Added: 3 years ago
From: biancawoehlk
Views: 332,528
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,017)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i like it

    

  • i love his voice and the lyrics.

  • thanks for this amazing video!! i voted for him every performance!! and im so proud to call myself a fellow "word nerd" "cookiemonster" <3

  • amazing...

  • I love this song very much :)

  • i love this song!

    best wishes form germany! :)

  • I mean I love the whole song,but the passage between 1:00 and 1:30 is absolutely gorgeous! I love it :)

  • RIP Adam Cook }{

  • lol truly better than original... those who arent the opinion are rly gay

  • @WithTheFrag Actually your completely wrong, this can't touch the original. Learn to talk by the way.

  • He has definitely done this song justice really good!! Love the original.

  • Amazingly well done, and inspiring!

  • IM SORRY TO SAY BUT NO 1 I MEAN NOBODY CAN EVEN GET CLOSE TO THE VERSION FROM OUR LADY PEACE

  • Comment removed

  • im a huuuuugge OLP fan and I dont agree with some people hating on his cover, his voice is rough and scruffy, yet when the chorus comes his voice is soo soothing, I really like this cover, better orginal is always best<3

    OLP FOREVER<3!

  • @MusicG00d - I agree. All I said was that Cook is technically a better sing but Maida has more heart. They are his lyrics after all.

  • I like this version better than the original.

  • The original is amazing, but David Cook does it justice.

  • Love this studio version, amazingly good, compassionate, really all about this guy's point of view. And his voice....wow.

  • nothing beats the original, the chorus is a bit rushed, bu i like it he has a great voice

  • Wow. At first I was kinda upset that Archie didn't win, but after listening to his first Cd, I now know, that I am okay with him winning. They are both really good singers, but I still love Archie!!

  • Wow, it's one thing to say you don't like a cover, and another to say he ruined the song. Seriously what the fuck are you hater's problems. He is clearly a talented musician.

  • He completley ruined this amazing song.

  • He sung this song for his Brother who sadly passed away from cancer. You can feel the emotion, he truly is a deserving winner of American idol and a very very very top singer. Good on you David Cook.

  • @Hoooooorseyman5 He sang 'Permanent' for his brother, Adam. But yes, David Cook is THE best.

  • He is so amazing, and if I could take him home with me oh god how I would. He's a perfect specimen of a man. I would give anything just to meet him someday, or even have a private performance.........

  • it's good but the original is always the best, olp forever

  • Love this performance one of his best and you can tell he feels what he's singing

  • i think his best performence.

  • one of the few people to go on american idol that i like.cook,clay,adam,kris,andre­w,crystal and chris.

  • Im a huge fan of Our Layd Peace, and this is one of my Favourite songs by them.I gotta say, he did an amazing job with it! Bravo David!=D

  • i bought this song because of him, can't say that about any other idol contestant

  • best singer in the world never gonna be anyone better

  • I cannot remember him seeing this song on idol, but I wish I would have payed more attention to it 'cus its freaking amazing.

  • @ZivXanthus i dont really remember him singing this either, but I think he sang it for idol gives back... song fits

  • @randomlydia It really does. I like it a lot!

  • One of my itunes highest play count of his studio versions. Flove it

  • i luv david cook

  • THANKS FOR POSTING! LOVE THIS SONG! LOVE HIS VERSION! LOVE the emotion he pput on the song ;))

  • i think his version is better than the original... his vocals are awesome...

  • Cook is good...one of the only Idols (from both US and Canada) I can tolerate.

    But NO ONE can beat Maida, even if he's 40...Maida's is better, Cooks is too deep for this song, but it's done well

  • @kennygmang

    sorry if i offend you with my comment... i just really admire Cook's vocals.. he's so versitile... the only song i know from Our Lady Peace is Innocent.. well i think i can't compare them... they're both amazing..

  • Love The Song

  • Good. He really has nice voice. amazing.

  • why dont people like him i mean yeah the girl might like archuleta but come on david is way better idk why i like cook probably cause he sound awesome

  • luv him

  • He needs to go out and be more original with it, I think.

    It's good, by all accounts, but what he did with Eleanor Rigby and Billie Jean was so different, and I was expecting the same here.

    But it is good. just make it your own.

  • @tfinuyasha I really think that David DID want to keep this specific song the same, because he loves Our Lady Peace...and he said he wanted to stay true to this one. And I listen to Our Lady Peace a lot, and he DID change a few things, nothing drastic, but he put a small personal spin on it.

  • lol He did other people's covers.

    Chris Cornell did Billie Jean like that first.

    And some other band did Eleanor Rigby.

    HE admitted to doing it like them.

    Always Be My Baby was (I think) one that was really good and different.

  • i like the way david sang this song.the rhythm of the sound and david's voice. but i wonder why simon didn't like it.

  • @patatim26 cuz simons just stupid

  • So true

    oscar13erdiansyah, so true.

  • <3 this man!!

