Songbird (Electric Demo)

[slashoasis156]

hello everyone,

so it seems like the new youtube just keeps updating stuff everytime, and now there's no way to find the "groups" option where you could go and post your original songs and get feedback. I hope I'm not bothering anyone with this comment, but I'd like to get some feedback on this song. (I'm still working on it)

watch?v=D83a5hJRHTc

thanks in advance!, just copy and paste the link above, if it doesn't work, just go to my channel and click on the song "yesterday". thanks again!

[rosswood0602]

hmmmmm ''i should of known better'' by the beatles? hmmmmmm... I LOVE IT!

[PageGallagher15]

THE BRITS WRITE THE BEST MUSIC EVER

60's- The Beatles

70's Led Zeppelin, Deep Purple

80's Dire Straits

90's OASIS BABY

ALL BRITS

[NoelGallagherIsGod]

@PageGallagher15 i've got no problem with that 60's and 70's list, but Bob Dylan absolutely needs to be there too

[Joker2009yuyo]

Japanese music also sucks. I envy British people.

[SDCParrot]

I'm a generic american that likes Oasis. Give me thumbs up, bitch.

[MiCretinaLisa]

I mean seriously guys? Nirvana was such a good band but their songs were too commercial, Oasis is way better than Nirvana, from an Argentinian girl :)

[MegaBanana51]

MUCH BETTER THAN THE ORIGINAL VERSION!!!

[Glenfenton]

I should of known better?

[AndrewBlair93]

@Glenfenton hahah i thought the same thing, you can hear the harmonica in the background.

[unclepic1]

@daystilljersey i disagree respectfully Nirvana was a great band no doubt, but trust me they were overratedin the states

[89thatsnumberwang]

i think when beady eye decide the time is right to throw a few oasis songs into their set this version of songbird would be brilliant for it.

[unclepic1]

God being American sucks if i ever say i like Oasis people go naahahanaha fucking Nirvana BRO!!!! Or Nah bra Pearl Jam far better! and i just want to say shut the fuck up take a second and listen to Definately Maybe and if your nothing short of a retard your opinion will change!

[NoelGallagherIsGod]

@unclepic1 same here... all i ever hear from friends is "wonderwall" or that they're beatles rip offs... then they proceed to listen to Kid Cudi or 50 cent. It's disgraceful.

[ATtravel666]

@NoelGallagherIsGod Wonderwall is what really got me hooked. Oasis are the only band that consistently produced tracks that I really liked, others had their good songs, but there were always some naff ones. Not these lads.

[daystilljersey]

@unclepic1 Nirvana's best album was better than Oasis' best album. Love to you from an English boy.

[NoelGallagherIsGod]

@daystilljersey Nirvana is garbage

[merocket]

@NoelGallagherIsGod You seem like a judgmental prick. Oasis were a fantastic band...but more so with their first two albums to be honest. Nirvana had 3 studio albums (if you want to even include Bleach cause it's definitely not as well known) and they were all phenomenal. Especially Nevermind to most people. You'll never come across a more iconic video than the one for 'Teen Spirit', but after all it's not fucking sports, it's music, who cares. Oasis were amazing as well.

[NoelGallagherIsGod]

@merocket i'm well aware nirvana meant a lot to a lot of people. That doesn't change my OPINION that Nirvana were garbage and overrated.

[merocket]

@NoelGallagherIsGod Want to elaborate?

[merocket]

@unclepic1 Where are you that people actually have an opinion and don't go "who"? I wish I could discuss bands with people I knew. And it's not a fucking war, Nirvana were incredible. As are Oasis.

[unclepic1]

@merocket I 100% Nirvanna was a great band, but my only point is Oasis is as good if not better but theyre treated like garbage in the states, lucky though i will admit my good friends do know theyre music but its about 50/50 half like Classic Rock and half like Mainstream shit

[GAFMIKEAL]

@unclepic1 First-World problems

[misteriox90]

Aa esa armonica es bien es d elos maravillosos beatles pero daño la cancion :(

[cambruoso]

@MrZsazs Thanks mate! Do you think they will get back together? I definitely do think they will.Noel and Liam need time apart and time to reflect.

[cambruoso]

@MrZsazs Yes it is the same bass line.I'm sure Andy and Oasis know that.That's probably why they didn't release it.Great version though! Which CD did you get it off?

