambo999 2 years ago
i love it!!!
darksun604 2 years ago
wow...... amazing
rescueworld 2 years ago
My top 5:
1. Genesis
2. Queen
3. ZZ Top
4. The Who
5. Beatles
SPeacock 2 years ago
1st john 2-4 =understanding
jmp92688 2 years ago
A great song from one of the best of British rock bands of our time. Not forgetting of course Pink Floyd.
TheAjs39 2 years ago
is incredible,wounderful music
mack170772 2 years ago
The Best´s!!!
Lalay4ever 2 years ago
is it just my ears (which are admittedly ringing a bit due to some dire straits), but, at 5:46 does the drummer do "the drums bit" from in the air tonight?? i do know his name, just right now i've forgotten it...
russ13b 2 years ago
There is a drum machine and live drums being played together here. The drummer is Chester Thompson....and no that's not the famous "In The Air Tonight" fill. To my knowledge (and I know a lot about Genesis and Phil) it has only been used in 2 songs....of course, "In The Air Tonight" and "Thru These Walls".
firstmusic00 2 years ago
phil collins had a great vocal range in the 80's. on this one you could tell his voice was deepening. still good though. i wonder if he has a bit of falsetto left
jaggass 2 years ago
DARK.....very , but damn good!
MrLaggman 2 years ago 3
PINK FLOYD/GENESIS no contest. MAMA and HOME BY THE SEA no contest. Every band today state that they listened to Genesis and Pink Floyd for instrumental inspiration and talent. I agree. YOU RULE GENESIS. YOU ROCK GENESIS. YOU SET THE MOLD!!!!! i humbly bow before your genius!
lindaannreynolds 2 years ago
Both are my favorites! Well next to U2 and Coldplay. Im 14 and David Gilmour of Pink Floyd inspired me to play guitar. So much amazing talent!
shadow7725 2 years ago
My top 5 are
1. Floyd
2. Zeppelin
3. Genesis (and Collins's solo work)
4. The Who
5. Skynyrd
The Brits dominate this list...
TWern9 2 years ago
Top five is:
1. Floyd
2. U2
3. Genesis
4. Coldplay
5. Nine Inch Nails
Not sure if Trent Reznor is British but all of them are (U2 is Irish of course).
shadow7725 2 years ago
One of their best songs if not their best.
zaydrov 2 years ago 4
lol this song is on gta 4
911violentagro 2 years ago 4
halae hale halae halae halae halae
Dkr84 2 years ago 2
Eeiner der Besten songs die es gibt
morlemorls 2 years ago
4:30
mexftw 2 years ago
Great sound. You can really hear those Moog pedals...nice and thick sounding.
firstmusic00 3 years ago 5
For this song (performance) and many more, Genesis and Phil Collins are and will be INMORTALS
Michatahl 3 years ago 13
I have never heard this live version before! Nice work! ;)Was it in 1984 mama tour, right?
djeleix 3 years ago 6
This version is from concert at Knebworth, 1990. Beatiful performance with wind :)
TheBestPhilCollins 3 years ago
In 1990? So in Phil's solo tour.. Great!! ;) Thanx ;)
djeleix 3 years ago 2
good video
6raleigh2 3 years ago 3