Added: 3 years ago
From: KMkrimm
Views: 491,140
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,214)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I'm really glad to get such a positive response to my comment xD I love Tarja and Anette both very much. They're both beautiful women, and they can both sing, even if some prefer one style of singing over another. It honestly breaks my heart a little to see people arguing over which one is 'better'. I think that music is a beautiful thing meant to be enjoyed, not insulted. People put their love and imagination into it, and that's what we should be looking for in a band, not just a good singer.

  • but guys let's face it .. anette is sexier than tarja :D

  • @CyberDragon219 Really... really, really no, she isnt^^

  • yeaaah Edward Scissorhands :)

  • I think this song sounds better live.

  • oh no... someone killed edward scissorhands: 1:03

  • a there's a better picture @ 1:14

  • já nevim jak vy ostatní fanoušcí NIGHTWISH ale od té doby co je s touhle kapelou tahle zpěvačka tak ty písničky už nejsou tak pěkný

  • @dandaable hej islo to pekne do sraciek... marco mal spievat stale a hotovo

  • Anette is hot and can sing well enough. Even better now than then. On a more important note, this is my favorite Marco vocal part ever! Such power, fucking excellent.

  • I don't get the issue with the fans of the singers. I think they both have good qualities and like both of them.

  • I finally found this DVD. I wish it were longer, but so happy to have it that I'm not going to complain.

  • and now with the Imaginaerum, this band is in another level of perfection!!

    greetings from Brasil!!

  • Yes! they are ALL stupid for dismissing Tarja and hiring Anette!

  • You really got to addmit they are really terrible live with Anette,but I personally like them both in their own way,although thumbs up for those who think that Marco is the true source of their power ^_^

  • tuomas reminds me of the piegon guy from the One Piece xD

  • far better than the 2008 Wacken Festival version.... that performance just sucked xD

  • @Aramprez

    OMG totally agree! I've never been as disappointed in my live! That concert was the turning point that made me a die hard Tarja supporter. And even the autograph session was cancelled, I was so mad -.- You were there or just saw the version?

  • Nice song

  • I got more thumbs up in 1 week than the "tarja-is-better-guy" in 3 weeks....owned by Anette fans :p

  • perhaps not the great singer, but maaaaaan..she's hot! :D

  • @laifo01 if you want to watch hot chicks go to pornhub(dot)com

  • @GerTodesengel I don't need it, there's too many hot chiks in this video 1:47 :p

  • @laifo01 :]

  • oh my god that woman who sings bad. tarja sings much better

  • What the hell? I came here to see whether the rumours about anette are true ( that her beautiful voice depends on studio arrangements), and, god, seems like some people can only prove their point ( only not really) by lying...

  • She´s great i like her voice

  • I wish I could beat the sound engineer over the head with Hietala's mic, he took far too long to turn the volume up on it, and it even at the sound chorus it's still not loud enough.

  • she cant reach tarja's level.

  • @jaegae3182 not hold a candle to this is true

  • @nicolas2564 whattttttttttttttttttttttttttt­tttt?????????????????

  • sing*

    

  • sign it like on the album!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Could everybody just shut up about Anette vs Tarja? Tarja's been gone for over six years. If you really care so much, forget about Nightwish and go listen to her solo project. This has all gotten really old. Maybe you don't like Anette, but don't forget, she wouldn't be in Nightwish if the band didn't want her there. When you insult Anette, you're just insulting the rest of the band and their judgment for the music that THEY write. A band is made up of more than just their singer.

  • @KJHalonen I couldn't agree more. People tht systematically hates Anette just because she doesn't sing like Tarja are pseudo-fans. Sorry, but I'm not being respectful with them because they aren't respectful with us that still like Nightwish.

  • @KJHalonen True, do have to admit I like Tarja better but I think the problem is Anette can't do Tarja's music. Just isn't the same. Anette's music though is just as awesome. I don't think either one of them could fill the others shoes. Tarja has her music and Anette has hers. They both rock.

  • @KJHalonen As it happened, I didn't discover the band until Anette was the singer; so, I was a little surprised to find out there was so much friction between the Tarja fans and the Anette fans. But, in truth the problem seems to be all on the side of the Tarja purists. I have no problem listening to the older stuff, but I do like Anette better (probably because I heard her first). She sings in a purer tone than Tarja which I prefer in general. I, too, am so over the war. Who's better, who cares

  • @KJHalonen yeah... totaly agree!

