@EmoLexi333 Trent Reznor wrote the song, this is the original you moron .Also the song is about heroin addiction, not self harm or suicide so get your facts straight .
This would be a cool song to play after you die. Like you die then God/whoever plays this for you lol I say that cuz to me you can say life is joy & all that horse shit lol but Life rly is pain not in a emo way but everything slowly dies from the day its born & in the end life for all the joy there is 5x more sad & pain. I hav had joy but this is the truth about this muddy rock lol & this would be a good way to for life to say "Yea I know it was fucked up. Heres a song to sum it up sorry.." lol
I feel different... i dont intend to harm my self to this song like iv seen so many people say they have... I honestly really love this song and it touches me deep in my heart but doesnt make me feel like hurting my self... it just makes me feel like what ever idc.
Cutting used to be my addiction -i remember one time i cut so deep i needed stitches - my boy friend was there for me when i did it, he patched up the wound as best as he could until my mum got home - it snapped both of us out of our depression - we strive for happiness now, we cure our sickness with love, laughter and caring - and one day we will both heal, until then we make the best out of every day
I'm sick and tired of it. I'm not mean, but what the fuck. "Does anyone harm themselves while listening to this song?" Why, just why would you tell the world that you hurt yourself on the internet.Keep it to yourself please.
@TF2Medic2 why are you being a dick about it...? ...so what if people hurt themselves while listening to this? everyone needs an outlet...even if it means self-injury...not saying it's good...but it's their business...not yours...if someone wants to share it, let them...don't stop them...you might just push them over the edge by freaking out on them...
I just went and listened to the johnny cash version and I must say the original is waaay better *nods* I was never much of a Cash fan but this is way better *nods*
@stlplayr oh wow 6minute song is the longest you have ever heard?! you should try listening to jam bands once in a while you can get some great phish, umphrey's or the grateful dead songs that are over 25minutes long!
i think this is a really good song, and yeah it does have a lot of potential for covers but that is what is great about it. it is simple yet elegant and full of meaning and feelings. i could see a lot of bands doing a good cover of this.. but that doesn't make the original any less amazing!
I hate when someone covers a song and a bunch of dumbass people try telling you that the people who MADE the song ruined it with their cover... its like OMG you freaking idiot's try giving props to the correct people here...like when that rapper covered a daft punk song and people were like did daft punk steal that from the rapper... NO they rapper guy stole it from daft punk get it right ~_~" people do that crap all the time its really annoying :/
I can not believe that people actually think that Nine Inch Nails wrote this song. This is not at all the type of song a man like Trent Resnor would right. Trent Resnor never wen't through pain like this. Only a man like Johnny Cash could have written a masterpiece such as this. Go ahead and argue with me. I have proof that I am right on my channel. You will admit I'm right after you have watched the videos on my channel that proove that Johnny Cash wrote the song Hurt.
@stlplayr dude 6 minutes is not long for a song ever heard of 2112 (20 minutes), close to the edge (17 minutes), eat a peach (too long to remember), etc
First time I heard this song was on Johnny Cashs voice and I loved it so much it actually took me years to look for the original version (yes, I knew it was a NIN song).
The thing is, when I listen to this song it is awesome, powerfull, pure feeling, no matter the singer.
Truth be told, I don't see this and Cashs as two versios of the same song, to me they feel like to completely diferent songs.
Lol, what's up with all this talk about *versions*... If that version is better than you are watching the wrong video. Music shouldn't be a fucking competition. If this isn't good enough; then watch the other version of this song, and stop showing your ass online by criticizing the NIN version of this song. Like foreal...Nobody really gives a flying fuck.
@GublerRussia one of the most intelligent comments on this video. People should stop comparing the two versions and saying which is "better"... Come on, music is subjective. There IS no "better". There are only personal opinions. Both are amazing in their own ways. Can't people just be quiet and enjoy the fantastic music?
Reznor's version contains the passion, fear, and anger of a young man's despair. Cash's has the acceptance and regret of an old man's. Both are beautiful -- the fact that Cash made a cover of it is but a compliment to the song. It recognizes that the message is a universal one, known to all generations.
