True, doesnt seem as a tribute to Partch, the style is quite generic. Partch used microtonality more extensively, as well s capturing some antiqueness to the spirit.
@NevinJarek This has microtonality all over the place! This is definitely a Beck song, but it applies a good bit of Harry Partch's music theory. If he wanted to just do a Harry Partch song, he would have done a cover.
@cozymonk I know but microtonality wasnt the only thing that partch did on his music. Partch had a whole idea on aesthetics, not only tunings. Im not saying he should have interpreted one of Partch's works, but done something else with the singer, with the story, with the texture. And with theater...
Partch worked out very differently. This sounds mostly as generic western music in just intonation, with few use of microtonality and extended harmony.
I don't know how come he got it or why it's in this tribute, but 1:18-1:27 is definitely a sample of a song by an Argentine band. Look it up on YouTube, you'll see! Crucis-Corto Amanecer
Good for Beck to listen to Partch. Now if he would just let Partch influence his music a little, we'd be gettin somewhere. Far as Tater's concerned, we've been pussyfootin around the microtonal too damned long. We got the instruments, and we got the pulpit... how about preachin it?
@eerieyellowlights "there's a lot of microtonal music out there." Yeah, but Beck ain't doin any of it. See, he could get away with it because his fans expect him to be different and like it.
from an astrological perspective, both beck and partch were cancers. both were innovators, though obviously went in very different directions. not sure if this means anything, but thought it was kind of interesting. Regardless, pretty cool that such a mainstream artist decided to pay tribute to someone so obscure.
It is certainly unnerving that the entire internet media steam conflated Harry Partch with "Harry Patch"--oldest surviving war veteran--when reporting on this story. Just do a google search and be amazed by the incompetence.
i've just watched to your video, and it's great!!, beck would really appreciate your work, and this song is great, the most alternative song ever wrote!! no doubt beck is the best!!!!!!!
For those interested, Beck's website features information on Partch who was an iconoclastic 20th century American experimentalist musician/composer; his work is widely studied in academic circles, Check out the documentaries (on Beck's site) and you'll see some of the hundreds(if not thousands)of instruments he custom made. Beck's tribute to Partch further demonstrates his lifelong interest and knowledge in the creative and intellectual aspects of a wide spectrum of the arts.ThnX for posting!
True, doesnt seem as a tribute to Partch, the style is quite generic. Partch used microtonality more extensively, as well s capturing some antiqueness to the spirit.
NevinJarek 9 months ago
@NevinJarek This has microtonality all over the place! This is definitely a Beck song, but it applies a good bit of Harry Partch's music theory. If he wanted to just do a Harry Partch song, he would have done a cover.
cozymonk 6 months ago
@cozymonk I know but microtonality wasnt the only thing that partch did on his music. Partch had a whole idea on aesthetics, not only tunings. Im not saying he should have interpreted one of Partch's works, but done something else with the singer, with the story, with the texture. And with theater...
NevinJarek 2 weeks ago
so this is beck's response to the fiery furnaces dissing him. interesting. not bad.
movitmovit 11 months ago
Not quite well representative of Harry Partch, but still a fine Beck song.
Ersanven 1 year ago
Wow! Fantastic. Makes me want to write backwards!
modomnoc1 1 year ago
this is really crazy
suprisepunch 1 year ago
Partch worked out very differently. This sounds mostly as generic western music in just intonation, with few use of microtonality and extended harmony.
omgtkseth 1 year ago
Sounds more like a tribute to Appleton Syntonic Menagerie.
woodrailking 1 year ago
I don't know how come he got it or why it's in this tribute, but 1:18-1:27 is definitely a sample of a song by an Argentine band. Look it up on YouTube, you'll see! Crucis-Corto Amanecer
merrrlo 1 year ago
Is this on a certain album by beck?? If it is what is the name of that album or is this just a tribute tribute????
samuraiyao 1 year ago
If he made a full song just off the music between 4:48 and 5:25 .. I'm be really fucking happy. Sounds really friggin' cool.
Zerstorer23 1 year ago
@Zerstorer23 You and me both. Easily my favorite part, and I've found myself fast forwarding to it a few times.
GuyNeilJames 1 year ago
beck it's epic
Adamhall000 1 year ago
Good for Beck to listen to Partch. Now if he would just let Partch influence his music a little, we'd be gettin somewhere. Far as Tater's concerned, we've been pussyfootin around the microtonal too damned long. We got the instruments, and we got the pulpit... how about preachin it?
TaterGumfries 1 year ago
@TaterGumfries there's a lot of microtonal music out there.
eerieyellowlights 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@eerieyellowlights "there's a lot of microtonal music out there." Yeah, but Beck ain't doin any of it. See, he could get away with it because his fans expect him to be different and like it.
TaterGumfries 1 year ago
from an astrological perspective, both beck and partch were cancers. both were innovators, though obviously went in very different directions. not sure if this means anything, but thought it was kind of interesting. Regardless, pretty cool that such a mainstream artist decided to pay tribute to someone so obscure.
XylenRoberts 1 year ago
@XylenRoberts yeah that doesn't mean shit
jfleminator 1 year ago
4.08 THAT'S THE FREE DESIGN!!!! (Don't cry baby is the song)
Cassettomusic 1 year ago
It is certainly unnerving that the entire internet media steam conflated Harry Partch with "Harry Patch"--oldest surviving war veteran--when reporting on this story. Just do a google search and be amazed by the incompetence.
featheon 1 year ago
@featheon You gotta admit, they had similar names.
SomeMightEvenDie 1 year ago
SomeMightEvenDie has a point; "r" is not often followed by "tch."
Ozarkeree 1 year ago
If you want to be an apologist for the increasing unreliability of journalist reporting, you're welcome.
featheon 1 year ago
If anyone needs some context to the origins of this track; check my info further below...thanks
LIFEONPLANETBECK 1 year ago
I made a music video for this song. Just click my name I suppose to seeeeee it.
peppergod 2 years ago
i've just watched to your video, and it's great!!, beck would really appreciate your work, and this song is great, the most alternative song ever wrote!! no doubt beck is the best!!!!!!!
wasabihansen 2 years ago
Wow. Never heard anything remotely close to this level from beck. Great!
guyeylon 2 years ago
@guyeylon
Check some of his older stuff. Perhaps his "hidden" tracks? I can hear some influence there, too.
BigJimRiffenger 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Thanks, perhaps I should really. I can't stop listening to this track.
guyeylon 2 years ago
He's still got it.
TortaDeHelado 2 years ago 7
sounds like Zappa
drcatellino 2 years ago
and there i was thinking this was just a very clever ruse to get back at Matt Friedberger for insulting him and his chosen religion.....
featha97 2 years ago 4
For those interested, Beck's website features information on Partch who was an iconoclastic 20th century American experimentalist musician/composer; his work is widely studied in academic circles, Check out the documentaries (on Beck's site) and you'll see some of the hundreds(if not thousands)of instruments he custom made. Beck's tribute to Partch further demonstrates his lifelong interest and knowledge in the creative and intellectual aspects of a wide spectrum of the arts.ThnX for posting!
LIFEONPLANETBECK 2 years ago
02:04
so awesome!
arschlochhh 2 years ago
04:12
Dream pop - ish
Anyone can tell me if its a sample and from which music it comes from?
psirou 2 years ago
Comment removed
number105 2 years ago