  • @KJHalonen Couldn't have said it better myself.

  • ESTE TEMA ES MUY BONITO MEGUSTA MUCHO

  • tarja better then anette ! x9999 ! fuck off anette !

  • Live sounds so miserable.SUx.Annete sux bad...

  • 1:45 beauty

  • honestly - i wonder why -.- , nightwish concerts after having anette as a singer and not tarja , they r like almost every time '' yea whatever just let s get done with it '' . frankly they seem like they r not even enjoy it anymore ... if someone compare anette s concerts with tarja s it is quite obvious that with tarja 1)the audience goes ALWAYS crazy and 2) nightwish r so fucking passionate and they so fucking love being there ..... what the helll ... it s a shame ... tsk -.-

  • now nigthwish sucks :( popwish

  • Love this song!!!!

  • Nightwish without Tarja = Just one more band of metal!

  • True fans don't hate Anette.

  • @GerTodesengel that's just my opinion!

  • @Nemarism hating someone is not a opinion...it's .. can't describe it in english sorry..I'm from germany

  • @GerTodesengel Das trifft sich gut! Ich nämlich auch

  • @Nemarism das wort war unhuman...kp...1. ist mir der Satz nur in den Sinn gekommen und ich fand ihn gut...und 2. wenn du Anette nicht so gut findest wie Tarja kein Problem...aber es ist ein Unterschied ob man Anette SCHLECHTER findet oder ob man sie schlecht findet, weil sie singt sehr gut...und wenn sie in Tarjas Songs nicht so gut sing wie Tarja ist das überhaupt kein Problem...neues Album rockt nähmlich !!! Da kann man die beiden zum Glück nicht mehr vergleichen

  • @GerTodesengel das ist ganz meine meinung! ich finde die beiden sind einfach nicht vergleichbar deswegen versteh ich die leute nicht die die ganze zeit auf anette rumhacken.

    die beiden haben einfach grundverschiedene arten und auch tuomas passt die lieder so an dass es wie immer meisterwerke werden...mir ist klar dass anette die tarja-songs niemals so genial singen wird wie tarja aber das gleiche gilt andersherum! die neueren lieder würde niemals so genial klingen wenn tarja sie singen würde :)

  • @Nemarism du sprichst mir aus der Seele ... ich hab dich vorher nur falsch verstanden..bzw. du hast mein egnlisch vielleicht falsch verstanden aber das ist kein wunder :p

  • @GerTodesengel true fans argument not the hate but the fact that she does not fit the band

  • @LoArlequin Exactly, she didn't fit the band. That's why Tarja left :p

  • @FreddyMercry i meant annete, tarjas was amazing! XD

  • @LoArlequin I know what you meant...I saw this on another video. It said:

    Old fans like Tarja

    New fans like Anette

    True fans like Nightwish

    I'm a true fan

  • @LoArlequin arguing (if that word is correct) is not hating...but there are ppl that hate

  • @GerTodesengel no arguing, argument. i meant that i dont hate any singer, i just think that annete does not fit the band. Tarja left cause of "her diva attitude" acording to the open letter. I dont defend or attack Tarja or Annete, i simply say that annete does not fit nightwish as tarja did

  • @LoArlequin than its all right (even my opinion is different ^^ )...I think she can't sing the songs from Tarja as good as Traja does, but they still sound good with Annete...but imo the new album is a success and it sound good

  • @GerTodesengel

    True. They hate Tuomas!

  • @GerTodesengel but prefer Tarja ...

  • @GerTodesengel

    everytime i watch this video and see anette i have to masturbate

  • where are you TARJA

    

  • Anette is so good in this song *O* but it's the only song of Tarja she know how to sing...

  • @talifurn uhh...this song is from the Dark Passion Play album....Tarja never did this song.....it's originally Anette who sings Bye Bye Beautiful.....just sayin'

  • @Timmavid167 I kind of wish that Anette spent some more time training her voice, listening to this I kind of think of the way she sings almost as an uncut diamond, there is a rough edge to it that careful polishing and training could mould into something better. Had she the same level of training that Tarja clearly had, then I don't doubt she'd be as good, the voices wouldn't sound the same, but she'd be as good

  • @talifurn idiot this song was made after tarja left..!

  • pretty nice vocalist.

  • I like the girl that appears in 1: 45 ..... Thumbs for Her!!!