Now that I've heard both, I consider them to be just as good as each other. I personally think Cash's voice fits the song better, but I like the original's music better.
I feel like Johnny Cash is one of the only artists out there who was ever worthy enough to cover a NIN song. And now he is dead. :P Certainly more worthy than Linkin Park.
i respect the johnny cash version, how could you not? BUT trent's voice is classic to me personally. cash is definitely a legend but i can relate to trent better. probably just because of the generation im from. i'm a 90's kid. and it reminds me of afi's sing the sorrow days, for some reason.
@filoponex6 I disagree, I mean I had onlt heard the johnny cash version at first and I loved it, but then I heard this version and I prefer it so much more, just because I feel like it's more their style than his. but the Cash version is still amazing
@filoponex6 I disagree, I mean I had only heard the johnny cash version at first and I loved it, but then I heard this version and I prefer it so much more, just because I feel like it's more their style than his. but the Cash version is still amazing
This has been flagged as spam show
Listen to the Johnny Cash version its the real and its WAYYYY BETTER :D and its not about self harm or suicide
EmoLexi333 1 month ago
Listen to the Johnny Cash version its the real and its WAYYYY BETTER :D and its not about self harm or suicide
EmoLexi333 1 month ago
@EmoLexi333 they both has the same lyrics... they're both about the same thing, and they both preseented it in roughly the same way O.o
iateyourspaghetti 4 weeks ago
@EmoLexi333 if my real you mean original, you need to do a bit more research.
Grimm124 3 weeks ago
@EmoLexi333 Trent Reznor wrote the song, this is the original you moron .Also the song is about heroin addiction, not self harm or suicide so get your facts straight .
MrChristophe156 3 days ago
This would be a cool song to play after you die. Like you die then God/whoever plays this for you lol I say that cuz to me you can say life is joy & all that horse shit lol but Life rly is pain not in a emo way but everything slowly dies from the day its born & in the end life for all the joy there is 5x more sad & pain. I hav had joy but this is the truth about this muddy rock lol & this would be a good way to for life to say "Yea I know it was fucked up. Heres a song to sum it up sorry.." lol
MySpaceSuckx 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos
Would be a lot better without the wind current in the background.
xRothkox 1 month ago
I feel different... i dont intend to harm my self to this song like iv seen so many people say they have... I honestly really love this song and it touches me deep in my heart but doesnt make me feel like hurting my self... it just makes me feel like what ever idc.
nikkaayy1 1 month ago
Comment removed
wildlifepics27 1 month ago
Cutting used to be my addiction -i remember one time i cut so deep i needed stitches - my boy friend was there for me when i did it, he patched up the wound as best as he could until my mum got home - it snapped both of us out of our depression - we strive for happiness now, we cure our sickness with love, laughter and caring - and one day we will both heal, until then we make the best out of every day
ImATacoIswear 1 month ago
I'm sick and tired of it. I'm not mean, but what the fuck. "Does anyone harm themselves while listening to this song?" Why, just why would you tell the world that you hurt yourself on the internet.Keep it to yourself please.
TF2Medic2 1 month ago
@TF2Medic2 Sharing sadness halves it while sharing happiness doubles it
xias0mors 1 month ago 19
@TF2Medic2 why are you being a dick about it...? ...so what if people hurt themselves while listening to this? everyone needs an outlet...even if it means self-injury...not saying it's good...but it's their business...not yours...if someone wants to share it, let them...don't stop them...you might just push them over the edge by freaking out on them...
regiswithwingtsun 2 weeks ago
Does anyone else harm themselves while listening to this song?
xkrishax1 1 month ago
I like cash' cover.
kpoepje 2 months ago
can anyone tell me, did Rez and Cash hang out?
Rez wrote this and Cash made it his own. Both versions are awesome.
kiljoy67 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
Comment removed
footballbabe86 2 months ago in playlist Hurt-Nine Inch Nails
@kiljoy67 They never did hang out but they have talked before. Cash passed soon after his version was released.
footballbabe86 2 months ago in playlist Hurt-Nine Inch Nails
Not the sort of thing I'd be listening to, But I really love it! Brilliant song if I'm honest.
