Carrie Underwood AI Rewind "Please Mr Postman" Group Performance

[MrsCountryBeast]

I love Carrie!! 1 question though how did Lakeisha Taylor not make it past seriously?!?!?

[imarunner89]

Paula seemed jealous of Carrie.

[4lionking]

I will never understand how Screaming Carrie won!!!!

[hjb103055]

A star is born.

[xxY2JLEDGENDKILLERxx]

funny how carrie and vonzell where in the top 3...

[marysparkles121]

are you fucking me??? lakeisha shoulda made it, not the other girl!!

[CMUfanenglishfreak]

I fell in love with Carrie another 10 times just for her "Yes, sir?"

[littleremy2007]

I have never seen this performance before. Thank-you so much for taking the time to post it.

[kellytaylorjenegarth]

Carrie was the bomb diggetty I llooovvee her and shes so cute!!! Haahahah she's so funny

[starshollowresident]

hahaha is it hilarious that i got all sweaty and nervous when randy went to tell her if she made it or not?

[GipsyPinstrument]

what are the odds in having two of the final three from that season in the same group at hollywood.

[belizeanalien]

they did not air this on the show

[thirdysaruca]

Did anyone here her say:"There must be some word today,from my BOYFRIEND?"wtf!

[dadizzie]

@thirdysaruca lol yeah but those are the lyrics to the song. It was sung correctly.

[BruDDahLeKii206]

@thirdysaruca LOL those are the lyrics to the song haha

[GipsyPinstrument]

I don't get some people saying Vonzell should've been sent home?

she came 3rd that year.

[cooolness3]

Lakeisha Taylor was the best out of all three. Even though Carrie Underwood has become really successful, she was waiting to become a product, which she now is.

[Jussayindonthate]

Carrie is so funny! I love her comments at the end. I just cant believe how shy and reserved she used to be and now look at her!!! SUPERSTAR!

[Cowellini]

yeah Lakeisha was good. I liked her voice too. too bad

[jesuismadison]

its funny how they almost cut her, and she almost went home. it seems like there's luck involved in these contests too

[ThePurpleParrot37]

Oh snap! I can't believe that cut the big girl after this. She was good!

[MistuhMooshii]

Lakeisha probably made some kind of mistake that the producers didn't want to show for whatever reason. Otherwise i don't think Lakeisha would have been eliminated.

[luverchick]

i think they were all good actually i think they just discualified that first gurl cuz of her looks...my friend tried out for american idol and they said she has an amazing voice but that she didnt have the look they were looking for...

[stewman65]

As Simon told Carrie on day 4, many people were sent home that shouldn't have been because they have to balance out the show. In other words, if you have two girls that sing great but they have the same style of singing, probably the overweight one or the ugly one will go home.This is reasonable, in the real world, because the judges also have to look for Marketability, Can they sell albums if they win American Idol. Only two Idols so far have been Marketable and Talented. Carrie and Kelly.

[4everchocolate101]

im so glad she won :)

[ilizashlesingerrocks]

Carries so cute, Yessir

[dgagnon313]

Powerhouse group. Vonzell and Carrie were top 3 in America's mind and the other girl probably deserved a shot in the top 24, though not further.

[JLTurnerMusic]

ahahah

"so now i gotta figure out what safe means, and how not to do it anymore."

love her :P

[EpicAmends]

Lakisha was way better than Vonzell.

Thank goodness they put Carrie through! They would have been crazy not to.

[xxcountrygirl23xx]

"After much deliberation..??? ThanK God they put her through!

[mardgreen88]

i know! imagine if they hadn't? goodness...

[Jussayindonthate]

@xxcountrygirl23xx HECK YES!!! Where would my life be without her and her music!!!!!

[jonoconner1]

I thought they were all very good and I liked Lakisha a lot.

[ROGER459]

PAULA... is Boring...!

[Jussayindonthate]

@ROGER459 LOL!!

[jonathan3691]

Vonzell seems like a real human being. See the nervous look on her face just before she receives her critique. Endearing.

[ssssuuuzzi]

um, i thought the first girl was the best of the three in this song....

[animekay6]

'So now I gotta figure out what safe means...'

lol. It took me a long time to figure out what they meant by safe. It would help the idols more if the judges were a little more specific with their comments.

[Enjouchi]

Well they have a lot of contestants and groups to go through. Besides, all safe means is that she's taking little or no risks. It wasn't that difficult.

[JayMe2823]

vonzell was horrible. lakisha should have made it with Carrie.

[dadizzie]

No all were good and all should have made it.

[JayMe2823]

Excuse me I am allowed to have my opinion. No ones opinion is right or wrong.

[dadizzie]

Right... I am too arent i. Did the same as you. I stated my opinion jus like u, we both said it like it was fact. We didn't say "i think" or anything jus made a statement. I just understood that was an opinion and thought you'd understand too.

[JayMe2823]

um. this is silly im not gonna "fight" on youtube. lol

[dadizzie]

Oh you were fighting? I wasn't fighting. Sorry if i came off that way. Just was stating my opinion. My apologies. No sarcasm intended.

[JayMe2823]

haha. no! I wasn't. it's all good:)

[InspiredbyLiszt]

I wonder why Lakeisha Taylor didn't make it past Hollywood... She has a nice big voice.

[spongemike44]

Not to mention a nice big ass. I'd hit that from the back

[NegativeX83]

@InspiredbyLiszt a little off key

[KnowYourEnemys]

@InspiredbyLiszt probably cuz they seen that she wouldn't win this season.. so they wanted her to come back any other season to win, or maybe even go bigger than idol (if that's possible)

[SaxPlayersPwn]

It's weird that Carrie almost got kicked out in Hollywood,

and that Carrie and Vonzell were in the same group, seeing as they were like, First and Third,

maybe that will happen with Kris Allen and Matt Giraud!

:D

They were in the same group:P

[countrySTAR06]

oh lord she cannot dance. lol

[AtYourSide]

Thanks for this video, i'd never seen Carrie in this round. Bless her talking about no more being safe