@tanpeke yo antes escuchaba esta voz engolada tambien pero ahora ya no estoy tan seguro, la voz corre mucho en el teatro y una voz engolada pues no correria asi creo yo.
Was das wirklich traurige dabei ist, er konnte wunderschoen singen frueher: JONAS KAUFMANN - SOGNO MANON - 1993. Was ist passiert? Musste er seine Stimme so kuenstlich abdunkeln, um dem Markt zu entsprechen fuer eine Weltkarriere? Das sagt leider viel ueber den Zustand der Oper aus...
Well, in the end it's a matter of taste but it's a ridiculous statement of course. Kaufmann does not and never will have the popularity and uniquely beautiful sound that Pavarotti had. He sounds more heroic but it's achieved in a bad way since he is manufacturing the sound, it just sounds throaty and constricted, "Knoedel" comes to mind ;) Not even Del Monaco forced his voice in a way that Kaufmann does imo. Welcome to the future of Opera, the "Terminatenor" is born :) :)
@medusaview I know and they're not even the same type of tenor. Pavarotti if I'm not mistaken was more of a Lyric Tenor. I can't quit make Kaufmann's type. He sounds like either spinto or maybe dramatic to me, but i'm not too sure.
@medusaview Genau so ist es! Ich habe immer gedacht, Kaufmann hat halt so eine tiefe schwere Stimme, aber das ist nur die halbe Wahrheit. Es ist ein kuenstliches verdunkeltes und gedruecktes Knoedel-Gedudel!
Leider sehen es viele Leute anders-meistens die, die keine Ahnung vom Singen haben.
Schauen Sie, wir sind doch Deutsche..., waere ich nicht stolz, wenn es wirklich wahr waere, dass Kaufmann, so wie in Youtube behaupted, der beste Tenor der Welt ist? Man geht sogar noch weiter:"besser als Pavaotti" habe ich gerade hier gelesen!So etwas ist eine Unverschaemtheit und eine Beleidigung fuer einen der Besten, die es je gegeben hat! RIP.Meinen Sie nicht?
Ich stimme Ihnen zu. Ein bisschen aehnlich singt Cura, der seine Stimme auch kuenstlich zu verdunkeln scheint. Bei Kaufmann sind es aber andere Dimensionen, die Natuerlichkeit der Stimme scheint in keinem Bereich seines Stimmumfangs zu existieren. Klingt heroisch, dramatisch, ja, aber ist das schoen, so monoton? Ich habe ihn in Rigoletto in Zuerich gehoert und war erstaunt, wie schlecht man ihn ueber das Orchester hoeren konnte, hat auf Volumen gesungen ohne strahlenden Kern in der Stimme.
Sinceramente...aspetterei a dire che è un grande!!!....ha una voce potente però il colore della sua voce è davvero strano....carica troppo i suoni e poi quando sfuma ha una voce stranissima...bha...
@jcbcn751 finalmente qualcuno che l'ha capito. Tra un paio d'anni sarà completamente spompato (già ora è afono... ovvio, dato che ingola tutti i suoni).
Jonas Kaufmann is one of the leading Tenors in the world. I am sure thats only the beginning of a verry, verry long worldwide succes. His voice is awesome and powerful. Here is coming the next Domingo. At the moment is in this Tenor Voice-Category noone is better than Kaufmann!!! Next Year he is singing in Bayreuth and ia msure this would be another triumph for the best dramatic Tenor the world have.
Più Marullo che duca
nabucco46 5 days ago
if there's a tenor who doesn't need a microphone, it's jonas kaufmann.
stuorme 1 month ago 2
Even Carreras at 2:32 said wow....completely amazing!!!
butlertyrek 1 month ago
He is phenomenal! His tone is some of the best I've ever heard.
MrBrian24601 1 month ago
e' bravo ma non lascia liibera completamente la sua voce... essere belloccio aiuta a quanto pare ....
ideal841 2 months ago
un disastro ..... anche se rigoletto non è stato scritto per la sua voce!
fra1979it 6 months ago
ademas el italiano no lo dice muy bien.. y me gusta mucho pero.....
MrPedrogranados 6 months ago
si la tiene un poco engolada si...es un poco fallo...que pena
MrPedrogranados 6 months ago
a heavy tenor tone, Lovely.
musicfanish1 1 year ago
I won't say this is not his role. But this is more like B. Nilsson singing Queen of the Night. I do prefer JDF in this Aria.
Faullici 1 year ago
Awesome to see Jose enjoying the performance at 2:31!
KatieKaboom21 1 year ago
Ridiculous voice, more people need to hear this!
Operasinger91 1 year ago
tiene la voz engolada no me gusta
tanpeke 1 year ago
@tanpeke yo antes escuchaba esta voz engolada tambien pero ahora ya no estoy tan seguro, la voz corre mucho en el teatro y una voz engolada pues no correria asi creo yo.
mannullll 6 months ago
Ups que maravilla, simplemente increible como parte, tremenda voz y tecnica.
Que envidia, Sana obviamente
Bravo
chrisvetera 1 year ago
Jonas Kaufmann a handsome man and nice tenor star.
pedro2726 1 year ago
he is good but no Kaufmann
dziady1 1 year ago
Was das wirklich traurige dabei ist, er konnte wunderschoen singen frueher: JONAS KAUFMANN - SOGNO MANON - 1993. Was ist passiert? Musste er seine Stimme so kuenstlich abdunkeln, um dem Markt zu entsprechen fuer eine Weltkarriere? Das sagt leider viel ueber den Zustand der Oper aus...
Pollione88 2 years ago
People said here: Kaufmann is better than Pavarotti! This is a insult against one of the best Tenors of all time, RIP!
