Added: 4 years ago
From: 1superstarjames
Views: 394,692
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (514)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I'm not a Barbra Streisand fan but her version blows this out of the water.......if you seriously think that this version is better, you are either related to the singer or tone deaf!

  • The sound quality is horrible, but JHUD does a fantastic job, love her. Also, wouldn't it be awful if every artist sang and sounded the same, think about it. There's no need to put down one artist in efforts to make your favorite star shine brighter.

  • Good, but doesn't compare to Barbra.

  • @skye1212 nothing and no more compares to Barbra.

  • Jennifer is amazing! I love her!

  • Just sounds forced

  • oh.... she's screaming all the time......

  • Best sound quality? Are you serious? I'm cringing here for the distortion...sheesh!

  • Barbara will always own this song-- no question!

  • Liza's problem is she too is good but her voice just overpowers the orchestra -- it's like you know the loud mouth Carol in the choir -- she's the only one you hear lol. Love liza though.....

  • This woman cannot sing this piece. I am not familiar with her, and perhaps she can sing other music, but she leave music like this alone.

  • Jennifer Hudson is good, but the combined voices of Streisand and Evancho (yes, 11 year old Jackie Evancho) really do this song the most justice.

  • please listen to the version of ms regine velasquez of somewhere cause its the best version ever had.

  • There's something about her voice that kind of ruined the subtlety of this song.... watch streisand sing this live ... wearing a white suit.... that's the perfect version.. her voice is at it's greatest!

  • hey i have uploaded a video of myself singing this song, please listen to it and let me know what you think :)

  • I tell you, REGINE VELASQUEZ's version is better. Try to listen very closely and set aside her nationality.

  • Good soul,R&B,Gospel voice! ....She doesn't need to be Jealing in order to show off her Talent!

  • Jennifer you are the best. Love your style in this performance!!!!!!!

  • IM SORRY BUT NOTHING BEATS THE MOVIE VERSION OF THIS SONG THE SCENE AND THE VOICE. HER AND BARBRA AND CELINE DID A GREAT JOB BUT NOT EVEN CLOSE TO THE MOVIES VERSION=)

  • People can lie and pretend that this isn't incredible all they want. But it's totally ridiculous to say this doesn't sound great. Just because you are a Barbara Streisand fan or any other fan doesn't discount that this was performed BRILLIANTLY by Jennifer Hudson. If we wanted to hear the other versions, we'd go to THEIR vids...lol DUH

  • she might be good but she's no match to miss regine vealasquez

  • this is awful, her voice yuck

  • Very nice version on Somewhere but " Streisand " is the shit on this song still to date !!

  • awexome..

  • sorry but this sounds like chalk accross againista board

  • Regine Velasquez is better than her search her in you tube...

  • way better than whitney's vocie

  • omg. listen to the uncontrollable vibrato along with the shouting.

    a very lucky amatuer at best.

    the vibrato gets wide enough to drive a truck through.

  • @rdc300 Stupid comment is stupid.

  • omg. listen to the uncontrollable vibrato along with the shouting.

    a very lucky ametuer at best.

    the vibrato gets wide enough to drive a truck through.

  • I have liked Jennifer Hudsons other songs very much. To be honest...I think she OVERSANG this one....it requires a bit more restraint then she displays here.

  • I like Jennifer Hudson so much. However she doesnot do this lovely song justice.I donot care for her version of this song.

  • didnt care for her version at all....however , the woman got some pipes

  • All she is doing is shouting and killing the song,Barbra Streisand is fantastic no contest.

  • Comment removed

  • @wire4paladin I cannot understand why they have block your comment i think it was smack on , thank you for your reply.

  • @artexjohn Scroll down,It's there. I kept removing them because I noticed spelling errors after I posted them...I hate that!!! LOL

  • @wire4paladin I Don't understand why she was yelling this song! Damn!

  • @SamCorNat I don't either. I know the girl can sing, and she's a good singer, but she used bad judgement on this one. Part of being an "exceptional" singer, to the likes of singers such as ; Sinatra, Nat King Cole, Barbara Streisand, and Sammy Davis Jr., is having great repertoire, and knowing how to sing the song...