SeventhMonthOfTomorw 2 months ago
crown of thorns > crown of shit.
jcbpotter93 2 months ago 2
I think all the views on this video are from me,just sayin'
StubblyBubbly1 3 months ago in playlist Liked videos
colombiana
santorian123 3 months ago
Why? Why can there never ever be a Hurt video that doesn't compare the two? Why? Why?
VaticanAssassion 4 months ago 7
@VaticanAssassion That's like asking for a Metallica video where no one mentions Megadeth.
xHighPotencyx 3 months ago
first, by 20 years
scabjelly84 4 months ago
This song is amazing. This video is good too. Thanks for the upload!
TheGeekishOne 4 months ago
Tis' a good song. I really like the font you use!
airgear123456 4 months ago
this song is creepy as fuck
MrSTFU80 5 months ago
Correction. The lyrics were written by Trent Reznor.
annainess 5 months ago
I love this song and the Johnny Cash version but this ones a lot more grunge <3
9BlueLady6 5 months ago
I just went and listened to the johnny cash version and I must say the original is waaay better *nods* I was never much of a Cash fan but this is way better *nods*
alabeecha 5 months ago 3
@stlplayr oh wow 6minute song is the longest you have ever heard?! you should try listening to jam bands once in a while you can get some great phish, umphrey's or the grateful dead songs that are over 25minutes long!
alabeecha 5 months ago
@alabeecha he said loneliest, not longest
xias0mors 4 months ago 21
i think this is a really good song, and yeah it does have a lot of potential for covers but that is what is great about it. it is simple yet elegant and full of meaning and feelings. i could see a lot of bands doing a good cover of this.. but that doesn't make the original any less amazing!
alabeecha 5 months ago
I hate when someone covers a song and a bunch of dumbass people try telling you that the people who MADE the song ruined it with their cover... its like OMG you freaking idiot's try giving props to the correct people here...like when that rapper covered a daft punk song and people were like did daft punk steal that from the rapper... NO they rapper guy stole it from daft punk get it right ~_~" people do that crap all the time its really annoying :/
Idiocy runs wild in this country..
alabeecha 5 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
I can not believe that people actually think that Nine Inch Nails wrote this song. This is not at all the type of song a man like Trent Resnor would right. Trent Resnor never wen't through pain like this. Only a man like Johnny Cash could have written a masterpiece such as this. Go ahead and argue with me. I have proof that I am right on my channel. You will admit I'm right after you have watched the videos on my channel that proove that Johnny Cash wrote the song Hurt.
DeliveryManBoy 5 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy
I Love Johnny Cash but you sir are stupid if you think this
Cleric12332006 4 months ago
One of the loniest songs I've ever heard.
stlplayr 6 months ago
@stlplayr dude 6 minutes is not long for a song ever heard of 2112 (20 minutes), close to the edge (17 minutes), eat a peach (too long to remember), etc
TheChanneldejavu 5 months ago
@TheChanneldejavu Don't forget NOFX's "The Decline"! It's a one song album!!!
jackhitman47 5 months ago
@TheChanneldejavu Have you ever heard of a change of seasons by dream theater ? Some version are like 35 minutes !
SimonMC321 4 months ago
@TheChanneldejavu Sleep's Dopesmoker- One hour, three minutes.
jridenoure 3 months ago
I heard the cash version first but I feel that NIN put more meaning behind the words. I didn't fully understand the song until I heard this version.
zztops08 6 months ago
Comment removed
zztops08 6 months ago
First time I heard this song was on Johnny Cashs voice and I loved it so much it actually took me years to look for the original version (yes, I knew it was a NIN song).
The thing is, when I listen to this song it is awesome, powerfull, pure feeling, no matter the singer.
Truth be told, I don't see this and Cashs as two versios of the same song, to me they feel like to completely diferent songs.
Imdtkpg 6 months ago
had to say...i cry everything i listen to this song...
MrDothedewb 6 months ago
describes everything im feeling
thewallpus 6 months ago
nice
gunguy9mm 7 months ago
First time I heard this song I cried, no lie.
