Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (121)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • he should of won for sure not scotty!

  • hes talented bt he is such a copy cat toward adam lambert and that really makes me mad.

  • There is no question in my mind that James added diversity and talent to Idol. He helped their ratings, for sure. So many little kids were cheering him on. This song is my favorite of the entire Season 10. Too bad Idol didn't bring Carole King in to mentor! James is the boss!

  • should've been a durban/reinhart finale

  • I love this song sooooooooo much:)

  • wow James Durbin really is amazing! DITTO

  • AMAZING JAMES DURBIN!!! U ROCK!!!!

  • One word....AWESOME

  • my mom loves this song o_O... yes by james i was randomly playing it and then i get "who is singing that kelly, he sings it really well"

  • Of all the contestants, I would hands down by his album. I truly hope one of his albums will have remakes of favorite rock n roll songs like Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow. He just plain rocks and I am and old geeser (60+).

  • I don't care who won it, James is still my favorite no matter what the rest of America voted

  • @AstronautCactus Some people in America didn't take the time to give james, or metal a chance, it is their mistake. :)

    ♥ James

    James all the way

  • Lol 99.9% of comments are about Scotty.... Get over it he won months a go

  • I THINK I AM IN LOVE.... <3

  • America should of given metal a chance

  • I'LL LOVE YOU TOMORROW & ALWAYS, JAMES. ♥

    omg you should have won!!!

    <3<3<3

  • America just has bad taste!

  • @PinkNoseGirl1 He was my dad's favorite too and mine as well. 

  • I have an unhealthy addiction to this song. I raped the replay button.

  • i love james durbin hes not bad looking haha

  • james is the new generations of great rock star....his voice should be a national treasure...will buy all dvds of his concerts...lady gaga move over...james has arrived

  • I love you police, I still love you tomorrow

  • i love the beginning from 0:00 to 0:38

  • james is way hotter than scotty any day and if i had to choose who shouldve been saved wouldve been pia and not casey and the final two shouldve been haley and james and haley shouldve won

  • HE SHOULD HAVE WON. I am so confused.

    Seriously.

    How could they let Scotty, the only-country singer, win??

    Clearly James is more talented than that little country boy.

    WHYYYY?! D':

  • @SecretlyyNerdy exactly

  • @magicalunicornable

    yeah! Seriously, I'm totally and completely confused.

    Nothing against Scotty but....all he could sing was country... and it was just boring old country.....nothing special about it. We have plenty of country singers JUST LIKE Scotty.

    James brought something unique. And also, just face it. He's more talented.

    SO HOW DID SCOTTY END UP WINNING?

    I'm not as angry as I am confused.

    Actually, I'm equally angry. It's so frustrating.

  • @SecretlyyNerdy I think it was all the teeny boppers that have a crush on Scotty voting for him.

  • @jafarjasminefangirl

    Ugh that is so stupid.

    He isn't even that...cute...and all.

    IF ANYTHING, I'd have a crush on James Durbin because of his talented singing!

    Scotty was just so boring.... I was thinking he'd make into the top 8, tops.

  • @SecretlyyNerdy Amen to that!

  • @PinkNoseGirl1 Yes he did, that same week that he was voted off :)

  • Aww this made me love James even more.

  • he shouldve won american idol plus he could of sang with steven tyler

    america doesnt know music

  • its a shame that america doesn't know good music anymore :/

    James, haley, and casey culd bring the real music back.

    and i believe that if they continue trying they can change back to the real music people once used to listen to. not tht stupid auto tuned shit tht isnt even real.

  • i hate scotty.james should have been in the top 2 and won.it should have come down to james and haley.

  • I cried during this song. It was so good. He should have won, and I also cried when he got eliminated. He'll get a record deal, he's far too talented not to.

  • can't wait for James to put out his own cd and I will buy it in a second! Daughtry didn't win either and look where his career is now! ROCK ON JAMES!