  • @wire4paladin So true... She is great and I love her. But this song, well lets just say don't sing it again until she is ready to sing it.

  • @SamCorNat Well said, my friend!

  • jennifer is good, but this song, the magnificence is gone

  • God has made her great ! Not only is her voice awesome but she can act as well. But the real truth of character showed when she was able to forgive the one who took her family away ! You go Jennifer ! Much love for you.

  • why are people comparing the two?

    it depends on what your into.

    personally, i prefer barbara's soft version to this,

    but others may prefer the louder jennifer hudson :P

  • bad sound quality and she destroys a soft romantic song

  • the sound quality on this video is awful doesnt do Jennifer justice..there are better versions of this video of Jennifer on this site...amazing vocals though xxxx:)

  • barbra owns this song...no other singer can sing this as beautiful as barbra can...soul + power= BARBRA STREISAND!!!

  • @cherryliza Are you sure there isn't a bit of racism laced in that compliment to Barbara.

    I think both singers made it their own and both versions are beautiful.

  • this is not even close to striesand is the best ever aall this lady is loud

  • You cannot compare Barbara and Jennifer. Barbara is a pop singer - very good and I like her but she cannot compete with Jennifer in range, power, control or sheer emotion. Also, Jennifer is a LOT better looking!

  • Miss Hudson is awesome but.............. BARBRA is only the greatest vocalist that ever lived !!! 50 years of superstardom... STREISAND rules !!!

  • barbra streisand is way better

  • thought this was supposed to be best sound quality? its wank lol love the song but the copy is cack

  • I LOVE THISSSSSSS!!!!!! : >

  • adi cohen,Ben ASHKENAZY

  • Loved love love j hudson but shit she tore this to shreds too big a voice for such a beautiful song love u tho jen :)

  • she's have a good voice.. very good quality...

  • This isnt good sound quality. When the music starts it gets bad

  • video and all dat bitch can sing! such pipes. she needs some shaping, but she's well on her way to being someone great! love you j!

  • u can't really judge jennifer's performance with this crap video - she would've sounded phenomenal with a great quality video...and BTW barbabra sounds like she has a snotty nose when she sings this song

  • Everyone talks about Barbra Streisand's tone, the one that inspired all those comparisons to the world's smoothest condiment. They also speak of her range, which mirrors the distance between the depths of the Grand Canyon and the peaks of Everest. Her lung power invites equal comment; Small wonder since, at full bore, it can flatten a town.

  • omg. listen to striesand. she is the best.

  • @e0159742 you are right... barbara sang long notes n wave....

  • @e0159742 Try listening to Reri Grist's performance, you will be amazed. She was Consuelo in the 1957 Broadway production and it was an amazing performance, will take your breath away.  Even Streisand can't touch Reri's version on the cast album.

  • @julielvsliason

    i listened. sorry i don't agree. reri is a coloratura soprano who spent most of her time in opera. barbra is not an opera singer although her voice is quite amazing.. the two voices are completely different. while i think reri has a great voice i still think barbra's version is better and for me it's because it seems to have more humanity. there is a richness/warmth in barbra's voice that few female singers have. i don't get that from listening to reri's version.

  • @e0159742 I didn't need you to agree, so all is good. I respect your opinion. I am not a huge fan of Streisand. I admire her range, her vocal strength and technique but for me I personally don't hear warmth and emotion. I grew up in a house with a mom who adored Streisand and she always raved about her too. None of the pathos that marked Garland voice is present in Streisand's FOR ME. I do hear warmth in Reri's version too, I also hear it in Hudson's voice. Personal choice I guess :)

  • I found this awful--Screaming--try listening to Barbra Streisand sing this song. Talk about purity, This song is not made for Jennifer Hudson's voice. I had to shut it down . She reuined this song.