[DannyMadFerIt]

@MrZsazs I just wanted to write it :D

[125years]

I would much prefer this version if it wasn't for that DAMN HARMONICA TUNE in the chorus! It ruins this version! If it wasn't for that, then I think that this version would be better. Love the fact that Liam's voice sounds like it's been destroyed.

[arijitanywhere]

Liam...the last great rock God...

[TelepathicTraffic]

Can't believe I never heard this version before. I can see how it didn't fit the album, but it gives an otherwise simple song a bit more interest.

[fernandinhaeu]

I like it so much!! =)))

[mauuro79]

i don't know why they included the other version.. this is better

[NoelGallagherIsGod]

sorry to spam you guys, but I wanna shout out my 2nd YouTube channel.

.com/TheRapture03

Any Call of Duty/video game fans please subscribe! Not really spectacular gameplay, just good objective based killin

[Chunkazoota]

The bass... ah, I know what it makes me think of! Rain by the Beatles.

I love this song, and this version is pretty cool, but I'm glad they went with the arrangement on the album.

[cyyytr0n]

makes me think of some early Beatles ;)

Especially "I should have know better" !

[yiddoluke]

the bassline ended up being used for probably all in the mind on the same album!!!!

[cushy23]

Us Americans are ignorant to real music like this. I wish I grew up in the UK

[NoelGallagherIsGod]

@cushy23 me too man, me too

[paccyc]

I am from Oklahoma City and have been a fan since the beginning with Oasis Tattoos to prove it, SO some Americans DO KNOW OASIS as the greatest band of all fucking time!!

[NoelGallagherIsGod]

@paccyc heh, yea. i got a couple Oasis tattoo's myself. (reppin Chicago by the way)

[indoorsun]

Never played this before - I fuckin like it!

[mitchc12345]

love gem's firebird collection

[stuartgunthorpe]

DIFFERENT! :-D

[griffinmiller24]

Bass part sounds sorta like rain by the beatles. and the harmonica sounds like I should have known better, but i like this song anyway

[fieldpool]

better than the original one ... <3

[psj3809]

Prefer this version by far. Great tune, had this version played at my wedding, me and all my mates went mental to it. Great original version, wish this was the song they released

[cupolove1]

sounds like gem playing lead more than noel.... maybe there will be some stuff like this on the new beady eye.

[38Highbury]

bass line is 'very andy bell' is it the same as Go Let It Out? Sounds like Waterfall too.

[NoelGallagherIsGod]

@38Highbury Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe this is the same bass line that ends up being used in (Probably) All in the Mind

[DanielCNP]

@NoelGallagherIsGod: exactly right! thats the all in the mind's bass. Did u know that it's bass was inspired on the beatles's within you or without you?

[Loud0glbc]

@38Highbury wasnt that noel on bass on go let it out?

[michaelkyoo777]

@38Highbury Noel played bass on Go Let It Out

[dpmagan]

@38Highbury Actually it was Noel the composer of the tabs for guitar and bass in Go Let It Out, you can see him playing a rickenbacker bass in the vid (only time in official video I guess), Andy was not recruited yet...

Cheers.

[bobbygolfing59]

blows the album version away

[LeBuckeye]

Man if this is what Beady Eye is gonna be like we are all in for a treat.

[andrx04]

o thanx !!! god how much i live it !!!!1

[TheMartin2212]

Oasis is fuckin' great! The best band in the world!

[WLuico]

good times

[monkeyboy0910]

they should have released this version. it's far better!

[madferret96]

I get this Christmas feeling when I listen to this version

[damoos]

Better than the album version. By a country mile !

[strettyford]

The backing sounds so like something straight from The Beatles/ Bob Dylan, I love it :)

[pansyxrevenge9]

por que no pusieron esta evrsion en el album?!

[Hugoow16]

vocals are brilliant on this.

[blink87ita]

that version is completly s.hit

[blink87ita]

that tune is a completly shit, the best version is only the acoustic one ;)

[MrMUGS94]

better then the orginal

[MrMUGS94]

so much better than the original why wasnt it on the album its fucking great!

[oneUNITED7SS]

The background sounds similar to that Beatles song that they played on the train in 'Hard Day's Night'.