  • i cried with james wen he got eliminated he is my FAVORITE he gave 200% everytime he got on stage he didnt deserve to go HALEY did

  • @nicolejstarr2011 YESSS!! Exactly how I felt. I cried AND thought Haley should've gone!

  • @twistty2 yes regardless people are pissed haley got eliminated but idk how ppl voted for her she was good but not as good as james is and thats the honest truth

  • @nicolejstarr2011 WHAT?! Haley was the best female, I wanted a Haley/James finale.

    And @JustAboutEveryone Pia was not the best female.

  • @nicolejstarr2011 i know i thot james was amazing he gave 200% everytime he performed i was blown away wen he got eliminated.. i think the judges shud have at least 2 saves next year cuz alot of great singers got eliminated this year and it was sad everybody shud of got a chance to be in the finale

  • @PinkNoseGirl1 i was really upset because this dude has raw talent. He can sing anything: country, rock, metal, and so on.

  • I MISS HIM A LOT I THOUGHT HE WAS GONNA WIN HE WAS MY FAVORITE SINCE THE AUDITION

  • James is amazing! He sould have at least been in the top 3 :(

  • This is totally my favorite James Durbin performance. I hope whenever he makes an album and it will hopefully have a love song on his heavy metal style

  • perfect. absolutly perfect

  • first pia, now james. i'm not watching this show anymore.

  • @afejzaj2 i totally agree with u!! those 2 were the BEST :)

  • type in and watch -

    "Beamer James Durbin"

    check out this talented 8 year old doing his rendition

    of James Durbin's Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow.

  • James was totally ROBBED!! I fell in love w/Heidi & his darling son. James you WILL HAVE A CAREER!! Ignore the Haley fans who are trashing the final contestants's sites! My husband is especially upset with your elimination!! He loves METAL!!! Go forward with your TALENT sweet boy!  Blessings from "McGranny" in Virginia, Your career is there 4 your taking!!

  • i dont care if he is good or not i love it

  • James should have won the whole thing. Haley should have gone home and tje bottom two should have been between lauren and james. His voice is too amazing to go home

  • @funnybuddies4ever12 thats what i said! haley doesnt deserve to be there anymore. if he had stayed i wouldve thought the final 2 would be james and lauren. lol

  • James babydoll you got robbed!!!! It should have been Haley leaving!! She is such an arrogant person. Scottty was crying it hurt so bad!! I thought you & Scotty would be the final 2. Blessings to you & Your cute family!! McGranny in Virginia

  • 4 people who disliked didnt give metal a chance!

    GIVE METAL A CHANCE!! I LOVE YOU JAMES

  • scotty is crap

  • I cried when he went home last night :(

    Even though Lauren is my favorite...

  • this was his moment on the show, he was gypped last night

  • I almost cried when I herd he did not make it. :(

  • oh james,i loved you so much...its not fair.

  • I remember when I heard him sing this on AI for the first time ... I got chills people. Go Durbin !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • OHH, WHERE CAN i GET THE MP3 FROM?, my country's stupid itunes dont have these idol perfornances.

  • james is gonna win.in my eyes hes already won it.they shouldnt be on him for not controlling his emotions.hes great.

  • He is awesome! I feel sure he will have a long and lucrative career no matter what place he ends up in. I would buy his music.

  • He is awesome at any song he has done. He will have a long and lucrative career. wtg James!!!!

  • Trust me, James, fans are going to love you far longer than just tomorrow.

  • Awesome, beautiful and amazing. I have downloaded this great song on itune and I will buy all of James Durbin's CDs. American Idol 2011 is here! Please vote for James every Wednesday night for this star to win.

  • Yeh, most of time studio versions would be better than the live performances, but his live performance on this is too good that I just have to listen again and again.

  • He's great but unoriginal. Haley beats him any way from originality, and overall quality.

  • no originality! he's a clone of adam lambert!

    

  • @timosw91 Not a clone, he's more heavy rock if you know what I mean. Lambert is more acoustic rock these days.

  • everyone i know who was a casey fan, and i know a lot of casey fans, are going to vote for james now. i have a feeling james gained all the other casey votes.