  • Please try to listen regine velasquez cover version of this song i'm sure you will love it....thanks

  • Impressive and gloriously sung. However I would suggest to learn how to give more refinement to her singing, more pathos and meaning to the words. Singing "piano" would be appreciated too in certain passages. She sings everything with too much strength and she may over-use her precious voice in the long run. I hope not, cuz it's an amazing voice and a terrific Lady. Best wishes to her.

  • is this a joke best sound quality

  • I made it thru the end of this 2:47 minute tape, on mute!! Jeez, my eardrums are still bleeding...

  • She is a great talent..just needs some mic tips.  With a voice as powerful as hers..you gotta back off that mic at the loud parts..

  • Terrible sound quality - headline is a lie

  • First of all, she is black, not white, her voice is heavier than whites and it carries. Stop trying to make her something she is not. In my opinion she did an awesome job. Looks like the people agreed, take another look.

  • @tonitoni1967 What! I'm black and this is shit!!! Yelling is not how this song should be sung.

  • a lot of pauses and screaming

  • I much prefer the Streisand version.

  • Phenomenal

  • WOW dat was phenominal

  • OMG what AN ASSAULT!!!

    Maybe some mic control if you cannot control the blasting...OMG...this is one of my most favorite songs...isn't this gerswhin? not first baptist!!!

    I sing Gospel and this was abusive...OMG...

  • @TheSanctifiedSoldier true. However-Bernstein. Definitely need some Mic work, mixing, etc.

  • What's with the screeching? Terrible version. It's a bad idea to try and top Streisand and she doesn't even come close...

  • Not in the same class as Streisand.

  • this is awful.

    she seems to have no understanding of the song.

    it's a bunch of screaming and awkward pauses. by far my least favorite rendition.

  • I write any sheet music

  • I love Barbra's version and I really enjoyed Jennifer's as well...her version evoked a triumphant feeling in me and Barbra's, a more wistful one. Both are good.

  • you can tell that she has a good voice...but in this song....way too much screaming as opposed to controlling her voice to make softer,and more mellow sounds.Give it another go..only next time ...much softer please!

  • She is over using her powerful voice. she should control. It's more of a show off not a performance to entertain people. But to impress, nevertheless, she just give me vertigo by merely listening to her shouting.

  • Just because a singer demonstrates powerful dynamics doesn't mean that they are screaming. Projecting from your diaphragm is always going to produce much force and vibrance while everyone's voice is going to produce different timbres when they evoke that kind of power. I sincerely wish non-vocalist would educate themselves a little before being extremely critical of others, especially Jennifer. I appreciate Jenny's and Barbra's versions; Apples and Oranges people, they're both GOOD for You! LOL!

  • I bet her hubby does what he's told.

  • Horrible. She murdered a great song. No need for all that shoutin an screamin.

  • JH.. wonderful demonstartion of God's gift. Go. girl...........Someday.......

    Shertomja.

  • no control thats all I can say...

  • Where and when was this?!

  • Das ist niemals Barbra Streisand!

    Ich finde es fast empörend, so etwas ins Netz zu stellen! Es gibt genügend homo-Streisand-Nachmach Fans, aber bitte doch nicht so! Da gibt es wesentliche bessere schwule Interpreten!

  • well i like it she does her rendition and thats why i like it ,its her i love when she belts we need more strong singers like her

  • Comment removed

  • love

  • she failed to make this song shine... i hate to say it because i really like her voice and it's such a beautiful song

  • You suck dude ! this lady is amazing and  she is not holding back

  • @djmatar2i jennifer hudson may well be a good singer but this is not her song and streisand does it better if u bother to listen. the song is not meant to be sung like hudson is singing it.

  • This is incredibl, she has a great voice and a large range. It is not too much power, that is all in the feeling as a singer myself I know that :)

  • She is incredible.

  • Too much power and showing off her voice, and too little feelings. I think the quality of the recording makes it worse than it probebly sounded live, as it sounds like she screams a lot.

  • You know I totally agree with you... This is actually a really sad song with a lot of meaning and significance to it. It's one of those songs that can be sung without all the runs and power and carry a hell of a lot more meaning to it.

