Why do all of you keep saying the ' Sax ' its not a saxaphone, its a Clarinet. Not sure you should judge music if you don't even know the difference between two completely different instruments !! Do you.. Excellent music either way...
@KaZeDaRKWiND Of course it includes a sax, tough the notes ain't the exact onesthta Jay plays here. In fact, the recording process can be seen in the first DT DVD
I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LI
WOW i just couple days ago listened to this on itunes and i thought the sax solo is played by J. Rudess with keyboards...damn, this dude beats almost the epic sax guy
He would have improvised all of his sax parts, just like he did in the studio when they recorded the album. I too think that it's not as good as I&W, but it's still pretty damn good.
@Silvioismorespiertu jaja if u were a sax player u knew who is the guy its playing there. a clue.... Spyro Gyra. u need to learn more about good music.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Pobre James... no tuve una buena noche ese dia ... no pego un tono. y los agudos ? se se los comieron los ratones... jejeje... no... hay que cantar another day... muy complicado vocalmente, otro que no se salvo fue el saxofonissta no pego un puto tono desafino como un hijo de puta... jajaja°°°
@maxvega61 =S dios santo, anda al medico y hacete ver los iodos, o mejor todavia sacate las papas de las orejas... o mejor aun, deja de decir tantas boludeces juntas
Mira man... yo no hablo boludeces... y Dream es una de mis bandas favoritas! de hecho soy tecladista y "Rudess" es mi "idolo!!! para tu info...y se reconocer cuando tocan como el cul@, y esta no es una buena performance, si para vos esta bien es por que sos un sordo y nos sabes perder!
@maxvega61 JAJAJAJA es una exelente performance en VIVO!!!! por ahid eberias dejar de usar tanto salmpler, y tanto sonido predefinido y usar un instrumento mas analogico para saber lo q es sacr uno mismo el sonido ;)
ahh y otra cosa: si para vos esta bien es por que sos un sordo y nos sabes perder! cuantos años tenes?? :S 5? por tmb no me vas a acusar con tu mama :S
Para tu info canto también imbecil... y tengo un registro de tres octavas y media... y tengo grandes cantantes como influencia!!! y hay cosas de labrie que me gustan... por ej... en las baladas... los matices que tiene son geniales! Y aclaro no es por quedar bien con vos... pero también toco la viola y VAI es un idolo!!! a lo igual que SATCH el (GORDO) jaja y otros!!! asi que no se por que te ofendiste... si lo que dije es verdad?? DREAM es de la ostia! y hay otras performances mucho mejores...
really like this guitar solo, it's structure. Here he played the first part the way it suppose to be - smooth, lots of slides, and creamy sounds. But - he mess second part (started with quick progression)- many unwanted tones, pitches, nervous ending.
Basta de decir que Portnoy es un grande..!!! en el fin del solo de "sax" bajo el tempo muy feeeooo...!!! y en el gran solo de Petrucci mete esos redobles pedorros..que arruina lo que petrcci quiere decir.. es una pena ya que es una cancion demaciado bella como para......
they're not robots to do eveything perfect dude, and I don't hear nothing wrong with the sax, all I hear is not exactly the same notes than on the recording :S
Look at how he does it these days. His tone here is at least listenable. So what if he can't hit the notes? Since when are high notes the only important part of a vocal?
Hope live in Jakarta same day...
oyemaya01 2 weeks ago
I love I love I love!!!
TheFenice0 1 month ago
Spyro Gyra is amazing. I suggest everyone check them out.
OneTakeJesus 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
labrie don't sing anything here. This is the problem, not the sax.
youdontmesswithzorro 3 months ago
labrie don't sing anything here. This is the problem, not the sax.
youdontmesswithzorro 3 months ago
2:32 turn slow :p
spinkicker27 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
search @ Soprano Sax, you'll see a sax that looks like a klarinet...
hahaha, its a ty people!
gsxracer1977 6 months ago
Hahaha, I look like a total soprano sax snob. Sorry about that >:] Amazing video though. I wish it would have made it to the DVD.
kklocket2 7 months ago
Soprano Sax people. Nothing more, nothing less.
kklocket2 7 months ago
Why do all of you keep saying the ' Sax ' its not a saxaphone, its a Clarinet. Not sure you should judge music if you don't even know the difference between two completely different instruments !! Do you.. Excellent music either way...
danieledney10 7 months ago
@danieledney10 Oh geeez......it's a freaking soprano saxophone man. :|
kklocket2 7 months ago
@danieledney10 it's a sax dude....
csraquino 7 months ago
@danieledney10 Yeah it's definitely a soprano sax, it sounds completely like a sax and they don't make clarinets out of metal
thericecrispy2 7 months ago
@danieledney10
you're rightman, look @ 1;45 all!!
it's no sax!! Oh, and i love the old DT :-)
gsxracer1977 6 months ago
Best part is when sax start at 4:00
MsPetar1995 7 months ago
Damn good sax player.
BloodTar 7 months ago
Is this Jay Beckenstein? He ruined the original sax parts of the song, and he's out of tune with the rest of the band.
jerinian 9 months ago
@jerinian The original song doesn't include a sax... and he isn't out of tune from the band... I can confirm this, I am musician myself.