  • This man could sing the phone book and it would be amazing! he is the greatest person to ever grace the american idol stage! in my opinion this is by-far his best performance.

  • @brittanytaylor89 he's good. but i give the 'greatest person to grant the american idol stage' award to Miss Kelly Clarkson..by far

  • @brittanytaylor89 Have to agree with you about David Cook. Amazing is not a good enough word for him. Don't know if I'd call this his best only because I couldn't begin to choose a best. They're all really good, and many of them are simply fabulous. Best Idol EVER. Seriously talented man with the most magnificent voice I've ever heard.

  • Does anyone know the chords for this song?

    It's really good and i'd love to learn it on guitar:P

  • This is a fan-made video, not a real music video, so I don't get the comparison. Cook performed this OLP cover when he was a contestant on American Idol and this is just a "studio recording" for fans of the show. It is not even available for distribution. Nonetheless, I still love the way Cook sings it.

  • can someone tell me which episode or whtevr they were doing from 1:42 - 1:50????

  • It's from the Top 10 results show. And what they're doing is the famous Mavid chest bump #1. ;)

  • he was in a minor band that played at a bar - he isn't a professional - he had a job and everything, singing was a hobby.

  • Actually, if you look at it, almost all the other top 12 contestants had even more experience or connections than he did. Archuleta had won Star Search, Castro was on the MTV show Cheyenne, Carly released a record on MCA while Randy was working for them, Kristy Lee Cook had her album released by a major Nashville label, Michael Johns' old band had a major label deal, the list goes on.

    Anyway, the original is my favourite song of all time, so for not totally butchering it, props to Cook.

  • PAAAAULAAAA :( WHY DID YOU GOOO???!!!

  • hes alright but noone can beat raine maida's version!!!1 :D he does an ok job but raine is better singer on every level especially live!!!

  • You don't deserve the thumbs down for reppin' OLP man.

  • I definitely prefer OLP's version, but David does a pretty good job.

  • I melted when I first heard this. I had (and still have) the biggest most obsessive crush on him. I counted the weeks from the day that I fell in love with him (I think it was March 24, 2008... The day that he did Billie Jean).

  • Of course it was after Billie Jean :-/

  • Are you implying that I got the date wrong, because I know that I probably did.

  • No I'm just saying...

    A lot of people tend to forget that David had an album before AI that got taken off itunes and stuff and was a legitimate artist before.

    AND that a lot of people tend to start riding David's nuts after his 'best' performance.

  • I, personally, thought that Always Be My Baby was his best. And I really enjoy his pre-idol stuff. Silver is a great song, and is is Optimistic to a Fault.

    When David Cook did Billie Jean, I was in the middle of this Michael Jackson obsession and I'd already loved Cook from when he did All Right Now, and Billie Jean just made it official for me because it was like he'd read my mind..

  • Oh well then I'm so sorry for being a dick to youu

    :-)

    For real, I'm really sorry!

  • Oh its fine, I totally understand. A real Cookie must always defend David :)

  • i luv always be my baby and optimistic to a fault 2!!!!! and the list goes on and on for me i luv all his songs.........

  • Very good, David!

  • just another great cover from David : )

  • ugh no!!! our lady peace is briliant! this is just no good, he should try to sing kinda lifehouse style!

  • i´m not a purist, just i think this kind of voice is not suited for a rock pop structure song. i think he should try with others styles like rock folk, or maybe hard rock. Our lady peace version is almost perfect.

  • our lady peice version is way better but this is pretty good

  • I love when guys voices are hoarse lol :) it sounds hot! lol

  • I love this song,when David had this version...I love it...I swear....Shows how versatile,talented and amazing he is....

  • ur the best ever i listen to it 5x a day :) keep rocking it ur better then original

  • cook's vocals is okay..he won anyway..

  • cook's version is a good cover

    of course he does not sing like the original

    BECAUSE he has his own style of singing

    and song interpretation

    he did a good job with this

  • shit!!

    he can't sing like Raine Maida does!

    David stinks xS

  • if by ruin you mean sings CIRCLES around the original and makes the song worth listening to... then yeah you're right....

  • oneneo228. You're crazy. Cook may be able to hit all the notes that Maida hits, and may even be a better singer technically. But he can't match Raine Maida's heart and soul.

  • But you cannot say that he is bad.

  • dis vidio is makadiyos

  • It's a million times better than the live one.

  • wow...this guy is totally not Raine Maida! Not a terrible cover, but I'll take the real thing.

  • Our Lady Peace sounds better doing this song and yet David Cook singing this song is more memorable for me.

  • OLP rocks...

    and david cook's voice is great with the song!!

    i feel that i'm like johnny..

    i also "wish to be famous, spend my time alone in the basement, with the LENNON and COBAIN and, a guitar and a stereo.. "

  • wow. i love our lady peace (im going to see them in concerton june 20th)

    but this is really good. i love it alot

  • I FRICKIN LOVE THIS SONG!!