  • I advice you to check out the a capella version from celtic woman, 4 amazing singers who takes it slow with much feeling and great harmonies. watch?v=-Fo1nf15bPg&fmt=18 ;)

  • I love JHud but she missed the boat on this song. However, I have to say the same thing about the Celtic Woman version. The harmonies are lovely but there's about as much feeling in it as there is in a loaf of Wonder Bread. For some reason most a capella groups sing like they're synthesizers. I find it really annoying. Elevator music.

  • are u for real bad singer are u sure ur listening to the same singer as me

  • very bad singer.

  • Too much yelling over the higher range, indicates a lack of control. Poor.

  • Sorry but she ruins it. Nothing against Jennifer but meh.

  • To much power but no passion

  • Simplemente ella es una cantante SPINTO, es decir de empuje con la voz, no grita.

  • there is a point between belting and screaming... its not bad but sometimes it too much it sounds scary... right?

  • I don't get what was so wrong about her cover of this song. We all know sometimes Jennifer oversings, and she belts in places where it is not needed. That is just her style of singing. No one complains when Rihanna or Keri sound shrieky live or when Mariah voice cracks. People in Hell want ice water but guess what? They ain't getting it. MOVE ON!!!! The past can't be changed!

  • Fools this is POOR QUILITY VERSION

    J Hudson does not scream

  • Not to mention the fact that she probaly has never heard the original or know where it is from or about.

  • WTF DID SHE DO TO THIS SONG?

    She riffed all over it and it does not fit her voice at all.

  • I was in this audience and my headache got up and walked out..with me right behind...

  • Anyone who thinks JHUD screams and is not talented is friggin silly----This is a song she should probably not be singing though!---does not sound as smooth as barbara---she needs music that fits her tone/range

  • Nothing original about her; she's no Jennifer Holiday, and certainly no Barbra!

  • young blood how are u...first off Barbra is good but not as good as JHUD..Jennifer is not limited to one sound unlike some artist..She has power,range,depth,and anointing..So in all actuality, she cant be compared ok young blood?

  • JHUD SCREAMS! It doesnt cound pretty at all!!!!!!!!!

  • Undercover brother...u betta recognize aight.open ur ears u are insane...do me a favor and google Jennifer Hudson pretty...lemme kno what u come up wit..as a matter of fact..listen to her CD

  • I call that screaming!! lol

  • OBAMA! Lol.... Now WHAT????

  • EXACTLY!!!

  • Music is music.

    Comparison is pointless.

  • Comment removed

  • Say WHAT? Come Again?u sayin that all blabk people scream, and that no black people can sing? ARE U NUTS<OUTTA UR FREAKIN MIND? This singer,Jennifer Hudson is the most talented singer in all of the world...She can sing anything and she is tha bomb. Dont ever talk about my sister like that..o and dont talk about my race either...I take offense to that recognize what ur syin b4 u open ur ignorant mouth..okay?!!!

  • @1800tryf8th LoL! She can sing anything, well she didn't sing this song right!  Best singer in the world, you are going a little bit too far!!! If she was the best she would know how to control her voice and not kill this song in front of the whole world! Black people can hear that, because I'm am.

  • Perhaps you've never heard of Leontyne Price, Jessye Norman, Kathleen Battle or Marian Anderson.

  • That is the shitest sound quality I have ever heard - total crap.

  • i love it !!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Jennifer is the superstar magnificent

  • WOW, i can't believe everyone thinks she oversang the song. I think she did an awesome job and made the song very powerful with her strong vocals. YOU GO GIRL!!!!

  • goes to prove that a great voice can still ruin a great song if you dont really understand what you are singing...

  • she has an incredible voice, but unfortunately she mistook this song.

  • Pfffft..... abysmal video. It can stay "Property of Superstar James" as far as I'm concerned. Learn to film before you start plastering your name over embarrassingly bad videos like this.

  • unbelievable

  • Que MERDA, quem fou o FDP que

    colocou esta porra aí ???

  • WORST SOUND QUALITY

  • @damian2000usa u aint lying.

  • @damian2000usa: you aint lying.