KaZeDaRKWiND 8 months ago
@KaZeDaRKWiND Of course it includes a sax, tough the notes ain't the exact onesthta Jay plays here. In fact, the recording process can be seen in the first DT DVD
aruizislas 7 months ago
@KaZeDaRKWiND It does have a soprano sax. Check out a making of from the album, or just listen to the tone quality of the instrument. It's there.
kklocket2 7 months ago
I'm a fan of sex
vgsjim777 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LIKE I LI
TheOnerdw 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
watch?v=wDRCR3OVrzM
Strange Deja Vu
my version!
goryyen 11 months ago
WOW i just couple days ago listened to this on itunes and i thought the sax solo is played by J. Rudess with keyboards...damn, this dude beats almost the epic sax guy
apina313 11 months ago
wtf! i got this dvd, but it doesn't include this track...
MrLiveMetal 11 months ago
if the sax is improvised not know, but I liked
langehirth 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
yes The sax player is Jay Beckenstein of Spyro Gyra......most of the best players
raggionapoletano 1 year ago
He would have improvised all of his sax parts, just like he did in the studio when they recorded the album. I too think that it's not as good as I&W, but it's still pretty damn good.
TehMickster 1 year ago
Dream theater is nothing without you Mikey!
666jamesroot 1 year ago
@666jamesroot wrong
Ouann 1 year ago
@Ouann nooooo
666jamesroot 1 year ago
Guitar was perfect. Vocals could've been better.
razorslice17 1 year ago
@razorslice17 A lot better... But he tried. Dropping down to the lower octaves was a good idea on his part. :-)
leifo5343 1 year ago
The saxophonist is not so good as i thought, and i say this coz i am a saxophonist
Silvioismorespiertu 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Silvioismorespiertu is Jay Beckenstein of Spyro Gyra. youre not a saxophonist.
Doppler1704 1 year ago
@Silvioismorespiertu jaja if u were a sax player u knew who is the guy its playing there. a clue.... Spyro Gyra. u need to learn more about good music.
Doppler1704 1 year ago
@MistaMeeetch i think its a soprano sax.
cfybbdrummer 1 year ago
@cfybbdrummer yes its a soprano man.
Doppler1704 1 year ago
3:12 - 3:41 <3
BEAUTIIIIIIIIIFUL!!!
VicaCOBHC 1 year ago
@VicaCOBHC as always JP sound awesomeness
Ouann 1 year ago
@Ouann right! lol XDDDD
VicaCOBHC 1 year ago
My first DT solo on guitar and complete song learned of them, I spent like 20 days practicing that solo... and still one of my fav.
bkarame 1 year ago
i like this video a lot... it reminds me our past gig... i sing this song until now........one of my favorite piece!!!!!!
krayzievhinx 1 year ago
i love how when petrucci hits that sour note in the solo *QUICK PULL OUT BRAIN BLASTER IMPROVE!!
Lakross101 1 year ago
@Lakross101 There is no such thing as a sour note in a solo.. let alone a Petrucci solo. :]
GoatseFarm 1 year ago
why wasnt this on the metropolis dvd? :(
Fergusforslipknot 2 years ago 2
la cancion del tabito 2010
nicoxedge 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Pobre James... no tuve una buena noche ese dia ... no pego un tono. y los agudos ? se se los comieron los ratones... jejeje... no... hay que cantar another day... muy complicado vocalmente, otro que no se salvo fue el saxofonissta no pego un puto tono desafino como un hijo de puta... jajaja°°°
maxvega61 2 years ago
@maxvega61 ... yo creo que si uno canta 4 horas no tiene ni voz... y james canto 4 hroas y se pego esta cancion... yo creo q el wn es brigido...
DavidAGA1 2 years ago 3
@maxvega61 =S dios santo, anda al medico y hacete ver los iodos, o mejor todavia sacate las papas de las orejas... o mejor aun, deja de decir tantas boludeces juntas
yjmpgkl 2 years ago
Mira man... yo no hablo boludeces... y Dream es una de mis bandas favoritas! de hecho soy tecladista y "Rudess" es mi "idolo!!! para tu info...y se reconocer cuando tocan como el cul@, y esta no es una buena performance, si para vos esta bien es por que sos un sordo y nos sabes perder!
maxvega61 2 years ago
@maxvega61 JAJAJAJA es una exelente performance en VIVO!!!! por ahid eberias dejar de usar tanto salmpler, y tanto sonido predefinido y usar un instrumento mas analogico para saber lo q es sacr uno mismo el sonido ;)
ahh y otra cosa: si para vos esta bien es por que sos un sordo y nos sabes perder! cuantos años tenes?? :S 5? por tmb no me vas a acusar con tu mama :S
yjmpgkl 1 year ago
Para tu info canto también imbecil... y tengo un registro de tres octavas y media... y tengo grandes cantantes como influencia!!! y hay cosas de labrie que me gustan... por ej... en las baladas... los matices que tiene son geniales! Y aclaro no es por quedar bien con vos... pero también toco la viola y VAI es un idolo!!! a lo igual que SATCH el (GORDO) jaja y otros!!! asi que no se por que te ofendiste... si lo que dije es verdad?? DREAM es de la ostia! y hay otras performances mucho mejores...