  • @xoloball I like the one that stands on the stage and looks fucking sexy as hell

  • 2:10 What tha fuck?

  • nightwish is over.....

  • @fermtl Are you kidding me? Nightwish has just started to make awesome music!

  • bring these guys down to download they wouldnt survive

  • looks like a bible meeting where the fuck is the mosh pit sorry this sucks ass

  • oh my god, Anette is so hot alive, she has a great voice and Marco is a god. I love nightwish.

  • great quitaly

    and great band

    where i can buy this CD

  • 2:53 sooo cute, i´d fuck her so hard, and than say bye bye beautiful:D

  • Anette is the hottest woman alive.

  • @MrCameltoeKiller She's over 40... u knew that right?

  • @freddyXDyeah You're point ...?

  • @freddyXDyeah Who cares. She looks like she was 20 in this video and it was 3 years ago.

  • @MrCameltoeKiller i so agree with you

  • Hello I am Chuck Norris and i aprove this song!

  • ♥_♥ Oh Anette I love you!

  • 2:10 epic fail :-D

  • This song is about Tarja.

  • @runescapeverslaafd no it's not!stop telling that because they are just singing a song!they don't need to hate each other because tarja left!

  • I love her voice : )

  • turn up marco's mic ffs

  • @thralldeathh Then noone will ever hear what they call their singer nowadays.

  • the only song that Annette know to sing

  • @mateus9sul that's how she feels the song

  • Comment removed

  • @mateus9sul if she cant sing tarjas songs as tarja doesnt meen she cant sing.tarja cant sing anettes songs either

  • @elodsisc And who gives a fuck? Tarjas voice in the combination with the rest of the band was a thing.... you only had known of Nightwish! It was awesome! No other band had this!

    And now? They have a normal singer... jear, she sounds great, she has a great voice too! But she isn´t as epic as tarja, because of the missing opera voice!

  • @GriessbreiLP

    I agree with the fact that Tarjais great, but not with Anette being OK. She is one of the lowest quality singers I ever heard.

    The difference between them is not the style but the quality as an artist.

  • @elodsisc

    I think I read this from other biased individuals and I asked the same question:

    "It's obvious that Anette can't sing Tarja's songs because we heard her performing them and she made our skin crawl.

    Tarja never sang any new Nightwish song. What makes you think that a word-class voice like her can't sing these simplistic songs?".

    It's not a rhetorical question, I really am wondering.

  • @mateus9sul then listen to The Escapist live in Houston, TX and then delete your comment.

  • @mateus9sul i hope all the best, this is actually only song one anetta can sing . too bad ....so sad to wait the future,,,

  • @mateus9sul If you think it's so easy try to sing it at the next Nightwish concert -.-. I'm not saying that Anette sings better than Tarja (tarja was much better for old songs) but new songs fit well with Anette voice just my opinion.

  • tarja > annete:D

  • @weedon2011 Too bad she got kicked out...

  • I dont like how anette moves :/

  • J'adore !

  • waaaaaaaa los amo, tienen que venir a GDL por lo que mas quieran =0 xoxo

  • 2:10 el elenco de super cool se hizo presente ene el concierto xD

  • es muy bonita :3

  • nice!!!

  • I love both Anette and Marco, BUT IN THIS ONE THEY SOUND LIKE THEY HAVE A FLU OR SOMEBODY SHOVED AN IRON DOWN THEIR THROATS.

  • @elliesmilegirl That's the Lowlands effect! :D

  • @philosopherNL well then they must never come to Lowlands :|

  • sucks :|

  • 3:54 omg!!! 

  • nightwish woudnt be nothig without MARCO

  • no le llegas a tarja ni a los talones britney Olzen jajajaj

  • 2:53 omfg she is beautifull

  • why can't I hear the crowd??? o_O

  • forever and ever TARJA

  • Anette eh uma bosta.

  • 'some old songs Anette can sing better than Taja'

    plase tell me ...one only one that you think she sings better.....

  • @flasatos wish i had an angel

  • @flasatos I think that Anette is much better than Tarja and i like them both. Stop fighting! Real Nightwish is TUOMAS

  • is she really the vocalist of nightwish?

  • херня!!!! ---1

  • i live for the day we say bye bye to anette

  • @flasatos I live for the day everyone stop fucking complaining about Anette and praying for Tarja to come back. 6 fucking years already.