[DoJoCasiNo]

the bass line seems the one from "Waterfall"

[adamm919]

loyal US fan here. I love Oasis, and its a damn shame that most fellow americans dont know a single masterpiece by them besides wonderwall.

[NoelGallagherIsGod]

I know what ya mean. We're stuck here listening to shitty music like rap, and that American Idol wanna be shit.

[adamm919]

seriously=/ if i ever went on one of those programs to sing it would be this song and a Fing tribute to Oasis

[slimjoel14]

too right mate, too fucking right

[TheBurningOcean182]

@NoelGallagherIsGod so true

[savagebhoy]

@adamm919 ..........mate i like your chat..

[larsmelsom]

MINT!

[noelwannabe]

better than the finsl version, the harmonica is the same as "i should have known better" and thats a good little solo

[thelastpartizan]

Brilliant Version, fair play for uploading it.

[ldmunoz]

so nice!!! i love this song and this version fucking rules!!!

[0308920133]

where can i download this

[monkeyboy0910]

this is better than the original i think

[where8angels8play]

The bass sounds like 'probably all in the mind'

[mrleefosho]

i like the harmonica and outtro tho.

[LiamGallagherGod]

OASIS FOREVER

[noelsplectrum9]

thats just mega that is summery as fuck i luv mouth organs

[hahayouredead33]

They should have taken the harp scheme and the drumming into the album version, I think.

[emioasisfull]

the best version of his song

[NoelGallagherIsGod]

yea, i like this version better, but it would've worked on the album. I like it being a little hidden gem.

[Elmo5195jan]

fucking amazing, Gem is my idol

[TheArgentoMusic]

i want to download this fuckin version!

its awesome!

[RoastieFella]

This only didn't make the album because Noel was behind all the music on it,

Simple as.

[herewefukingo]

never heard ths a4 good likes

[hipwell4342]

Epic.

[aklein123456789]

same bass line as "rain" by the beatles....

[stevemodeen]

good spy!

[Loothy]

acoustic ftw!

this verson is good yes, but in terms of the whole 'feel' of the song and lyrics, acoustic is better. plus you cant beat the hand claps and the beat of the acoustic version.

[saaroron]

brilliant!

[manualfie112]

well maybe because its a real love song about liams then girlfriend, now his wife, liam simply wanted it to be an acoustic number dedicated to his loved one.

this sounds fuckin quality though i do prefer it

[fhuf45rh4r54ukr4jhrn]

this was life wasnt it? sure i heard it the vids on youtube

[george2912]

very beatles-esque

[stevenmcg69]

tyhis is the 1 that should have been on the album

[wegaify]

sounds better than the album version..........

[jeremylovesmusic]

Sounds classic =]

[Woodyhcfc]

sounds veryyy similar to "should have known better" by the beatles. Great song though :)

[kosk94]

THIS VERSION IS FUCKING AMAZING !!!!

[elwebon87]

This song , sounds like a song from the Beatles

[MoonwalkerWorshiper]

Your comment sounds like a new daftheaded ignorant tosspot having a shit; "Oh oasis are beatles tribute band and I'm a faggot who knows 0% about music"

[marcpreston1]

The Best Version Of This Is When The Single Beat Bass Drum Is In The Background

[Furhood1982]

i like this demo version lot more better than the album version...the bass sounded so bad ass, very 1965 the beatles revolver and you bird can sing kind of feel...top song.

[GoCubs3425]

Exactly what I was thinking... I like em both

[RamiroHF]

bassline - all in the mind

[fayaoasis]

of course better than original

[danilson69]

Better than the original.

awesome bass all the song.

[lolZEPPELINrules]

i like this version almost as much as i like the original... I'm willing to guess that noel wrote alot of the arrangement for this version tho... maybe thats why they stuck with the original

[PinkBeltedNinja]

I'm not too fond of Liam Gallagher (I still love Oasis itself!), but I've always liked this song and the fact that he's written it. I also like this version of the song. :]

[andilovetheBeatles]

I'm fond of Liam but I agree with you :)

cheers

Love Oasis!

[luesant]

i love this electric demo version !!!! el la melodia del bajo queda super bien .

[md47bot]

this version is like rain you know the beatles song

[CaptainWillJackSparr]

sor of but its more like "i should have known better"

[md47bot]

well it's just a matter of opinion

[MartynField]

two opinions, i also agree...