  • David is amazing!!!He is so handsome and his voice is beautiful !!

  • true, but.. you kept spelling "you're" wrong, its you are not your. [:

  • INCREDIBLE!

    I liked the live version more though.

  • Awesome job on this song

  • omg. This song is amazing, He is amazing...

  • this is the song that got me in to david

  • me too aswell :) cook is way better than lambert

  • nooo, well i LOOOOOVE them both :)

  • youre right. :))

  • @ejgonzalez11 yes Cook has a warmer voice than Lambert

  • amazing version

  • i really love this song! and he does so well at it too!!! <33 ! ily david! <3

  • i thought one the best moments when he was asked what the highlights were was when he said Raine maida called him and said what a good job he did with Innocent, i cannot imagine how overwhelming that phone call must have been for him.

  • Hardcore OLP fan here. I have to say that David Cook did a decent job singing this, but nothing can touch Raine Maida's original version. You can try to imitate Raine's voice, but you can't imitate the raw emotion he sings with.

    Again, though, I was still pleased with David's version.

  • yeahh..... no offense to you or anything, but i hate archuleta. he can sing about as well as my 10 year old sister. and he looks her age too! DAVID COOK 4 EVAH!!! <333 !!!

  • David is Da BEST!

  • One year performance anniversary (4/8/08). I love OLP, and I also loved this performance that Dave did. The studio version is awesome. David Cook, I miss seeing you every week on Idol. You are amazing. How refreshing to have had a true musician on Idol.

  • Yeah David!!!!!!! :)

  • wow...much better than his live performance (as it ought to be)

    he does much better when he's yelling more so than when he tries to imitate Raine's low voice....

  • xoxoxoxox

  • Love it, keep coming back to it. x

  • LOVE this song and him <3

  • nah man. this cant touch our lady peace. not even close. good attempt though. leave it to raine though :)

  • i didn't liked it the first time, but it wasn't bad, at least it's better than 4 or 5 archuleta's performances, considering this wasn't his good

  • i loveeeee himmmm sooooo muchhhhh he is soooo amazinnggggg!!!!!! <3333333

  • yeah this awesome, im not sure if his is better then olp verison though. i would like to see david sing supermans dead

  • lol idk if he can hit the high notes that raine hit in that song but it would b awesome

  • awesome!love this!!!i love him i went to his concert and it was awesome!!!!!!

  • you really make fantastic videos :) nice job! on all of them!

  • i dnt know this song but he rocked it and i keep listening to this song, its really good! go david!!!

  • I love this song ;) Cook's version is so good!

  • Our Lady Peace's version is so much better than this.

  • wow -4 thumbs down dont hate hes right olp is much better

  • D. Cook can certainly sing but sooo right, not even close to original by OLP. Raine Maida's voice is so unique--makes trying to cover it a no win situation for guy with more classic polished style.

  • Comment removed

  • he is ahmazing im goin 2 his concert in 8 days!!!!im so excited!!!!he was ahmazing on the show and now going with his career!!!!he is soooo awesome!!!!!!!

  • This a really beautiful song I just happened to stumble along. I like the video!

  • this is an excellent version to the song. done.

  • saw this on scrubs :D

    but i just head the original by Our Lady Peace its a bit better but David Cook is still awsome at this song and his cover of eleanor rigby :)

  • i love david cook!!!

  • saw this on scrubs, starnge they would use a american idol song in a telvision song

  • i know me too i just watched the new the scrubs and i heard this so it made me listen to this again

  • and which scrubs was this? i try to watch the new ones but i missed one or two.

  • Simply beautiful  (David, his voice and his big beautiful heart)

    I love that he chose this song over other better known songs because it was a song that meant so much to him.

  • Lo Adoro!!!!

  • definitely better than our lady peaces version

  • awsome song david sings it awsome

  • I love this. :) David is the best.

  • this is great.

  • I lovee him. :58 is my screen saver on my cell phone.!

  • i am a total arch angel but i like cook too and i loved this song by him, i cant believe the judges totally bashed him for this

    :/

  • ughhh i love him (: amazing voice :)

  • after hearing this, i listened to olp. love both. but made me want to hear more of olp.

  • at 2:59 he is so seductive!

  • omg i totally agree!! :)

  • ahh omfg, yesssss, he totally is :D

    watta hottie :P

  • OMG I know! haha :) :) :)

  • DAVID COOK RULESSSSS!!!!

  • I love Olp and David Cook, I like Olp's version better, but David still got an awesome voice.

  • He gets points for hitting the falsettos nicely, but his voice is nowhere near as interesting or compelling as Raine Maida's, even if he is a decent singer.

  • the judges look to see who has ORIGINALITY

    that means you CHANGE the song from it's original version to make it YOUR OWN version

  • OLP will forever be a great band, but that doesnt mean David Cook didn't do a phenomenal job on this song. It's a little more edgier, and sexier to be honest, and I LOVE OLP mind you.