5andreaa5 7 months ago 4
Lol, what's up with all this talk about *versions*... If that version is better than you are watching the wrong video. Music shouldn't be a fucking competition. If this isn't good enough; then watch the other version of this song, and stop showing your ass online by criticizing the NIN version of this song. Like foreal...Nobody really gives a flying fuck.
DemonSemon117 7 months ago 8
next, people will be trying to say that Soundgarden covered Johnny Cash's 'Rusty Cage', lol.
KarmicApexIntellect2 7 months ago 3
I have been looking for this song for over 3 years. Thank you, @xias0mors. Thank you so much.
zoezoewriter 7 months ago 3
It rocks that Johnny did them as a cover.... what an honor
jamiepickens4206 7 months ago
This song makes me cry...everytime
apriltaylor93 8 months ago 2
i love both versions :) but i prefer this one.
EssenceEvans 8 months ago 3
Johnny Cash and NIN are both super good so every one can shut up now.
GublerRussia 9 months ago 5
@GublerRussia one of the most intelligent comments on this video. People should stop comparing the two versions and saying which is "better"... Come on, music is subjective. There IS no "better". There are only personal opinions. Both are amazing in their own ways. Can't people just be quiet and enjoy the fantastic music?
DudeMeister44 8 months ago 2
@DudeMeister44 Thank you. Your my new ffav person right now.
GublerRussia 8 months ago
Johnny Cash did a great cover of this song. I'm a big fan of Cash, but a bigger fan of Nine Inch Nails. 8^)
ojmardueno 9 months ago
love it.
anillusionaryworld 10 months ago
Reznor's version contains the passion, fear, and anger of a young man's despair. Cash's has the acceptance and regret of an old man's. Both are beautiful -- the fact that Cash made a cover of it is but a compliment to the song. It recognizes that the message is a universal one, known to all generations.
nucleardragon19 1 year ago 12
thanks .
krisnnaabraham 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this song sounds like a retard trying to play music. its fucking gay
pauley314 1 year ago
Now that I've heard both, I consider them to be just as good as each other. I personally think Cash's voice fits the song better, but I like the original's music better.
SporeRider92 1 year ago
I feel like Johnny Cash is one of the only artists out there who was ever worthy enough to cover a NIN song. And now he is dead. :P Certainly more worthy than Linkin Park.
Fox5593 1 year ago
i respect the johnny cash version, how could you not? BUT trent's voice is classic to me personally. cash is definitely a legend but i can relate to trent better. probably just because of the generation im from. i'm a 90's kid. and it reminds me of afi's sing the sorrow days, for some reason.
mbrattoo 1 year ago 2
i love this song so much it describes my life so well excpet for needles but everything else is so true.
shadowmere94 1 year ago
Good video:)
MsWolf211 1 year ago
NIN Version is better :)
cyclonethefox132 1 year ago 49
NIN are a lot better than Cash... And let me tell you... I love Cash. And to Cash, cover NIN is a honer.
dinobarbosa100 7 months ago 3
@cyclonethefox132 cash's is pretty good too :P
regiswithwingtsun 2 weeks ago
i think you did well. the font seemed to go well for the song 5/5
xsmurfx3x 1 year ago 2
To be perfectly honest I prefer the Johnny Cash version. I've got nothing against NIN, it's just I find his version a little easier to digest :).
filoponex6 2 years ago 25
@filoponex6 for most people cash is easier, but tis not the nature of the song .
xias0mors 1 year ago 64
@xias0mors who are you to say what the nature of a song is? music is art and as such it is open to interpretation.
hasao21 1 month ago
@hasao21 its obvious what the nature of the song is, have you no empathy ? lol
xias0mors 1 month ago
@filoponex6 I disagree, I mean I had onlt heard the johnny cash version at first and I loved it, but then I heard this version and I prefer it so much more, just because I feel like it's more their style than his. but the Cash version is still amazing
HoratioC919 1 year ago
@filoponex6 I disagree, I mean I had only heard the johnny cash version at first and I loved it, but then I heard this version and I prefer it so much more, just because I feel like it's more their style than his. but the Cash version is still amazing
HoratioC919 1 year ago 2
great song (:
monthy95 2 years ago
Comment removed
jauchiu 2 years ago