  • I think the final 2 will be him and Lauren, then I think Lauren should win. James is too independent and wants to do it his way instead of have some label tell him what music he'll do. That's why I think it'd be better if he didn't win, cause once you win you pretty much sign your life away to the American Idol people and the label. James already knows exactly what he wants to do musically, so that would be bad for him. Lauren is young so she would need more guidance and direction.

  • The live version is definitely better than the studio version. Either way, though, this guy's got it going on! He's awesome!

  • I used to hate him, but now i think he's the best, he's never had a bad performance on the show.

  • Hes Fucking Ganna Win Amarican Idol(:

    Ganna Miss Casey But Durbin,I LOVE!!! Im Buying His First CD!!!!:P

    James Your So Fucking HOTT And AMZINGG!!!(:

  • I love James. But somehow I dont want him to win because he's too good of an artist. He should make his own music instead of eating what those stupid record companies give to singers. Go James and Haley!

  • One of James's best performance!!! =)

  • James durbin is words cant describe. I love how he ssid this was for heidi(:

  • Although he isn't my favorite, he is going to win. He is amazing.

  • He is an IDOL.....stunning voice, sexy as all hell.....and rocks the house! WE LOVE YOU JAMES!!!!!!!!!

  • best version of this phenomenal song.

  • his actual performances are always better than studio versions

  • @ldw13794 I disagree, his Studio while my guitar weeps was better

  • It's perfect!!!!! Like it so much!!!!!your voice so clear!!!!!that's wats up!!!!

  • look at every channel that uploads these american idol videos, he has significantly more views than anyone else he will be americas next top idol, i do not see how anyone could come out on top over him.

  • @BradHoliday Everyone else is just so.. similar, he really stands out in EVERYTHING he does!!!

  • Excellent version! Too fast, no way...it was perfect! Keep on rockin' James!

  • @davidbooke The beginning of the song is too fast... the rest is almost perfect.

    

  • Awesome well done James my favorite idol

  • Way too fast... still amazing though...

  • James Durbin is a problem for me xD this guy is so talented, and versatile and amazing. He even won a country idol a few years back...I've never been interested in an American Idol contestant before James. :D

  • Very cool sound on this one, thx. This is why they call it "Idol".

  • james is awesome! NEXT IDOL FOR SURE! :)

  • This performance was just beautiful. Shows he can sing rock and go soft and BACK and forth. Spectacular

  • I think he'll take it..and if he isn't the winner, I will be completely shocked. He's the best one in it. He can sing, he takes risks that work and he's amazingly entertaining...everything you want in a performer.

  • @FMNelly YES :)

  • @FMNelly

    I think it's safe to say that there are more people than not... that followed this entire season (like myself who don't usually watch Idol) just to see James perform every week, I'm a musician and a big fan of metal, rock, and anything else that takes talent and I can also safely say that there were way too many "shocked" people the other night when Haley's smirky disrespectful ass laughed while James was given the boot (like she does everyone). That's fine, James is already a success.

  • @DeEzriel James was class all the way. Haley=attitude issues. She's not gonna amount to anything. James is gonna be the true winner regardless of his shaft on AI. He's a a truly amazing singer and gifted musician and I appreciated everything he brought to the show. I can't wait till I hear his songs on the radio and cd's.

  • He's fucking good. Hope he takes it. Gonna miss Casey but Durbs the shizz

  • represent santa cruz go james!! :]

  • it started so high.. then higher.. and higher.. not so emotional compared to the original version..

  • I am in love with this song.

  • I love this dude!!!

  • I wish this studio version was set up like the live version.

  • Whoooahh.....! :)

    IDOL!

  • Go JAMES!!!!!!!!

  • waow!!!

    

  • will buy ur idol CD now. so so top class.

  • nice uploads dude

  • COOOLLL!

  • Love your videos. Thanks for uploading these gorgeous songs :) I'm waiting on Scotty's from tonight haha :P

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more