[BrotherHoodUtd]

te pic at 0:46 is amazing lol

[CaptainWillJackSparr]

Its a mix of Songbird and I should have known better!!!!!! i love it!!!! :D

[tucc4113]

naw other version

[ItsTheQuigley]

Love this Beatle-ish version, great

[tomrizzo41999]

I agree, I have this version on my iPod, and I like this one far more then the final.

[noddingtons]

how do you download this version to iPod?

[aidaninc]

the other instruments ruin the point of liam's song, but i think they should have published both versions on itunes.

[saitoasis90]

no, its the harmonica the one that sounds like the beatles

[rockfreakbitch]

damn i love this version better!

[desasterz]

the best , they should've used that one

[jorgeeL92]

who the fuck is blur?

who the fuck is manutd?

fuck that!

OASIS IS ROCK!

[Mrlovemedo]

sounds better then the original

[725pete725]

top bassline, very beatles-esque

[DiefortheClan]

what a brilliant outro!

[queenodoubt]

sounds too much like the beatles

[Gabotas21]

I thought exactly the same when I first heard it...

[connaught2008]

only the bass sounds like the beatles i think

[merlinmercer]

like taxman

[knoxiuz]

woah andy bell nice bass line haha

[PICHICHI90]

sounds like paperback writer

[yenrald]

the intro of demo version was just like i should have know you better by the beatles

[emanuoasis]

no evil... very nice, also so is be liked..

[sparlund]

it's kinda lame to do and old popular song as a b-side on a new album. Then everyone would whine about how they cant make any goods song today, so they have to use the old ones.

[bulldog359]

he means the actual song should not have been on heathen chemistry but should have been some sort of bonus/b-side.

[sparlund]

ops, sry.

[LIL2511]

Beeeeeast

[mag666gam]

I think the albumn version works better

[lately31]

the intro SONGBIRD(oasis)= "I Should Have Known Better"(THE BEATLES)

the harmonica.

[SGustafsson]

they should've kept the harmonica

[ffmcracdcftw]

I wish they didn't go plain and simple on this song, the harmonica and bass is awesome and addicting.

[shizpenguin]

fact is if they didnt change it people would cry about it copying the beatles, besides it loses some of its appeal by not being as simple as it would have been.

I like both, but from a guitarists perspective the album version is more intricate, albeit much simpler.

[supersonicspringy]

this to me is better than what they put on the album

[Jalla008]

Magic tune from the kings

[plz1981]

i never thought the album version cud be bettered but fookin hell, this version is awesome!! anyone know where I can get this version for my IPOD?????

[sparlund]

Google on things like "youtube to mp3", and you'll find programs that can do it.

[RetroGuy5000]

ive been askin myself this question since 1994 why are oasis the best band in the world?! answear is coz they just fucking are!

[crispyeverclean]

the bass is from probably all in the mind of heathen chemistry.

[Samantha2342]

this version is better than the final version

[wallythelegend]

pic at 00:45 is mega!!

fuckin tune also....mad fer it!!!

[myjobispoo]

fookin mega!!!

[Geraldon1]

pretty fuckin cool

[superlonely90]

uyy seria un albun bueniiiisisisimo

[jgreenwood99]

tbh, if this had been released and then we heard the acoust version now then wed all be saying that that was better, and a lot better at that. its only cos its different that you like it. in my opinion this version sucks all the emotion out of it.

[flagga]

Much better than the final version

[taxblyte]

I  shoulda known better lol defo got this from the Beatles great melody tho

[sgeorge99]

The doors are only rated because Jim Morrison is dead....the same as Kurt Cobain was revered only after his death and the same for any other idiot who kills themselves (looks like Amy 'needs a bath' Winehouse is going that way too, hopefully).....Noel is living legend, a songwriting genius....btw, Noel never wrote this song, Liam did!

[doorsforce]

so the beatles are only rated cause of john lennon's death?or perhaps george harrison's?is bob marley remembered because of being shot?

how about keith?

how about bonzo?

how about hendrix?

how about janis?

stfu they're remembered for their work,not for their "infamous" deaths

[JayJaySoul]

i ask you..

would 2pac and biggie be so big if they were alive..?

i think maybe not.. but beatles definatly remember'd for music and not deaths.