Could you say something here, that those people are shutting up?
medusaview 2 years ago
Well, in the end it's a matter of taste but it's a ridiculous statement of course. Kaufmann does not and never will have the popularity and uniquely beautiful sound that Pavarotti had. He sounds more heroic but it's achieved in a bad way since he is manufacturing the sound, it just sounds throaty and constricted, "Knoedel" comes to mind ;) Not even Del Monaco forced his voice in a way that Kaufmann does imo. Welcome to the future of Opera, the "Terminatenor" is born :) :)
Pollione88 2 years ago
@medusaview I know and they're not even the same type of tenor. Pavarotti if I'm not mistaken was more of a Lyric Tenor. I can't quit make Kaufmann's type. He sounds like either spinto or maybe dramatic to me, but i'm not too sure.
petion2010 1 year ago
I agree - better than Pavarotti. Kaufmann is fabulous tenor!
gautama2009 2 years ago
better then pavaroti
cez1005 2 years ago
@cez1005 nobody is better than Pav,God included,but this guy is amazing.
doddsalfa 1 year ago
@cez1005
better?! depends what you mean - better in proffecionalism / technique or better in sound of voice?!!!
If you mean the first - you have to be a competentive in this field but if you mean the last - you failed as both have original and unique voice.
NinoUrushadze1 5 months ago
oh please!, wash your years
promopera 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Verdi wuerde sich wohl im Grabe umdrehen!
Kuenstliches verdunkeltes und gedruecktes Knoedel-Gedudel!
medusaview 2 years ago
@medusaview Genau so ist es! Ich habe immer gedacht, Kaufmann hat halt so eine tiefe schwere Stimme, aber das ist nur die halbe Wahrheit. Es ist ein kuenstliches verdunkeltes und gedruecktes Knoedel-Gedudel!
Pollione88 2 years ago
Es freut mich seh, dass Sie meiner Meinung sind.
Leider sehen es viele Leute anders-meistens die, die keine Ahnung vom Singen haben.
Schauen Sie, wir sind doch Deutsche..., waere ich nicht stolz, wenn es wirklich wahr waere, dass Kaufmann, so wie in Youtube behaupted, der beste Tenor der Welt ist? Man geht sogar noch weiter:"besser als Pavaotti" habe ich gerade hier gelesen!So etwas ist eine Unverschaemtheit und eine Beleidigung fuer einen der Besten, die es je gegeben hat! RIP.Meinen Sie nicht?
medusaview 2 years ago
Hoeren Sie sich mal hier in youtube folgendes an:
Jonas Kaufmann "Recondita armonia" -Deutsche Oper Berlin-
Da Kriegen Sie "Plack in den Ohren"!!
Habe dies mals dort ausfuehrlicher beschrieben.
medusaview 2 years ago
Ich stimme Ihnen zu. Ein bisschen aehnlich singt Cura, der seine Stimme auch kuenstlich zu verdunkeln scheint. Bei Kaufmann sind es aber andere Dimensionen, die Natuerlichkeit der Stimme scheint in keinem Bereich seines Stimmumfangs zu existieren. Klingt heroisch, dramatisch, ja, aber ist das schoen, so monoton? Ich habe ihn in Rigoletto in Zuerich gehoert und war erstaunt, wie schlecht man ihn ueber das Orchester hoeren konnte, hat auf Volumen gesungen ohne strahlenden Kern in der Stimme.
Pollione88 2 years ago
Comment removed
medusaview 2 years ago
Sinceramente...aspetterei a dire che è un grande!!!....ha una voce potente però il colore della sua voce è davvero strano....carica troppo i suoni e poi quando sfuma ha una voce stranissima...bha...
liEder89 2 years ago
Bravoo!!! bravoo!!!
AndresVera24 2 years ago
I saw him live in Vienna and Berlin as Cavaradossi, he was great both vocally and artistically.
vilabreze 2 years ago
He's absolutely incredible
Carguello615 2 years ago
He is Amazing.
CJfactcheck 2 years ago
CANTA CON LA VOCE IN GOLA!!!
jcbcn751 2 years ago 4
@jcbcn751 finalmente qualcuno che l'ha capito. Tra un paio d'anni sarà completamente spompato (già ora è afono... ovvio, dato che ingola tutti i suoni).
CateSoprano 4 months ago
What a concept - someone actually ACTS this aria for once!
KatherineXIX 2 years ago
Like you all, I'm really impressed with this young man's voice. And his Italian pronunciation is fantastic. It don't get much better.
joelweisberg 2 years ago
Bravo !!!
jackylen57 2 years ago
Jonas Kaufmann is one of the leading Tenors in the world. I am sure thats only the beginning of a verry, verry long worldwide succes. His voice is awesome and powerful. Here is coming the next Domingo. At the moment is in this Tenor Voice-Category noone is better than Kaufmann!!! Next Year he is singing in Bayreuth and ia msure this would be another triumph for the best dramatic Tenor the world have.
WAGNERIANER1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
too bad he sucks
aroncooker 2 years ago
this is one of the best versions that i have heard and his voice is so rich...
MichaelOW1983 2 years ago 4
this was soooo beautiful!!!!!!!!!!! i loved this!
jcmcpr 2 years ago
Brilliant cadenza, ravishing diminuendi, and the most solid fortissimo high notes one could ask for--must've been quite the phenomenon live!
forallyouknow 2 years ago
Look at 2:31. It seems as if José Carreras says something like "Wow". It looks like he was thrilled about the Performance of Jonas Kaufmann. Bravo !
pullypally 2 years ago
It looks like „bravo.
leonorafl 2 years ago
Yeah, shame ITV butchered this show and didnt broadcast the even better E Lucevan le stelle
MrGary66 2 years ago
I'm liking Jonas :)
zooropey 2 years ago
Isn't he fab!! :D x
profondement 2 years ago