maxvega61 1 year ago
from 3:15 onwards, you will see that the sax player is enjoying John Petrucci's solo. what a compliment. :)
rexpinsel 2 years ago 7
I didn't like Portnoys' playing in this specific song...it was way too uninteresting..Liked the album version more...(Imo)
McbrainisgoD 2 years ago
Is that a sax? What kind of sax is he using?
steelattack 2 years ago
he's using a soprano sax. im actually trying to learn to play the sax part for this song with my band
eldioblo911 2 years ago
this song is cool ... but i really hate when an instrument like trumpet, saxophone etc. is played in a smooth way, like kenny g does.
Beuma 2 years ago
Poor James, a four hour set. Only teh best can do this. Amasing to see this vid!
JeffLamercy 2 years ago 3
i know, he was struggling, but he did it!
steelfish66 2 years ago
where did you get this?? it isn't included in the metropolis 2000 DVD
metal1583 2 years ago
It's included as an extra in the Live Scenes from New York 3-CD pack.
rodolfostanic 2 years ago
The sax player is Jay Beckenstein of Spyro Gyra????????????????
brisky81 2 years ago 33
clarinet
VerdiKtagrad 2 years ago
@brisky81 yes
Matttix 1 year ago
@brisky81 Yes. exactly
danielworks 11 months ago
I love this music solo. *---*
LucasFH85 2 years ago
What a sax ! Incredible !
fabinhosp1977 2 years ago
its a clarinet
soske19 2 years ago
XD XD XD
villevalojr 2 years ago
Comment removed
Lavern86 2 years ago
nope. Soprano saxophone.
Motorheadrummer 2 years ago
really like this guitar solo, it's structure. Here he played the first part the way it suppose to be - smooth, lots of slides, and creamy sounds. But - he mess second part (started with quick progression)- many unwanted tones, pitches, nervous ending.
wujekg 2 years ago
embouchure of a god
excellent all round
metALLIca15091993 2 years ago
Petrucci has god-like tone on this performance!
kcajk 2 years ago
Basta de decir que Portnoy es un grande..!!! en el fin del solo de "sax" bajo el tempo muy feeeooo...!!! y en el gran solo de Petrucci mete esos redobles pedorros..que arruina lo que petrcci quiere decir.. es una pena ya que es una cancion demaciado bella como para......
leandrummmer 3 years ago
love this song
123jozef 3 years ago
I've got that DVD but another day's not there :|
bubum4n 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
labrie at 2:13 is just fucking amazing!!!!
polfer 3 years ago
poor james, u can tell he's strugling to find his old voice...but he STILL did FUCKIN AMAZING!!!!!!!!
fatass0123 3 years ago 4
Sax is out of tune, LaBrie sometimes sing to low. Except that, it is beautiful music
zboj12 3 years ago
they're not robots to do eveything perfect dude, and I don't hear nothing wrong with the sax, all I hear is not exactly the same notes than on the recording :S
BrewtalDamage 3 years ago 17
I agree the sax is fine, shame petrucci doesn't play sax as well as guitar it would be a face melting holy crap that was amazing sax solo XD
Chrisakacloud 3 years ago
@BrewtalDamage Hmm, i must say, i wasn't a fan of this sax, but what the hell do i know? I'm a bassist, not a sax player.
Equipe3v 1 year ago
@BrewtalDamage man it's perfect!!! the voice is a little tuned down
alfonsominnella 8 months ago
@BrewtalDamage I agree. Improvisation is one of the most beautiful things in music
15MetalRocker 6 months ago
@BrewtalDamage This IS the studio version :)
JujoCro 6 months ago
@JujoCro they never dissappoint :)
BrewtalDamage 6 months ago
the sax was stay in tunes,c'mon dude,that's was Spyro Gyra's sax player
Parcolon 2 years ago
lol how is a sax out of tune?? it is not like a guitar that can detune. it is out of tune if it was not crafted properly
NonEternal 2 years ago
Oh come on, I wrote it about year ago. I was young and silly :P I suggest not to comment that old messages
zboj12 2 years ago
lol alright
NonEternal 2 years ago
a sax can go out of tune too you pleb
ungfla 2 years ago 2
ofc a sax can go out of tune.....you've got to pull out/push in the mouthpiece to get it in tune
wickerman12345 2 years ago 4
I agree with you.
epicubby 2 years ago
This song makes me cry...
SellYesterday 3 years ago 2
this isnt in the dvd wtf where did you get it
livio1396 3 years ago
labire nails this song. This is the first time I've seen him sing this not horribly.
campbell92 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
LOL this is not horrible? i'd like to see one of his poorer performances. :)
metropolis3043 4 years ago
Look at how he does it these days. His tone here is at least listenable. So what if he can't hit the notes? Since when are high notes the only important part of a vocal?
ozzymeetsjesus 3 years ago
cool *-*
carlitchamm 4 years ago
Fantastic music
Sax marvelous.
robsonjunioraltered 4 years ago 3