  • @helixnebula2

    what you dont seem to understand is that we are all fans of nightwish...not fans of tarja.....we feel sad because she is the last person on earth they should hire as a singer.how can you help comparing them?if you like anette ok no problem with me.its just truly sad how she executes the old songs.the new may be ok for her voice but the old ones......please mercy...

  • @flasatos yeah I know, but talking about it is not bringing her back. I prefer Tarja too, I'm just sick of all this meaningless discussions and pointless comments about Anette and Tarja.

  • @flasatos people she isnt a bad singer you guys are just made that she isnt Taja and she has changed the old nightwish..... this isnt the only band that has gone through that guys, new singer new sound.... but i have to say some old songs she shouldnt sing but some old songs Anette can sing better than Taja, i liked Taja but the band needed a change and they made a good one and the right time..... get over it

  • @flasatos I live for the day I'll fuck her !!!! This bitch is so baddass !!!!

  • I would die for her speaking-voice range.

  • i feel great when listen to nightwish

  • 1:56...boy or girl?you decide!

  • @AcidRainAgain girl

    

  • @AcidRainAgain obviously girl dude... she is a friend of the BEAUTIFUL girl at 1:45, they also appear at Nightwish's concert at lowlands 2005...

  • nightwish sans tarja ce n'est pas nightwish

  • I really dont like annette.....

  • Missing Tarja... Yet.

  • Where her notes??? bad, Anette, very bad

  • Does anybody know what kind of bass Marco is using in this video? I love it, but I can't find the kind anywhere.

  • @TheWablewable It seems to be a Warwick Vampyre NT

  • Bye bye haters! :P

  • If Anette just stopped singing songs that were famous sung by Tarja the holywars would stop simultaneously - no comparison, no accusations, no arguments. Anette can sing well and she looks quite well on stage but she will be always compared to Tarja, no way out of this, guys. I prefer Tarja. She will be the voice of Nightwish for me forever... There is no that magic beauty among them anymore, and it`s very sad...

  • @MissHorneAudrey It's not that easy. Tuomas knows the fans also wants to hear the old songs and a lot of them happen to like the Anette version as well. It is what it is...

  • Tarra white...

  • Anette's moves are hypnotizing. She moves way better than Tarja. It seems like Anette likes performing more than her.

  • There is a Edward Scissorhands figure in top keyboard :P

  • 2:10....what the fuck!!!

  • @AcidRainAgain it is godzila

  • @AcidRainAgain

    hehehehe

  • @AcidRainAgain God you're phatetic... Aren't fat people allowed to enjoy some good music? idiot....

  • @8911145533 just joking man!just joking...

  • @AcidRainAgain I really hope so man, i really do

  • @AcidRainAgain ROOLFLFLLFLLLLLLLL

  • oh god that girl in 1:46...so beautiful!!!

  • i was then then,,,,,damnit i wish i was older than i was gonna watch

  • good.хорошо))

  • Anette has a pretty voice. But her voice is to weak. She stays in front and sounds like a background-singer...........

  • I wanna Nightwish live at the Rock in Rio 2013

  • to nie nightwish NIGHTWISH TO TARIA!!!!!!

  • the audience omg it`s SO changed. I bet that they even listen to pop. I`m just saying...

  • Metal de baitola!

  • Man, I wish Marco was up louder in this video. Would be nice is Annette pulled back a bit when he was singing. Good to see he scream like that live.

  • How can random people judge the way she is singing. None of you know what the hell your talking about she is singing perfect live go and listen to the horrible lady gaga or katy perry live and tell me which is better

  • @jwdoggs Very well said! Just once I would love to see any of the haters get in front of 40,000 people and pour their hearts and souls into the music. Maybe when they get laughed or booed of the stage they will realize just how much talent and determination musicians need to get the kind of following Nightwish has. In the studio, a good engineer can make almost anyone with marginal ability sound ok, but only the most dedicated professional musicians sound this good in front of a live audience.

  • 2:15... what the fuck is that chorus all about??? She did the EXACT same thing on "Wish I Had An Angel"! She sounds OFF... just OFF! She losses her voice on stage, everytime! She can't perform live.... it just sucks!

  • this reminds me of saw.

  • 1:45... What a beauty!! xD

  • @Jrlisson 2:10 what a beauty - hahaha

  • @boelchen hahaha no one is perfect xD

  • @boelchen JAJAJAJAJAJAJA... made my day!

  • must say that the chorus is fucked up common i cant sing but i can sing it right